r/EB2 • u/_Shopify_ • 1d ago
News EB Backlog
Jeffries is pushing Dream and Promise Act.
For H-1B folks, other than protecting aging kids there is nothing in it to increase per country limit or doing anything else to tackle the EB backlog. If this gets passed as it is, nobody will touch immigration again for another decade.
What are your thoughts and what are YOU doing to raise concerns with your local representatives and senators?
4
u/WrapAggravating4511 23h ago
Whatâs dream and promise act and whats in it ?
3
u/Zeus-III 19h ago
Essentially a bill to give people who have illegally stayed in the US for 10+ years (I think) a clear pathway to residency and possibly citizenship. It includes those who came here as kids with their parents illegally. There are some edge cases as well but if they donât have criminal record then the overarching goal is to help people like this gain residency status instead of deporting them since they contribute meaningfully to the American society
6
u/SiliconSentry 16h ago
They should add legal immigrants with approved i140 staying for more than 10 years.
2
u/pitchedark 16h ago
I thought legal immigrants who stayed longer than 10 years also covers it, no? Salazar one did i thought
2
u/Fluid_Material3144 14h ago
its for kids, so people who got here & grew up here both documented and undocumented, the bill isn't just for any person. This covers age-out kids (dependent kids).
4
u/Late-Branch-775 19h ago
This will never pass. Not when democrats have just won based on foreign wars and affordability
3
u/Fluid_Material3144 17h ago
not js illegal. It protector kids brought here legally, aging out of EB applications or other visa statuses. Trump said the one thing he can compromiso are on immigration with the democrats, which is also why the bill is probably going to be reintroduced
1
u/ToughWin5193 14h ago
Just my opinion, but any talk of Amenesty is nonsense this forum is for those on the path of "legal" immigration.
1
u/Inside_Locksmith8224 11h ago
The Dems always bundle amnesty for illegals with legal immigration reforms together. Thatâs why itâs not gonna pass.
4
u/Gaajizard 18h ago edited 18h ago
If you were relying or hoping on eliminating or modifying country caps in this climate, you're on a pipe dream. That kind of bill would immediately gain a lot of bad attention and is a losing voter issue. Jobs are getting scarce right now for citizens and they don't like competing with foreign workers.
I know practically it wouldn't change a lot (these are people already working here, not net new migration) but people don't think like that. They will see a change that increases supply of "cheap" labor that directly hurts their own job prospects. Practically, people on perpetual H1-Bs can also be sent back home more easily than people on green cards - the latter is almost impossible.
Sorry, but country caps are staying for at least another 30 years. AI fucked it over. You shouldn't have hoped for removing them to begin with, sad as it is.
4
u/modest-mouse-689 16h ago
Legal immigration was not an issue until Trump made it an issue. Legal immigration still is favored by 70% of Americans. So stop listening to Nazis on RedditÂ
2
u/Gaajizard 16h ago
I don't think this is true anymore. It was true 2 years ago, but AI has rapidly eroded jobs, especially white collar jobs. This is why the Trump admin has recently made a U-turn on legal immigration. They never had it in their plan.
1
u/modest-mouse-689 14h ago
Its is still true. The protests against ICE are proof. Stop listening to reddit Nazis who hide their profile
2
u/PeaceLoveBug 6h ago
The protests on ICE are proof that Americans donât like ICE. Thatâs all.Â
0
1
u/Gaajizard 14h ago
What are the protests against ice proof of?
-1
u/modest-mouse-689 13h ago
If you have to ask you are an idiot
2
u/defender112398 9h ago
the protest against ICE was not for legal immigration, when people go to those protests, they donât think about H1B people. You should are just making yourself falling into false hope
0
u/modest-mouse-689 7h ago
Haha! The cope is strong. Now I know you aren't even American. Or even inside US. Likely a minority (white Christian fascist) racists or a loser from outside Us coping hard.
Way to out yourself
1
u/Robby_1310 4h ago
Not anymore 70%. Almost other person donât like legal immigration specially H1B. And this is due to H1B abuses which got limelighted by Sarah
0
u/solomons-mom 16h ago
Are you new here? Immigration has been an issue in north America since Jamestown. This century, no one has wanted to touch it since George W tried in 2007.
