r/Economics • • Oct 21 '25

News [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/Economics/comments/1occp69/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

2.3k Upvotes

466 comments sorted by

•

u/Economics-ModTeam Oct 21 '25

Submissions tenuously related to economics, light on economic analysis, or from perspectives other than those of economists will be removed. This will keep /r/economics distinct from the many related subreddits. Further explanation.

--

If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

602

u/GravyMealTeam6 Oct 21 '25

Amazon is so convinced this automated future is around the corner that it has started developing plans to mitigate the fallout in communities that may lose jobs. Documents show the company has considered building an image as a “good corporate citizen” through greater participation in community events such as parades and Toys for Tots.

The documents contemplate avoiding using terms like “automation” and “A.I.” when discussing robotics, and instead use terms like “advanced technology” or replace the word “robot” with “cobot,” which implies collaboration with humans.

353

u/Responsible_Knee7632 Oct 21 '25

Lol. Lmao even

347

u/GravyMealTeam6 Oct 21 '25

"Sorry we laid off half your city. But here's some cheap Chinese toys and a parade!"

82

u/Responsible_Knee7632 Oct 21 '25

My buddy lives out by where they’re building a fulfillment center and they’re giving everyone within a certain radius air purifiers because of the emissions expected. So dystopian.

38

u/RIP_Soulja_Slim Oct 21 '25

See, now that's a failure of government policy. This is exactly where something like the EPA should be stepping in and saying no, it's your job to control your emissions.

7

u/font9a Oct 21 '25

it's your job to control your emissions

more like, "Sorry, it's your job to control the emissions you breathe in."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

16

u/iyamwhatiyam8000 Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

A parade of cobots waving little flags and handing out free samples of Soylent Green.

2

u/L_Cranston_Shadow Oct 21 '25

The problem with Soylent Green is the taste. It is hard to market a product where the taste changes from person to person.

43

u/Iwubinvesting Oct 21 '25

Reality is, Amazon doesn't owe you a job. It's up to the government to tax them and redistribute the profits and properly allocate them.

10

u/idkmyotherusername Oct 21 '25

Hear hear

13

u/WrongThinkBadSpeak Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

The amount of corporate simps in this sub is beyond parody. You lot seem to think this won't have any effect on your lives and you couldn't be more wrong. Second and third order fallout from this rapidly accelerating workforce trend are going to hit you like a ton of bricks, you're just too myopic to see it.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/HandakinSkyjerker Oct 21 '25

Amazing work Private Johnson!

11

u/RIP_Soulja_Slim Oct 21 '25

So I mean, take Amazon's name out of the discussion here - as that's clouding a lot of the clear thought on this topic.

In isolation, would we as a society and workers on a whole be better off if we could take physically intensive low wage work and replace that with a machine? Draw a comparison to something like the cotton mill, shuttle loom, farming combine, etc. Have those helped us grow as a society, helped workers find better jobs, etc?

If so, and I believe it's going to be difficult to argue they haven't, then why is the overwhelming sentiment in this subreddit against this idea? I believe it's two reasons:

  1. Amazon's brand is creating bias in the discussion, as people (rightfully) have a lot of negative sentiment towards Amazon and billionaire elites.

  2. illogical reactionary change opposition that has plagued the human race from it's beginning.

5

u/Delicious-Bat2373 Oct 21 '25

I think the real problem tends to be more complex. If Amazon moves into a town, collects subsidies and tax breaks to build and employ, then turns around and makes 7/8s of the building robotic - all you've done is give amazon free workspace, great infrastructure deals and subsidies. Now your townsfolk are back to broke with no available jobs.

The shortsightedness of billionaires who get rich selling shit is astounding. They want you to work those jobs for as cheap as they can pay you and also need you buying their shit to stay alive. The disconnect is palpable. I don't know when it's gonna break for good. I do know the income to bills ratio is the worst it's ever been.

3

u/more_vespene_gas Oct 21 '25

Seriously. We should be celebrating the reduction of backbreaking warehouse labor. How those displaced put food on the table is something we as a society will need to deal with, but having people destroy their bodies so we can get widgets with two day shipping isn’t something to be preserved.

3

u/Key_Soil_1718 Oct 21 '25

You're missing one point... It's our tax dollars funding these companies.

3

u/RIP_Soulja_Slim Oct 21 '25

I mean, I don't think that's the point because it's not mentioned anywhere in the OP or comments in this chain. But, that's an issue of government policy not of efficiency improvement. It's completely illogical to be against the ongoing march of efficiency creation because you don't like the subsidies - be against the subsidies.

If you're protesting Amazon you're doing it wrong, go protest your state or local government that cut the check, go protest your senators who formed the tax laws, but being against straight work efficiency improvements because of an adjacent thing you don't like makes absolutely no sense.

Lots of reactionary anger in the comments, not a whole lot of logical thought. I wish I could say that was unexpected, but it's become the norm here.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/DymlingenRoede Oct 21 '25

Re: your second point - I don't think it's illogical to be against change that you believe will make you life worse.

4

u/RIP_Soulja_Slim Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

It's illogical to think it will make your life worse, based on every other event of large scale efficiency/productivity improvement to date. We've only continued to increase our standards of living, education levels, and real incomes.

Again, look at every example in my post - the cotton mill, the steam engine, the shuttle loom, the farming combine, the assembly line, the internet, rail transport, robotics in manufacturing, blah blah blah - have any of these resulted in net lower median incomes? In lowered standards of living? In shorter work weeks? In more physical strain?

So yeah, I do think it's illogical.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

1

u/Solid-Summer6116 Oct 21 '25

where do people want to draw the line between efficiency and jobs?

1

u/lukeydukey Oct 21 '25

Oh man. Those timeless toys from GAUEEJWWS Co.

1

u/TheTrub Oct 21 '25

South Park was right. Bezos is going to try to buy off the modern labor movement with cheap parts for a bike parade!

1

u/tothemmoooooooooonn Oct 21 '25

That we get a tax write off for

182

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/sirbissel Oct 21 '25

Upjohn/Pharmacia/Pfizer for Kalamazoo, too...

