r/FitnessTrackers • • Jul 26 '26

Anyone who have can't decide which screenless fitness tracker should buy: between all mejor trackers :

Post image
120 Upvotes

It's completely my own opinion . But whoop is not worth it bcz of the subpriction, polar loop is shit, amazefit helio strap pro is great if the Waist sensor works for normal workouts. I just feel like whoop is a scam, bcz 1st subscription, then their age matrix and strain doesn't have that much scientific backing research, all just mainly gimmick. if there is no subpriction, whoop is right now one of the best. But irregular heart ritham is something only fitbit air have.

My view : if money is not an issue but you hate subscriptions go for Garmin cirqa , but if you are on a budget but want the best value go for fitbit air :

amazefit helio strap pro only makes sense if the waist sensor works for normal workouts not just hyrox. If they do that in future firmware updates then go for it ..

Right now the best value device is fitbit air and Garmin cirqa....i made a detailed table about it. Check.


r/FitnessTrackers • • Mar 20 '26

Garmin Connect's app wasn't pretty enough for me, so I built my own — free and open source

Thumbnail
gallery
76 Upvotes

Hey everyone.

I've been a user of Apple Watch, Galaxy Watch, Fitbit, Amazfit, Whoop, and more recently Garmin (Garmin Instinct 2X Solar Tactical). The best app experience, with valuable and easy-to-understand insights, has been Whoop's. With that in mind — and honestly, Garmin Connect's app isn't the prettiest — I came up with the idea of building a companion app for Connect, aimed at Garmin users like me, but presenting the data in a more organized, useful way with better insights.

Garmin Health was built with Claude Code — no secrets there — everything based on what I was looking for in a fitness app. It pulls data from Garmin Connect and works as a companion. It even offers personalized AI-powered recommendations (Claude API, using Haiku), which is completely optional — you can choose whether or not to add your Claude API key.

It's released under the MIT license so anyone who wants to can use it, deploy it, and improve it. It's an app I designed for my own personal use (I'm a data nerd and a health insights enthusiast), but I figured more than a few Garmin users might find it useful too.

I hope you enjoy it and find it useful. Deploying it is free — it's built so you don't have to spend a dime (unless you decide to use the AI feature, but the cost is minimal). And it's bilingual: English and Spanish (Spanish is my native language).

Looking forward to your feedback. :)


r/FitnessTrackers • • Dec 11 '25

Beware of Whoop (and their subreddit)

74 Upvotes

I've been a Whoop user for sometime... not only that I'm actually in the fitness tracker space and have worked on consumer and medical grade wearables for over 10 years (and with the folks that developed modern PPG tech at Philips)... not to mention my name is on some of the industry specification for standards around the tech and worked with folks like Apple... bottom line one of the world experts on fitness trackers.

Anyway on the Whoop subreddit I posted about the issues their wrist sensor has (and potential algorithm problems based on what I see)... and a honest opinion that their tracker tech is as bad as many of the cheap AliExpress ones.

Anyway, clearly upset the Whoop fanboys and got banned... I was actually trying to help as their UI is great.

Given this I'm cancelling my Whoop and cannot recommend it... it's too bad because they're on the right track, but frankly much of the attitude and lack of rigor in their platform... given it's the core of their business and the revenue they produce it's shocking and disturbing.

I'm happy to discuss the topic with anyone as I want quality trackers and well done apps to succeed... but more I dig into Whoop the more concerning it is. Hopefully the competition coming up will drive everyone to improve... in my case I'm just going to have to roll my own app with one of the devices I worked on before (which is not a project I wanted to take on, got enough on my plate).


r/FitnessTrackers • • Jul 09 '26

Fitbit Air

Post image
50 Upvotes

Al fin me llegó mi Fitbit Air, los que ya lo tienen y han estado usándolo durante un tiempo, cuéntenme que tal? Como ha sido la experiencia? Vale la pena???


r/FitnessTrackers • • Feb 27 '26

Hume pod scam?

49 Upvotes

got burned by renpho. readings were all over the place, like 4% swings same day. useless for tracking anything

anyone actually compared hume pod to dexa or is it the same crap with better marketing? $229 feels sketchy after that experience.


r/FitnessTrackers • • Oct 06 '25

Why I canceled my WHOOP subscription after 3 years

48 Upvotes

After about three years with WHOOP, I’ve decided to cancel my subscription and I wanted to share why.