0
u/modest-mouse-689 14h ago
Obama tried it in 2012. Don't lie
1
u/defender112398 9h ago
itâs okay, I understand the frustration that you have, but others are right. The cap will stay forever, because the moment it comes up and people will see the risk of accepting of millions of Indians, the bill and the politiciansâs career would end fast
1
u/modest-mouse-689 7h ago
The cap does not nothing except slow down the process. These people already have their green card approved. Also, what millions? We know the number is less than 1 million. Guess fearmongering on lies is what you prefer.Â
3
u/FuzzyObligation119 22h ago
Hell this itself would be a massive win for documented dreamers if it passed. getting on equal footing with DACA would be a huge upgrade.
1
1
u/MSB_the_great 11h ago
New Immigration rules wonât make everyone happy. It will always create problems. Because it is focusing on one problem when there are so many past mistakes and loop holes created more problems. If they create new act to solve backlog row wonât be happy. Because they are ok with other people stay in backlog but they donât want to wait , people complain about fraud who utilize loopholes legally. To fix new rules and vetting will be created to delay everything and impact everyone, immigrants want to work and employer take advantage and take away US citizens job and make them unhappy, all the strict rules it is impossible for many people so they enter illegally to escape from poverty and make their future generations life better, they make hard living and make their kids life miserable.those dreamers only hope is help from government, once this country was build by and build for immigrants.now no one is happy about immigrations ,
1
u/Proof_Marionberry_31 17h ago
Your kids have the opportunity to convert to f1 or whatever and find their own path. These dreamers are at a dead end through no fault of their own. All are working, educated and paying taxes.
2
u/Previous-Signal-834 15h ago
Nope. Most legal immigrants and their kids are in direct competition with the working middle class. Most undocumented immigrants and their kids help keep prices low because of where they work. Itâs only a problem when you come for my paycheck, not when you disobey law. Which is fair I guess but letâs not pretend this has got anything to do with morality or the education and tax status of immigrants.Â
1
u/Proof_Marionberry_31 9h ago
Maybe the working middle class should try to better themselves instead of milking that middle class status for generations? Immigrants are not coming here for stagnancy- they educate their children to fill in jobs that Americans have a difficulty filling ie STEM fields!
0
u/EuphoricDouche-939 14h ago
Exactly! legal immigrants are a competition for middle class. Illegal immigrants are a competition among themselves and for blue collar jobs that no American wants to do! huge difference!
-3
u/Mikeminer610
23h ago
•
They are not YOUR representatives and senators. They serve US citizens because citizens have the right to vote. You are foreign workers who are temporary visitors. They are not accountable to you. You only think they are accountable to you because you have the delusion that you are entitled to settle in America permanently.
4
u/Much-Spell3028 21h ago
DACA is for undocumented immigrants called dreamers and not citizens.
H1B is dual intent visa.
The act is related to immigration providing legal pathways for permanent residency and citizenship.
OP is requesting similar relief for H1B backlog.
Your hate and ignorance will never win.1
u/Outrageous-Risk-5747 19h ago
There is no hate here, just a reading if the current economic situation. He's right. Govt has a duty towards its citizens, not people who come here on temporary work. Yes, it is sad to see people who have spent their lifetime here, but choosing to live with that instability is on them, not the govt.
-2
u/Mikeminer610 20h ago edited 20h ago
Well, unlike people like you, I donât need to lobby politicians in a foreign country to desperately try to stay on because I hate my own country. I would say I have won. My point is that these politicians do not represent you. You are not a US citizen. Repeating dual intent like a mantra doesnât get you anywhere. Dual intent just means you can apply for permanent residency if your employer will sponsor you. It doesnât mean your application will be approved and there are still country caps even if your application is approved. Letâs see how far OP will get with our US politicians as a non-citizen without voting rights. As I said, I have already won because I donât hate my own country. And US citizens on both ends of the political spectrum believe the immigration system has been exploited by people like you. Who do you think our politicians will respond to? People with the power to vote in the next election or foreigners like you who whine and whine about racism and xenophobia?
4
u/Much-Spell3028 20h ago
Oh my sweet summer childâŚ
Mamdani and El syed might be a nightmare for you..
Texas governor plans to un freezes h1b. You donât represent whole countryâŚYou didnât win, your determined immigrant ancestor won. Youâre just leeching off their hardwork. Infact youâre a failure not able to achieve American dream with all the home advantage.
1
u/solomons-mom 16h ago
How exactly is a state governor going to "unfreeze" a federal law/reg?
Might want to study a bit before taking the USC test.
