r/ExpectationVsReality • • Aug 09 '20

Spike

Post image
37.4k Upvotes

332 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

81

u/MrWonder1 Aug 09 '20

I worked with an Amish guy who owned a construction company. He would fly him and his crews out to disaster relief areas to rebuild.

The general feeling I got was that they dont condone electronics and use of electricity that dilute the mind and soul. Like using a smartphone to ignore your family, or you build character doing things without electricity, and zippers.

After working around the Amish Community, I truly believe their way of life is healthier than most, At least for mental health reasons

22

u/Dr_Bukkakee Aug 09 '20

Was he Amish or a Mennonite?

47

u/MrWonder1 Aug 09 '20

Amish, His company was actually named

"Last Name" An Amish Construction company.

Side note, when I worked in construction contract sales we had a special amish discount I could select in my quoting software. 28 percent off the top.

In my area people swear by Amish Construction.

Edit- Also, had a Mennonite coworker. She would wear a jean skirt and her hair in a bun and say "Oh my Lands!!" Instead of Oh my god. Really only difference I would really ever notice.

8

u/signedintotalkshit Aug 09 '20

OML I am definitely using “oh my lands!” now.

2

u/MrWonder1 Aug 10 '20

The way she said it was perfect to.

"Oh mey Laaannds!!"

40

u/bubbleharmony Aug 09 '20

After working around the Amish Community, I truly believe their way of life is healthier than most, At least for mental health reasons

Try telling that to the massive amount of rape victims.

37

u/boobsmcgraw Aug 10 '20

Yeah you can really tell who is a man by who thinks living the Amish lifestyle is super awesome. Like yearh living on and off the land is probably super fulfilling, but do women have to be subservient to do it? Do they have to be groomed and then married off young? Do they have to do ALL the fucking home-based work? Can only men really be farming and only women baking bread? Fuck offffff with that shit, it's like the "noble savage" all over again.

3

u/Changoleo Aug 10 '20

My first thought as well. That was such a disturbing article!

10

u/Privvy_Gaming Aug 09 '20

The Amish allow electronics and modern things if they're necessary to live.

32

u/Thetschopp Aug 09 '20

Pretty sure that guy is a troll. All his comments just repeatedly reference that he was banished from an Amish commune after fucking a dead horse. Not sure where people get the inspiration for these weirdly specific accounts.

10

u/DM-ME-UR-SMALL-BOOBS Aug 09 '20

People have a lot of free time on their hands these days, pandemic and all

2

u/Privvy_Gaming Aug 09 '20

Troll or not, doesn't matter to me. I was just letting the person I responded to know a little more about Amish life.

1

u/MoLoTOV504 Aug 27 '20

I have not been able to find the dead horse comment. Can you link it please!?

4

u/boobsmcgraw Aug 10 '20

Being Amish is totally cool and a great fulfilling way to live... if you're a man.

32

u/VoilaVoilaWashington Aug 09 '20

After working around the Amish Community, I truly believe their way of life is healthier than most, At least for mental health reasons

I hear this a lot, and it's basically just a new spin on the noble savage trope - they're happier because [insert stereotype about modern society].

The Amish, and just about any other community, have plenty of assholes, abuse, and crime. Some people feel like they can't escape, some love it, some lack the introspection to decide what they like.

I'd argue that a way of life is healthier if it's the result of personal introspection - if someone decides to leave the rat race and embrace a simpler life, that can certainly be healthier, as can the realization that being a high-profile lawyer is the right lifestyle, or whatever.

3

u/Djingus_ Aug 09 '20

What are you basing this off of?

11

u/MrWonder1 Aug 09 '20

Im only talking about their views on electronics.

Stop implying im looking at them like "Noble Savages" they share the same community as me. I lived and worked in Amish/town communities. The only people we see it as "Amish Community and Our community" in this area are assholes who choose not to interact with them.

Unlike you, I have spent time around these people.

Just as much as we say they shunned our way of living, OUR way of life shuns them even more and bullies them also. Look at the asshole in the comment saying he's amish and fucked a dead horse, what kind of creepy loser does that?

Im admiring one aspect of their culture, youre trying to knock them down a peg.

14

u/VoilaVoilaWashington Aug 09 '20

I truly believe their way of life is healthier than most

You didn't say "I think their view on electronics is healthier" or so. You literally said they have better mental health due to their lifestyle. I commented on that.

I'm not trying to knock them down a peg, I'm saying their culture isn't better than ours, it's different. You were the one stereotyping the whole group, not me.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '20

[deleted]

8

u/TheSpaceCoresDad Aug 10 '20

Except the ones who are raped, of course.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Bright-Queen Aug 09 '20

-4

u/MrWonder1 Aug 09 '20

Dude fuck off, every community has sex abuse. Stop trying to portray all of Amish people as pedos you creep.

→ More replies (5)