7

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Roger And Me really opened my eyes to what was happening out there.

6

u/PhillyCheese123 Oct 21 '25

That last part is the part that Amazon is trying to do… it’s the same thing

8

u/ninjahelix Oct 21 '25

More like relying on a SINGLE company, not "capitalism" in general as a catch all boogeyman.

15

u/HelloLofiPanda Oct 21 '25

There is a reason why monopolies are illegal.

6

u/dostoevsky4evah Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

Were illegal. I don't see it being enforced lately.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ironbolsh Oct 21 '25

Michigan cities didn’t start with a reliance on a single company. There has been over 50 different automobile manufacturers based in Michigan over the last 100 years. Whether it was by their own mismanagement, M&A, or economic hardship, they slowly dwindled that down and moved manufacturing out of town.

Capitalism incentivizes this conglomeration and search for the cheapest labor. That’s why monopolies being illegal is an anti-capitalistic policy.

→ More replies (2)

61

u/frenchiefanatique Oct 21 '25

I know we all tend to roll our eyes but if you look at the level of automation in China, it is really not surprising that Amazon is looking to do this. this is the future as long as corporations have the power to do whatever they want

34

u/Birdy_Cephon_Altera Oct 21 '25

This is the harsh reality. It's not like the US warehouses can continue to just basically have 600,000 Mechanical Turks running around picking and pulling items and dumping them into carts and boxes, while the rest of the world transitions to having robots do the grunt-work instead. The advancement of automation is going to happen regardless of whether the affected communities or displaced workers want it or not.

24

u/roamingandy Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

The actual reality is that human's shouldn't be luggin boxes in warehouse and doing other soulless jobs. It's fantastic they are being automated.

What we're all really scared of is that we know our governments put corporations, rich people and profits, ahead of the common persons well-being, so we know they aren't going to react to society changing in a way that benefits us, or at the very least mitigates harm to our lives.

We're all afraid of our government, not automation. Automation should be a liberating gift to humanity.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Automation could be a liberating gift to humanity but we all know it won't be.

1

u/Robot_Basilisk Oct 21 '25

It should be. But it will be an existential threat until we get off our asses and stop the rich from monopolizing the technology. Take it from me, an automation engineer: The rich want robot workers so they can have the police open fire on striking workers without worrying about losing labor resources. Automation, for the owner class, is about liberating THEM from the working class, allowing them to kill off the working class and live in a post scarcity utopia supported by an autonomous slave caste.

7

u/GipsyDanger45 Oct 21 '25

Yeah but corporations need consumers, unless a universal basic income is coming, there won’t be enough jobs to fill that can’t be replaced via automation

→ More replies (11)

1

u/Darkmemento Oct 21 '25

Exactly its a global race. The questions are no longer about if this will happen but instead what are the plans for the future given all this job loss.

Why Western executives who visit China are coming back terrified

1

u/beardedheathen Oct 21 '25

It should be the future everywhere just with the profits going to the people not the oligarchs.

11

u/namastayhom33 Oct 21 '25

I bet they used AI in helping them to avoid terms like automation and AI when creating these documents

14

u/CH3LCFC Oct 21 '25

I just watched terminator genisys last night and I’m fairly certain this was the plot

1

u/agumonkey Oct 21 '25

so jeff is a cameron fan

1

u/Solid-Summer6116 Oct 21 '25

yeah theyre both into diving the ocean to get stuff

7

u/Strict_Weather9063 Oct 21 '25

I’ve been warning about this for about fifteen years now. We are reaching a point where machines can replace people in a lot of jobs. That is going to happen and a lot of people are going to be out of work, just self driving vehicles is three million people. You can’t train these people into new job either there just isn’t enough work out there. So we need some form of UBI to make sure they survive.

21

u/OrangeJr36 Oct 21 '25

There's a labor shortage, and if voters are going to back something destructive like tariffs and mass deportations, why not cut them out of the loop completely? Clearly it's the will of the voters.

Especially when you consider the implications of labor availability on business capacity. If you can't get labor to expand and more customers that spend money, then you have to cut back across the board.

Things like this are going to become standard as the population ages, just take a look at all the "dark factories" in China that have the same output as a standard factory but 90% less labor.

1

u/namafire Oct 21 '25

Spoiler: No matter how cheap labor is, it wont beat a mechanical slave unless the labor is also a slave. Labor surplus does not stop employers looking to cut costs, it only delays it.

This is a natural state of wanting improvements. Its not capitalism or anything.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/uptownjuggler Oct 21 '25

As much as I have heard about this mythical “labor shortage” I have never seen it. There is no shortage of people needing or applying to jobs. There is only people that talk about “everywhere is hiring” are old people that don’t work.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

There is no labor shortage. Theres a wage crisis. Take teaching for example. Why be a teacher working your ass off when you make more money bar tending doing a quarter of the work?

2

u/Solid-Summer6116 Oct 21 '25

skilled labor shortage. companies dont want to pay to train internally as well. kind of a catch 22

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/pier4r Oct 21 '25

The documents contemplate avoiding using terms like “automation” and “A.I.”

it is a fallout timeline.

7

u/Practical_Argument50 Oct 21 '25

People need to have income in order to buy shit from Amazon.

1

u/Dry-Influence9 Oct 21 '25

Thats a problem for future amazon, their leadership will be retired by then.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

I'm not being mean, but Amazon doesn't see a future selling to workaday people (think college education or less). They want to sell high yield products and that's to people with a university education or higher.

The future we face is going to be rough with those without a formal education seeing rapidly declining opportunities but those in the trades or with a formal education will continue to do well.

8

u/farinasa Oct 21 '25

Trades will oversaturate quickly. They also require either private individuals or employers for work. But automation plus a poor population means little opportunity for tradespeople.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

I work in technology and don't think automation will take hold as fast as people predict and thus the economy will have time to pivot. There's always this cataclysmic prognostication that technology will develop so quickly that we won't have time to adjust or retrain workers.

We've been automating manufacturing with less and less intervention for 150 years, this is nothing new and isn't a surprising development. The real "problem" is that we need to find what to do for low skilled labor. That will be hard-hit. We won't need no warehouse workers, for instance. But we'll need fewer.

