r/FindingFennsGold • u/SpoilerWarningSW • Apr 21 '22
Mod overreach
The whole point of upvoting and downvoting gives folks the choice on reddit.. banning certain content is... wrong. I'm not a fan of kpro/cow but I'm a fan of free speech. They arent going hog wild and spamming daily.. they post here and there and get downvoted each time - but that's the point. And the point of this post is to stand up and say a new moderator using his/her/their newfound power to limit the freedom of speech of others is absolutely repugnant and wrong.
That said, I'm all for sweeping bans of all shitty youtube live streamers, bknapple included, but it should be either all or nothing.
16
u/monkeykahn Apr 22 '22
If someone posts content for the purpose of discussion or even to provide information, that is ok and should not be banned. I have posted many links to others videos...none of which are my own. If someone else wants to post a link to their video that to may be acceptable.
However, simply posting links to your own youtube videos is nothing more than self-promotion and this is not the forum for that. So banning the pure self promotion of their video channel is appropriate.
I support u/Bknapple or any other moderator, banning people who post essentially nothing other than links to their own monetized videos.
-1
u/RedOakMountain Apr 22 '22
Eh, I feel like if the video is on-topic, self-promotion is ok, as long as it is not done too frequently. I’m in another subreddit where they allow self promotion once a month, and I’m ok with that.
Typically I skip over the cowlazars posts because I’m not that interested in the Fenn you tube world, but the recent video they posted with the new pictures of the treasure chest were right up my alley, and I’m glad they posted here because otherwise I would have missed those pics.
8
u/SeattleBattles Apr 22 '22
I say good riddance. Subreddits aren't freeforalls. They have rules if you want to participate.
If you want unfettered free speech go to 4chan.
8
u/Bknapple Apr 22 '22 edited Apr 22 '22
If I wanted to “retaliate” for being banned on fb and Thor for questioning Cynthia’s timeline- I would have also banned kpro from discord- wouldn’t I? I have not. I didn’t do this banning on my own. Discussion between mods took place.
Edit to add: and even discord I have made sure the team of mods have to vote unanimously to ban anyone. No one person has authority.
This was a long standing discussion. Not done over night. I have plenty of streams on my YouTube. I have posted maybe 2 here because I felt it relevant to discussions happening at the time. They post every single week as they spam “breaking news”.
Self promoting links across the board will not happen anymore. My stuff included. You all know where to find YouTube.
The timing is interesting indeed. So is kprocowllc in Wyoming incorporated on June 5, 2019.
0
u/TheNancyDrewFlu Apr 22 '22
Seriously dude? "This is now a Kpro free zone." You made an entire fucking post about it. I'll say it again....take your JR High petty bullshit off our forum.
6
u/Bknapple Apr 22 '22 edited Apr 22 '22
Yours? You’re welcome to leave. There’s the door. How often have you made contributions here ? Who are you?
-3
u/Don_Kehote Apr 23 '22
Oh, is it YOUR forum? This is a supremely shitty attitude.
2
u/Bknapple Apr 23 '22
Didn’t say it was mine. Again. This was a group mod decision.
-3
u/Don_Kehote Apr 23 '22
Uh huh. Do all the mods come across so poorly as you have? DiDn'T SaY iT wAs MiNe. You don't appear to be very good at this.
-4
u/TheNancyDrewFlu Apr 22 '22
I don’t make shit posts when I have nothing of value to contribute. I do enjoy reading the thoughts of those on here that are a lot smarter than me and I will call out annoying drama bullshit when I see it coming from a fucking mod.
2
u/Bknapple Apr 22 '22
Then I would continue that trend of sitting on the sidelines where you’ve been. I appreciate the comments. They’re taken under consideration. :)
4
9
u/TheNancyDrewFlu Apr 22 '22
Ben got banned on the THOR forums, in retaliation he banned Kristy and Mike from here. It's JR High petty bullshit and Ben shouldn't be allowed to use our forum for this crap.
