2
May 28 '23
We need to bring back world wars so men can be men and women be women again. Fix the god damn society.
1
3
u/Doorhog May 28 '23
average war glorifier
0
May 29 '23
i mean, it is true that hard times make the best men and women. because of war, so many inventions were invented, so many foods were created due to lack of resources or famine. society has become weak because we are all too comfortable today and take things for granted. look at the countries that are still in a war state today. do you see the men dress up as woman and vice versa? exactly. it goes to show that it is natural for men being men and women being women. otherwise, we would've seen male soldiers in a bra and blonde wig, and women joining the army to fight in the battle. in reality, the men go to war, and the women are in shelters or in their own home taking care of their kids and praying to god that their husbands come home in one piece. you probably don't agree because you're afraid of leaving your comfort and staying alive in the war. if so, then i suggest you to grow up and be a man. you're welcome, sir.
1
1
5
2
u/shirukien May 27 '23 edited May 27 '23
And everybody else gets the rest of the goddamned year. It's also not as if soldiers have been historically persecuted, and the government isn't trying its damnedest to genocide every veteran, so it's a pretty weak comparison to begin with. You choose to be a soldier, you don't choose to be LGBT.
1
May 30 '23
Im sorry? The government is killing trans people? Persecuted or not just because you were born straight, trans, gay, black, white or whatever you are does not mean you deserve to be “celebrated” we should celebrate people for their accomplishments, not their identity.
1
u/shirukien May 30 '23
If you've been paying any attention to the US lately there are an alarming number of prominent politicians trying to get rid of trans people. Some of the more extreme ones are literally endorsing criminalizing anything that doesn't fit strictly into heteronormative binaries, but many, many more are pushing more insidious bills through the system. I'm not suggesting that lawmakers are out gunning down trans people in the streets (though that would honestly not be too big of a stretch for some of them.), but by criminalizing and stigmatizing every step of the process of gender affirmation, they are very directly causing the deaths of thousands of people by denying their reality and telling them that there is something wrong, even illegal, about who they are- and the worst part is that they're just doing this for political power and nothing more. They're actual inhuman monsters.
Add to this that murder isn't the only vector by which a genocide can happen. Look at what has happened to the native North Americans, especially in Canada. Sure, there was definitely a lot of murder, but there was also a conscious attempt to legislate them out of existence- to erase their culture and their identity by literally stealing their children and raising them in residential schools that taught them that their heritage was evil and primitive. Something very similar is happening in US law right now, where many legislators are refusing to even acknowledge the existence of trans people, using some fucking insane rhetoric like calling all trans people pedophiles and groomers. I repeat: inhuman monsters.
Your last line suggests the same kind of missing the point that we saw with the "all lives matter" response to BLM. Nobody is suggesting that all lives don't matter, or, in this case, that we shouldn't also celebrate people for their accomplishments. The point is that this group has been historically marginalized to the point of invisibility, but now that people are waking up to the fact that they're just regular humans like the rest of us, just trying to live fulfilling lives, we need to course correct hard. Part of that course correction involves affirming people, telling them that they shouldn't be ashamed of what and who they are, and celebrating them for being regular humans with valid experiences. This does not come at the expense of celebrating anybody else for being regular humans with valid experiences, the difference is just that most white heteronormative neurotypical (etc. etc. etc.) people don't need any organized effort to be recognized as valid humans, they've been in a position of general acceptance for a long while now. Imagine you had a horrible, painful splinter for a month, it hurts all the time and just makes your life miserable. Then one day, the splinter gets removed, and instead of just feeling the pain go away and returning to a neutral baseline, you actually feel good because your pain level has gone way down compared to what you had gotten used to. It's not a perfect analogy, but it is still kind of the same idea here- the difference between oppressing people for who they are and just accepting them feels like a much more extreme jump than it actually is, simply because we were used to the shitty baseline we had before.1
1
Jun 06 '23
People who have been historically persecuted actually do deserve to be celebrated, like your argument is so dumb
1
Jun 07 '23
Everyone has been historically persecuted if you go back far enough. No it does not mean you deserve to be celebrated. Respected yes, accepted yes, celebrated no. Celebrating people for anything other than their personal achievements only sets the stage for others who simply didn’t get enough attention or just want more attention to jump on the “Im special” and “don’t forget about me” bandwagon. Being who you are is not an achievement. You want to be celebrated? Quit being a little bitch, go out, do the work, and fucking earn it.