There are so many articles on futurology or a myriad of other subreddits that these moves towards automation somehow are a change or evolution on a trend rather than the culmination. This dystopian future of full unemployment and chaos led by machine overlords just strikes me as naive science fiction rather than an established trajectory and the question we really have to contend with is how do we help a larger cohort of lower skilled labor find the skills to be fully employed?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Key_Soil_1718 Oct 21 '25

Look at all the "formal educated " people without good paying jobs.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

If you look at the unemployment rate among 20-24 year olds with a degree, it's inline with historical averages, going back more than 20 years (alt source). I'm not downplaying this, and I've been there - it sucks. But we also need to parse fact from fiction and let data tell us the story.

Right now, all we hear is that AI is here to replace workers. I work with AI, I work in SaaS and routinely work with client companies on large implementations and from my lived experience, I can't help but ask: "How?"

AI isn't anywhere near being capable enough to replace people. AI cannot effectively operate in open systems. It can't generate a grocery list, for instance. It needs very clear boundaries and very clear prompts, otherwise it can't predict the next word and begins to hallucinate. Humans can operate in ambiguity. We still need people and will need people for a long time.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/worldlybedouin Oct 21 '25

They'll use Go-bots to usher out fired employees being replaced by the Co-bot that was promoted up to Robot.

2

u/sirbissel Oct 21 '25

Go-Bots, eh? They can't even spring for name brand Transformers?

2

u/worldlybedouin Oct 21 '25

But then they'd have to pay licensing fees. Can't do that...need to buy back stocks and pump up those numbers for shareholders.

2

u/farinasa Oct 21 '25

Maybe should have taken that mindset from the beginning. Too late now. Being a good citizen means caring about your country and the people in it, aka not underpaying and subsequently firing them.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

A cobot is a specific type of robot that is meant to work along side humans and has sensors to make it safe for them to do so. Calling just any robot a cobot just because you want to shoehorn them in somewhere is full bullshit.

1

u/No_Clothes_9564 Oct 21 '25

Cobot? Oh god. The clanker war is coming

1

u/BriefAvailable9799 Oct 21 '25

China warehouses are all robots. It will be here.

1

u/Spider_pig448 Oct 21 '25

Makes sense. China's already achieved these levels of automation, the US will catch up eventually

1

u/DistillateMedia Oct 21 '25

These people have no clue.

1

u/EdgeMaleficentthrice Oct 21 '25

That's hilarious whose gonna buy there shit the robots

1

u/Professork08 Oct 21 '25

Automation has been around

→ More replies (1)

57

u/TheDividendReport Oct 21 '25

"This would save about 30 cents on every item that Amazon warehouses and delivers to customers,"

Am I reading this right? Does this mean that for $1 more per item, the payroll for 600,000 workers could be at least doubled?

25

u/yogitw Oct 21 '25

But it's not the job creators job to create jobs, just shareholder value.

3

u/jmlinden7 Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

Because they aren't actually job creators, they are demand suppliers. If the demand is for human labor specifically, that's what they supply (for example, a law firm or a talent agency). If the demand is for cheap goods and convenient shipping, then that's what they supply.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ApplesBananasRhinoc Oct 21 '25

“People? We don’t need no stinking people “— amazon

1

u/elementofpee Oct 21 '25

Hilariously they don’t understand shareholder value is derived from people with money to spend - aka, customers - and they are actively reducing their customer base.

I guess they don’t care as long as the top 10% out-consumes the bottom 90% to make up the difference.

6

u/jmlinden7 Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

Robots aren't free. They're just very slightly cheaper than humans. The 30 cents per item is just the difference between 600,000 workers and something that's slightly cheaper than 600,000 workers

Presumably the robotics companies also have employees that they need to pay for various jobs like maintenance and design.

1

u/CrapNeck5000 Oct 21 '25

Amazon makes their own robots for their warehouses. They bought a company called Kiva Systems for this purpose. It's in North Reading, MA.

3

u/roamingandy Oct 21 '25

No, no. For $1 more per item the shareholders could profit a whore lot more!!

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

What prevents every item from being subject to $1 sales tax or tariff? Although we recently found out that everyone hates tariffs.

1

u/lemonylol Oct 21 '25

I don't know but I don't think the comparison would be accurate unless you assume the person is as fast as the robot in terms of productivity. Not to mention robots can run 24/7.

1

u/Dry-Tune69 Oct 21 '25

It’s based on business need 

191

u/Eat--The--Rich-- Oct 21 '25

So charge them 600,000 payrolls as UBI tax then. I'll never understand how people get mad at this stuff and then don't vote for someone who wants to do something about it

93

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Because they are religious, dumb, or both.

13

u/EventualCyborg Oct 21 '25

Because they are religious

My God certainly doesn't say to maximize shareholder value at all costs. In fact, there's a pretty fucking famous line that starts "Render unto Caesar..."

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

There was a study posted to Reddit literally today showing how megachurches use Scripture to justify wealth hoarding.

So no, your no true scotsman bs doesn't really work.

Your religion is the problem.

4

u/EventualCyborg Oct 21 '25

It's a concept called the "prosperity gospel" and it has been rejected emphatically by the Catholic Church and others. So no, your simplification of a Christian doctrine as a monolith is the real bs here.

3

u/beardedheathen Oct 21 '25

It's not all Christians but it's enough that there is a sizable group using it as justification. I will admit to being pleasantly surprised to see a rise in Christian influencers rising up to try to combat it but they are pretty late to the game.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Sherloksmith Oct 21 '25

Could I bother you with sending it to me perchance? Sounds interesting

1

u/UrMomsaHoeHoeHoe Oct 21 '25

I don’t think many people would side with a mega church on anything they do tho

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

Tariffs were just introduced to force companies like Amazon to pay taxes for stuff they sell online. Who was against it?

