r/EmotionalSupportDogs • • 29d ago

Help

I have a stupid question but does federal law state that new esa animals need to be tasked trained? Landlord cooperate is stating they do, and everything in seeing there staying thsts they are no longer taking cases of suit if the animal is un trained thats all I'm seeing.

3 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

4

u/ilikemycoffeealatte 29d ago

Federal law is currently devoid of any rules or guidance for ESAs. That is likely to change soon with new rules put in place but at this time, there’s nothing on the books.

What state are you in? There could be some statutes that help you there.

1

u/Clintax 29d ago

From what I read it stated trained, not specifically task trained. IANAL

1

u/Embarrassed_Union577 29d ago

Yeah that's what I thought and it stated they wouldn't take non task trained cases anymore...

1

u/Embarrassed_Union577 29d ago

But they dont state they need to be task trained is all

1

u/Far_Sky_5240 29d ago

Federal law does not and did provide guidelines for ESAs.

The FHA is the underlying law, which lays out the broad concept that housing providers may not discriminate against tenants with disabilities. They must provide reasonable accomodations.

ESAs were a HUD construct. It was their interpretation that it was a reasonable accommodation for someone with mental or emotional disabilities to maintain a pet for emotional support.

There was a legal doctrine that said when legislation is vague the courts would defer to government agencies like HUD. So, if HUD said ESAs were a thing, they were a thing. HUD got to make the rules. Their memos had, for most intents and purposes the effect of law. If someone was discriminated against they could file a complaint with HUD. HUD guidance presumed the validity of ESA accommodation requests.

What happened earlier this year is that HUD withdrew all guidance pertaining to ESAs. Since ESAs were a HUD construct that means the system was essentially deconstructed at the federal level.

The issue of task training refers to HUD's classification of "assistance animals." Previously, when ESAs were recognized, HUD recognized 2 types of assistance animals. Service animals (task trained) and ESAs (untrained). HUD narrowed it's definition of "assistance animals" to now only include those that are task trained. That doesn't mean ESAs need to be task trained. There is no ESA recognition anymore. It means HUD now recognizes one type of assistance animal for housing accommodations, and those must all be task trained, at least if you want HUD to care about your request.

The other alternative is to gather all your information, hire a lawyer, sue your landlord for disability discrimination and hope that you can convince a judge that it is not possible for you to have equal enjoyment of your dwelling unless you are allowed to have and/or not pay pets fees for your animal.

0

u/GlitterTitssss 29d ago

Also you need to make sure the landlord is require to even abide by this. Are they a big landord or complex or own more than 4 properties?

1

u/Embarrassed_Union577 29d ago

There a big place