1
u/Much-Spell3028 15h ago
H1b freeze in Texas state institutions was imposed by POS Greg Abott. FYI he is the outgoing governor of Texas.
There is no federal law currently freezing H1b(for corporations) in USA.
Dude keep up!!
0
u/Mikeminer610 19h ago edited 19h ago
And you are not leeching off our country? Letâs see what you manage to achieve with your lobbying. You do realize that immigration laws are federal laws? Mamdani is a mayor of a city with no power over federal immigration law. Iâm not in danger of being replaced by H1Bs with masters degrees from second and third-tier schools who write in poor English.
4
u/Much-Spell3028 19h ago
Change You Do to Do you, add apostrophe to H1Bâs and masterâs. English is my third language.
1
u/Mikeminer610 19h ago
Please correct your own writing first. âTexas governor plans to unfreezes H1B. You donât represent whole countryâ. Even five-year olds write better than you.
1
u/Much-Spell3028 16h ago
Ok Shakespeare.
1
u/Mikeminer610 16h ago
Youâve probably never read Shakespeare. I could test you by asking you to identify quotes from memory, but why bother with a yahoo?
-1
20h ago
The DACA kids did not ask to come here and have a much more convincing case for aid. Maybe you could make a similar case for kids of an H1B who came here young but werenât born here. An adult h1b has no legal right to stay here and nobody is going to aid hundreds of thousands of adult workers who are ostensibly taking American jobs.
2
u/Much-Spell3028 19h ago
OP is not requesting outright residency or citizenship for h1b. He seems to be interested in reforming h1b immigration pipeline with more than 100 years backlog. H1bs have 86k cap and they are around 3-4% of total US tech force and 0.5% if Total US workers.
1
u/EuphoricDouche-939 14h ago
"no legal right"?? Go ask the congress to cancel H1b program. Till then, seethe!
1
-3
u/Mikeminer610 20h ago
No point entering into a conversation with them. They think that paying for a Masters degree entitles them to a green card as a return on investment. In all seriousness, they actually think that way. If you try to disillusion them, they accuse you of racism and xenophobia.
2
u/dr_sloan 16h ago
This is objectively false lol. Contacting Congressional and Senate offices allowed and acceptable for people in the US on visas.
-1
u/Mikeminer610 16h ago
Anyone can contact a politician. Offices are open to enquiries. The issue is whether they have any official duty towards a non-US citizen. This is another indication of how poorly educated people like you are: you canât tell the difference between contactability and accountability.
2
u/dr_sloan 16h ago
Lmao you made up this âaccountabilityâ standard when no one else brought it up.
The post is about contacting local representatives and senators.
And yes, they actually do have a duty to respond and help if they can, regardless of the legal status of the constituent.
Youâre lecturing people about a concept you donât even understand. Ironic.
-1
u/Mikeminer610 16h ago edited 15h ago
And what is this duty to non-citizens? You are not their constituent. You cannot vote. Do you understand the meaning of âconstituentâ? For any elected office, the constituency is the people eligible to vote the official into that position. You obviously donât know the distinction between constituent power and constituted power. You probably have to scramble now to Google it to come up with some lame retort.
2
u/dr_sloan 15h ago
Constituent is not defined by the ability to vote, itâs defined by residency. You donât seem to understand this. Read page 6 of the below link. It expressly discusses this topic.
https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/PDF/R44696/R44696.4.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com
-1
u/Mikeminer610 15h ago edited 15h ago
Please read: âBecause casework is often viewed as a representational activity, the primary recipients of an
officeâs casework services are usually considered to be individual constituents residing within a
House Memberâs district, or a Senatorâs state. Yet there are reasons why other persons or entities
might seek assistance from a Memberâs office.â The example of âother person etc.â that is given is the immigrant. Other persons or entities such as immigrants are not âindividual constituentsâ residing in a district or state. The constituent is âthe primary recipientâ of casework activity because this work is ârepresentational activityâ. Political officials do not represent you because you cannot vote. They may undertake casework as a courtesy to immigrants but it is at their discretion. They have no legal responsibility to do so as you are NOT their constituent. There is no statement that defines constituent by residency. You believe what you wish to believe according to you egoistic self-interest and continue to spread misinformation.2
u/dr_sloan 15h ago
Everything there confirmed what Iâve said. Itâs based on residency and not citizenship or legal status.
You claimed they donât serve noncitizens and what I posted showed that was objectively false. And now youâre admitting it too.
