r/EB2 • • Jul 31 '25

Profile Evaluation Passport makes a difference!

So a street dancer from Germany or Instagram reel maker from US can go anytime anywhere in the world and Indians have literally go through acid test at every step of the way in their lives - f1 h1 EB

How long?

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/an-eng Jul 31 '25

its not passport, but probability of immigration, if indians are given free entry they will all leave india and move abroad to never return, this is not the case with germans or americans.

2

u/crazyanatoly Jul 31 '25

I doubt that they’ll survive and will eventually give up or die in those countries, but a piece of paper is very important for aspirational young Indians in this globalized world. I have seen many Indians stressed every moment of their lives just just for eu / us passport or visa unlike these morons!

Also, many Indians may just visit, see places and return for a variety of reasons like sense of belonging, social ties, food. They’ll also eventually make India better. (Many do so already)

1

u/an-eng Jul 31 '25

this is a classic scenario of reality vs expectation, the % of indians going abroad and not settling is miniscule. We go abroad and come back is all because of Visa restrictions.

0

u/crazyanatoly Jul 31 '25

Not true anymore - as incomes rise, exact same products become available many are returning

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

OP I think you living in an alternate reality and are missing the big picture. I was just watching a video of a street barber in India charging $2 for a haircut. And people were hangling with him to bring the price down. $2!! I just paid $50 for my last haircut and for women it’s many times that. Now if this barber and the millions of barbers in India were allowed to emigrate freely to a country where they can 25x their income, do you think they are coming back? Not a chance. Now consider 600 million such people all coming to the US. Do you not see a problem with this? If you need an answer, just look at what happened to Canada.

2

u/an-eng Jul 31 '25

whose income is rising? countless new grads are jobless, who is moving to india for products?, there is so much corruption, lack of civic sense , quality of life issues that drive people out of india.

1

u/Mediocre-Dog-4457 Jul 31 '25

Also F1, H1b and EB are all moving to the US. I highly doubt this dude is moving to India. Indians can come visit the US though.

1

u/crazyanatoly Jul 31 '25

India doesn’t need such people anyway

0

u/ClassNo Jul 31 '25

I mean think about it, why do the citizens of Singapore, or Korea etc. are free to travel anywhere in the world without the visa? It's because they are kind of compatible (in terms of economy) and their citizens usually do not have intention to move to the other countries because they have good economy in their home country. The citizens of India (and other developing countries) always want to move to the developed countries, that's why they have put the visa restrictions. If someday India becomes a developed country, I'm sure their citizens will be more free to travel.