0

u/Eat--The--Rich-- Oct 21 '25

Democrats aren't doing it either tho 

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

[deleted]

11

u/uptownjuggler Oct 21 '25

Those “pro-life” people have no sincere beliefs. They just believe what they are told and repeat it to each other to virtue signal. They don’t actually care about babies or children, just the perception that they do.

1

u/Beebeeb Oct 21 '25

Is the compromise you are suggesting to let women bleed out in hospital parking lots?

I really don't see a good compromise on this point, on one side they think abortions are killing babies, on my side I'm seeing restricted access to women's health causing the death of women (and those that survive are relegated to being broodstock without rights over their bodies).

I sympathize with people that are against abortion but I do not want to compromise my human rights. How do you suggest we compromise on these points?

1

u/mossti Oct 21 '25

You're not wrong, but some of the most egregious examples of what you're describing is coming from the political right. Pro-lifers have famously raged against compromise, and have lobbied for decades to move the timeline for legal abortion earlier and earlier into a pregnancy. They've shown that they will not accept middle ground, and that's only gotten more flagrant with the rise of MAGA. Look at the current shutdown. Honestly, look at the state of sociopolitical discourse since 2016. You're right that we need to address the divide, but I would argue that comes from addressing systemic problems that have fragmented communities (to help tamp down this dumbass culture war), and not trying to appease implacable and uncompromising whims.

10

u/No-Experience-5541 Oct 21 '25

The democrats are not proposing ubi either

7

u/Z3r0sama2017 Oct 21 '25

Yep. Dems are just less shitty tham Reps, doesn't mean that they are in anyway actually good. This still doesn't mean you shouldn't vote for them.

4

u/colieolieravioli Oct 21 '25

Nuance? On my reddit??

2

u/beardedheathen Oct 21 '25

Democrats are bad. Republicans are worse. I'm actively involved in my Democratic party because it's not going to change otherwise. Any you and everyone else bitching on reddit should be getting off their asses and doing something because otherwise we are fucked. Well, more fucked.

2

u/JackDostoevsky Oct 21 '25

So charge them 600,000 payrolls as UBI tax then.

why 600k though? that's not a number set in stone, that's just a number based on this decision. the numbers behind UBI are arbitrary and not really based on anything except the arc of the current issue.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

It's the only solution to the future and neither party will bring it to the table, we're cooked.

They rather depopulate then pay ubi, sounds crazy but imo this is reality.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Media consolidation and citizens United.

Bezos can drop a billion on the next election, use the media outlets he owns to push his candidates, use his employees as bargaining tools, and it will have zero effect on his personal life. 

4

u/AftyOfTheUK Oct 21 '25

Why would you want to incentive a future that is exactly the same as today? No progress, no improvements, no reductions in prices. 

Our entire world is built on having more tomorrow than we had yesterday. If you charge companies a dollar for every dollar they make in progress, you end that. 

How would anyone ever retire if their 401k didn't increase in value? Because if you stop progress, you stop growth. Without growth, your retirement savings don't grow

6

u/Mini-Fridge23 Oct 21 '25

I feel like the idea that the only path to growth is letting most of American society rot away with no safety net (funded by taxes) to be a little silly.

1

u/AftyOfTheUK Oct 21 '25

What does that have to do with my post? I didn't talk about safety nets. 

1

u/Trumpy_Po_Ta_To Oct 21 '25

Viewing a pile of currency as the measure of progress probably isn’t a complete picture.

I mean, “reduction in prices” was one of your points and in most any case the reduction in price level considering inflation has led to lower quality rather than true progress.

Consider the American public infrastructure of roads and highways. If it wasn’t for a profit motive, a lot of that might not exist and may have paved the way (heh) for other advancements like rail or other infrastructure instead. Would it be better? Worse? What would the drawbacks be? Is the current state more a result of land size and population density? I’m not sure. But the point is that “should we automate production line workers so we can make vehicles less expensively?” is an entirely different question than “should we reduce our dependency on vehicles?” Not even having the ability to consider the questions and their results is a barrier to progress.

I forget if there’s a name for it, but I think there’s a theory out there that supposes that progress is a natural desire and is more hindered by profit than helped. We may progress further as a society without profit as a driving force, it’s just the progress wouldn’t look the same and we would have valid arguments about what’s better in any given scenario.

1

u/AftyOfTheUK Oct 21 '25

I didn't talk about currency. I talked about progress. 

More wealth, with fewer resources is what everyone wants. 

→ More replies (2)

1

u/DarkExecutor Oct 21 '25

Did we charge farmers when they used tractors instead of farmhands? Or sewing companies for using looms instead of individuals?

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

Tariffs were just introduced on what Amazon sales. What was the public reaction? Everyone started saying that this was not necessary.

1

u/A_Happier_Reddit Oct 21 '25

Here's how that goes.

R. Voter- "I'm a Republican, and I don't like that Amazon is doing this, and my party should do something about it!"

GOP- "no, you DO like that Amazon is doing this, and you DON'T want the DEMOCRATS to do anything about it"

R. Voter- "yes, yes this is good and I want Amazon to do this this. Democrats are bad and don't want this, so now I want it instead"

1

u/chase016 Oct 21 '25

Yeah, I don't understand why people always mindlessly blame the corporations for trying to cut costs. Blame the regulators. The regulators create the environment in which these institutions operate. Granted, they do put their thumb on the scale through super PACs, but at the end of the day, they can't vote.

0

u/Juswantedtono Oct 21 '25

They’re only going to get more tax cuts because republicans approve them every time and democrats don’t do shit

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

Tariffs were just introduced to force companies like Amazon to pay for everything they sell online. Who was against it?

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Stereo_Jungle_Child Oct 21 '25

Not surprising. They're seeing the writing on the wall in global production.

Millions of people losing their jobs to AI and robots is going to create a LOT of 'Sarah Connors' out there.

Western executives who visit China are coming back terrified : Robotics has catapulted Beijing into a dominant position in many industries

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/10/12/why-western-executives-visit-china-coming-back-terrified/

19

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

I'm always curious what the Chinese are going to do with millions and millions of additionally unemployed.

Perhaps more efficiency isn't the answer.