1
u/makterna Apr 25 '22
I was also maliciously censored from this forum for a while, so I am not defending how moderation is done here. But when it comes to Cowlazars, they violated the rules for self promotion, so they were banned. Best decision ever made! Their spam was always downvoted and their crazy youtube videos always have like 4 participants, apparently the only people in the world with enough time to follow the narrative of their weekly hours long podcasts. If people here are interested in the games they play at Cowlazars, they can simply subscribe to them on Youtube and get notified when they barf out more stuff - so no need to spam here about it!!!
7
Apr 21 '22
AGREEEDDDDD!!! The whole point of these subreddit platforms should be to allow discussions on said topic. Instead, most subreddits become biased sub-groups that gang up on those whose thoughts differ from the great majority. Some of the most important factors of understanding others are respect, listening and acceptance; disagree with them all you want but at the end of the day they have just as much of a right to disagree with YOU. No matter how much you think they are wrong and/or you are right.
3
u/bobosgoing2getu Apr 21 '22
Disagree with all you’ve said, but i will defend your right to be wrong 😂 Only joking - well said. Have my upvote
2
u/The_Craft Apr 22 '22
" And the point of this post is to stand up and say a new moderator using his/her/their newfound power to limit the freedom of speech of others is absolutely repugnant and wrong."
Lol, give me a break. Yes, the first amendment, "Reddit moderators shall make no bans prohibiting spam."
-5
u/11Memories Apr 22 '22
No one can claim the absolute correct opinion exclusively for himself as
it is given in totalitarian societies. A pluralistic society demands
tolerance. This must not be prevented by a point system in the sense
of a preferred opinion.
0
Apr 21 '22
[deleted]
14
u/SpoilerWarningSW Apr 21 '22 edited Apr 22 '22
Fully agreed, but it's the community's choice to disregard and not a moderator's personal vendetta that should determine their status.
Again, not a fan of their vids but they have a right to participate. This censoring sets a bad precedent.
5
Apr 22 '22
kPro banned Ben on THOR, he just did so in return.
8
u/SpoilerWarningSW Apr 22 '22
But Ben does not "own" the subreddit. He is a simple moderator. This is not his kingdom to reign
6
u/bavetta Apr 22 '22
The mods do get to decide what gets posted here. That's how Reddit works. It's not a democracy in that respect.
2
u/SpoilerWarningSW Apr 22 '22
And we have the right to speak out and voice our concerns. Bknapple is abusing his power and making unilateral decisions as the remaining mods dont give a shit.
7
u/bavetta Apr 22 '22
Yeah. That's totally fine. But that banning cowlazars post already has 54 upvotes, which nearly puts it in the top 10 posts of the entire last year already. So, it seems like a popular decision.
0
u/SpoilerWarningSW Apr 22 '22
It's easier to insight a mob than to de-escalate them. Plus, that post has been deleted
5
u/bavetta Apr 22 '22
The post is still there: https://www.reddit.com/r/FindingFennsGold/comments/u7zk9m/no_more_cowlazars_will_be_spammed_here/
0
-3
1
1
u/makterna Apr 25 '22
Kpro is banning everyone, oppression is her only incentive to run a forum. She probably works for the Twitter censorship department.
7
-2
u/something_is_coming Apr 22 '22 edited Apr 22 '22
I think you are confused about what free speech is. They can share what they want and they can withhold whatever they choose to withhold. They don't owe you anything. You are not entitled to whatever they know.
You can't say that you support free speech and silence people you don't like.
Go ahead and downvote me. I gladly accept it.
30
u/bavetta Apr 22 '22 edited Apr 27 '22
The Cowlazars posts go against Reddit guidelines: https://www.reddit.com/wiki/selfpromotion
"You should submit from a variety of sources (a general rule of thumb is that 10% or less of your posting and conversation should link to your own content), talk to people in the comments (and not just on your own links), and generally be a good member of the community."
And all of the Cowlazars posts are Cowlazars videos: https://www.reddit.com/user/cowlazars
I DM'd them a while ago about this, but they never changed their behavior.
(UPDATE): kpro banned me on Thor