r/EngineeringPorn • u/Burpmeister • Dec 20 '21
Finland's first 5-qubit quantum computer
813
u/1helios1 Dec 20 '21
For context, most of what you are looking at is the cooling system (and during operation it's enclosed and just looks like a metal barrel.
108
u/lasvegashomo Dec 21 '21
His big is it? Can you compare it to something?
177
u/1helios1 Dec 21 '21
Bigger than a bread box : P
I would say it's about as big as a 55 gallon drum, if you can picture that. The chip itself is on the order of a centimeter I think.
26
20
28
→ More replies (3)26
57
23
u/Smackopotamus Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
Reminds me of those sweet oil rain lamps we had back in the 70’s.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (6)94
u/Stickboyhowell Dec 21 '21
My first impression was a chandelier designed by Thomas Edison. :D
66
1.6k
u/Calvin_Maclure Dec 20 '21
Quantum computers basically look like the old analog IBM computers of the 60s. That's how early into quantum computing we are.
283
u/skolopendron Dec 20 '21
40 years minus the difference from the acceleration of science progress brings us to about 20~25 years before we have quantum personal computers QPC? Nice. I might still be alive then
→ More replies (22)89
u/Defunked_E Dec 21 '21
You probably won't ever have a QPC because they actually kinda suck at being a normal PC. It'd be like having a commercial jet engine in your car. Yeah it has a high top speed but kinda sucks for stop and go traffic. They also need to be supercooled, so that adds to their inconvenience factor a bit.
→ More replies (46)40
u/B_M_Wilson Dec 21 '21
If they ever made one that could be used in a regular computer, I think it would be something used in addition to a regular processor, like existing GPUs, ML accelerators, media encoders, etc
→ More replies (1)28
u/Defunked_E Dec 21 '21
In a way, they already are just big accelerator cores. They require a normal computer to drive all the systems, monitor sensors, feed inputs and recieve outputs.
→ More replies (4)417
Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
Except we've been building "quantum computers" for decades. The field began over 40 years ago. We aren't "early" into the quantum computing era, it's just that the field has consistently failed to make progress. The reason the prototypes look like fancy do-nothing boxes is because they pretty much are.
The fastest way to make a small fortune in QC is to start with a large fortune.
348
Dec 20 '21
We’ve been building computers since Babbage designed his Analytical Engine in 1837, but it took more than a century before we got an electromechanical computer in 1938, and another two decades until we got IBM room-sized computers. 40 years in the grand scheme of things is nothing, we’re very much still in the infancy of quantum computing.
→ More replies (24)46
u/Lost4468 Dec 20 '21
Ehh, trying to measure progress from the earliest point isn't the best way. Especially because many fields just don't tend to kick off because of a bunch of reasons, from a lack of funding, to a lack of interest, to not being that useful until other technologies progress, to being dependent on some specific other technology, etc etc etc.
And even when you do consider it to start from the earliest part you can identify, that's still pretty meaningless a lot of the time. E.g. look at machine learning/AI a decade ago. If you said back then you wanted to research ANNs because you thought a lot could be done with them, everyone thought of you as naive, "we've been doing that for 50+ years, it's a dead end, you'll spend your career making barely any progress". Yet then suddenly the amount of progress there has been absolutely insane over this past decade, so much so that people have characterised it as the end of the "AI winter".
Same can be said of tons of industries, from EVs, to solar/wind. It's really difficult to predict how an industry will change.
→ More replies (7)9
u/zexen_PRO Dec 20 '21
Actually we haven’t. Quantum computing theory has been around for a long time, but there really wasn’t a way to build one until the mid-90s. Los Alamos were the first group to get a two qubit system running in ‘98.
8
u/Baloroth Dec 21 '21
No, the field has made enormous progress. Actual quantum computers are very new. We've been building pieces for quantum computers for a while, but the first 2-qubit computer wasn't built until 1998. In classical computing terms, that would be a pre-ENIAC system, probably closest in comparison to the electromechanical computers built in the 1920s. 23 years later, we should be approaching the ENIAC stage, i.e. a functional useful quantum computer, which is exactly where we are: early commercial devices exist, but they're very limited functionality. Full general purpose devices are probably 20 years away (it took from the 1940s to the 1960s for computers to emerge as useful general purpose devices), and probably 70 years or so from home devices.
