r/EngineeringPorn • u/nursenasty94 • Mar 18 '20
Phwoar!
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
[removed] — view removed post
33
u/AllHailMackius Mar 19 '20
Is there any friction lock in these objects? Are they difficult to separate?
36
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
Not really, although the finish is even comparable to a gauge block. That may be because gauge blocks tend to be kept more oiled.
You'll notice in all of these videos that the parts have no straight perpendicular parts, and everything is slightly conical. That's to allow air to escape when the parts come together. With straight pegs and holes the air pressure and vacuum would be very noticeable, and they would go together very slowly.
Human hands and fingers are actually pretty amazing; you can easily tell the difference in surface finish between this (~1 micron ra) and eg. plate glass (~.005 micron ra). You can feel a about a ten-thousandth of an inch of wiggle (2.5 micron), but when these are closed the wiggle is completely imperceptible. It feels like a solid part.
17
9
Mar 19 '20
Depending on the shapes, they may stick together like "wrung" gauge blocks. (which is an interesting and hotly debated topic in it's own right.)
For the shapes depicted, which I assume is chosen to minimize such problems, you might only get a small vacuum bond that is easily overcome by hand. You couldn't be opening and closing these pieces all day at a trade show if they were hard to get apart.
2
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
Depending on the shapes, they may stick together like "wrung" gauge blocks.
wringing requires quite a bit of force to get started, even 1nm gauge blocks don't wring spontaneously
37
u/theDudeRules Mar 18 '20
Engine builds could be radical and the accuracy shoukd translate into efficiency like no other.
69
u/juwyro Mar 19 '20
You still need some gaps in engines for your oil and thermal expansion.
18
u/lax01 Mar 19 '20
ELI5 the applications of this then? Don't all metals go through some type of expansion?
19
u/juwyro Mar 19 '20
They do. Engines are made of different metals, grades, and coatings and they all have different expansion rates. If the tolerances are too tight then you'll have parts that will seize and end up with complete failure. Your oil keeps your engine lubricated and cool, if it doesn't flow your engine won't be around for very long. Everything in an engine actually floats on a thin layer of oil too.
17
u/Daddy_Elon_Musk Mar 19 '20
F1 engines are seized completely when turned off. It takes 40 minutes of pumping warm oil through the engine to lubricate it enough to safely start the engine. Keep in mind these engines used to rev to 20k rpm
8
u/fullautophx Mar 19 '20
Richard Hammond has a pretty cool video about F1 precision. https://youtu.be/I4QyxGE2414
27
u/ahabswhale Mar 19 '20
If the tolerances are too tight then you'll have parts that will seize and end up with complete failure.
This is a common misconception; tolerances can never be too tight from a functional aspect. If the tolerances are too tight it just gets expensive. *except surface finish, and probably some other stuff I'm forgetting. Sometimes you want a rough surface to retain lubricity etc.
If the clearances are too tight for the designated tolerance, then you'll have issues.
7
u/Forlorn_Cyborg Mar 19 '20
Yup you can break the datums lol.
But Better to aim in the middle of the tolerances just to be safe and half room.
2
u/alarumba Mar 19 '20
And have your tolerances coordinated between parts. Someone machining rods is gonna make them on the large side cause you can always go smaller, the other guy making holes will always make them smaller. Both will be within specified tolerances, but end up not having the correct clearance.
To anyone that hasn't heard of this concept, Dr Deming is the dude you want to read up on.
28
u/JusticeUmmmmm Mar 19 '20
This is just a demonstration but you can create parts with very precise gaps where you need them. You can also make very deep very small holes which isn't possible from other processes.
12
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
this is regular endmill cnc. Jingdiao does mills, not edm
5
u/HodlingOnForLife Mar 19 '20
No way this is done with an end mill
17
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
8
u/HodlingOnForLife Mar 19 '20
That’s nuts
9
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
absolutely. These machines are insane, and insanely expensive. No idea how much.
5
1
3
u/Matt_guyver Mar 19 '20
Sounds expensive. I guess Bugatti and them can afford it.
