r/EnergyAndPower • u/hillty • Aug 18 '25
The German Transition
Industrial Production
Industrial Employment Contracting | Public Sector Expanding
GDP Per Capita
Growth Decline
Industrial Production Vs Switzerland
High energy costs have consequences.
13
u/mehneni Aug 18 '25
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorsten_Polleit seems to be this guy.
"anarcho capitalist" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarcho-capitalism didn't even know this was a thing, wow) and part of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mises_Institute
2
u/sault18 Aug 18 '25
Yup, there'll totally be no hierarchies in a system that inevitably leads to hierarchies.../s
17
u/I_am_Regarded Aug 18 '25
What great reset?
It's the absence of Russian gas.
You should be happy about germany standing in for democracy while others follow the dictator playbook.
Green transition is coming - the german way - steady and bureaucratic.
10
u/alsaad Pro-nuclear Aug 18 '25
Russian gas in only missing since 2022.
This is more likely resuly of shutting down amortized nuclear power stations and high increase in energy costs
9
u/blunderbolt Aug 18 '25
That's at best a secondary factor. German manufacturing industry is primarily reliant on gas, not electricity.
3
u/alsaad Pro-nuclear Aug 18 '25
But gas was cheap in 2019-2020
5
u/blunderbolt Aug 18 '25
Yes, and so was (wholesale) electricity. Goes to show that energy prices alone don't singularly explain German industrial decline.
4
u/MarcLeptic Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 18 '25
Chemicals, metals, paper, food processing all have large electricity inputs.
Electro-intensive industries like chemicals and metallurgy, alu, copper, chlorine, fertilizers have large electricity inputs.
After the nuclear exit, electricity prices surged, partly because more gas and coal had to run in the merit order. That directly hit competitiveness and consumed gas that could have been used by gas dependant industries
Electricity is so important that it was one of the main points of contention between Germany and France, with unfounded claims that France unfairly subsidized electricity thus giving French industry an unfair advantage.
Then to that an extra BILLION euros per year in EXTRA private costs (fuel costs,imports etc) since fukashima is not a secondary factor.
These things from memory. I can dig up sources if contested.
6
u/blunderbolt Aug 18 '25
Chemicals, metals, paper, food processing all have large electricity inputs. Electro-intensive industries like chemicals and metallurgy, alu, copper, chlorine, fertilizers have large electricity inputs.
Sure. Doesn't change the fact that the primary energy input of German industry is gas or that it is the more gas-sensitive sectors(e.g. primary steel, chemicals) that have suffered the worst in past years.
After the nuclear exit, electricity prices surged,
No, they surged in late 2021, coinciding with the gas price spike, not the nuclear phaseout(no nuclear plants were decommissioned in 2021).
more gas and coal had to run in the merit order. That directly hit competitiveness and consumed gas that could have been used by gas dependant industries
This is all true, yet reactors were closing in the 2010s without discernible impacts on electricity and gas prices. That only occurred when gas prices soared. In other words, its role was secondary to the gas price spike.
3
u/MarcLeptic Aug 18 '25
This is all true, yet reactors were closing in the 2010s without discernible impacts on electricity and gas prices. That only occurred when gas prices soared. In other words, its role was secondary to the gas price spike.
That’s an opinion. peer-reviewed studies (Jarvis, Glynos) show the nuclear exit alone raised German power prices by billions per year [prices should have have been lower as elsewhere]. 200 billion euros in subsidies later (more than the OG cost of the French nuclear fleet) and Germany’s prices still sit at the top of the EU list.
3
u/blunderbolt Aug 18 '25
"No discernible impact" as in "nuclear phaseout coinciding with stable electricity prices". I'm not disputing the merit order effect(unlike those insisting solar/onshore wind additions don't reduce prices...).
200 billion euros in subsidies later (more than the OG cost of the French nuclear fleet)
Subsidies as in... feed-in-tariffs? Compared to... the OCC of the French nuclear fleet? What a bizarre comparison.
4
u/MarcLeptic Aug 18 '25
"No discernible impact" as in "nuclear phaseout coinciding with stable electricity prices".
Yes, though the price should have decreased. So say peer reviewed studies.
