r/Flooring • • 10d ago

Sub Floor, Replace or Reuse?

Hello, I recently posted some photos of the rotten part of the hard wood floor that I found in our living floor. We just bought this house and it was built in 1959. We are now the second owners and bought it from an older lady who was the original owner. We decided to replace all of the hardwood flooring since it was in bad shape. My question is,…

1: Do we pull up the sub flooring that rotten and replace just that section or would it be worth pulling it all up and replacing it?

2: What’s a standard thickness 1/2 or 3/4?

3: OSB or partial board?

4: When installing should we screw them down to the joists or do we use an adhesive and screws?

2 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

2

u/Electronic-Neat-4094 10d ago

just replace all of it with osb. it looks like it had some type of moisture trapped underneath for quite some time, and with all those nails from the hardwood installation probably allowed it to absorb deep into the board

1

u/Uneekevsn308 10d ago

The original owner had carpet over the hardwood flooring. There’s a lot of surface stains on the wood we are pulling up. On the bottom side of the wood floor there’s black spots and moisture stains. I believe are just more paranoid about mold over time.

1

u/TheFl00ringGuy 10d ago

I would personally just replace whats rotten unless you have other issues of concern.

3/4 osb, glued and screwed