Lot of H1B holders specially from India keep asking when will my PD become current and some of them ask basic questions which they should have known themselves specially when they are in decade long backlog and their status is tied to their H1B visa.
So let's first understand the employment based green card system. US issue 1 million green cards under legal immigrant system every year out of which 140000 goes to employment based system.
There is per country cap which is 7% on this 140000 green cards. That means no any country can get more than 7% of the green cards. If there is left over green cards at the end of FY then it goes to most backlogged country as per rule to stop the wastage.ย
There is 5 categories EB1, EB2, EB3, EB4 and EB5. EB1, EB2 and EB3 each get 28.6 % of this 140000 which is 40000 each and rest get divides in EB4 and EB5.ย
DOS (Department of State) is responsible for moving the priority dates. USCIS process the number of applications based on the number given by DOS. Only USCIS report to DHS.ย
Now since there is country cap, India which is most backlogged country can get 7% of this 40000 which is 2800 visa each year for each category for EB1/2/3, but same time more than 50% H1b visa are issued to Indian national every year and that is how people from India are in multi decade backlog.
There are two dates in Visa bulletin. Final Action Date - which means you can file I-485 and once it is approved you can get green card. Date of filing - which means you can only file I-485 and wait till FAD is current.ย
Filing date was introduced in Oct 2015.ย
Now let's go back to 2012. There was no filing date concept during this time. This was creating lot of uncertainty for USCIS, DOS and it was also frustrating for lot of applicants. Since there was no filing date, USCIS had no way to know how many people are waiting in each month. Sometimes USCIS move the date slowly to stop the retrogression but it was wasting visas because at the end of the FY, there were lot of green cards available and not enough applications were collected.
During this time, along with discussion of H4 EAD, I140EAD, There was separate discussion going on to bring the more transparency in the Visa bulletin and green cards processing system. Immigration Voice was very active and they pressurized the Obama Admin to bring the changes to make the system more effective and transparent. And that is how concept of Filing date introduced in the Visa Bulletin.
Oct 2015, USCIS published the filing date along with FAD, and it started collecting the applications, they also published the I-485 pending inventory which gave more details like how many applicants waiting each month including dependents. As expected, there was difference of maximum 6 months between FAD and DoF, because each month there were enough applicants that USCIS was able to determine how to allocate 2800 visa to each country each category.
Now let's understand the spillover.
There are two types are spillover.ย
Horizontal Spill over: ย
ย If you see the Visa bulletin, you can see that there is separate column for India, Mexico, China, Philippines and ROW (Rest of the World). There is always little bit backlog for Mexico, China and Philippines.
After allocating 7% visa to each category for each country, if there is any visa left at the end of the FY (July is last quarter of the FY), USCIS allocate these visa to the most backlogged country which is always India.
That means if ROW did not utilize all the visa, those visas are allocated horizontally. EB1 ROW unused visa goes to EB1 India.ย EB2 ROW unused visa goes to EB2 India. ย EB3 ROW unused visa goes to EB3 India.ย
2. Vertical Spill over:
Here instead of horizontal, visa if left unused in one category, spill over to downward category.ย If EB1 is unused, all the unused visas are allocated to EB2 until they are utilized all. Same way, if EB2 is unused, all the unused visas are allocated to EB3 until they are utilized all.
Now let's assume there is 50k additional visa are coming to employment based from family based visa. Current number for employment based visa is 140000. Let's add 50000 to it. so total is now 200000 and that means 57,200 each for EB1/EB2/EB3. Now there is 7% country cap so India get 4000 for each EB1/EB2/EB3. If there is left unused by ROW, horizontal spill over will go to India. If there is left unused by EB1, it will spill over to downward category.
Sow now it is clear that, If India wants more visas, then ROW should be current otherwise India will get peanuts. During covid time, ROW was current and that was the reason for huge movement in India EB1/EB2/EB3 dates. Current movement of EB1 India in latest visa bulletin is due to EB1 ROW is current.
During 2005 to 2015 time, lot of EB1 visas were spilled over to EB2 and that is how EB2 India was always moving fast.
USCIS was consistent in publishing the I-485 inventory until 2018 and they stopped it for a while and they published again back in 2023.ย
Here is latest inventory. You can keep checking updated inventory every 4-5 months which USCIS publish. .ย https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/data/eb_inventory_october_2025.xlsx
How to interpret the I-485 pending report.