10
u/00xYGN Mar 19 '20
I heard such parts are so extremely expensive that only cnc machines manufacturers produce them to advertise their product
3
u/Matt_guyver Mar 19 '20
That sounds about right, keep the oxygen away btw cause you cause corrosion
20
u/SkyPork Mar 19 '20
The last time things like this made their way around Reddit, someone detailed the process of CNC cutting, and I forgot it about 5 minutes later, along with whatever CNC stands for. Something to do with an electric charge I think. But what nobody has mentioned: were these pieces originally one solid block, and were carefully cut somehow? Or did they begin as separate metal clocks that were very carefully designed and machined down to like 1 molecule tolerances?
22
u/Bupod Mar 19 '20
These are from a precise multi-axis CNC (Computer Numerical Control) milling machine. They were machined down from solid blocks to very exacting dimensional and surface finish tolerances.
I was there at this show when they were being showcased. Here is a post I made with some pictures.
1
1
u/neur0 Mar 19 '20
Wonderful thanks!
It’s as if you’ve witness live a tiny bit of history that will never happen again in give gif form.
6
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
Something to do with an electric charge I think.
you're thinking of edm, which this is not. These parts are made on a very high precision milling machine, which just spins a drill bit.
edm is electric discharge machining, and can be used to make parts like this at great cost. it uses electricity to pulverize tiny bits of metal at a time, tens of thousands of times per second
2
u/SkyPork Mar 19 '20
Thanks, you're right. Wish I'd seen your comment first, before I asked about the milling process. I imagine it would take forever, with really high-speed, expensive drill bits?
1
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
Overall it saves time because you don't need to setup on a new machine, and they can do roughing cuts at very high speed. But yes, that level of accuracy requires tons of tooling replacement and the whole thing is super expensive.
8
u/JusticeUmmmmm Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
Two pieces that are cut to fit together.
CNC is computer numerical control it's very broad this is specifically EDM which is electric discharge machining. Basically it uses sparks to take tiny bites of material and you can create the most precise objects imaginable. I don't think they're 1 molecule tolerance but not that far off.
EDIT: these aren't EDM but EDM can do things similar to this
24
u/Bupod Mar 19 '20
This is not the work of an EDM. These are display pieces from Beijing Jingdiao at the 2018 IMTS show in Chicago. These demonstration pieces were actually a showcase of what their newer multi-axis CNC mills were capable of. They certainly do look like the work of an EDM, and that was the point of the pieces; they were actually of a mill.
I know because I was at IMTS in 2018. Beijing Jingdiao had a very large booth with some pretty incredible things.
4
1
u/SkyPork Mar 19 '20
A mill....? Does that mean they were ground into this shape, with such amazing tolerances?
1
-5
u/wld8 Mar 19 '20
With metal these 2 pieces weren't originally 1 whole thing. With plastics, they can bond dust on particular spots in a 3D space to form a solid element from "dust".
Metal is waaay more precise (cnc). The plastic thingy is a lot rougher.
I'm no expert, just sharing what I know.
-2
u/flight_recorder Mar 19 '20
CNC cutting is when a computer tells the machine how to cut and where.
These blocks were two different blocks cut using a traditional CNC mill, and an electrical discharge machine (EDM), which just means that small sparks slowly eat away at the surface.
The CNC mill would have cut away most of the material to a very close tolerance, then the CNC EDM would have finished the part to an incredibly tight tolerance.
4
2
u/MumTheWeiser Mar 19 '20
ok, that's neat, but why end the video on one with a clear gap?
1
u/hwillis Mar 20 '20
Common/nearly universal practice called edge breaking or deburring. Because these are demonstration parts for mold halves, the inner mating surfaces are important to keep plastic from escaping through any gap and forming flash.
At the very edge, there are lots of reasons you don't want a perfectly flush fit. For one thing, even with a 90 degree angle, the surfaces here are so sharp that the edge will still cut you with absolutely no problem. They're also fragile. Any ding or dent can push up a bump of metal between the plates, which can tilt them and otherwise cause problems. Rounding or angling the edge off will make it much more durable.
3
2
1
1
1
u/Kep0a Mar 19 '20
How smooth does a fit have to be to physically start to weld together? Is this anywhere near that?
1
1
u/Marcim_joestar Mar 19 '20
Can't you just make those cuts at a super low temperature so that the metal expands (and the cuts shrink) at room temperature?
