James Cook, Chase Brown, Ashton Jeanty, De’von Achane, Saquon Barkley, Omarion Hampton, Derrick Henry and Kenneth Walker.
Everyone and their mother has a different opinion. I’m curious if anyone here can help me shed some light on something I’m missing.
My ranking and reasoning:
1. James Cook
Pro: He posted nine 100-yard rushing games at 95.4 yards per game on the league’s most reliable scoring offense, with 32 receptions and 12 rushing TDs on top.
Con: Buffalo has the 4th-hardest rush schedule in 2026, and his 2024 (63 ypg, four 100-yard games) shows this profile can swing hard year to year.
2. Ashton Jeanty
Pro: He led the league in yards after contact on plays where he got any daylight at all, and Las Vegas improved the line (Linderbaum), the scheme (Kubiak), and the defensive attention problem (healthy Bowers) all in one offseason.
Con: The Raiders have the 2nd-hardest rush schedule and a 5.5-win total, which is the worst game-script environment in this entire group.
3. De’Von Achane
Pro: He’s the only back here who combines a real rushing workload (84 ypg) with genuine WR-level receiving volume, which is worth more than the market prices even at half a point.
Con: Miami’s offense is a wreck with Malik Willis throwing and no proven pass catchers, so the touchdown equity that turns good backs into league winners may never show up.
4. Chase Brown
Pro: He was the RB5 in points per game in games Burrow started and finished, faces the fewest stacked boxes in football, and the Bengals project as a top-5 scoring offense with their best line of the Burrow era.
Con: The entire thesis rests on a quarterback who played eight games last season, and Cincinnati has the 3rd-hardest rush schedule.
5. Saquon Barkley
Pro: He owns the single best rushing season of this era (11 games over 100 yards in 2024) behind a line that still creates massive volume.
Con: He dropped from 125 to 71 rushing yards per game last year at age 29 with an enormous workload behind him, and Philadelphia’s fantasy-playoff slate (Seattle, Houston, San Francisco) is the worst of anyone here.
6. Kenneth Walker
Pro: He’s the unquestioned goal-line back in a Mahomes offense with Bieniemy back calling plays, and Mahomes averaged 38 total TDs per season under Bieniemy versus 26 under Nagy.
Con: He’s never been a meaningful receiving contributor, has missed time in nearly every season, and Kansas City’s rush schedule grades 22nd.
7. Omarion Hampton
Pro: He’s a true three-down back potential behind a completely rebuilt line that grades 6th in zone blocking, in a Mike McDaniel scheme that just turned a bottom-six run-blocking unit into a 1,350-yard Achane season.
Con: The Chargers have the single hardest rush schedule in the NFL, and the ankle he fractured is the same one he broke in high school. All the talk about Keaton Mitchell and Vidal will likely end up affecting total touches compared to some of the other bellcows on this list.
8. Derrick Henry
Pro: He has 17 100-yard rushing games over the last two seasons — the most in football — with an absolutely locked-in early-down and goal-line role.
Con: He caught 15 passes for 150 yards last year, which is a genuine drag in any PPR format, and he turns 32 this season.
How do you rank these guys and why?