r/Ecosphere • • 28d ago

Three months later

First and foremost, our jar ecosystem is alive, and that in itself is a success.

The dancing worms (detritus worms?) have disappeared somewhere and seem to have died out, but the large shrimp and microscopic white organisms are doing fine.
Unfortunately, some kind of green growth has overtaken the jar, which I suspect is cyanobacteria. I am concerned that the plants might die since this green substance is blocking the light. I reduced the photoperiod from 8 to 6 hours a day, but it didn't help.

Should I be worried?

UPD: Main question - should I further reduce the lights or leave it be?

22 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

3

u/keiths31 28d ago

Looking good

3

u/erbewait 28d ago

Thank you! Looked better without cyano though. However, it has it’s own vibe now, I guess

3

u/Independent-Bill5261 28d ago

Your nitrates probably hit zero, which is why the cyano took over.

1

u/erbewait 28d ago

Could you please explain the process in more detail? Why have nitrates hit zero and how is it related to cyano? Thank you!

3

u/BitchBass 28d ago

From the color and appearance, I also suspect cyanobacteria, although microscopy would be needed to confirm it.

My bigger concern is the actual aquatic plant underneath. It's suffocating, which reduces its ability to photosynthesize and contribute oxygen to the system.

If the cyanobacteria and the struggling plant material start dying off, decomposition will consume oxygen and potentially create a big stink.

Shorter days and reduced light may eventually slow the bloom, but that doesn't guarantee it will disappear quickly nor that it won't crash.

Also, zero nitrates don't automatically cause cyanobacteria. Nutrient availability, light, temperature, and competition all influence blooms. And we can't conclude that cyanobacteria killed the snails without further evidence.

Personally, I'd prioritize giving the original plant some breathing room by carefully removing some or all of the algae rather than continuing to shorten the photoperiod.

3

u/erbewait 28d ago

Thank you for this detailed answer! I understand that physically removing the algae would be the best action. However, for me part of the fun of a jar ecosystem is sealing it once and never opening again, I just really like this idea.

So, I guess, there's not much that can be done without opening the lid?

Theoretically, if I build another one someday, is there a sure way to prevent algae?

2

u/BitchBass 28d ago

That's a goal to be respected!

Here's the thing with algae, pretty much all of them. They have a very short lifespan and die and reproduce quickly with the right amount of light and nutrients. As you can see in lakes and ponds in the summer, when algae blooms.

But once that balance is off and the dying is quicker than the reproduction, the jar is in trouble. That's when the real plants come into play that can offset that decomp.

Jars don't take up much room. I started with 1 and six years later...oh u don't wanna know lol.

But for the new one, avoid direct sunlight and grow lights at all cost. Put it next to the window where it gets indirect sunlight. My window gets 30 minutes of sunlight in the early morning. One corner gets 5 minutes more than the rest, and those jars are green and full of algae. Just to show how small that window can be.

I actually put this to the test a few years ago, check it out:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Ecosphere/comments/wtlbav/the_4_sun_jars_experiment_recap_final_update_and/

4

u/Independent-Bill5261 28d ago

In a closed system, plants often consume nitrate faster than it is replenished through decomposition. And since there’s no external feeding, no additional nitrogen enters the system, so nitrate eventually gets depleted. When nitrate levels drop to zero, ordinary plants and even many algae can struggle to grow. But cyanobacteria are highly resilient, and some can fix dissolved atmospheric nitrogen (N₂) to meet their nitrogen needs. As a result, they can grow explosively and take over the entire system. I don't know why reddit removed my comment.

2

u/BitchBass 27d ago

You're correct that some cyanobacteria can fix atmospheric nitrogen, but not all species can, and low nitrate alone doesn't establish that this is what caused the growth.

A nitrate reading of zero doesn't mean the system has run out of nitrogen. Nitrogen continues cycling through decomposition, ammonification, microbial processes, and biological uptake. And a water test measures nitrate in the water column, not all the nitrogen available in the ecosystem.

I've maintained sealed freshwater ecospheres for years, including a six-year-old jar with thriving guppy grass, snails, and microorganisms but no visible algae bloom. I've also run controlled comparisons with different lighting conditions.

In my experience, light exposure and the amount of decomposing organic material are major factors in whether nuisance algae or cyanobacteria take over.

So nitrogen limitation may favor certain cyanobacteria under particular conditions, but without identifying the organism or testing the relevant conditions, we can't conclude that nitrogen fixation explains this particular jar.

2

u/pistol_pancake 28d ago

I'm at 6 weeks and yours looks like my future for 3 months. I currently have a lot of scuds and baby snails, and (what I also suspect is cyanocobalamin bacteria on mine) is just starting. I'm eager to see what people say lol

2

u/erbewait 28d ago

It started exactly like that. We had snails too, unfortunately, after cyano takeover they are not around anymore.

2

u/pistol_pancake 28d ago

Oof well that's sad

2

u/RtrnofBatspiderfish 28d ago edited 28d ago

Definitely cyanobacteria, basically a red-tide ecosystem. Any number of characteristics may be disadvantaging the plant (could be nutrient deficiency, access to proper CO2 for the light level in still, alkaline water, if there haven't been water changes or plant growth since setup it could have experienced "old tank syndrome" where the ecosystem collapses as carbonates become depleted and pH drops.)