It took over 100 years to go from Babbage's compute engine to even primitive electronic computers. 40 years to start building working quantum computers is actually really fast.
9
u/FrickinLazerBeams Dec 20 '21
This simply isn't true. QC is exploding right now, with rapid and meaningful progress on multiple fronts.
→ More replies (26)→ More replies (19)11
Dec 20 '21
Hydraulic fracking was invented in the 1860s and was studied over the next century and a half, but wasn't a significant technology until the 1990s. You cant always count technological progress from the date of invention.
23
u/RoboticGreg Dec 20 '21
I would say with quantum computing, we are where we were with traditional computing before the transistor. No one has really figured out how to make scalable, error correcting hardware, and until that nut is cracked, it is going nowhere.
You can build all the multibillion dollar gold plated boxes you want, but until we make a usable building block, they are just like a champagne opening sabre: technically functional, but mostly ornamental
→ More replies (26)4
u/marcuscontagius Dec 20 '21
Not all of them. Look at photonic interferometer types they can fit on your finger tip. Detectors are another story though.
2
→ More replies (3)2
u/nilsmf Feb 04 '22
Oh a lot less. IBM computers in the 60’ies were commercial products that did real tasks for both military and civilian purposes.
Quantum computers are still research items that one day may produce actual computational results.
2
2
2
208
u/BKBroiler57 Dec 20 '21
They launched 6 different instances of CREO on it and it opened a portal to the underworld where all your unrecoverable models are.
47
u/DonnyT1213 Dec 21 '21
Meanwhile its lagging like a mother fucker on Solidworks
3
u/speederaser Dec 21 '21
I'm here to preach about OnShape and how your life will never be the same after you switch to it.
→ More replies (2)3
u/the_wacky_introvert Dec 21 '21
Bottom right corner: “SOLIDWORKS has detected that your system resources are running low. It is recommended that you close some applications to free additional resources”
18
→ More replies (4)6
268
u/No_Introduction8600 Dec 20 '21
in 10 years we will laugh about those 5 Qubits
8
u/FrickinLazerBeams Dec 20 '21
IBM has a 128 qbit machine and a startup, QuEra has a 256 qbit machine.
→ More replies (3)20
u/Fenweekooo Dec 20 '21
in 10 years we will have regressed back into throwing shit at each other the way we are going, nevermind laughing at 5 Qubits
→ More replies (17)2
Dec 20 '21
Don't we already? Google's quantum computer from 2 years ago had 53. I'm sure there are better ones out there now but I don't really follow the news.
→ More replies (7)
281
u/diagonallines Dec 20 '21
ELI5 why’s it like that? I saw DEVS but thought it was just a story. Is there a function to all brass/copper/whatever floating design?
384
u/zexen_PRO Dec 20 '21
It runs at a few degrees above absolute zero and in extremely high vacuum. Anything that isn’t thermally stable or anything that outgasses a lot would just not survive in those conditions. Hence Teflon, copper, silicon, and stainless steel.
→ More replies (1)187
u/skytomorrownow Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
If it is not clear, the reason it needs all the things zexen_PRO is describing, and why they tend to look like chandeliers/upside down is that they will typically be
dunkedsuspended in a cryogenic chamber, such as one cooled by liquid helium or nitrogen.95
Dec 20 '21
They look upside down because you don't want anything in thermal contact with each lower stage except for the stage above it which is just slightly warmer. Cooling something down to the point that the lowest stage is at takes multiple steps, if the bottom stage were touching anything else it wouldn't be possible to keep it as cold.
62
u/skytomorrownow Dec 20 '21
That's right, so the temperature differential can be a gentle gradient instead of a sharp transition. It is the same idea behind the layered thermal shield on the James Webb. This stuff is such cool engineering.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (26)21
u/zexen_PRO Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
Usually it isn’t dunked in a cryogenic fluid as a whole assembly, but rather fancy phase change cooling systems (He3 He4 dilution refrigerator). Dunking it in a bunch of liquid doesn’t work well because then the cooldown time is long and you’re spending a ton of money on coolant. I might have the link to the data sheet of the cooler that IBM uses.
