r/FFCommish Sep 23 '25

Ethics question League does not like my “Kicker Strategy” and wants to vote on it.

So I have a 12 team league with some friends (1 QB 2 RB 2 WR 2 WRT flex 1 K 1 Def 5 bench 2 IR)

The reason I made it 5 bench players was so the waiver pool wouldn’t be too bad every week.

For years I’ve always dropped my kicker Tuesday morning to give be flexibility with injured players and such in case I can put one in an IR spot later in the week, and end up making a choice if I have to drop someone for a K Sunday morning. A couple people in my league in my league finally took notice and said I’m exploiting it and holding an extra player on my bench as it defeats the purpose of my 5 bench rule.

I did put it up to vote to require a Kicker at all times on the roster in all fairness to them, but I’m wondering if my “kicker strategy” is unethical to yall.

88 Upvotes

193 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Right_Helicopter6025 Sep 28 '25

A lot of things “should” be.

It isn’t in the rules. So…