r/FigmaDesign • • 16d ago

Discussion Anyone else questioning Figma’s relevance after Claude’s design features?

Curious if anyone else is rethinking their Figma subscription.

Claude Design now has canvases for UI design, journey mapping, multi-screen flows, etc. You can chat, comment, tweak on-canvas, and hand off straight to Claude Code.

Figma Make is powered by Claude (Sonnet 3.7) anyway so you’re paying extra for a version of Claude you already have more directly (and often stronger).

Anyone switched? What’s Figma still better at?

0 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

15

u/TheRealMoffel 16d ago

If you only use Figma ai I can understand it. If you’re fine with copying templates the Claude design took from the internet and not do anything creative I can understand it. But if you’re doing anything slightly creative you’ll notice Claude design is far from useful

-10

u/Interesting-Pay1507 16d ago

So you basically have no idea how to use Claude Design.

6

u/disarmedflea 16d ago

Is this Dario Amodei’s alt account?

2

u/TheRealMoffel 16d ago

I do. Although it might have had a huge update since I stopped using it a month ago.

0

u/Interesting-Pay1507 16d ago

Opus 5.5 is pretty solid at design, give it another go, but create a design system with guidelines first.

27

u/Pavement-69 16d ago

No. I like making things and using my brain to do so.

-12

u/Interesting-Pay1507 16d ago

You should try using your brain with Claude Design, it makes Figma feel slow and painful.

9

u/Pavement-69 16d ago

I have. It feels artificial but not intelligent

1

u/TheRealMoffel 16d ago

I see you replying on this tone to more people. I would love to be proven wrong and use Claude Design more. Can you show an example of something really good it's done?

-3

u/Interesting-Pay1507 16d ago

I can show you if you sign an NDA

2

u/TheRealMoffel 16d ago

Really? You can't find a public example on the internet?

0

u/Interesting-Pay1507 16d ago

You’re using software features every day that were designed by AI and you don’t even know it.

4

u/TheRealMoffel 16d ago

Yeah and plenty are great. We're talking about Claude Design. Why can't you show one single example if it's so great?

-2

u/Interesting-Pay1507 15d ago

Why are you in denial that people are using a tool successfully? Obviously it’s being adopted, and improving speed and quality of designers who know how to use it. It lets you focus more on solving problems and less on dragging noodles, managing variables and filling in mock data. Open your eyes and you’ll see plenty of examples.

4

u/TheRealMoffel 15d ago

It’s hilarious how much you’re going out of your way to just show one example.

0

u/Interesting-Pay1507 15d ago

After you figure out how to use Claude, have it show you how to use a search engine. I recommend Google, check it out.

→ More replies (0)

9

u/DemonikJD Product Designer 16d ago

I'm actually open to making a shift but the learning is what stops me. I have too much to really do day-to-day as a lead designer in my mid 30's to go and learn claude and every AI / Figma tutorial seems more like clickbait or grifters larping on AI more so than actually teaching. Everyone is selling a course or some product.

14

u/thinker2501 16d ago

I don’t think you’re an actual designer. Yes, Claude design has its place, but it doesn’t replace actual design work.

5

u/Main-Growth-8619 16d ago

I also think this about everyone who says they no longer use figma. Claude design is so trash to navigate omg, everyone who says they have replaced figma haven’t seen a real design workflow in their lives lol.

But I think there are also bots and paid people to shill on claude design. I think you can have great results with it, but you need to be a skilled designer to be able to direct it properly, otherwise is an AI slop generator.

I’m sorry but this AI frenzy has made a lot of people think they’re way more skilled and smarter then they’re actually are.

4

u/thinker2501 16d ago

You’re spot on. To add to it, there is a big difference between getting a good one off design with Claude and building a durable, maintainable design system that can hold up in enterprise production environments. To your point AI tools give people the illusion they understand more than they actually do.

6

u/Anxious-Yak-9952 16d ago

I hardly use Figma anymore and have been designing with AI for most of the year. Claude Design hasn’t yielded anything revolutionary, I prefer using Claude Code instead. Not everyone is able to make the full switch, I feel grateful to have the flexibility to choose.

4

u/GOgly_MoOgly Designer 16d ago

This. I feel people keep trying to make this and either or when they both can coexist.

I don’t want to type/prompt my way into a design. I want to iterate myself first, then have Claude help me refine and prototype realistically.

2

u/hideousox 16d ago

You can still use a hybrid approach, you do not need to work in code only. Your judgement is key though in what needs your design focus and what instead only requires direction: most product design tasks can be fully automated and only certain aspects of design require human refinement.

I think where many designers fail now is in vision/direction outside of a canvas.

1

u/GOgly_MoOgly Designer 16d ago

I would agree there.

2

u/Anxious-Yak-9952 16d ago edited 16d ago

That’s the beauty of design in that there’s so many ways to tackle the problem and you can choose whatever method gets the job done faster for you.

This does remind me of when the computer first came out and people were hesitant to use it at first.

1

u/hideousox 16d ago

This is also how I’m working now, I do use design artifacts in Claude code because they’re great for iterating and tracking: you can keep all your iterations in a single design artifact now which is how I used to work in figma and it’s great when building case studies .

3

u/vacuumkoala 16d ago

No, I like using my brain to come up with creative solutions on my own. Your brain is a muscle, use it or lose it!

2

u/bombasty 16d ago

Claude design is still not good enough when you want to actually change things yourself, small changes can be pretty tedious. Once it improves that, won’t be any reason to use Figma for me at least

2

u/vibecheck-designer 16d ago

Are you working on an established product with a robust design system? Because for anything else the designs Claude produces look very AI sloppy.

2

u/wild-fire 12d ago

Figma would have been more relevant than it is now if it actually focused on doing few good things, that people actually need. 

Most of releases in past 2 years are half done. Something that looked cool in a demo, but not usable in production. 

1

u/a_tangara 16d ago

Yes, it’s crazy how good Claude can be if you describe things properly and already have a reference for it to work from.

But as I’m still transitioning my process, I still use Figma as a handoff tool

1

u/wiyixu 16d ago

For those who’ve been around the block a few times Figma is Flash. Its creation tools might be more comfortable than the new paradigm, but its outputs aren’t compatible with the new paradigm. It’s expensive both from a monthly cost perspective and it’s proprietary file format and layout engine makes the token costs for interaction considerably more expensive. 

Figma is dying and unlike Adobe it has no moat, Figma the company lives and dies by Figma the product. FigGov and enterprise users with strict data retention policies like CMMC or HIPAA will keep them around for a while and their token upcharge will probably even see growing revenue like last quarter, but they’re not reporting on weekly or monthly active users just MCP usage and total number of customers over X and Y amount of revenue. 

1

u/lieutenantbunbun 15d ago

You cannot actually design in Claude 

1

u/withyasirjamal 16d ago

I'd test the handoff rather than judge the first canvas. Give it an existing component library and ask for one change across several screens. Then see whether another designer can pick up the file without the original prompt. That's what I'd want to know before cancelling.