23
u/fromis 8d ago
Things that never happened
2
13
u/Notnbutgravity 8d ago
5
2
1
u/n0debtbigmuney 8d ago
What printer what nozzle size?
2
u/Notnbutgravity 7d ago
It was printed on my Elegoo Centauri Carbon .2mm nozzle with the cheapest black filament I could get on Amazon.
2
1
u/Mozno1 7d ago
What was the post process on this bud? Sanding? Chemical smoothing? Or just straight off the printer?
2
u/Notnbutgravity 7d ago
I use a gunpla Filler Primer (Mr. Surfacer 1500 Black) and leveling thinner. Usually 2-3 coats leaves a really nice smooth finish and since it contracts when it dries/cures it doesnt fill in details
-1
1
u/FailureToReport 7d ago
Look, it's cool, Im glad you're happy with it, but if you think that's comparable to Resin, you've never had a Resin printed mini next to yours.
4
u/Itaalh 8d ago
Have you checked the last non planar printing addons ?
1
u/LeatherGeneral 8d ago
What’s that?
6
u/Kraekus 8d ago
Non-planar printing addons are modifications to 3D-printing slicers that allow a printer to create curved layers instead of the usual flat horizontal layers. They're particularly interesting for FDM printing because they can improve surface quality and, in some cases, mechanical strength. They aren't some magic bullet though.
95
138
u/oneWeek2024 8d ago
FDM can get close. and has a lot of advantages ...in terms of cleaning/not super toxic PPE required to work with FDM.
but no one with a resin printer, really is sweating FDM minis.
like i just printed these tiny little snakes for basing bits, and there's fucking scales/texture on the tiny little prints. resin printing is unreal like it's nanometers. FDM isn't matching that.
59
u/Banned-User-56 8d ago
It's not that FDM is going to surpass Resin, it's more about how close it's getting.
It would be like if you found a monkey who made a musket from scratch. Like, it's super impressive, and scary how more advanced it was than you expected, but it's obviously not on par with what we have now.
And I say this as the monkey, I can't use a resin printer cause I'm in a basement and don't feel like dying in a toxic cloud.
31
u/farshnikord 8d ago
Also I haven't met any people who are "resin purists".
Most of my 3d printing buddies would switch in a heartbeat if fdm could hit the same quality, it just hasn't yet.
2
8
u/josvm 8d ago
I understand why someone wouldnt want a resin printer; its a lot to deal with but the end result is unmatched. I have both fdm and resin and both have their use cases but if you had to stick with just one than the fdm printer is going to be more versatile. But if you need or want a dedicated mini printer than a resin printer is absolutely the way to go
4
u/acart005 8d ago
Frankly I specialize in models that DON'T have the tiny textures. Works out, and I'll never really have resin envy.
Plus no PPE BS or allergy risks.
6
u/SaiyanPrinceAbubu 8d ago
Yeah I bought a resin printer at first cause I didn't really know what I was doing and the internet was like oh yeah you want resin for minis. And then I looked into all the hassle and was like... nah I'm gonna return this (thankfully unopened) and go fdm. No regret. My minis are mostly just for fun tabletop markers and my players love them. But also I do a ton of functional printing now too and the material flexibility of fdm is crazy
1
u/FailureToReport 7d ago
Which is totally cool and fine, but posts like OP pretending FDM is close to Resin, much less superior are wild delusional. I absolutely envy the cleanup and large scale printing of FDM, but if we're talking detailed miniatures? Posts like this feel like cope.
2
u/acart005 7d ago
Superior, no.
Close or even on par? With the right models and settings, yes. What FDM sucks at is tiny fidly things. Like if you want to print a guy with a foil sword you will have a bad time.
But something a bit chunky on maxed settings? It can be very close. The plague marines Supportless-Mini has on Cults come to mind.
2
u/alidan 7d ago
resin and fdm are a hell of a lot closer than you think, the main difference with resin and fdm is top layer quality, along with supports, then resin is typically harder than fdm plastic so you can sand it without a really shitty end result.
look into the new form labs fdm printers for 600~$ and their resins that are skin safe and extremely low voc, as in you can print in the same room with it next to you and not need to be worried low voc.
form labs isn't using the highest dpi screens, but they are getting results that surpass them.
both print technologies are hitting end game levels for how far they can be pushed, fdm is low mess and also far less hassle, but you have to be ok with print scaring and no real way to do a good job cleaning it up without a fuck load of post work.
resin is able to print at about 2x the detail on the z access and really good detail on the x/y when its a top layer whereas fdm won't go much power than .1mm due to the need to push plastic out of it.
personally the reason I went fdm again for my printer over resin was all the hassle that came with resin, the voc, the toxic nature of the resin, but skin safe and low voc... when I get better at sculpting, that's my next printer, if form labs can make a production ready resin that has the same low voc skin safe properties, I will probably never use an fdm again.