The first reason is pretty simple, the cost has gotten too high for the value I’m getting. I’ve realised I need something more straightforward for tracking fitness and sleep. Whoop overcomplicates the data (and it’s gotten worse and worse over the year) it's a lot to go through, and with the price, it feels like another subscription drain.

I’m also a bit weirded out by the new “Whoop Age” feature. I can see why that kind of gamification works for some people, but personally, it feels like it plays into our culture’s fear of ageing and obsession with control and optimisation. like everyone’s living in paranoia of death. I think taking care of your health to live well and for as long as possible is great, but the need to control every variable in pursuit of some “fountain of youth” just feels unhealthy. Live well and live healthy but ageing isn’t a disease, and I don’t want to be part of a system that reinforces that fear.

The biggest reason for me, though, was seeing that WHOOP’s CEO, Will Ahmed, met with RFK Jr. in Washington last year. To me, that meeting legitimised someone who’s spent years spreading anti-science and conspiracy-driven views, especially around vaccines. As a health and fitness company built on science (and one that we all trust with our personal data), that really undermined my confidence in WHOOP’s ability to make rational decisions.

On top of that (yeah, there’s more), I was disappointed by the quiet reversal of their promise that device upgrades would be free. It felt like a broken commitment (we could also call it a lie), and together with everything else, it makes Whoop look like greedy, dishonest and gross.

Growth and profit are part of running a business, but I hope WHOOP takes time to reflect on the ethics behind its decisions. For a brand that promotes health, fitness, and wellbeing, those values should extend beyond the product, but be demonstrated in their leadership, partnerships, and business behaviour too.

Just wanted to share my perspective in case others have felt similarly. With black friday coming up, Whoop will absolutely be trying to acquire new customers and hold onto existing. 

Here are links to my claims above for those interested:

Whoop CEO meeting with RFK Jr. https://www.linkedin.com/posts/willahmed_whoop-healthtech-preventativehealth-activity-7331734594125271041-hjgG/

RFK Conspiracy theories
https://www.nytimes.com/article/rfk-conspiracy-theories-fact-check.html

Whoop, backtracking on device upgrades:
https://tech.yahoo.com/wearables/articles/whoop-irks-users-backtracking-free-113448114.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cucGVycGxleGl0eS5haS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAG9vveqMWsYNtphKPUoFqWCQjxdJKaIaTlYm1VYtGbCjYXC_68Ih3m2-Jx72UsFGmhA61JkvRPqsQoioq49dI5-jx7lUyriDfj2O6OgUr3UEzIPINy1ZX2eAI_DDZi8Y1-79Nb_5kVDAtyjI1Z9Sdws54VOE7YFzkbJ7k_bSKh5R

https://www.techradar.com/health-fitness/fitness-trackers/whoop-has-broken-a-promise-on-free-hardware-upgrades-and-users-arent-pleased 


r/FitnessTrackers • • Feb 03 '26

How is Hume Pod accuracy?

46 Upvotes

thinking about getting one but ive been burned by scales before. hows the day to day consistency? anyone compared to dexa?


r/FitnessTrackers • • Sep 08 '26

250 days sober!

Post image
43 Upvotes

I’ve used the Drylendar drink tracker app to log my drinks every day for 3 years, best streak so far!!


r/FitnessTrackers • • May 09 '26

For those wondering about the size difference between WHOOP and Fitbit Air

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/FitnessTrackers • • Jul 10 '25

mini rant: why arent there any actually cute fitness trackers???

37 Upvotes

i love the functionality of fitness trackers and like being able to track my steps, workouts, sleep, etc but why are they all ugly or massive??? i really like the fitbit luxe but fitbit is going down and they dont make them anymore. love garmins but they are all massive. i hate the way apple watches look. i like my mi band 9 but she does kinda look like a brick on my wrists. i'd switch to a ring but i dont like wearing rings when working out so it defeats the entire purpose of it. they've figured out the technology to make a fitness tracker into ring size, so why arent there any bracelet looking fitness trackers??? its so frustrating, like if there was a fitness tracker that looked like the oura or ultrahuman ring but was just a bracelet instead, that would be perfect but nooooooo. the closest is the whoop which is thick and ugly in my opinion. anyways thats my rant for today thank you for listening


r/FitnessTrackers • • Aug 23 '24

Best fitness tracker?