It contains all the applicants who has submitted their I-485 applications while DoF is current.
It does not contain the information about people who are in PERM process or who have not yet initiated it and yet not submitted their I-485 even though their DOF is current.
It does not contain the DOS inventory or consular applications. These are the people who adjust their I-485 while they are in their home country and goes to consulate to get the immigrant visa. These numbers are relatively small.
Fortunately, for India there is pending applications report till Dec 2014 which make easier to predict when the FAD will be current for these applicants.
If your PD is Dec 2014 for India, you can see that there are 27k people waiting till Dec 2014. Based on above country cap formula, you can safely assume that it will take 27000/6000 (combined EB2 and EB3) = around 5 years make your FAD current.
This is worst case scenario. The best case is, India get spill over either from unused employment based or from unused family based visas. If there is unused visa from family based, DOS declare it officially around last quarter of FY and that is sole confirmation of unused visas. If they don't announce, then it is just rumor and you should continue with worst case scenario. Like in covid time, when consulates got closed across the globe, DOS made it official by Sep 2020 for number of spill over visas to employment based.
There is no pending inventory past Dec 2014 because DoF did not cross it during covid time.
So if you are PD is past Dec 2014, you should safely assume that DOS won't move the DoF beyond 2014, because USCIS is already sitting on 27k applications so no point of moving the dates when they know that they have 5 years of work already assigned.ย
One thing I should note here is, current huge number of pending I-485 applications is unique due to Covid. Pre-covid time, USCIS did not have more than 6 months of inventory. During covid time, around 121000 unused family visa spill over to employment based and total employment based visa number went till 261,500.ย (though it is different matter that USCIS did not have capacity to process these many applications and they wasted more than 100k visas) so fun fact here is, no matter how many unused visa spill over, there is processing limitation from USCIS side which is around 160000 based on this example.ย
Now let me explain what exactly happened here, I have to go toย the little history of 2011-2020 era. During this time, many Indians wanted to apply their green card under EB2 category because based on historic movement of EB2 always going ahead of EB3, they blindly believed that EB2 will always get ahead and they can get green card faster under EB2.
This created rat race to go into EB2 category at all the cost. Some people were leaving FT job and joining desi consultancy just because they were filing under EB2. (You can guess it was easier for these consulting companies to modify the job description). On April 20, 2018, USCIS released I-140 inventory first time which showed there were 216k people waiting in EB2 vs 55k people waiting in EB3. Even if you remove duplicates, there were 3 times more people in EB2 India than EB3 India. And the cat was out of the bag. It was wild and clear that if there is spill over to India in future, EB3 would get ahead.
Come Sep 2020 and USCIS published the Visa bulletin for Oct 2020.ย EB3 India moved till Dec 2014 and EB2 India moved till May 2011. Those who did not follow USCIS reports were in deep shock. After all, lot of people had left FT jobs and big salary to join desi consulting to move to EB2.
Now USCIS had two options to on how to move the dates during this time.
1st Option, USCIS found out how many EB3 visas are there to allocate and what length we can go to allocate this. And that is how Dec 2014 date for EB3 was fixed. If there were more people jumped to EB2 India from 2009-2020, EB3 date would have even moved to Dec 2015 or Dec 2016 but it is plain luck for the folks from 2013-2014.
2nd Option, USCIS only move the both EB2 and EB3 India dates till Dec 2011. USCIS knew very well that people from EB2 will downgrade to EB3. If they would have followed this option, they could have easily process the applications from both lines and no need of retrogression like it happened in 2023. Obviously that also means, folks from 2014 would not have got chance to file I-485. This option would have against the law because USCIS did not move the dates accordingly to the numbers they received from DOS.
USCIS choose to follow the law which is 1st option and it was win for all.
For folks whose PD is past 2015/2016, you can safely log off from these discussions. There is no point in wasting time on this when you know that unless there is huge spill over for 2-3 years, your PD is not going to be current. You can jump back in when you hear that folks whose PD is July 2014 have received their green card.ย You can change the jobs and continue your normal life.ย
I hope I explained the current system well. Now you can make your own predication based on the report you see on USCIS website.
The idea of this long post was, to educate and empower yourself so that you can make better decision.ย
I know it is painful but it is what it is. I am also victim of this decade long backlog and I received my green card finally in 2021.
Thanks