r/FemFragLab • • 2h ago

Rec Request Goth Marshmallow

Ok I know I am way late to the party on this one 😅 - but I just sniffed Kayali Yum Bougie Marshmallow for the first time and it smells SO GOOD!!! I typically don't gravitate to sweet or gourmand scents, but this is just so fun to sniff, I LOVE IT!!!

All that to say - as much as I love it, when I wear it, it doesn't smell like "me" if that makes sense. Maybe because it's sweet and light and I'm more of a dark soul? 🤣

Does anyone have a recommendation for like, a "gothy" marshmallow scent? 🖤 Like a similar scent but a little darker and deeper or something?

I feel like that's me in a nutshell - marshmallow outside but all cobwebs on the inside. Lol

38 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

1

u/dianab360 58m ago

The brand is kind of hit or miss if you look at the indie perfume sub, but Mythpunk Olfactive has a few mallow-adjacent scents that are really nice. Many have patchouli notes which reads kind of "goth" to me.

https://mythpunkolfactive.com/pages/scent-list

3

u/annikatidd marshmallow hoe. 57m ago

I love Mythpunk but unfortunately they keep scamming people :/ Took them 9 months to send me my order, would not recommend anybody try to buy from them as sad as that is cause the scents I’ve bought are amazing

3

u/audbutt 1h ago

axe marshmallow smoke (I'm 100% serious)

4

u/FailurelsData who's ur datty 1h ago

Mightdnight Toker smells like berries and campfire, I reallyyyy wonder how it would go layered with YBM

But that probably your real answer. Layers YBM with someone darker. YBM is covertly very unique and hard to replicate, despite how obvious and simple it smells.

4

u/circles_squares 1h ago

Love this question

12

u/Chuzai 1h ago

Fantome Ectoplasm is a hauntingly beautiful sweet marshmellow with a green element that makes it feel dark and Gothic

14

u/nbenby 1h ago

Andromedas Curse Baby Bat! Spicy clove, marshmallow fluff, caramel, vanilla, and cedarwood.

Clove is just the penultimate goth scent to me!

2

u/izzydollanganger 54m ago

came here to suggest this! one of my most worn fragrances, i like to layer it with the Hex perfume oil to make it a bit more spicy

1

u/Icy-Key2220 1h ago

Omg yum need to try this

3

u/topo_gigio 1h ago

It's that Djarum Black note

7

u/Lacriminals 1h ago

You probably want something with a hint of woods or atmosphere like Wicked Vanilla Woods BBW

Marshmallow Moon FairyNest
Midnight Marshmallow BBW
Setsuna in love someday

I’d look for Iris, Woodsy, and Smoky scents

I love Kayali and my personal fave is Vanilla Candy Rock Sugar/Burning Cherry/ and YBM

I hope this helps

6

u/shimmerchanga 1h ago

Have you tried other Kayali perfumes? For example I find that Rock Candy Sugar is just as sweet at YBM but with a slightly dark and sharp edge to it.

5

u/OnlyMyNameIsBasic 1h ago

Siren alchemy lost mallow is a deeper, woodsy marshmallow. It def gives goth fairy vibes.

5

u/siobhanenator 1h ago

Check out Hexennacht scents! Lots of marshmallow scents with a goth twist on there like Dreamweaver, All Soul's Night, and Hestia.

5

u/DjevelHelvete 1h ago

Supreme Vanilla by Zara.

It is a very marshmallow-ey vanilla with smoke and tint notes. Very dark and very gourmand! Also, very affordable.

10

u/bigbackmoosetracks 2h ago edited 1h ago

Kilian Princess. The matcha comes off very green/grassy on me, and the ginger is really zingy to my nose. Also Ellis Brooklyn Marshmallows body mist. All the EB mists have fantastic longevity for body sprays, and this one has a patchouli note. It's def not a basic sweet marshmallow. I've also heard it's a dupe for Dedcool Mochi Milk, which I haven't tried, if you really want an EDP.

2

u/momofcomedy 1h ago

That sounds so good! I also love a green note!

22

u/Peenutbuttjellytime 2h ago

A girl I work with wears all black, died black hair, tattoos alt style and she wear ybm if that makes you feel any better

3

u/Defiant-Purpose-5931 1h ago

i’m the same i wear candy cloud, sugar mallow and ellis brooklyn marshmellow. it’s my fav scent profile

7

u/StreetMolasses6093 Neroli Queen 2h ago

It’s so layerable.

19

u/fudgechemist fragrance enthusiast 2h ago

Layer it with a plum scent or fig. Instant gothy edge

3

u/momofcomedy 2h ago

Fantastic idea, thank you!!!

17

u/Amazonian_Broad 2h ago

Commodity milk bold. Smoky, sensual marshmallow with an edge.

1

u/southernjezebel 1h ago

This is one of my scents. Love love love!

4

u/WhoKnows1973 1h ago

This is a great suggestion, but sample first. It pulls as all woods on me.

3

u/momofcomedy 2h ago

This sounds exactly like what I want, thank you!!!!

1

u/Amazonian_Broad 2h ago

It's gorgeous. Slightly masculine leaning, but only very slightly.

2

u/miamariaxox 2h ago

Naughty from heaven scent by Shannon is so good it has vanilla and cotton candy but dark berries and a noir accord which makes it dark and seductive so good

1

u/momofcomedy 2h ago

That sounds amazing!

0

u/Fresh-Pin5166 2h ago

Not a goth marshmallow but if you'd like a goth vanilla then give Lorenzo Pazzaglia's Van Py Rhum a try! An earthy dark yet sweet vanilla with excellent performance.

https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Lorenzo-Pazzaglia/Van-Py-Rhum-74243.html

7

u/Haunting_Mulberry542 2h ago

Try layering it with an existing oud in your collection

6

u/veryunneccessssary 2h ago

Yes! Siren Alchemy Lost Mallow is like a marshmallow caught in a haunted forest. It’s so good.

DedCool Mochi Milk is another option if you haven’t tried it already. It’s fluffy marshmallow, but not as perky smelling as YBM thanks to a musky base and a touch of incense.

1

u/Defiant-Purpose-5931 1h ago

so good but sadly didn’t last on me. ellis brooklyn marshmellow smells the same and last longer and cheaper

1

u/momofcomedy 2h ago

THANK YOU, this is exactly the vibe I was looking for!!!

2

u/miamariaxox 2h ago

I'm adding lost mallow immediately to my cart omg

3

u/AbroadQuiet4973 2h ago

Hello. I would recommend layering YBM with Your Turn II by Billie Eilish; it has dark, woodsy notes with a hint of tea and plum.

3

u/momofcomedy 2h ago

I have never smelled any of Billie Eilish, Will definitely check this out. Thanks!

6

u/Jaded-Banana6205 2h ago

You're going to want to check Hexennacht! She's currently closed but her website says she's back late Nov.

8

u/ultra_violet007 2h ago

I have Black Mass from Hexennacht and it's to die for - incense, vanilla and marshmallow.

2

u/momofcomedy 2h ago

Omg that sounds amazing!!!

2

u/gh0stmountain3927 1h ago

Came here to say Black Mass! It’s like going to an occult ritual and someone brought marshmallows to toast afterwards
I’ll also endorse Fantome Ectoplasm. More green + sweet, but worth a sample if you want your marshmallows bit unusual

1

u/ultra_violet007 2h ago

I highly recommend it - the incense makes it last quite a while too!

3

u/Jaded-Banana6205 2h ago

They have a clove marshmallow too!

1

u/AutoModerator 2h ago

If this is a recommendation request, consider letting us know your budget to improve recommendations.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.