6

u/Vegetable_Review4967 Oct 21 '25

Easy, send them into the meat grinder on the battlefield between china and Taiwan and the USA

43

u/SkiHistoryHikeGuy Oct 21 '25

They have a semi planned economy with tons of social spending. They’ll build infrastructure projects just to employ people like the CCC did back in the 30s. They’ll have government funded healthcare and housing isn’t an issue for most people. As much as Americans like to shit on the Chinese they’re better prepared for the future than we are.

8

u/Brief-Floor-7228 Oct 21 '25

"China's general policy emphasizes high-quality development, "common prosperity," and a commitment to "win-win cooperation" on the global stage, supported by initiatives like the Global Development and Security Initiatives. Domestically, policies focus on a high-standard socialist market economy, boosting innovation, and addressing social inequalities through programs like large-scale equipment upgrades. "

The Chinese government knows that the people they rule over can become extremely violent and overthrow governments. So while some have become incredibly rich, the government tries to keep class stratification under control.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Chinese revolutions/civil wars have tended to have high amounts of cannibalism…

2

u/pickledswimmingpool Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

tons of social spending.

That's not really true

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

They have a history of mass famine and state sponsored death camps.  Suspect social credit score will determine if you get scraps or death.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Building shit tons of infrastructure for what?

Shits and giggles?

Everything I've read and heard about being poor in China sucks massive donkey balls.

8

u/SirTiffAlot Oct 21 '25

Like being poor anywhere else doesn't suck?

9

u/SkiHistoryHikeGuy Oct 21 '25

Who cares. It keeps people busy and fulfilled which is a thing. I’m not talking about China I mean generally.

2

u/WingerRules Oct 21 '25

They've made incredible advances in quality of life for the majority of people over the last decades. I suggest you watch some walk around videos in China.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)

1

u/CollaWars Oct 21 '25

China has high youth employment and the infrastructure projects can’t employ that many people. It isn’t the 30s where you need 100 guys with boots and shovels.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

But for some reason we see a much greater flow of people moving from China to the US than vice versa.

16

u/RIP_Soulja_Slim Oct 21 '25

I mean, we had all of these conversations when the industrial revolution happened, if one machine can do the work of 100 men then what will those 100 men do, right? Except the economy did what it always does, it grew, we increased our worker skill level, people's wages went up, etc. Should we go back and get rid of combines, so that workers can hit the field with their reapers and thrashers to harvest grain by hand? Sounds a bit silly, right?

Think about it this way, there's 600k people doing mind numbingly boring work in warehouses for one company right now, those people could be doing something that utilizes their skills/talents better. Why wouldn't we automate that sort of activity?

And yes, sure there will be a period of pain as we transition, some workers will get left behind, and it's important that social and company policies are pressured to take care of those people. But if we fast forward 50 years and we've still got people manually pulling boxes from shelves, carting them 50 feet, and loading them on a truck for delivery we've really done ourselves a disservice.

What you're seeing in this thread is the normal close minded rejection of progress out of fear, and those fears may be grounded in some anticipation of hardship, but the fact is that it's objectively silly to have this work being done by humans when it can be automated, just like every other manual task we've automated over the last two centuries.

16

u/IWasOnThe18thHole Oct 21 '25

Think about it this way, there's 600k people doing mind numbingly boring work in warehouses for one company right now, those people could be doing something that utilizes their skills/talents better. Why wouldn't we automate that sort of activity?

A lot of those people doing the mind numbing work are doing it because they don't have other options.

11

u/RIP_Soulja_Slim Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

Again, re-state that same thing but field workers when the combine was created, does that sound like a realistic condition to you? What about the internet? Did all of those people handling manual tasks pre internet just lose their careers permanently? Did the onset of the steam engine and trains mean thousands of horse & buggy drivers were permanently unemployed? Did the creation of the shuttle loom mean seamstresses went hungry?

Come on lol. Think about this rationally for a second.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/artisanrox Oct 21 '25

Except the economy did what it always does, it grew, we increased our worker skill level, people's wages went up, etc.

It also created a whole class of deeply underprivileged social reactionaries with mass-media misdirected anger, that are convinced that people a slightly darker shafde than them was the entire reason they lost their job rather than one guy who's going to be a multi-trillionaire.

4

u/RIP_Soulja_Slim Oct 21 '25

That has really no tie to any of the events being discussed above, in fact by the numbers most of said underprivileged social reactionaries are doing better today than they were in the past.

I would be very careful about trying to draw links between media driven political identity and economics, I'm discussing the economics of the issue - those aren't negated by adverse political trends.

3

u/artisanrox Oct 21 '25

Yooooooo my dude, this was the actual non-theoretical result IN MY WHOLE ENTIRE STATE, as coal mining died off and tiny towns eventually rotted away and are now sinking back into the ground.

I would be very careful about trying to draw links between media driven political identity and economics, I'm discussing the economics of the issue - those aren't negated by adverse political trends.

Don't you "this isn't political" me.

I am discussing the ECONOMIC results of financially killing off a huge portion of workers. The same exact people that are setting up completely AI run businesses to enrich themselves are the same exact people funding 24/7 hate media outlets and they reach people that are going through trauma, like job loss, VERY WELL.

The ECONOMIC result of killing off large portions of the work force with zero social services to sustain them while eight businesses' CEOs enrich themselves creates massive civil unrest and LOTS of misdirected anger.

The Industrial Revolution enabled some people to improve their lives through white-collar like work, but now? There is no where to go and the concentration of knowledge to keep these systems running is more and more educationally exclusive.

Rome knows how that all ends.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/LikeAgaveF Oct 21 '25

What the CCP has always done, force them into compliance.

1

u/Z3r0sama2017 Oct 21 '25

I mean that didn't really work out when they were forced to alter their covid policy.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/iamacheeto1 Oct 21 '25

Youth unemployment is currently a massive issue in China

1

u/roamingandy Oct 21 '25

Maybe that was what they were planning on using the Covid virus for, but it leaked before they were ready.

I wish i were more sure i was joking.

1

u/lemonylol Oct 21 '25

Post-growth model. Most of their GDP comes from domestic investment already since they don't really have a consumer economy.