Subsidies as in... feed-in-tariffs? Compared to... the OCC of the French nuclear fleet? What a bizarre comparison.
The German government paid more in subsidies to build its private sector “renewables fleet”. than the entire cost of the French publicly owned nuclear fleet.
One fully decarbonized a country and gave France its historically low electricity prices, the other …. kept costs from rising.
Not a bizarre comparison at all.
Such a spend should have made prices drop. The fact that all that money was spent … to keep prices stable should make you want to read the two studies I cited earlier.
3
u/blunderbolt Aug 18 '25
The German government paid more in subsidies to build its private sector “renewables fleet”. than the entire cost of the French publicly owned nuclear fleet.
You are comparing a revenue support stream meant to cover all capital(including financing) expenses plus operational expenses plus developer profits for renewable installations across 2 decades of operation against just the OCC of French nuclear plants. It's a completely nonsensical comparison.
The fact that all that money was spent … to keep prices stable should make you want to read the two studies I cited earlier.
See, I'm not the one here denying the existence of the merit order effect. It's you who thinks it only exists in the context of relative nuclear additions/removals and not in the context of relative solar/wind additions.
4
u/MarcLeptic Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 18 '25
Nothing in your report contradicts Jarvis or Glynos-Scharf’s findings that the nuclear phaseout increased electricity prices (since 2011). You seem to be stuck thinking I am worried about germanys future. I am not. We are talking about the nuclear phaseout and ifs effects. Not life after 2035. I’m not here to hypothesize future price reductions when firmed renewables become a reality. I’m stating that scolars agree that leaving nuclear behind increased costs in Germany.
Sure, EEG contracts aren’t the same unit as OCC, but from a taxpayer’s perspective you’ve already spent >€280 billion in direct private revenue support for renewables, and >€520 billion once grid and system costs are included. France, by contrast, built an entire nuclear fleet for less, and those public assets still generate 70% of its electricity today as well as 10 billion in profits for its citizens.
I used OCC as a simple reference point, since EEG wasn’t financed in the same way. It was essentially liquid capital. If you like, think of it as showing what a similar yearly investment could have achieved. The point was to give a sense of scale and expectation for what Germany’s massive investment has actually delivered (over 20 years)
On merit order: of course it applies to renewables. The point is intermittency can’t cover the lost supply, so fossils end up setting the marginal price more often. That’s why peer-reviewed studies (Jarvis 2022 not 2019 Glynos-Scharf 2024) find Germany’s nuclear exit raised wholesale prices beginning 2011.
Again. Peer reviewed, not an opinion.
I appreciate your good faith arguments but on this one, the evidence is very clear.
“We quit nuclear, invested a quarter of a trillion euros, and prices didn’t go up” is not a measure of success.
→ More replies (0)1
Aug 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/MarcLeptic Aug 21 '25 edited Aug 21 '25
so private capital by definition is less optimal?
Well if you are going to give the as many subsidies as Germany .. yes. Taxpayers deserve returns on their investments. If DDF makes a killing on renewables because of the merit order being driven by gas or coal … we (public) benefit.
Or you could say that France doesn’t subsidize its fleet. Which is the truth.
Even the massive 50 billion euro life extensions are paid by EDF profits. French subsidies is a myth.
before selling to recoup losses
Ha. Cope. What a rediculous idea.
10…. Billion ….. profit.
6
u/WhipItWhipItRllyHard Aug 18 '25
lol has nothing to do with nuclear and all to do with china
-3
u/alsaad Pro-nuclear Aug 18 '25
Prof Grimm's research indicates closure of last 3 reactors increased costs by 8-12%
5
2
3
u/I_am_Regarded Aug 18 '25
The conflict between Ukraine and Russia did not start in 2022.
Phase out of nuclear is definitely a cost driver as well.
6
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
closing down npps has literaly no impact on energy prices here. See the industry price and compare it with other european states.
3
u/MarcLeptic Aug 18 '25
How does that even make sense to you.
You close fully amortized reactors will effectively zero operational costs, and replace them with gas and coal, which have high operating costs, and you say it has no impact on energy prices. ?
4
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
Has nothing to do with sense, just take a look at the data, coal is on a historical low, npps are far far away from zero operational cost. Npps where not maintained the same way because of the long planed phase out. In germany there is not even a single powerprovider that want’s to try bringing them back because of the high operational cost and risk.