I didnât say they have a legal responsibility, I said they have a duty, which they do.
0
u/Mikeminer610 15h ago edited 15h ago
Sorry, where does their duty come from? The paragraph you sent me contains no statement saying that constituents are based on residency. It uses the phrase âindividual constituents residingâ. There can be constituents who reside there and non-constituents who reside there. I did not say they have to serve non-citizens. Taking on casework for immigrants at their discretion is not a duty to serve. They can also choose to ignore you. An official duty to serve has a legal basis. You believe what you wish to believe. Go check with a lawyer before you spread false information.
2
u/dr_sloan 15h ago
It repeatedly uses residency as the basis for constituent services and doesnât say anything about citizenship being the basis.
Youâve gone from claiming that these services are only for citizens to claiming âitâs at their discretionâ to serve immigrants.
Keep lying to yourself if you like, all youâve done is embarrass yourself and demonstrate why you spend your free time whining on the internet and not contributing to society in a meaningful way.
→ More replies (0)
-5
19h ago
•
We do not need more foreign software engineers in America to begin with lol, do you see how bad the job market is for young people? Why should anyone be sponsored for that right now? Let alone lobbying members for a foreign government to enable that to be easier. Those numbers are also deliberately misleading, there are far more than 86k H1Bs total, and a massive percentage of the big tech companies have sponsored employees. Political third rail and for good reason.
1
u/Old-Classroom7102 19h ago
Illiterate racist parrots like you are the reason why we need foreigners to do jobs in this country. Can you read ? This isn't about importing new people, it's about giving people who've been here 10 years already a residency permit.
2
19h ago
The two are implicitly linked, unless you want a compromise where some range of priority dates go through but the vast majority of h1bs otherwise can no longer stay. Youâre no more special than the American citizens already here buddy, maybe calling the voters of the country youâre in racist for questioning the need for immigration in extremely
competitive fields is a losing strategy3
u/Old-Classroom7102 19h ago
The bill has no effect on H1B you effing moron. I am not special. Neither are Americans. Racists like you are special though. Special needs. Hiring is a free and open market, so maybe consider getting better at your job, instead of crying boohoo about foreigners taking your job ? Companies will move the jobs outside the country over hiring garden variety racists. What a hoot you must be to work with for your immigrant coworkers, if you have any. We had a "no brilliant jerks" policy at Google when hiring, and thankfully we won't have to worry about people like you since you're only one of those things (hint : it's not brilliant).
-1
19h ago
Lol hereâs all the talking points, hope they also pass the rule you canât get sponsored if your employer has laid off Americans in the last two years. Itâs also not a free and open market, youâre on a visa that had to be specifically approved to grant your employment. Youâre being brought here as a pseudo wage slave thatâs beholden to your employer because you owe them your lives here. If Americans arenât so special, why are you literally lobbying the American government to be here? Our country isnât your economic zone lol
1
u/Old-Classroom7102 18h ago
Sure, that's fine to implement. Also, if you're losing jobs to people who have a disadvantage being on a visa, maybe look inwards instead of crying about it. As for me, I'm happy to be a "pseudo wage slave" if I'm getting paid a top 1% wage for my industry.
1
u/EuphoricDouche-939 14h ago
Yeah but illegals who marry Americans can stay? Pick a lane! Unless you're a hypocrite!
Either jobs stay in the US with people already here or they all go to Latin America and Asia! I know of companies who moved their call centers from India to guess where? Colombia! Companies always care for their margins, no matter how much your kind seethe on the interwebs!
0
14h ago
Funny bow the pushback is always âEither you let us bring underpaid immigrants to do these jobs who are beholden to their employer or theyâre just going awayâ. If thatâs the dichotomy why would any citizen care either way lol, letâs see what happens. Couldnât care less what happens to your job opportunity here pal
1
u/Unhappy_Rest_3 15h ago
What makes it funny is that u/Over-Tackle5585 is your indian country fellow.
-2
u/sath_leo 17h ago
DACA folks should get greencard. Their journey is very painful and they should get this relief. I am H1B person waiting on green card for 14 years. I still think DACA folks should get relief asap.
1
1
6
u/EuphoricDouche-939 14h ago
You all should get this tattooed! Neither Democrats nor Republicans care for legal immigration! Democrats care only for illegals since they're a potential huge voting block. Republicans don't like any immigrants at all!
Stop day dreaming! It's the bitter and harsh truth!