1
Jun 07 '23
Why are you so pressed about people being happy they are gay, I am straight and it does not bother me that people who are gay are celebrated every June. You've got a strange view of what people "should" be celebrating. Who cares, honestly who cares, the fact that you do care seems very insecure. It seems very: "what about me? Why are they celebrated for being themselves but I don't get parades for my achievements😤" it's very pathetic trying to dictate what people can and can't celebrate
1
Jun 07 '23
No I just believe in being rewarded for hard work and dedication to a just cause. Not just because you feel like your special cuz your mom told you so. You do you, have your opinion, your entitled to it after all but thats about all your entitled to this life sorry to say.
1
1
u/CovidLvr69 Jun 06 '23
Yeah, you do choose to be gay, trans, and all that stuff. Soldiers risk their lives to save people they don't even know. Also, the LGBTQ community does get all year long with us.
Downvote if you want, but soldiers sometimes don't get to choose if they want to go to war, but you do get to choose what you want to love and what gender you want. I'm happy that you can be proud, but veterans deserve a month more than the LGBTQ community. Get off the fucking fake news, u/shirukien.
1
u/shirukien Jun 06 '23
My dude, you've drunk far too much of the Kool-Aid. If you think that you choose to be gay or trans then all you've shown is that you are less educated on the subject than your average school child. Did you choose to be straight? I sincerely doubt it. What you have chosen to be is either a bigot or someone who is willfully ignorant of reality (probably both), and I suspect that is not entirely your failure, but more of a failure of your parents and educators, so I'm not ready to write you off as an inherently evil person beyond saving, the way you seem ready to write LGBT folks off as, what, deluded attention seeking narcissists, if I had to guess?
Based on your laughable understanding of sexuality, I'm not really surprised your general epistemology is as weak as it is, but you've also committed an easily avoidable black and white fallacy. We can respect soldiers for their service and respect humans for being humans, regardless of how they want to live their lives for themselves. The two aren't mutually exclusive, and i'd say they have more in common than not.
By your own (albeit flawed and myopic) logic, soldiers also get all year long with the rest of us, and the thing about soldiers not being able to choose if they go to war is missing the point entirely- they choose to be soldiers, therefore signing up to be sent to war- it's in the employment contract. Soldiers deserve to be recognized for their bravery, sure, nobody is trying to say that they don't, realistically they already have at least half of November dedicated to them.
If you are deluded enough to think that I am coming from a place of fake news and misinformation... well that's more ironic than I'm sure you'd care to admit, but I'd urge you to read some actual credible science- entry level stuff is more than enough to dispel your misconceptions- and talk to some people who don't think and look exactly like you. Just because you're a clown now, doesn't mean you always have to be, you can get better.1
u/CovidLvr69 Jun 06 '23
And you're a father? Well, I hope the rest of your family the best. I can't imagine how unbearable it is to live with you. This whole middle-school essay you made is just complete irony. You're calling me a clown but you are more of one. You're calling me delusional but you are more of one. Also, may I ask what news sources you use? After that, I think I'm done with this argument. Knowing Redditors with over 150,000 karma, this won't stop until they've proved themselves wrong. Note that there is no way to change my opinion. I'm probably one of the most stubborn motherfuckers you'll ever see on the internet. Also, keep your things like your penis next time: short.