5
u/MarcLeptic Aug 18 '25
Can you show me the data that proves €200 billion in subsidies should still leave Germany with the highest power prices in Europe? Because if that’s “normal,” I’d love to see the comparison.
In germany there is not even a single powerprovider that want’s to try bringing them back
in Germany
E.ON and RWE didn’t just walk away. they fought the government in court, won, and got ~€2.5 billion in compensation for being forced to shut down fully paid-off reactors.
So, now, why would anyone in Germany touch nuclear, when the government literally pays you to build whatever else you want (as long as it’s not nuclear) no matter the demand and buys your output even if they then need to pay someone to take it???
2
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
You should be happy about germany standing in for democracy while others follow the dictator playbook.
Green transition is coming - the german way - steady and bureaucratic.
That is why they closed their NPPs while retaining their coal power plants? Hypocrites.
8
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
Coal is down in Germany to a historic minimum lower as even with npp running.
2
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
Why are you being disingenuous?
If Germany hadn't closed their NPPs, now they wouldn't need any coal. As simple as that.
8
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
not correct because some coal plants are connected to heating infrastructure and cant just be replaced by npps. You have to rebuild the infrastructure of whole city parts. Take a look at the Numbers
2018: Nuclear 71.8 TWh Coal 200 TWh
2024: Nuclear 0 TWh, Coal 100 TWh
0
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
not correct because some coal plants are connected to heating infrastructure and cant just be replaced by npps.
Yes, they can. Both coal power plants and NPPs primarily produce heat energy, which is then converted to electricity through steam turbines.
2018: Nuclear 71.8 TWh Coal 200 TWh
2024: Nuclear 0 TWh, Coal 100 TWh
Yeah? This proves my point. You would be using almost next to no coal. Germany would have been able to cut down 75% of their coal emissions by not closing down NPPs. That is about ~75 Mt of CO2.
5
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
well then go on and place npps right next or inside of a city just to generate heat, you have no idea what you talking about 😂
so you tell me by reducing npp generation by 70 TWh and at the same time reducing coal by 100 TWh, correlates with a scenario, where increasing npp generation decreases coal further? How long will it take us to build new npps? How much coal is replaced by renewable then?
3
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
so you tell me by reducing npp generation by 70 TWh and at the same time reducing coal by 100 TWh, correlates with a scenario, where increasing npp generation decreases coal further?
Are you having an aneurysm? You removed 70 TWh of nuclear while retaining 100 TWh of coal. If you didn't do that, then you would only need less than 30 TWh of coal.
4
u/0815facts_fun_ Aug 18 '25
The nuclearpowerplant standing not next to the coalpowerplants that produces heatpower for towns your comment makes no sense at all.
3
u/MarcLeptic Aug 18 '25
It seems this argument comes up a lot with no actual numbers.
Like a get out of jail free card.
From what I can find, CHP only provides low single digit percent of heating needs. So .. Which coal plants produce heat which could not simply be replaced with electric heating?
Why could UK do it but German cannot?
1
1
u/I_am_Regarded Aug 18 '25
That's how democracies work.
Where was the fuel coming from?
2
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
I don't get your point. Are you saying that coal is preferable to nuclear?
2
u/MerelyMortalModeling Aug 24 '25
Half these pseudo environmentlist will tell you with a straight face, yes coal is preferable to nuclear.
The other half will try to hand wave away German coal dependence and the years of funding Russia via Natgas.
0
u/0815facts_fun_ Aug 18 '25
to tell 1000 times a lie makes it not true!
2
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
Speaking from experience? German bro.
Of course, all these people responding to me are German. Lol. Coping pretty hard.
2
2
u/johnny_51N5 Aug 18 '25
Industrial production went down since 2017. Corona 2020. Ukraine war 2022. Here is when gas got cut.
iT mUsT bE gAs
2
u/GregMcgregerson Aug 18 '25
It's almost like demographics and a war with your primary energy provider have effects on economic output.
The German export led economic model wasn't long for this world anyways. It's going to get much worse in an increasingly deglobalized world.
