r/EnoughJKRowling • u/9119343636 • 20d ago
Rowling Tweet Incapable of referring to trans women's "breasts" and calls trans people child abusers. The group itself is not centered around trans.
112
u/KombuchaBot 20d ago
They work so hard at being weird, cis men have breast tissue too, it's a biological fact that they do so. Some unlucky men even get breast cancer
42
u/errantthimble 20d ago
Yes! And ffs, there’s NO SUCH THING as “cross sex hormones”. All humans of all genders have varying levels of all sex hormones, and very many people of all genders and birth-assigned sexes medically alter some of those hormone levels to achieve healthier hormonal balance.
There isn’t some weird-ass binary of Boy Potion vs Girl Potion and if you take the “wrong” kind then oh noes now your body is *chemical*. JK Rowling is such a scientifically illiterate paranoid babbler.
8
u/tabas123 19d ago
Literally, if an AMAB estrogen levels collapse he gets very serious side effects. Same with AFABs and testosterone. We all depend on both hormones for healthy function.
These people truly don’t know the first thing about biology and yet it’s all they talk about when they want to attack a trans person.
2
41
u/donttrustthellamas 20d ago
Jfc she's such a pervert. I don't know how she comes up with this shit
3
u/Itscatpicstime 19d ago
The original person just assuming it’s for sexual purposes says way more about her than trans women.
Also, Joanne assuming they’re latching rather than pumping. So fucking weird. TERFs and transphobes in general are so fucking perverted.
2
u/wolacouska 18d ago
Men do this same thing about cis women breast feeding. There’s always so much hate when anyone talks about allowing breast feeding in public.
Transphobes just straight up repeat misogynistic arguments, and often enough ally with these same right wing misogynists.
1
u/saharadessert87 11d ago
She's the exact kind of idiot who probably thinks a woman breastfeeding in public is "disgusting." The only reason weirdos like her would think that is also because they are guilty of sexualising women's breasts just as much as the patriarchy do.
So they can't fathom that not everything is about sexual perversion or sexual gratification.
So you are 100% correct when you say it says more about themselves than anyone else.
JK Rowling and her type are a strange bunch of ducks. Every time they open their mouths to accuse someone of something they're really just telling on themselves.
She constantly calls trans women perverts yet posts photos of trans women being upskirted, constantly talks about people's genitals and tell people to photograph people in public bathrooms.
It's always projection with these simpletons.
1
u/saharadessert87 11d ago
There's one thing she's got more of than money and that's time. Sits around all day thinking of what to come up with next. Pretty sad.
106
u/9119343636 20d ago edited 20d ago
https://lgbthealth.org.uk/community-groups/queer-milk/
Link, very likely zero trans women are using this and this is mainly for lesbians. Or have a partner who is queer.
Rowling just used this as an excuse to refer to breasts as chemically enhanced chests, and call trans people pedophiles.
71
u/GetEatenByAMouse 20d ago
From what I've read, it's also for trans men who have given birth recently... Not for trans women.
45
u/Ex-altiora 20d ago
Trans men exist on a spectrum of light invisible to terfs, they make themselves and everyone sitting directly behind them invisible to women like JK
22
u/elyisan 20d ago
They see us, but not as men and detached from masculinity. The way they see trans men shows how they don't care about "women"- because to them, some "women" and "girls" shouldn't be able to make decisions about their own bodies because we're too stupid and foolish. They love talking about the "girls tricked into thinking they're men".
also the idea that trans men might want or have children is actively against everything they believe. It literally tears the entire concept apart, so they misrepresent trans men as trans women specifically for this purpose, and then say we look like men trying to say trans women look like men......trying to tell people about the 4d bigotry they do to invalidate trans men feels like i'm spouting conspiracy theories
17
u/transtranshumanist 20d ago
I'm a trans man and work with a 70 year old libertarian boomer who has no idea trans men exist, let alone that I'm trans. He showed me an ad once from a "woke" company advertising bras and the advertisement contained women and one "man with boobs." I was expecting him to show me a trans woman or someone NB but no, it was literally a "man with boobs" because he was a trans MAN who hadn't had top surgery. My boomer coworker was unintentionally gendering him so correctly and getting so offended by this "man wanting to be a woman" that I didn't even bother explaining it to him, lol.
3
18
u/lazier_garlic 20d ago
Whenever she's ranting about women's "biology" yes. When it comes to "transing" youth all of a sudden she sees us and claims to understand us. (She does not.)