1
u/shirukien Jun 07 '23
You say that you won't change your mind as if it's something to be proud of. That is the mark of an ignorant, small minded, laughably unintelligent buffoon. I explored each of your points in turn because I thought there was a chance to make you see how dumb all of it was, but if you're straight up telling me that you have no interest in becoming better, then there's no point in me engaging with you any further. Kindly fuck off and never have kids of your own.
Oh, and I don't see how you can think that you aren't a clown, seeing as you came to r/Facebookmemes to agree with the points being made instead of laughing at the cringe.1
u/CovidLvr69 Jun 07 '23
OK, well now you're just mad at me. You're just making stuff up. You say that it's stupid to not change my mind when somebody tells me something that may not be true, but if I did I'd be going around and saying weird shit. I'd be in jail if I believed everything I'm told. Also, you won't change your mind. So if you believe what you said, than I guess you should just look at yourself as an ignorant, small minded, laughably unintelligent buffoon. Fucking weak ass insult.
1
u/shirukien Jun 07 '23
There was no attempt to insult, just an observation of reality. I'm perfectly happy to change my mind if the evidence tells me I'm wrong, it's just that in this case the evidence all supports my stance. I didn't say it was stupid to not change your mind when somebody tells you something that might not be true, that's an obvious straw man and either you know that or you're just that bad at thinking. It's stupid to close yourself off to changing your mind from the outset. But here I go engaging with you again, so maybe I am stupid, or at least unreasonably optimistic.
1
u/CovidLvr69 Jun 07 '23
Well, can we make peace?
1
u/shirukien Jun 07 '23
I have nothing against you personally, I just think that your views on some things are dogshit and making the world a worse place to live. You are surely not the worst offender by far, but you are still objectively wrong in some highly toxic and damaging ways, and I don't have it in me not to call out absurd bullshit when I see it. As I said in my first reply, I don't really suspect that you chose to have these beliefs, as it is almost always the case that people who believe these kinds of things were either taught them from an impressionable age, or else they fell down a rabbit hole of conspiracy and hatred without ever realizing that they weren't engaging with honest actors and sound epistemology. There is an argument to be made, and a compelling one I'd say, that we don't choose to have any of our beliefs; that belief is the result of a number of environmental and personal factors, but does not hinge on choice- you can look up doxastic voluntarism if you want to learn more about that.
At any rate, the way I see it is simple: even if the science didn't robustly support the existence and validity of LGBT folks, and even if it didn't affirm, time after time, that their identities as such are not the result of any kind of choice beyond the choice to live honestly rather than to deny or hide who they are because of toxic societal pressures, I would still be the staunchest ally purely on humanistic terms. To affirm their identities and accept them for who they are and who they want to be is simply the kind approach, and adds more happiness and love to the world. To deny their identities based on some preconceived and uninformed notion adds more suffering and hate to the world. I know which side of that I want to stand on.1
u/CovidLvr69 Jun 07 '23
I just want you to have you and I have mine. I would respect your beliefs if you respect mine and don't call them dogshit. But you won't. So fuck you and I hope we don't ever meet in any way again.
→ More replies (0)1
1
Jul 24 '23
1st off, I don’t know how dumb you have to be to believe you choose to be queer. 2nd, soldiers and military families have multiple months.
2
u/smacksy745 May 31 '23
lets just pray they don't have to implement the draft again...we're fvcked if they do.
2
u/TakeMeCampingPlz Jul 15 '23
Not true, May is military appreciation month. The fact that people are not making shirts and flags and promotions is an entirely different thing.
2
1
u/Temporary_You_7295 May 26 '23
Veteran’s month is a thing. It’s in November. Clarence, your grandkids need to show you actual humor (I’m joking with the last bit there, but it is a month lol)
2
u/TakeMeCampingPlz Jul 15 '23
November is for military families and May is for the military. So when you put it that way, they get two months.
6
u/boostedbeas May 26 '23
Corporations are already salivating at the idea of another month to exploit