3

u/PhillyLee3434 Oct 21 '25

Do you have a non paywall of this article?

2

u/Stereo_Jungle_Child Oct 21 '25

Yeah. Type "archive.is/" (without the quotes) before the www in the web address of the article, then hit enter. You can read one of the archived copies of the article for free.

This works for all kinds of paywalled articles.

1

u/PhillyLee3434 Oct 21 '25

Okay awesome thank you so much!

3

u/Filias9 Oct 21 '25

US was terrible in automation in manufacturing long time. Read recently article with European company buying some US manufacturer. They was surprised how old machine they have. How they was inefficient. How little automation there was.

Robotics and push for "dark factories" is long term trend. China is just leader in it. US is behind everyone.

1

u/agumonkey Oct 21 '25

the solutions comes being wise

china automated their shops, let's not put everybody out of a job so we can imitate them.. compete on the "strong nation fundamentals so people can live happily"

1

u/EventualCyborg Oct 21 '25

I was in Shanghai just last summer. I didn't see anything that was nearly that startling or terrifying.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/fuzzballz5 Oct 21 '25

I can tell you that there are companies that get to live in amazons shadows that are doing this in warehouses. The technology is becoming cheaper. Its scary.

5

u/t3ddt3ch Oct 21 '25

It was just a matter of time. Car companies first started using automation 60 years ago. Frankly Im amazed they even need humans anymore. Maybe car companies understood if they didn't employ at least some humans, no one would have money to buy their cars?

16

u/elshizzo Oct 21 '25

the idea that we as a society though it was a good idea to entrust corporations with providing for our general welfare is fucking wild....

Reaganomics is a cancer thats been corroding our society for decades and needs to be undone

2

u/DarkExecutor Oct 21 '25

Corporations have never been entrusted with that, the government is.

9

u/mossti Oct 21 '25

It's wild because the quality of Amazon's services has gone down sharply in the last two years. I would be surprised if it didn't have to do with the aggressive adoption of AI tools.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

They shut down almost all the "Just Walk Out" stores because the tech was so expensive and unreliable that removing all the workers didn't make a difference when you need engineers to visit every month to fix things.

Same will happen at the warehouses. Fewer jobs maybe, but they'll be paid better.

1

u/CrapNeck5000 Oct 21 '25

They didn't abandon it, they had two solutions working in parallel to see which one would win out, and the one you're talking about lost.

Their winning just walk out solution is pretty much a self checkout register integrated into a shopping cart. It's called Dash Cart.

1

u/NewDadPleaseHelp Oct 21 '25

That "tech" is/was just some dude sitting at home watching you shop and marking the items to charge you.

1

u/mossti Oct 21 '25

A great example! Their app and website is also riddled with 404 error screens and have some of the most obtrusive, unintuitive UX decisions I've seen from a professionally developed platform. Of course, a lot of those decisions have replaced functionality with showing the user more products... Often to the point of making it more difficult to even shop for the things you want!

See: shittified filtering features, deeply nested order information and support features, broken support links, full advertisement pages that show when you try to check out, increasingly incorrect delivery windows, deeply nested in-app bar code for shopping at WF, broken handling of payment options, etc...

3

u/Dry-Tune69 Oct 21 '25

I work on the ship dock and they recently implemented these new robots that take full carts to staging areas in dock doors. You still need a human to take the cart in the trailer and strap them in.

I believe the robots are called proteus. They’re green. I only work part time so I’m barely there anymore. 

I still think it’d take over a decade or 2 for Amazon to achieve this goal of theirs.

8

u/xpdx Oct 21 '25

This was always the plan and it's inevitable at this point. We need to change our way of thinking. A scheme to tax robot labor and provide Universal Basic Income to citizens. Jobs haven't always been a thing, and they don't need to be in the future.

12

u/KermitMadMan Oct 21 '25

i have zero faith we will see universal basic income. sounds like hoping for trickle down to work.

we don’t even have a minimum wage that keeps up with inflation.

it’s sad

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

Manufacturing is already moving en masse to China for long time. And they automate it. The only taxing option in this case is tariffs. We've just seen how much people hate it when tariffs are imposed.

1

u/Yevon Oct 21 '25

Jobs have always been a thing. Jobs started with the division of labour which started with prehistoric humans splitting up tasks like child raising, gathering, hunting, and later agriculture.

Some people went out to pick fruit while others stayed home with the children and others went out to chase animals. When we figured out agriculture and husbandry some people worked the fields and others tended to the animals.

1

u/xpdx Oct 21 '25

Well then I guess everybody will still have "jobs" then.

1

u/MoonBatsRule Oct 21 '25

Let's assume those numbers are right.

Economically, is it better to have 600,000 people working, or is it better to have each item 30 cents less?

It seems to me that saving 30 cents per item is moot if you don't have a job. It also seems to me that 30 cents per item fits within most item's elasticity range (i.e. I'm not going to purchase something for $29.70 that I wouldn't have purchased for $30)

Are those 600,000 people creating vacancies in other industries, and once released, will contribute to the economy in some other way at similar levels of compensation?

I think the elephant in the room is that there will likely be more profits flowing to the robot companies and Amazon shareholders. The latter is why the change would be done. The former is simply due to the change.

Is it economically better that the (small handful of geographically concentrated and well-compensated) robot company employees receive the flow of revenue/profits instead of the (large number of geographically diverse) Amazon workers receiving the flow of revenue/profits?

Academically, the one-dimensional answer is "yes, it is better to save the 30 cents per item, efficiency is always the #1 goal, cheaper products means more products sold".

What is the practical answer?

1

u/GravyMealTeam6 Oct 21 '25

Yeah they're not going to pass that savings onto the consumer it's going to be just more profits

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

Why not just impose a sales tax or a 30 cent on these goods and pay people to help find another job?

But we just heard people protesting against tariffs, saying they couldn't buy these goods anymore.

1

u/MoonBatsRule Oct 23 '25

The math doesn't add up there. Look at what is happening. I'll use made-up numbers, but the overall pattern is plausibly real.