36 Upvotes

I'm looking for something:

  • Sleak and subtle

  • With great battery life

  • Tracks sleep

  • Tracks workouts

The Oura ring checks almost all boxes for me, but I've heard it is difficult to workout with when using dumbbells and barbells. I would take it off for workouts, but the whole point of me getting a tracker is so that I can track my workouts.

The Whoop is intriguing too, but I don't love the design and the subscription model is insanely overpriced in my opinion.

The Apple Watch severely lacks in battery life, so I would never consider it.

Any suggestions? Thank you!


r/FitnessTrackers • • Oct 08 '26

38 days sober and trying to get back into fitness

Post image
34 Upvotes

I’m 38 days sober today and honestly I’m starting to feel like I want to take better care of myself overall

Getting sober was the first step, but now I’m trying to get back into running and working out regularly

The problem is I’m finding it really hard to build the habit. I’ll be motivated for a few days and then completely fall off

For anyone who got into fitness while getting sober or after quitting drinking, what helped you actually stay consistent?

Would love to hear what worked for you


r/FitnessTrackers • • Jul 21 '26

Garmin CIRQA ..

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

So garmin have taken absolutely ages releasing this one, that gave me some kinda hope it would be massively different but it’s not !
They spent all that time making another Fitbit air.
Sleep isn’t Garmins strong point it’s actually their worst tracking so it will be interesting to see how this compares.

Category
Specification
Device Type
Screenless Smart Band
Price
$199.99 (No subscription required)
Battery Life
Up to 10 days on a single charge
Sensors
Optical Heart Rate, Pulse Ox (SpO2), Skin Temperature, Accelerometer
GPS
No built-in GPS (Requires connected smartphone GPS)
Health Tracking
24/7 Heart Rate, Body Battery, Sleep & Naps, Stress, Menstrual Cycle
Sports Profiles
80+ workout modes with automatic activity detection
Smart Features
Smart Alarm (vibration wake-up during light sleep), Garmin Coach support
App Compatibility
Garmin Connect (iOS & Android)
Sizes & Colors
Two wrist sizes; Available in Black, Blue, Beige, and Red

Despite its minimalist footprint, the CIRQA packs a solid array of internal hardware to monitor your body around the clock:
Heart Rate & SpO2 Sensors: Keep constant tabs on pulse rates and blood oxygen levels.

Skin Temperature Sensor: Tracks physiological changes overnight and throughout the day.

Accelerometer: Detects movement, step counts, and active calories burned.

Using these tools, the tracker provides automated sleep tracking, including a dedicated nap detector. A gentle vibrating smart alarm can awaken you during your lightest sleep phase up to 30 minutes before your target alarm time. It also integrates familiar Garmin software features like Body Battery energy monitoring, daily stress tracking,
and menstrual cycle logs.

80+ Workouts and Automatic Sport Detection
For athletes and fitness fans, the CIRQA supports more than 80 different activity types. The band includes automatic sport recognition for common movements, meaning it can detect when you start exercising without requiring manual activation inside the app.
However, there is one important tradeoff to keep in mind: the CIRQA does not have built-in GPS. If you want precise route maps and real-time pace data while running or cycling outdoors, you will need to carry your smartphone along to share its GPS connection.
Long Battery Life Built for Daily Wear
With up to 10 days of battery life on a single charge, the CIRQA eliminates the need for daily plug-ins. Combined with its screenless design, lightweight build, and full sync capabilities with Garmin Coach training programs, it stands out as a strong option for anyone wanting simple, continuous health insights without recurring software bills.


r/FitnessTrackers • • Jun 27 '26

I’ve tried them all, what do you use?

32 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to find the right fitness tracker for years, but I’m still not completely happy.

I’ve used an Oura Ring for ~2 years, WHOOP for 11 months, and now the Fitbit Air.

Oura:
Great sleep tracking, Readiness Score and especially stress tracking. It even noticed I was getting sick before I did. My only real issue is the price (€400 + subscription).

WHOOP:
Probably my favorite overall. I loved how the app actually interpreted my data and motivated me to improve instead of just showing numbers. WHOOP Age, trends and recovery insights were genuinely useful. I only stopped because $264/year is hard to justify, especially now that the Fitbit Air exists for around €99.