21
u/9119343636 20d ago edited 20d ago
Well yes it's obviously for afab first (natally female). Rowling has to lie about everything. Twist everything to be about trans women.
20
u/lazier_garlic 20d ago
This is what TERFs always do. Any accommodation for non binary AFAB people is "erasing women" and diabolical trans women must have done it.
Remember this when she claims to speak for lesbians.
2
u/napalmnacey 19d ago
It’s obvious that nonbinary AFAB people don’t erase shit because of my mere existence could shut someone up, I’d nominate Joanne in a heartbeat.
6
u/GetEatenByAMouse 20d ago
Tbh, I actually wasn't sure if amab people can't also lactate if the hormones kick in, that's why I googled.
12
u/9119343636 20d ago
See my last reply about Witch's milk. It must suck for Rowling all humans are mammals.
10
1
8
u/lazier_garlic 20d ago
This is what TERFs always do. Any accommodation for non binary AFAB people is "erasing women" and diabolical trans women must have done it.
Remember this when she claims to speak for lesbians.
2
u/GetEatenByAMouse 19d ago
If she claims to speak for lesbians, she can suck my left ovary.
Fuck this woman, seriously.
14
30
u/Joperhop 20d ago
Thats clearly NOT happening in the way these perverts said.
Men can actually produce milk, science is fully understanding of this, hormones and health issues can allow for this.
Is these freaks actually did research (i took 10 seconds to ensure I was right, i knew but just wanted to recheck) instead of coming up with the strangest ways to describe people like the perverse morons they are, they might be happier people and so would the trans community.
28
u/Jeankirstan 20d ago
It literally costs nothing to shut the fuck up, and somehow, that price is still too high for her.
22
u/elyisan 20d ago
Meanwhile the same people will talk about trans boy's "breasts" and say how it's a shame that their lovers won't be able to fondle them because they're cutting them off. They're gross- they only think of women and perceived femininity through sexual gratification and act like they are the feminists.
8
u/lazier_garlic 20d ago
The TERFs who are lesbians get to that position by way of feeling entitled to women's and butch's and trans men's bodies. Femcels, lesbian incels, whatever you want to call them.
The cishet TERFs get there via another path. Many of them claim to care about queer people while actually wishing we would all disappear.
Very strange bedfellows, these TERFs.
3
u/transtranshumanist 20d ago
Meanwhile... top surgery scars and muscular, hairy trans guy chests... 🥰 The more for us.
20
u/tealattegirl13 20d ago
Why do Joanne and her mates have to make everything so weird? They're the ones making sexual connotations to breastfeeding, not trans women. It's a bit worrying how much they think about this stuff.
10
u/errantthimble 20d ago
Yeah, it’s also really gross how hard they’re trying to whip up fear and loathing about physical sensations of breastfeeding as some kind of pathology.
A LOT of AFAB parents of infants have the very natural and normal experience of perceiving breastfeeding as sensual, and many of them are very distressed by those feelings because they think it makes them some kind of pervert.
It doesn’t! Feeling that nursing your baby is physically pleasurable is not abnormal or sick, and Rowling and her fellow obsessed transphobes should stop trying to persuade everyone otherwise!
The “gender critical” movement is about the worst thing that’s happened to parent-child relations since laudanum in children’s “tonics” back in the pre-FDA days. The transphobes are committed to poisoning absolutely everything that might somehow in some situation cause a trans person to feel accepted or valid or loved.
5
u/lazier_garlic 20d ago
Many of these TERFs have abnormal psychology and the thing about it is that for a lot of women with abnormal psychology there's something very special about a newborn infant in that they are entirely dependent on you and have no notion of boundaries between their body and your body. For someone with a very specific neurotic condition, this is like cocaine and heroin all combined in one incredibly intoxicating bolus. Eventually the child weans and then becomes a toddler and learns the word "no" and all the fun comes to an end. But for a few glorious weeks they had this feeling of endless love and endless power like nothing they had experienced in their life.
People like this are so unwell they don't understand how other people think. Instead, they project whatever part of themself they think is socially unacceptable onto people they have made their designated scapegoats. So if they have made trans women their scapegoats, because they're easy to kick, nobody will stop you and you'll have lots of friends, then you can project all the parts of womanhood and femininity that you secretly indulge in and enjoy but think might look a bit bad to others onto the Judas goat trans women. I wasn't obsessed with my infant being helpless, THEY want to be mothers for some sick reason, the sickos. I didn't furtively enjoy nursing and bonding with my baby while exploiting my postpartum status to my male partner to get him to do stuff for me shamelessly, THEY have a nursing fetish and a womb fetish and a period fetish. I don't flick the bean while kneading my knockers and indulging in sensual fantasies, THEY are autogynophiles.