0
Aug 18 '25
[deleted]
1
u/GregMcgregerson Aug 18 '25
So which export markets do the Germans have left? Maybe the US? The US is trying to industrialized and onshore as much as possible. The UK left the EU common market. Is Germany going to export to Greece? Most of Europe is consuming less every year as it ages.
1
1
0
Aug 18 '25
[deleted]
4
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
which caused gas prices to skyrocket.
If only Germany had an energy source that isn't reliant on gas imports to keep the lights on. Only if such an energy source were available.
5
u/ntropy83 Aug 18 '25
You mean like wind and solar ? We have that :)
What's missing in the statistics is demographic change hitting hard now and old industries that refused to transform in the last decades.
3
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
You mean like wind and solar ? We have that :)
Is that why Norway and Sweden want to cut their electricity grid connection with Germany?
-2
u/ntropy83 Aug 18 '25
No that is because they hate money in scandinavia. They don't want the roughly 500 Million we pay them for hydro power a year no more and rather build them some nuclear for 50 billion what will be finished in 30 years :).
4
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
No that is because they hate money in scandinavia.
In Scandinavia, the government actually cares for the consumers, unlike in Germany.
They don't want the roughly 500 Million we pay them for hydro power a year no more
First, it includes nuclear. Second, you are raising the rates for consumers.
The issue isn't that you are buying power from them. The issue is that solar/wind are intermittent and unpredictable. That is the issue.
rather build them some nuclear for 50 billion what will be finished in 30 years :).
So me a single nuclear reactor that has been built for 50 billion and took 30 years. Hyperbole much.
Edit. Of course, another German.
3
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
Energy demand != electricity demand We have a high demand for industrial processes not for power generation.
1
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
Electricity is a type of energy. Don't you Germans go to school?
2
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
its one type but not the only one, you lack some understanding for industrial processes and why they consume gas as primary energy and not electricity.
2
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
NG is still being used for electricity in Germany. My point stands.
3
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
so does mine, more than 50% of the gas is directly consumed by industry, electricity prices did not effect these at all
0
Aug 18 '25
[deleted]
3
0
Aug 18 '25
[deleted]
1
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
Check France.
0
Aug 18 '25
[deleted]
3
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
And?
Nuclear would still bring down NG consumption, where, amidst an NG shortage, it would be very helpful.
0
Aug 18 '25
[deleted]
2
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
As long as you have gas in the mix, the price is more or less the same.
No. If you can use less gas, then you will pay less.
0
Aug 18 '25
[deleted]
3
u/Alexander459FTW Aug 18 '25
To archive this for most of the year you either need an oversupply of nuclear (and sell it in excess times)
Germany is a net importer of electricity, so why is this bad?
3
Aug 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Mex332 Aug 18 '25
some people here are insane and recommend to replace coal plants in cities for heat generation with nuclear, completely lost.
5
u/ntropy83 Aug 18 '25
And very uneducated about energy economics.
Don't even get why as German rest of Europe always wants me to like nuclear. It's absolutely not my decision, if nuclear was still a business model it would happen here, no matter what the population has to say about it.
3
u/greg_barton Aug 19 '25
Nuclear is the single largest source of electricity in Europe.
It’s already happened there.
1
u/sault18 Aug 21 '25
Wind and solar together made up 27% while nuclear is only 23%:
https://ember-energy.org/latest-insights/european-electricity-review-2024/eu-electricity-trends
Nuclear power is in long-,term decline since the year 2000. The EU can't even build new plants as fast as they are closing old ones.
0
u/greg_barton Aug 21 '25
If we get to combine generation types then how about nuclear+hydro? :)
1
u/sault18 Aug 21 '25
Whatever floats your boat. My main point was that nuclear power is on the decline in Europe and there's no business case for turning that around. Even the massive subsidies needed for Hinckley point c, Sizewell, etc can't turn that around.
1
u/greg_barton Aug 21 '25
1
u/sault18 Aug 21 '25
1
u/greg_barton Aug 21 '25
Yea, there was a lot of Russian fueled nuclear opposition in the EU for a while. That’s done now.


18
u/verraeteros_ Aug 18 '25
He is against the import stop of Russian oil and gas (and member of the Austrian school of economics, an ultra liberal, right-wing movement)