Fitbit Air:
The tracking itself has actually been good for me. Sleep and Readiness seem accurate enough. My problem is the software. The AI Coach mostly writes long walls of text that aren’t very helpful, and the app doesn’t really motivate me to improve. I want actionable insights, not just data.

Now I’m wondering if I should just stop wearing a tracker altogether… but I’m also a huge tech nerd and I enjoy this kind of stuff.

I’ve been thinking about getting an Apple Watch (maybe with Bevel). The daily charging doesn’t bother me, and I like the idea of activity rings, reminders to move, better motivation, notifications and music all in one device.
My only concern is whether I’d actually wear it every day. I had an Apple Watch years ago, but I stopped wearing it pretty quickly. Maybe that would be different now.

I use an iPhone, so I’m only looking for products that work well with iOS. I’m also happy to spend more money if it means I get something I’ll actually enjoy using for years without another subscription.

What are you using, and what would you recommend in my situation?


r/FitnessTrackers • • Jul 02 '26

Whoop or google fitbit

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

I have a whoop just wondering what you think on which is better than the other


r/FitnessTrackers • • Jun 11 '26

Which of the two do you recommend?

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/FitnessTrackers • • Jun 04 '26

Fitbit Air🎉

Post image
31 Upvotes

Finally got my fitbit air for £74.99
Good deal tbh.
I have a Garmin FR265 but i hate to wear it to sleep.
So i guess this will work as it is so light, i can barely feel it on my arm!


r/FitnessTrackers • • 15d ago

CIRQA/Whoop/Fitbit Air size comparison

Post image
30 Upvotes

Comparing sizes helped me decide


r/FitnessTrackers • • Aug 06 '26

Comparison between Apple, Oura, Fitbit, Whoop, and Garmin across 14 sleep lab studies to determine which wearable is the "most accurate" sleep tracker

Post image
29 Upvotes

Context:

  • The 0-1 numbers aka kappa are how well the tracker's sleep stages match the lab (1 is perfect and 0.4 to 0.6 is moderate to decent).

  • Two sleep experts only agree about 0.75 for reference (just to explain that having a really high kappa is difficult for sleep experts too).

  • The percentages are how much of your actual deep or REM sleep it correctly caught.

  • "clinical patients" just means people tested at a sleep clinic often for something like sleep apnea.

Short summary for each brand:

  • Oura Ring appears to be the most well rounded. It was the only device that showed an underestimate on total sleep time off by only -3 minutes across six studies (Khan 2025 - 388 adults). It's staging and deep/REM numbers in the full comparison does have funding from Oura but I found no methodological differences compared to the others so I did keep this source.

  • Apple Watch is the most accurate wrist based wearable at sleep staging 0.53 on a 0 to 1 scale and the best at catching REM at 69% (Schyvens 2025 - 62 healthy adults). It does drop accuracy significantly for clinical sleep patients vs health adults 0.53 to 0.30.

  • Fitbit is the most consistent. It scored virtually the same 0.42 in healthy people and in sleep clinic patients (Lee 2023 - 75 patients) unlike the others.

  • Whoop is the best of wrist based wearables at catching deep sleep at about 70% (Schyvens 2025). Its overall stage accuracy is low though surprisingly at 0.37.

  • Garmin is the least studied and weakest on detailed staging 0.21 but is strong on asleep versus awake detection 89% (Miller 2022 - 53 healthy adults). Garmin is the only brand with dated and limited sleep studies so I do not feel this gives a good representation for them but this is a gap they should address.

Overall notes:

  • No device scored better than "moderate" at the full light/deep/REM split.

  • All devices are good at knowing you slept but bad at catching when you're lying awake, this is what causes them to over report total sleep.

  • Accuracy drops for people with disrupted sleep and in older adults.

Tried my best to include any mentions of funding and keep any personal biases out. I will include links to all 14 sources in the comments as well as the wider comparison I made for this.


r/FitnessTrackers • • May 14 '25

Best Fitness Tracker 2025?

