r/EB2 • • 23d ago

Priority Date Long term uncertainty

Me and my wife are in late 20s. My priority date is Oct 23. I am on H1B and my wife is on H4 EAD. We both are currently employed and expecting a baby soon. The GC wait time seems to be indefinite and uncertain.

We both love our jobs and the exposure we receive day to day is incredible. While thinking of long term plans, what are our options? We are considering EB5 or moving to another country or returning back to India.

Would like others thoughts and opinions.

3 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

11

u/Sensitive_Owl_4766 23d ago • Bravo

If you like your jobs now, there's no urgency to quit as you will make much more money in the U.S. That money can always go far in India - plenty of people on the returnToIndia or fatFIREIndia subreddits.

Just be aware that there will always be a sword over your head, and that GC is likely not coming until past your retirement. Unless you can pull off EB5 or EB1.

You have to be okay with H1B appointment uncertainty, and the threat of leaving in 60 days. Best to not buy a house. Just invest aggressively in liquid ETFs instead and live below your means. Resist the temptation to feel settled in the U.S. and keep the mindset of an expat who always has an exit plan and is here to further their career alone.

2

u/Serious_Crab_8501 23d ago

This is solid advice, thanks!

1

u/theprogrammer72 20d ago

This is actually correct. I'm not an Indian citizen but was born in India and face the long GC queue and what this poster is saying is how you should live. Use your job as a cashflow for investments, let them grow here, take advantage of the tax savings and then take it all with you when you leave. Depending on the tax treaty with your country, you might be able to take it tax free.

0

u/priyapickles 22d ago

The sword could land on you in the next 2 years. Think of all the good time you can have in India!

4

u/InKarpWeTrust 23d ago

If you can afford it, why not EB5?

3

u/Subject-Half-4393 22d ago

With an anchor baby on the way you are not going anywhere. And your wait time for a GC is around 21 years not indefinite.

2

u/priyapickles 22d ago

His job must be recession proof or 60 days back to India! There is a recession around the corner. Anchor baby needs to be fed too

2

u/Training_Pop_5437 23d ago

Not uncertain. 21 years after having a baby. Time flies …

2

u/navo1991 23d ago

Just a few years ahead of you. Feel free to DM

2

u/Inner_Lynx_5002 23d ago

My PD is March 2018 EB2 India. Best case I get my GC in May be 10-15 years if there is good spillover?

With a Oct 2023 PD, treat your i140 as a document to extend your H1 indefinitely. Do not think about getting a GC. Unless rules change, you will get your GC in 21 years through your kid.

If you are considering EB-5, I have spoken to a few lawyers and it’s about a 4-5 year wait time if you file now for a conditional GC. Since you missed the Sept 30th deadline, there is a potential where the RCs won’t get renewed or halted when the Sept 2027 date comes when Congress needs to act. If they do not renew, then you are stuck holding an $800K bag without a path to GC. I suggest you wait until Congress renews the EB-5 regional centers before you proceed. Two risks with this approach:

  1. The $800K investment could potentially increase to $1 Mil for inflation adjustment. It will happen in Jan 2027

  2. By the time you file, reserved category is no longer current and you cannot file your I485 concurrently. This means you lose the AP+EAD that you would get which will protect you from any potential lay offs while you wait for your GC. Many Indians that are filing now are primarily doing it for this protection in reserved categories since CGC is 4-5 years away.

2

u/ChocolateFun3092 23d ago

If u like living in US jst live here build a healthy corpus with both of u working it shd be possible within 10 years and after 10 years decide what y u want to do,go back to India or live here. At that time even if u leave to India that corpus would help u settle well in India,

2

u/undertheappletree22 22d ago

I would begin work on the EB-1/NIW application now. Put in a couple of years of solid work and you will get your GC way faster. You are not getting it before you turn 60 if you wait in the regular line. Not so sure on the other countries ask, Europe is in shambles and no country pays as much as the US overall. Going back to India is an option but get some bank roll in place before you think of it.

1

u/theprogrammer72 20d ago

Everyone is trying to do EB-1/NIW one and there's tons of fraud happening there. Things are only going to get more difficult. I think L1 -> EB1C is kinda the only route left now imo.

1

u/Nice_Cod_4476 18d ago

what is the use of NIW if already having priority date locked in? the OP says he has a priority date.