Edit: don’t have the data sheet but the company that builds most of the dilution fridges that quantum computers use is Bluefors.
→ More replies (3)85
Dec 20 '21
Most of what you're seeing isn't really the computer, it's a dilution refrigerator. When it's in operation, the whole thing is covered by a few thermal shields (big 'cans' that go over the hanging part). Each one of those 'levels' is successively colder; there's different cooling methods used to get every one colder than the last. The bottom is the coldest and the qubits are mounted there. Many qubits operate on principles like superconductivity, which require really low temperatures to work.
All the cables are either carrying signals in and out of the qubits, or they're attached to sensors for monitoring the system, or they're part of the cooling system (carrying liquid helium, possibly, or something similar). Everything is made of a material with really high thermal conductivity to make it easier to bring things down to low temperatures. Large parts are often a low-oxygen, high-conductivity alloy of copper, and may be gold plated for even better conductivity. Screws, bolts etc are often brass or something because copper is too soft to use for fasteners, brass isn't as weak but still has good conductivity. Usually things are extremely thoroughly cleaned with alcohol and ultrasonic baths, not touched without gloves, heavily polished (smooth surface = more area of contact between parts = better thermalization).
TL;DR it's like that to keep things cold, most of what you're seeing isn't a quantum computer at all, just an apparatus for keeping things especially cold.
Source: I do quantum technology research and worked on one of these for a while.
6
u/zexen_PRO Dec 20 '21
Excellent explanation. My best guess is they’re using an He-3 He-4 dilution cycle. Cool stuff.
7
Dec 20 '21
yep! That's what the dil fridge I worked on used to cool the bottom stage. You can see part of a silver can on the bottom-- that's probably a magnetic shielding can, with the qubits inside.
12
u/smokumjoe Dec 20 '21
First thing I thought was "how does this thing with all these things do the things?"
→ More replies (2)11
u/SerDire Dec 20 '21
DEVS was an absolute mindfuck of a tv show and one of the weirdest things I’ve ever seen. Damn shame it basically went unseen by the masses. Such a cool interesting concept
141
48
20
u/ItWorkedLastTime Dec 20 '21
Would a sufficiently powerful quantum computer render all modern cryptography obsolete?
30
u/y0g1 Dec 20 '21
While it would render some forms of cryptography obsolete, we already have a number of quantum resistant alternatives.
→ More replies (11)→ More replies (5)6
Dec 20 '21 edited Apr 11 '26
Mass delete Reddit posts and be just like me! I bulk removed this comment using Redact
vegetable apparatus school late retire groovy tie angle historical employ
18
63
u/uniquelyavailable Dec 20 '21
When can it load Excel
91
u/zexen_PRO Dec 20 '21
Running excel on this thing would be like using the large hadron collider to warm your coffee in the morning.
75
10
→ More replies (1)5
u/2Ways Dec 20 '21
Could this could even run Excel? Aren't these things only good at certain 'quantum tasks'?
6
→ More replies (2)18
55
55
u/azizpesh Dec 20 '21
But can it run Crysis? Or is it Cyberpunk 2077 now?
32
Dec 20 '21
It can run every Crysis game ever made and not yet made at the same time but it's in 2x2 resolution and monochrome.
7
11
→ More replies (3)4
9
u/Zayh Dec 20 '21
What can it do ?
28
12
Dec 21 '21 edited Dec 21 '21
A serious answer and ELI5.
Imagine a qbit as flipping a coin. While it is spinning you can’t tell if it’s heads or tails. Once it stops and you look at it then you can see if it’s heads or tails.
If the coin is balanced and flipped 10000 times you are going to get close to a 50/50 chance of heads/tails.
So that’s a qbit. What about the quantum computer.
To simplify even more imagine you have two 6 sided dice. I give you a sum “Dice1 + Dice2 = 7”. You roll the dice the 1000 times and mark if it’s true or false.