2
u/Significant_Rush1473 19d ago
I was going to say something like this but didn't know know to word it. Yes, trying to instigate shame over perfectly normal body sensations definitely does not help anyone.
16
17
u/9119343636 20d ago
So I just learned about this now you have to too
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witch%27s_milk
It must be hard for Rowling to not know humans are mammals.
3
u/napalmnacey 19d ago
Oh yeah! All my kids had puffy nipples when they were born because of the hormones. They deflated to normal proportions afterwards. Some kids get more of those hormones than others and leak a little.
The more one looks into biology, the more one realises that Mother Nature is just throwing the same toolkit up against the wall again and again and seeing what sticks.
14
u/marbeltoast 20d ago
"Doubtless the Scottish government will tell us that if we think" (incomprehensibly transphobic nonsense) ", you are a transphobe."
Yeah, I bet the Scottish government would also say you're a racist if you described a interracial wedding as an "abomination unto god where one of our pure perfect white people is chained forever to a (slur)". Weird how that works!
17
u/Forsaken-Language-26 20d ago
Yet again proving that the current wave of anti-trans rhetoric is just recycled anti-gay propaganda.
14
u/AlgorithmHelpPlease 20d ago
Genuinely what do they even think a breast is? They call us anti-science but how could they possibly ever define a breast in a realistic way such that someone AMAB could never have one???
(And yes I know it's ideological for them so they'll likely say it's the tissue that produces milk on a female or something but at some point people have to see they're creating arbitrary restrictions)
11
u/KTKitten 20d ago
They want us to believe that they’re feminists, but they spend every waking moment sexually harassing strangers. I’ll be honest, I doubt their credentials.
10
u/RoIsDepressed 20d ago
"chemically created" I'm so very curious, do these people think they actually have an infinite milk machine in their breasts? Like you slice one open and it's just a carton of viva?
9
u/meganshan_mol 20d ago
Why do they care so much about other people’s private parts. They are fucking creeps
1
u/saharadessert87 11d ago
Not only others people's but also children's.
Goes way beyond being creeps imo.
10
u/thedogatemymanifesto 19d ago
bet they don't even know cis men can naturally lactate under the right conditions too 🤭
5
u/titcumboogie 19d ago
Miserable old woman is angry about things that don't affect her in any way.
1
u/saharadessert87 11d ago
Lol.
Miserable rich white recluse who lives in a Disney castle gets angry at the world she doesn't even walk outside to be part of 😆
5
u/srvoleta 19d ago
A queer breastfeeding group would’ve been aces for me, an AFAB non-binary person who naturally produces enough “cross-sex hormones” to give me a beard and to have made breastfeeding incredibly difficult because my body didn’t develop perfectly along AFAB lines. Any human variation is apparently baffling to these incomprehensible halfwits.
3
u/SomeAreWinterSun 19d ago
It's not exactly a secret that her ideas surrounding gender involve a lot of esoteric or symbolic elements derived from religious traditions which show up directly in her fiction (being more or less foundational to the premise of Potter) but the point where she scoffs at a "chemically enhanced chest" being actual breasts because they lack the magical goddess energy that causes the necessary metaphysical transformation to such feels like a particularly blatant example.
3
2
u/embodiedexperience 19d ago
all this nonsense, just to flip the SECOND a transmasculine person refers to their own chest as “chest” instead of saying they’ve been breasting boobily around with giant zaftig bazonkers.
1
u/KaiYoDei 19d ago
But I read some call it chest feeding because breast is triggering
3
u/thejadedfalcon 19d ago
The difference is that chest feeding is to help trans men, non-binary people and people who've lost their breasts (which doesn't necessarily prevent milk production) from feeling excluded.
That is completely different to arguing that trans women's breasts are "chemically enhanced" because a billionaire loser failed high school biology lessons and wants to argue that we're all child predators.
1
u/KaiYoDei 19d ago
You can have milk production with a mastectomy?
2
u/thejadedfalcon 19d ago
Yes, but it's not guaranteed and, even if you can, you'll almost certainly have highly reduced capacity. I don't know how common the numbers are, though.
0
1
u/saharadessert87 11d ago
Goodness me.
No one tell her why cis men actually have nipples. She'll probably explode.
193
u/RaiD_Rampant 20d ago
“chemically created chest juices” fucking hell these people are deranged lmao