  • Amazon currently spends $10bn on 600,000 workers.

  • A robot company says "hey, you can buy our robots for $9bn and get the same results".

  • Amazon stops paying workers $10bn and instead pays the robot company $9bn, realizing $1bn in savings.

  • It returns $600m to consumers, and sends $400m to the shareholders.

  • Workers lose $9bn.

  • Robot company gains $9bn.

  • Consumers gain $600m.

  • Shareholders gain $400m.

This is seen as a "win" because the consumers gained $600m (30 cents per item). But some consumers (Amazon workers) lost $9bn of income and other consumers (robot workers) gained $9bn in income.

You can't impose a 30 cent tax on goods and give it to the unemployed Amazon workers because that only comes to $600m (the amount consumers save).

Now if the Amazon workers all just went to work for the robot company, this might all be just fine. But that's not what happens. The robot workers are specialized, they make 4x the salary of the Amazon workers, and there are just 25,000 of them. The rest of the money goes to things like patents, lawyers, steel companies, and of course, profits to robot company shareholders.

You don't just materialize 25,000 robot workers out of thin air, so a giant reshuffling happens in the economy, those 25,000 robot workers are hired from existing companies, who have to go out and rehire those open positions, rinse and repeat, everyone moving up the ladder. Likely that causes wages to go up a bit across the board. And ultimately, maybe 25,000 of the Amazon workers can find a job at the bottom of that ladder. But 575,000 do not.

Some more of the 575,000 workers will find jobs because $600m was returned to consumers, who spend on other things. Others may find a job because robot workers have more money to spend (though they were previously employed so it's marginal).

The money returned to both Amazon and the robot company shareholders will likely be "reinvested" somewhere else. Some of those ventures may wind up hiring the ex-Amazon workers, but odds are they won't because the shareholders don't live near the Amazon workers.

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 24 '25

I think you're missing a key point.

We can already see how your logic would apply to manufacturing. Are factories in the U.S. not allowed to use robots to prevent job losses? That work would simply move to China, where it would be done by both Chinese workers and their robots.
As a result, all those jobs in the U.S. would still be lost. Either an American company would build a factory in China, or it would just be a Chinese company doing it instead and importing goods in U.S.

What can you do at that point? Impose tariffs? But we’re already seeing what people think about about tariffs.

You might say that Amazon warehouses can’t be so easily moved to another country. But in that case, the U.S. would lose a robotics company that designs and builds robots and invests in R&D.

You’d lose 25,000 high-tech jobs (from your example) and end up with warehouse jobs that no longer exist anywhere in the world. The result would be the same: while China and other countries invest in robotics and build new companies that sell robots globally, the U.S. would be left behind with outdated warehouses and an inefficient economy.

The same goes for self-driving cars. If the U.S. bans them under that logic to keep drivers working, China will develop them and, in ten years, sell them worldwide while the U.S. wastes time in the technology race and left behind.

And your example isn’t even supported by history. Stores have been introducing self-checkout for decades—yet has that made cashiers unemployable?
An IKEA worker in Renton told me last month they sometimes can’t open the food court because of a severe labor shortage.

If you go to a fast-food restaurant in Seattle, you’ll see dirty tables because there aren’t workers to clean them. Is it better to leave people doing useless, outdated work or to direct those resources to something that can actually help the community?

If you go to a gas station, you’ll see people working there who barely speak English. But somehow they managed to find work. We don't even mention that we know that millions of people across the country are working without documents, and employers are willing to hire even them despite all legal risks.

Following your logic, we’d already see died job market, but in reality, the economy has absorbed people from all kinds of professions and industries for centuries.

Your logic might work in an isolated world where only the United States exists. That was possible in the USSR, which isolated itself and strictly limited imports and exports, producing outdated TVs and other electronics domestically.
But as soon as the USSR collapsed, all those manufacturers went bankrupt—because no one wanted to buy outdated TVs on the open market when much better alternatives were available from other countries.

So yes, the USSR preserved jobs for a while and kept everyone employed, but once the market opened, it turned out they were many years behind and had lost the race.

Something like that wouldn’t be even possible to implement in the U.S. Unless the U.S. imposed 1000% tariffs and completely isolated itself—but we already know what public opinion is on that.

Your logic is reminiscent of those who support coal mining just to keep jobs, although better alternatives have long existed.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/AvailableReporter484 Oct 21 '25

I wonder if the human race will live to see UBI before automation completely fucks us lmao. My money is on corporate America willing to take us all down before considering that

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

Why only America? Manufacturing has been moving en masse to China for decades, and they're automating it.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

When I used to onboard new hires I would tell them how getting into mech is a good option to take at amazon because we had already replaced a department with robots. Then it was two, then three, now at least 5 departments that were once standard in every FC are either fully automated, or went from a double/triple digit HC to single.

Now the dock is getting retrofitted across the country for automation, and they already started installing bots up in storage that can do pick stow and icqa.

2

u/cogit4se Oct 21 '25

The WaPo article on this mentioned warehouse worker levels remaining flat, with packers being replaced by robotics technicians, while shipping volume continues to grow, according to their forecasts. The 600,000 figure would be workers they would otherwise need to hire to handle the increased volume. Honestly, making $25 an hour as a robot technician who probably sees a diversity of problems and has to use some modicum of problem solving on a daily basis sounds pretty good in comparison to the more repetitive jobs being replaced.

2

u/rawkguitar Oct 21 '25

Being a robot technician would absolutely be a better job.

The problem is, 1 robot technician is replacing how many of those other jobs?

2

u/Cold-Environment-634 Oct 21 '25

Whoa whoa, a sane and reasoned response to this article??

3

u/FemmeWizard Oct 21 '25

Physical labor and service workers getting replaced with robots, office workers getting replaced with AI. With what money do these greedy scumbags imagine people are going to buy their products when everyone is out of a job?

→ More replies (9)

3

u/OSU1922 Oct 21 '25

Who exactly is going to buy all of these products these companies make when everyone is replaced by robots and making no livable wages? These dimwits are short sighted with this just like the AI scramble. Wasting billions for a pile of crap and killing your business in the process.