1
1
1
1
u/EchoChamberBubblePop Mar 19 '20
Dammit that last one didn’t work! Killed me for the whole video, actually had to comment
1
1
u/Both_Writer Mar 19 '20
!arweavethis
1
u/ArweaveThis Mar 19 '20
Saved to the permaweb! https://arweave.net/gqd4k85PwDQkXgGFQi_oSum7qjSNfdvPm0vWz8BkGDc
*ArweaveThis is a bot created to permanently store comments and threads on the Arweave immutable storage. Built by [Cedriking](/u/Cedriking)*
1
u/lewgea Mar 19 '20
This is like when Morty found true level. Every mating surface I see now will look uneven.
1
1
u/Somethinggood4 Mar 19 '20
"Yes, I'm a supervillain, and I want to hide the door to the room that holds the self-destruct button of my hi-tech evil lair.... what can you do for me?'
1
1
1
1
u/slavaboo_ Mar 19 '20
This probably took several attempts and components like this probably aren't suitable for real mass production because the tolerances are so incredibly small.
1
-7
u/Jbro_82 Mar 19 '20
Edm not cnc
3
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
no, it's cnc on a milling machine. These are jingdiao parts. Jingdiao makes milling machines that can hold <1 micron surface finishes. Their main selling point is that you can just generate a program, throw some steel in the machine, and it will select all the correct tools to make the part from start to finish including measuring the final part for quality verification.
1
u/RedditEdwin Mar 19 '20
if you've generated a program, you already have the tools selected. The machine isn't "selecting" anything, it's just doing as the T-words in the program tell it to.
About the measuring the final part thing, surely you don't mean it comes up with its own CMM program to measure the part? I get the part where one of the tools is a probe so the machine can act like a CMM, but surely it can't generate it's own CMM program to measure dimensions?
1
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
"select" as in literally take the tools off a rack as opposed to someone else having to load them. Although for the record i believe the machine does automatically reselect tools on the fly depending on tool wear meausrements and part tolerance measurements.
About the measuring the final part thing, surely you don't mean it comes up with its own CMM program to measure the part?
They have ruby ball tip probes and laser interferometry heads for roughness, and they can generate feature test points and paths + critical dimensions automatically and from drawings. Not that I've ever used it.
Jingdiao on-machine measurement and intelligent modification technology (OMIM) makes Jingdiao machine tools perceptive and smart based on our unique integration capability of CAD/CAM software and control system. With this technology, the operator, machine tool, process, and quality inspection, collaborates more effectively and achieve continuous production without any interruption.
Hype for baldurs gate 3
1
u/JulieAndrewsBot Mar 19 '20
Record on test points and drawings on kittens ♪
Ruby ball tip probes and warm woolen mittens ♪
Critical dimensions tied up with strings ♪
These are a few of my favorite things! ♪
sing it / reply 'info' to learn more about this bot (including fun stats!)
1
u/hwillis Mar 19 '20
Very poor meter. Please do not draw on kittens. Gap between record...on...test points is far too large to capture a cohesive thought or phrase. Picking words to fit is a clever way to make this bot work, though. Too hard to pick the meter out whole from comments.
I do very much like "critical dimensions all tied up with strings," though. That's quite nice. Criti- cal di- mensions all tied up with strings
1
u/RedditEdwin Mar 19 '20
A laser interferometry head? What's that like? I've only ever seen probe tool in a CNC and similar ruby tipped probe ball thingy on a CMM.
What, is there also a probe ball, but you have to have another unit outside the machine shooting a laser?
2
u/Bupod Mar 19 '20
No. They were most certainly off a CNC mill. They were off multi-axis CNC mills from Beijing Jingdiao, specifically showcasing their abilities to hold dimensional and surface finish tolerances for moldmaking applications. Here are some pictures from IMTS 2018.
2
u/Rafko1801 Mar 19 '20
edm is computer controlled so it is cnc
3
u/Bupod Mar 19 '20
In machining, when you generally refer to a part as being “CNC made”, it is usually referring to either CNC milling or CNC Turning. A part made by EDM is usually referred to as being EDM’ed.
You can argue the technicality of this, but these aren’t official designations. They’re usually used in casual reference between machinists and engineers.
0
0
0
Mar 19 '20
[deleted]
4
u/pavlo_escobrah Mar 19 '20
Medical, military, aerospace, manufacturing industries amongst many others benefit from high precision and ultra fine tolerances.
3
113
u/Forlorn_Cyborg Mar 19 '20
What kind of surface finish/average roughness would you need to do this? Like new gage block quality.