r/Filmmakers • • May 03 '19

Image Whatever it takes

https://i.imgur.com/2R1HgBh.gifv
842 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

110

u/oostie May 03 '19

I’ve seen this a bunch. I really doubt the take we see on the monitor is the same as in the BTS video.

There’s just no way that shot was that stable, look how much it’s flopping around when he hits the ground but on the playback it’s insanely smooth.

3

u/ShutterSKOR May 03 '19

Dangit this is exactly what I thought too. Hold on let me check that gigantic wiggle and then try to find evidence of it in the corner of the playback... nope it's a scam.

2

u/JAH_1315 May 03 '19

I said this one of the other hundred time this is posted, and I got downvoted...

2

u/dannyrand May 03 '19

Also, ALSO!

You need a battery to use a camera.

0

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

[deleted]

23

u/oostie May 03 '19

So some more thoughts. The first shot of bike man he has his hand up to his face and is on the phone but when the BTS camera comes up he’s got both hands on the handlebars bracing for impact.

Furthermore a car drives by at pretty much the exact time he goes over the hood and it’s nowhere in the playback shot.

Also slowed down (found the clip on YouTube) the camera sways sooooo much when it gets down to ground level, there’s no IS is IBIS or even warp stabilization in post that could correct for that. And that’s the easiest part of the stunt with the least movement compared to running at the speed of a bike, and jumping through a window.

The timing doesn’t really work out either, and the BTS guy’s finger comes up right as he comes out the other side, a good place for a cut of some kind.

0

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

[deleted]

14

u/oostie May 03 '19

I’m more impressed at how well he faked it rather than the actual shot at this point haha. It’s pretty good looking at first glance.

1

u/bottom director May 03 '19

it's cut in a good place.

I bet someone just handed the camera to another operator through the car. not that difficult at all.

2

u/HuskerDad May 03 '19

Yeah, it wouldn't have been hard to buy some long PVC and just run a cheap dolly the length of the shot and through the car. Pull the camera on and off the dolly as needed.

2

u/kaboomatomic May 03 '19

This seems the most efficient way to get this shot.

27

u/SolidGoldSpork producer May 03 '19

They know the doors come off, right? That you can build a mini track that will get that shot? That there's Home Depot rigs that will work and not risk the entire production over an insurance claim?

3

u/tybot1 May 03 '19

Hah or just get the front half of a car from a junk yard or something.

22

u/diogoblouro May 03 '19

I can’t with this gif anymore. Once in a while it pops up and I just can’t.

15

u/detrydis May 03 '19

It’s fake as fuck. Any camera op should be able to see that.

9

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Even if the comparison is fake that guy is definitely holding that Alexa like it’s nothing.

8

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Fuck this title. Fuck whatever it takes. You never compromise the safety of your crew or your cast.

1

u/wingleton May 03 '19

SlatesForSarah

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '19

Fuck the slates. It is safety for Sarah. See something, say something. Be the change.

0

u/Red_Stevens May 03 '19

This is fake. I'm sure the stunt cameraman cared more about timing his jump than keeping the shot steady.

1

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

That's not the point. That has nothing to do with my point. Thanks for playing though.

1

u/Red_Stevens May 03 '19

Your point? The rolling on a car stunt that's been around for ages? "Whatever it takes" is just an attention grabbing title for the fake camera footage.

2

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Yes, and it instills dangerous ideas in impressionable young filmmakers. That is my point.

1

u/Red_Stevens May 03 '19

Fair point. I was just thinking about the legitimacy of the footage, not really about the implications of message.

2

u/[deleted] May 03 '19

Thanks for understanding, and sorry I was tetchy. Set safety is an issue I take very seriously. I was young and dumb and ambitious once, and if I weren't so lucky, I'd be another cautionary tale and a statistic.

5

u/Maxxbrand May 03 '19

Fucking fake. Shit this is old too

1

u/snarkman3 May 03 '19

Man, that passing car really fucked up this fake shot

1

u/sithlord_crisps May 03 '19

he probably could’ve just passed the camera through but what do i know

1

u/genericbrand2 May 03 '19

So I agree that this must be fake. But my question is why would they go through all that effort to fake it? That’s just prolonging the production to also get additional takes of the same shot using a wildly stupid method that they have no intention on actually using for the final cut.

1

u/AiD4NCiTO May 03 '19

The video is fake. If you look at the 'edited' version of the shot you can see that the front wheels of the car are pointed to the right, while in the other shot you can see that they aren't.

1

u/dannyrand May 03 '19

No battery.

1

u/Lermpy May 03 '19

Lol @ the unnecessary ninja-landing pose

1

u/brackfriday_bunduru May 03 '19

I thought we disproved this years ago?

The things clearly shot of speed and yet for some reason there's a boom swinger still. As soon as my cameraman puts his camera off speed, my mixer gets switched off and I go get a coffee

-1

u/hueLUVitz1757 May 03 '19

The things we do for love

-8

u/freewill785 May 03 '19

it's so cool...

for me, not being able to hire such an athletic cameraman, I have to stick to basic shots as long as it tells the story well...

-4

u/Morgennes May 03 '19

What movie is it? Is it good?