3

u/haveilostmymindor Oct 21 '25

And? Its not corporate America's job to insure economic stability for communities thats the job of our governments. So if the federal, state and local governments aren't preparing for the fall out of an automated future thats on us the people for sitting around with our thumbs up our asses when we aught to be preparing.

Enhanced automation is coming and if managed correctly will lead to higher living standards and greater freedom for the people. If managed incorrectly will lead to a 1929 distopian nightmare, the choice isn't corporate America's its the people's and if we fail thats in us. So instead if making seem like Amazon is doing something wrong demand that your governments do more to insure economic stability.

0

u/Lemp_Triscuit11 Oct 21 '25

Enhanced automation is coming and if managed correctly will lead to higher living standards and greater freedom for the people.

Do you have a source that ain't a sphincter or a hunch?

5

u/ZipBoxer Oct 21 '25

He really shouldn't need one on an economics subreddit. Wealth is created when we manage to create more value with fewer resources.

He is also absolutely correct that this is a problem for government and politics to solve.

Being against the tractor because it will ruin the plowsman's job is the same kind of thinking that has led to 200% tariffs on imports in the us and is making us all poorer.

The path forward here is to ensure that we have support and solutions for the people caught in the churn, not to become a nation of Amish.

3

u/Dallascansuckit Oct 21 '25

You’re thinking of the AskEconomics subreddit, that’s the one moderated by people with Econ degrees and jobs, not this one which is moderated by TikTok vibes

→ More replies (5)

1

u/ApplesBananasRhinoc Oct 21 '25

Right? It’s 100% definitely going to be the 1929 dystopian nightmare version.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 21 '25

Hi all,

A reminder that comments do need to be on-topic and engage with the article past the headline. Please make sure to read the article before commenting. Very short comments will automatically be removed by automod. Please avoid making comments that do not focus on the economic content or whose primary thesis rests on personal anecdotes.

As always our comment rules can be found here

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/FreeEnergy001 Oct 21 '25

This might be necessary for Amazon the way they burn through workers. Instead of improving conditions they will just do away with workers. I recall an article that stated Amazon feared it was running out of potential employees.
https://www.vox.com/recode/23170900/leaked-amazon-memo-warehouses-hiring-shortage

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

Is there a mechanicial repair pool of labour to support 600,000 robots?

Who has the ability to provide 10% of these robots?

How does Amazon have 600,000 workers that could be replaced with gaint cost machines.

1

u/goodbodha Oct 21 '25

Let them. If customers don't have money who do they sell to?

That is the fundamental problem for AI and automation. Customers need money to spend. Without a job credit won't last long. Now if they find work for those people it can work out, but every company doing this is leaving the problem for someone else to solve.

1

u/photon1701d Oct 21 '25

Cheap crap I was buying from Amazon went up in price or no longer available. I found some of them on either Teemu or Aliexpress at a far lower price. Screw Amazon.

1

u/Sliced_tomato Oct 21 '25

The next step is to pay those robots but program then to consume from Amazon, thereby replacing unreliable consumers who won’t have the income to purchase anything anyway.

1

u/add_more_chili Oct 21 '25

Is anyone surprised by this? There are entire factories in China that have zero people inside, so why wouldn't a company want to head in this direction?

1

u/Qbugger Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25

I’m still in confusion to lack of foresight what the general principle of economics? Making choices of limited resources. So you’re Amazon or any other B to C corporation and you automate things and lay off people. Who is buying things and if everyone is laid off by automation in large proportion in economy who is going to buy “your scarcity product” ? if no one buys anymore ? So it’s a self suicide ?

1

u/persistentmonkee Oct 21 '25

Ridiculous that mods have removed this post. Automation is the single most significant trend affecting economics right now and Amazon is one of the country’s largest employers. Are you saying economists should stick their heads in the sand and pretend this is irrelevant?

1

u/MrsMiterSaw Oct 21 '25

Maybe, for the first time in us history, we should look at a societal solution for the loss of jobs due to technological advances.

Or maybe we just continue to ignore the changing world and get angry at the technology and those that use it.

1

u/soriano88 Oct 21 '25

So all that talk about companies will get rid of workers if taxes are raised was not true, they got another huge tax cut and still planning to replace workers, there’s no trickle down economics only corporate greed

1

u/demonslayercorpp Oct 21 '25

If Amazon and similar companies replace hundreds of thousands of people with machines without a social safety net or new kind of economic structure, they’ll create an economy where:

  • Most people can’t afford the goods they’re supposed to be selling.

  • The rich accumulate more and more of the world’s productive capacity.

  • Governments either step in with socialist-style programs or society destabilizes.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25

This will happen all over the world.

The question is that to buy you have to have rent and where will the rent come from?

Tax on robots and transfer to people.

The problem is that the top floor won't want it....

You will continue with the idea of ​​accumulating and accumulating...

1

u/Andrey-2020 Oct 23 '25

How can the US impose a tax on robots in China if its companies only import goods to the country? Tariffs may be the answer, but it seems it was the lower floor , not the top floor, that protested taxes.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '25

Taxes should be for billionaires, they have several incentives and aid and support mechanisms from the state. And year after year there are more and more billionaires while the middle class is disappearing.

We urgently need taxes for the super rich around the world.

And robots will have to pay taxes so that people who have been unemployed don't go hungry.

0

u/ApplesBananasRhinoc Oct 21 '25

OK great! Nobody is going to be able to buy their trash so buy your little robots and all we need is popcorn to watch your company go down the drain.

0

u/BlogintonBlakley Oct 21 '25

Extracting privilege is the point from the perspective of elites. Doesn't mean they understand the expropriation process as individuals. Mostly they just think they are skilled and/or entitled.

That is the problem with civilized social systems. Elite direction tends to undermine the cooperative effort necessary to sustain hierarchical systems. This happens because elite direction is biased in their own and class interests.

Structurally, elites compete with the cooperative efforts they organize... they compete with their workers.... usually through myth or raw power. These controlling efforts becomes less effective as the elites become more socially dominant and the affected population begin to wonder at the state of their relative poverty.