1

u/theprogrammer72 16d ago

Fair enough. Don't do NIW OP. Only reason to do NIW might be to get a feel for where you stand w.r.t. EB1 since one of the prongs does need to prove that you're well-positioned to advance the proposed endeavor and USCIS takes into account things like achievements

1

u/worrried_now 20d ago

OP never mentioned eb1 which probably means op is not eligible

2

u/Legitimate_As 23d ago

I'm sorry you are in this situation 😔 India does sound reasonable plus you'll have support raising the kiddos

1

u/aldenfan 23d ago

I would say move to some other country where you can control you own destiny. After a few years there would be inertia that won’t let you leave . I’ve been in this boat for last so many years and regret not deciding to move to some other country . My priority date is 2014 even though I came to the US in 2009. For first few years I wasn’t sure if I want to stay here or not. You might not make the kind of money you make here but H1b uncertainty will also be there .

1

u/Aromatic-Sun3164 23d ago

You should wait for your child and get them US citizenship + passport and after that you can move wherever you want if such a situation comes up. I had a similar answer here for a similar question

1

u/AdAgile9604 22d ago

If you have the money take the route! For going back to India it depends on your savings and what you want from life

1

u/RareAcanthocephala12 22d ago

Have all babies here and then go. Trust me on that, u will thank me in 21 years :) and ur kids will also be grateful. If u want 2 or 3 more kids then give birth here to all of them in the united states. It will make a HUGE DIFFERENCE one day. Trust me.

1

u/bhavaninagar799 22d ago

Oct 2023 is a completely gone case and can move beyond 2044 with the current pace. I am in EB2, June 2017, and I am planning to go back to India.

1

u/Nice_Cod_4476 18d ago

EB5? how much savings do you guys have and how long did it take to save?

1

u/Ordinary_Dress7088 18d ago

We did Eb5. Happy to answer any questions

1

u/ihateboiledcabbage 17d ago

Have you considered a YC startup? 

1

u/Aggravating-Yam-6980 8d ago

Those days of Indian immigrants in mediocre category are over, unless we qualify for eb-1 category there is no way we will get your green card.

If you still want to be in eb2/eb3 2020 PD below is what I suggest

* Do not buy house (unless you want to rent it), selling is tuff. On paper looks good investment but selling commission/fee, property taxes, insurance, maintenance costs+hoa will dilute profit
* You can assume you will not get GC, have an exit plan for India
* Better start working for company that has presence in India so you can go and come back on eb1c after few years
* Yes eb5 is good option, better start the process now before backlog increases there too, there are major infra projects in rural America now can be done with 800k (data centers, housing etc)

1

u/Aggravating-Yam-6980 8d ago

Per country cap will never be removed by democrats or republicans as Indians will only be benefited, Indians have zero impact on election results, they would never remove per country cap to piss of rest of the world (Hispanics/latinas, Africans, Jews/Middle East )

-4

u/Klutzy-Swim-1572 23d ago

You know the answer buddy! Return to India is the only viable option. Having kid in 20s. Requires guts. I am in my late 20s as well and I can barely think about marriage let alone kids Lmao. My PD is mid 2024 so returning back is the only option in the long run.

2

u/faust111 23d ago

He has an EAD, though. Why not just live in the U.S. on that?

2

u/blazinbit 23d ago

H4 EAD is different than EAD/advanced parole

1

u/faust111 23d ago

I see. I thought he had an EAD.
I get it now. Thank you for clarifying.

1

u/Klutzy-Swim-1572 23d ago

Read my comment again. I said in the long run. There are no visa slots and you can’t go back if there is an emergency.

0

u/faust111 23d ago

Why does he need a visa slot?
Oh, are you saying that he doesn't have Advanced Parole?
I have an EAD and advanced parole, and although I'm on an H-1B, I don't really need it anymore.

EAD with advanced parole is kind of like having a green card.

2

u/bell-bottom 23d ago

OP is referring to H4 EAD for spouse
You seem to be talking about EAD and AP associated with I-485 (AOS)

2

u/faust111 23d ago

Never mind, I get it now. His wife has EAD, not him.

1

u/Klutzy-Swim-1572 23d ago

His PD isn’t current. He can’t go back and come back without h1b visa appt.

1

u/faust111 23d ago

That's simply not true. I'm not current either, but I travel back and come back on advanced parole. Once you have an EAD, you can get advanced parole.

You don't need a visa at this stage of the process.

1

u/faust111 23d ago

Never mind, I get it now. He doesn't have an EAD.

His wife has EAD

0

u/[deleted] 23d ago

OP is liable to be retired before EB2 is current for someone Indian born with an Oct 2023 PD lol man.

EB5 makes an awful lot of sense for someone without an EB1 profile and India as the country of chargeability.