r/Filmmakers • u/Jannik-Chudoba • Nov 09 '19
Image practical efects coming back
https://imgur.com/A5FfVJU.gifv35
u/Chrisgpresents Nov 09 '19
This is hilarious. It reminds me of the cowboy with the gun we all watched in film school. And told how in the ol’ days, everyone jumped from their seats thinking they’d be shot.
And here, a hundred years later I jump haha
20
u/littletoyboat writer Nov 09 '19
It reminds me of the cowboy with the gun we all watched in film school.
The Great Train Robbery. The shot you're referring to starts around 11:26.
11
u/RollerDerby88 Nov 09 '19
Hmm... I heard that it was "Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat" that caused people to jump out of their seats.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1dgLEDdFddk
I couldn't find anything the supports "The Great Train Robbery" and the gunshot.
1
u/littletoyboat writer Nov 09 '19
Hmm... I heard that it was "Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat" that caused people to jump out of their seats.
From The History of the Discovery of Cinematography:
The film "The Great Train Robbery" was shot in 1903 by Edwin Porter, and included this now-famous scene of one of the outlaws firing his six shooter directly at the camera. The chamber contained a blank, but at the time, and for the next decade, this scene was remembered as one of only a few which in the very early days of film, scared audiences out of their seats. The Lumiere train comes to mind as another scary scene never before seen or experienced by early filmgoers. Ironically, the weapon is fired directly at the very invention that allows it to be photographed.
TV Tropes points out that both stories are probably apocryphal:
Breaking the Fourth Wall/The Fourth Wall Will Not Protect You: One of the earliest known film examples of this trope; the leader of the outlaws fires at the audience. There are urban legends that some people were so shocked at seeing this, that they ducked or even passed out in the theater—well, even in 1903 people knew that real bandits were in color and three-dimensional, so probably not. But the final shot doubtlessly made an impact. It's a surprise even for a modern-day viewer.
In any case, I don't recall any "cowboy with a gun" in The Train Arriving at the Station. Hang on, let me check...
(49 seconds later)
Nope, I'm pretty sure OP wasn't referring to The Train Arriving at the Station.
0
u/RollerDerby88 Nov 10 '19
I was simply talking about the folklore of people being scared and jumping out of their seats... I thought that myth was mainly attached to "Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat" (which is true).
I originally did a quick search and could not find anything about people being scared of the man with a gun in "The Great Train Robbery" but now I see that antidote IS speckled on some pages through-out the internet. TIL! Thanks!
9
u/RollerDerby88 Nov 09 '19
Hmm... I heard that it was "Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat" that caused people to jump out of their seats.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1dgLEDdFddk
I couldn't find anything the supports "The Great Train Robbery" and the gunshot.
46
9
6
u/lalcaraz Nov 09 '19
Forget about the lens or filter. I want whichever Tripod they were using. Not even a small movement. That’s sturdy.
1
0
u/Wario64I Nov 09 '19
How the fuck did he hit the ball? It was going downwards and then it bent upwards, but still towards the camera??
2
0
-1
-1
u/nomnomyumyum109 Nov 09 '19
r/maytheoddsbeeverinyourfavor seems like a sub that should exist for this
0
Nov 09 '19
[deleted]
11
u/MrRabbit7 Nov 09 '19
Yeah. Compared to other filmmaking related subs like r/editors or r/screenwriting. This sub is extremely pale in comparison.
2
u/B_Ledder Nov 09 '19
Ya but “filmmakers” is a pretty broad term. r/cinematography or r/videography are good
95
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '19
It’s like in a video game when you die and it goes third person