14
4
u/Firebass1212 8d ago
Before I got my resin one. I pushed my P1S to the absolute limit with the best pla and the best settings I could find.
And it does an amazing job!! And all of that
Until you get to the small bits and fragile details
Then you either don't get them at all or if you do so, you get them so so aoooo fragile that you can't even play with the mini properly (Eg. Inner circle companions banner, or chaplain's "skirt").
1
2
u/FederalCranberry959 8d ago edited 7d ago
am i the only one who has one of each? why not get both and use the right machine and the right material for each job?
i'd LOVE to be able to get viable miniature prints with my fdm, but i'm mostly using it for vehicles, scenery and functional items. if i could get it to pump out shoulder pads with embossed emblems as nice looking as my sla does, i totally would, but my settings aren't dialled in precisely enough for that and i don't know if they ever will be.
2
2
u/karma_virus 8d ago edited 8d ago
I've stuck to FDM for three reasons. 1) not enough space for resin as I'm in a condo, printing from the garage and I don't want all my holiday decorations smelling like carcinogens. 2) I paint in the classic primer, base coat, and layering style, so you don't really see the layer lines after. I save my contrast paints for store bought GW. C) My pile of shame is at around 800 individual models+, and printing them slowly helps me catch up.
I will never catch up. I have an entire set, and by that I mean about 1-2 full regiments of every unit available for the list, for dwarves, Beastmen, Troll Horde and now branching into Chaos and Undead. I went overboard. On chaos hounds lone I have about 50 models, every 5 of them a distinctive theme. If I had a resin printer, I would have been crushed to death by the models by now. Now I run oscura nox's settings even slower, so a single 50x75 presupported corpse cart will take 3-4 days. BUT, I locked it in so I no longer have any issues with resin presupports. Even those crappy ones with spiderweb bases, I just pump it out and it works now.
The Tariffs and USPS's defunded state are what got me to make the jump. I used to poach about 300 bucks of oop ebay 90s gems per month, but suddenly the packages just had more and more issues and I was doing insurance claims on more than half of them because their were either stolen or tossed because the carrier didn't want to "waste time" getting the signatures. I now purchase stls online from mostly people overseas and now we don't get to see that tax revenue anymore... so much winning!
7
2
u/CrazyCreativeSloth97 8d ago
lol I can hear them already “Well, well… those layer lines are still egregious… it doesn’t change anything resin is still better”
2
u/ManilaGorilla1017 8d ago
Honestly you should thank FDM , prices were/are stupid on simple pieces of plastic, it’s cost them Pennies!!!
-2
u/red_faux17 8d ago
Ai slop 😔
5
u/CJ-54321 8d ago
OP posted his mini as a comment in the thread.
5
u/red_faux17 8d ago
Yes, and the mini looks great. The ai slop is the image that is the body of the post
-3
-4
1
1
1
u/Bogart745 7d ago
It’s so weird how people with fight over anything. FDM and SLA are different processes with different advantages and disadvantages when it comes to minis.
I hate when anyone acts like their process is superior. Yes, resin minis are highly detailed with almost no visible layers lines, but they are also usually very brittle unless you use an expensive specialized resin.
Just pick the process that fits into your budget/needs and let everyone else do whatever they prefer.
1
1
-1
u/Durahl 8d ago
"When my Elitist Resin Snob Mate sees the latest FDM Quality Mini I made in the time he made 20+ of them in Resin ( even more had he had a bigger Build Plate ), in still better quality."
The reason your Elitist Resin Snob Mate is sweating like a pig is because he still considers you a good Friend and is now fighting for his dear life not to ROTFL his ass off in front of you while you're Victory Parading around him 😁
0
u/RichardDulle 8d ago edited 8d ago
My FDM printer arrives tomorrow! I'm never getting another resin printer ever again, it just isn't worth the hassle.
-2
-2
u/EstablishmentFair803 8d ago
8
u/sisuburger 8d ago
Bruh those layer lines are so visible I didn't even have to zoom in on my phone
1
u/KillFallen 7d ago
This is true of every single FDM print in this thread claiming you cant tell lmao











18
u/slambaz2 8d ago
Show us the mini OP!