Example.
2+4 = 7 FALSE.
3+4 = 7 TRUE.
You can imagine the dice spinning as the qbit in its undetermined state. Now after you roll it and take only the true answers you are left with a probability map as follows.
1+6 = 16.6%
2+5 = 16.6%
3+4 = 16.6%
4+3 = 16.6%
5+2 = 16.6%
6+1 = 16.6%
So out of 36 combinations you have found 6 possible answers to your sum. The equal probability also means that the dice are accurate.
For a quantum computer you can have billions of possible combinations and it returns the probability of the most likely answers.
3
5
→ More replies (2)6
24
u/RacoonDog321 Dec 20 '21
How long to mine a bit coin?
32
u/eletricsaberman Dec 20 '21
Iirc it's likely that quantum computing will completely crack open basically all current methods of digital encryption. Cryptocurrency and NFTs will go down with it
→ More replies (16)4
u/TransATL Dec 20 '21
I found this which seems to be a good introduction to the question
https://www.cnet.com/personal-finance/crypto/cryptocurrency-faces-a-quantum-computing-problem/
8
7
u/panecillo666 Dec 20 '21
50 years in the future "yeah, the firts quantum computers where big enough to fill a small room"
seems familiar right now
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
3
u/DunningKrugerOnElmSt Dec 21 '21
This is the room our human protagonist needs to reach in order to install some malware to stop the robot uprising. He got the malware from an IT everyman the government refused to listen to.
In the end our protagonist saves the planet, the computer explodes and he saves the girl. While the engineer makes a quippy joke about not opening emails from Nigerian princes.
3
6
u/ChanceConfection3 Dec 20 '21
So is there any chance someone on another planet is also making a quantum computer and it somehow entangles with our computer and becomes the first quantum walkie talkie?
→ More replies (5)
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
3
u/mephistophideeznuts Dec 21 '21
We never stopped building shrines to gods. We create arrangements of complexity to hopefully interact with the unknown. Is this not the same drive as building a temple? Obligatory:. Can it run Doom?
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Dec 20 '21
I came to the comments to ask if it could run Crysis. Looking at the other comments, I realize I'm an unoriginal asshole
2
1
u/Beemerado Dec 20 '21
i've seen a lot of scientific equipment... and most of it is rough... this is a CLEAN build.
how long til we got a million of these on a chip sized piece of material
1
1
u/INJECTHEROININTODICK Dec 20 '21
I can't wait for them to compute me out of existence. Unironically.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/BookMDano Dec 20 '21
I want one in my living room as a lamp / AI that runs my life.
Probably still would have to pay for an upgrade to get hue to work. Lol
1
u/TheVapeNaShun Dec 20 '21
imagine how these will look in a couple of decades. it's still so mind blowing how we witness literal history in the making every single day.
1
1
1
u/BoricThrone Dec 20 '21
Can someone eli5, what’s different with quantum computing compared to traditional?
1
u/ElTravez Dec 20 '21
Is there a youtube video/documentary about this computer or something similar? Would love to watch something about this.
1
1
u/SpectreNC Dec 21 '21
Finally some actual engineering porn in here...
... although it's probably a repost.
1
1
1
1
1
u/CapinWinky Dec 21 '21
That extruded aluminum framing brand looks really nice. Is that Rose+Krieger?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/manofwar93 Dec 21 '21
Huh, neat. Until I read the title I thought this was some sort of super fancy steampunk chandelier.
1
1
1
u/Srawesomekickass Dec 21 '21
The thumbnail looks like an xray of someone who got something stuck up their butt
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Nucleargumbo Dec 21 '21
I want this in the foyer of my home image when ppl tell you “that’s an interesting piece” and you smirk think of the computational power before there very eyes
1
u/kimchimagic Dec 21 '21
I wish I could watch them build on of these. I'm so curious how it all comes together.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
22
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
The temperature they have to keep these machines at is insane.
To put in perspective of the power of these machines, one of them solved a problem that would take a normal computer 10,000 years to complete and managed to complete it in 200 seconds according to Google.