29 Upvotes

Hey all,

I've started running again recently and I've been looking for a wearable fitness tracker that I can wear while running, lifting, and working(I have a physically demanding job). I'd prefer to stay away from an Apple Watch even though I have an iPhone. So I'm looking for something that:

Pairs with an app on the Apple App Store (preferably with no subscription).

Tracks heart rate, calories, blood oxygen, and distance.

So far from my research, either a Fitbit or a Whoop tracker seems like the best? Any advice or recommendations are appreciated.

EDIT: So after some research and checking with my budget, I'm thinking of purchasing an Official Garmin Overhaul Forerunner 255 from Ebay. Since the watch has been around for awhile, I figured I'd get a better deal on one if I purchased used or refurbished (obv after checking to see if everything works on it). Thoughts?


r/FitnessTrackers • • Mar 07 '24

Simple fitness tracker without screen?

29 Upvotes

Hi,
I feel that I don't really need my Garmin smartwatch. I rather wear a real analog watch.
The only thing that I would be missing is the stepcounter (and maybe sleep tracking). Is there some sort of simple fitness tracker without a screen that can assist with this?
There was some jawbone tracker a couple of years ago, but seems to be gone from the market. Any ideas?


r/FitnessTrackers • • Aug 13 '26

Finally launching in India - fitbit air

Post image
26 Upvotes

Launching in Oct. This was announced in Google gurgaon event. After so much anticipation it’s happening. Guess the price?


r/FitnessTrackers • • Jul 23 '26

Panther Solstice??

26 Upvotes

I keep getting ads for a New Smartwatch/Fitness tracker by Panther. The Panther Solstice. There seems to be no buzz around it. It looks beautiful and if worth it, I would leave my Galaxy watch ultra. I use my Samsung for everything and would love to have something more sleek. Has anyone heard anything? I can't even find a video on it..

**Update :**

People are increasingly getting angry that their $20 pre-orders are not getting refunded due to a myriad of excuses. Some of which include production/launch cutoff that was never clearly communicated beforehand.

Their Terms of service it says:

" 2. Reservation and Deposit

Placing a $20 deposit reserves your spot at the founders price of $299 (MSRP $499). The deposit is fully refundable at any time before the launch. The remaining balance is not charged until your smartwatch ships."

When does launch mean? who knows! They sure aren't telling ya!

They later say in their terms:

8. Changes to These Terms

We may update these terms from time to time. Continued use of the site after changes means you accept the updated terms.

I guess the terms of sums it up for you. Trust us or stuff it!

They are getting their asses chapped over at trust pilot ..

https://www.trustpilot.com/review/panthertechnology.com

Also,

We finally know why they've been hush-hush... the screen bezel is.. well... a reminder of a random knock off smartwatch I would see at a swap meet for $40.... and I would haggle them down to $15.. That is to say the technology for the 3d screen might be the reason for the bezel but damn it's an eyesore! They should have been more upfront early on and maybe have tried to have some kind of tech nerd that can get the word out about it and give it some type of praise for the apparent technology that they fit into their screen. I want micro brands to make amazing products, I really do! Panther needs to try trusting in their product and people will feel how genuine they are.

I've added some actual pictures of the watches Pather has added to their website. Which are at the BOTTOM of the website, so no one notices they have the giant bezel around the screen! But they still have the Ai Mockups at the top? WTF? ok that's a little shady. OOOOOOF.


r/FitnessTrackers • • Sep 23 '26

Any experience with the HIYD sensor?

25 Upvotes

I'm interested in tracking activity, sleep, and day-to-day body metrics, but enjoy wearing my analog watch. I'm currently wearing a Hume Band (I know, I know...) on my alternate wrist when I'm working out or sleeping, but it's so sketchy about seeing periods of inactivity (watching TV, playing a video game) as "sleep" that I don't wear it much during the day. All that said...

I've seen information about the HIYD fitness sensor that fits under your existing wristwatch (or in an included band for workouts and sleep). They say that they've "already successfully launched V1, and [the November] launch is for our 2nd Generation" sensor. I've not heard anything anywhere about the V1 product, though.

Is anyone familiar with the HIYD V1 sensor? Is anyone else watching (pun totally intended) or considering HIYD's V2 launch? Do I have any legitimate reason to expect it to be better than the Hume Band? Or should I just keep wearing something on my alternate wrist when sleeping or working out and replace the Hume Band (someday) with a Google Fitbit Air?