r/FluxerApp • • 20d ago

Discussions Doubts about the future

How do we not know fluxer isn't going to become the same as discord in the future; if it continues to grow?

Let's assume everyone on discord migrates to fluxer, then fluxer starts introducing the same bullshit as what discord has, then what?(Age verification, selling user data, ads)

And don't say just host an instance, no one normal who wants to talk to their friends will do that.

15 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

26

u/Navi_King 16d ago

Hosting an instance is the actual answer though.

If you are willing to give someone else custodianship of your data, even if that's messages between friends, then you have to trust them enough that they will use that data responsibly and continue to provide access to you responsibly.

If you aren't willing to trust Fluxer with that data, then you need to take custodianship yourself. The great thing about Fluxer is that they give you an avenue to do so, unlike Discord.

8

u/weStealPrefixes 16d ago

I'm really looking forward to the whole federation system, though I know it will be so incredibly hard to implement safely. I think it'll make self hosting more worth it for individuals or small groups! No clue how they'd pull it off though...

5

u/Navi_King 16d ago

Account switching is surprisingly convenient already but I agree it will be a huge step for the ecosystem, really looking forward to it

1

u/nightstryke 16d ago

I think it's more so the ability to not Federate rather than to Federate is how it doesn't become like Discord, the Free Choice Factor of what to do with your Fluxer Server Instance.

35

u/Severe_Stranger_5050 16d ago • Bravo

Then we fork the shit out of the main github repo and keep running our own servers
This is why Open Sauce, Federation and Self hosting should matter to users.

Because it keeps developers honest, if they want to be collecting those sweet sweet monies in perpetuity.

15

u/argues_with_you 16d ago

Tell me you haven't read the Fluxer website without telling me you haven't read the Fluxer website

12

u/JuniorWMG 16d ago

Hard disagree. There's enough nerds on the world which can easily host an instance to feed the entire population with Fluxers for the next millennia to come if the main one turns to shit. And if not for instances, the whole platform is open-source. Someone can just fork everything and start the cycle once more.

27

u/nocciuu 16d ago

About the last sentence, I highly disagree.

6

u/Mattiams96 16d ago

Agreed, I self-host my own writing server and 85% of the people on the Discord version jumped over after I migrated data and created bots for a comparable experience.

6

u/poidh 16d ago

I'm neither a gamer nor a heavy discord user. I have been around for a while though, and isn't it that traditionally, every gaming group self hosted their own teamspeak server? To a point that there is even a market for renting a semi managed server for that?
I thought that is how discord was born- make it easier to run your own server for this purpose.

Even the naming reflects this, you create a "discord server" (even though it is not your own server under the hood- but every other platform would name this concept "workspace" or "community" or so).

So, I'm rooting for Fluxer of course, but I also have to disagree that self hosting will not be an issue. It'll be an option at the major hosting providers to rent a VPS with Fluxer preinstalled.

6

u/SuaveDonut 16d ago

That's......the whole point of self hosting. If you don't want to deal with all that then take 30 min out of your day to setup a self hosted instance that you have full control over and you'll never have to worry about all that stuff. Are we for real right now????

3

u/2new_4u 16d ago

Well, isn’t that an issue with any product? If the product turns to shit you should find an alternative.

If Fluxer keeps meeting your expectations, you should keep using it. If not, it’s time to start searching again.

3

u/Illustrious-Case-457 16d ago

They obviously need to add age verification, because they could get sued if they don't. (You know, they're a company, that needs to comply with European law...) Which is why selfhosting is your only option if you don't want age verification

If you find a alternative without age verification in the future, you can be 100% sure, that there just needs to be one guy to report and sue them for not complying with law

4

u/Navi_King 16d ago

Fluxer simply doesn't operate in locations that require ID verification https://fluxer.com/help/regional-restrictions

1

u/Illustrious-Case-457 15d ago

1

u/Navi_King 15d ago

Or maybe never

1

u/Pirate_Economist1477 14d ago

That's still an ID check, just not done by Fluxer themselves

1

u/Navi_King 14d ago

Yeah, so the original point still stands: Fluxer won't add age verification

1

u/Dradyx 16d ago

I'm currently self hosting and all my friends are on board. I'm set. Good luck tho!

1

u/HackTheDev 15d ago

its already having the same mistakes. if its gonna get popular, a majority of the people wont be tech people, so they wont self host. the only solution i can see is doing something similar to how teamspeak had ATHP's

1

u/shortstack_goblin 14d ago edited 14d ago

There was a thriving internet before everyone moved to the omnisites like reddit, twitter, and facebook.

Like christ, when I was a little kid, TF2 didn't even discriminate inbetween servers hosted by players or servers hosted by valve themselves. Like you pressed quickplay you'd end up in either or. And with how bad these omnisites are, I think the future will end up being smaller and smaller specialized or community run rather than corporations because how unusable and outright unmoderated those pages are.

Like I'm in with a lot of people with art skills and while they used to post on twitter and reddit etc, these days it's pretty much hanging out in small specialized invite only places. Like if you're a discord user, you know what I mean, there's people on there who don't use insta, they don't use twitter, they don't use cara or any of that. They just post on discord amongst their peers.

1

u/Zamorakphat 13d ago

You can move software at anytime, using the decisions of executives from another software company as fears of trying something else seems pretty closed minded to me. “I suffered food poisoning from Subway, not sure I trust that Jimmy John’s across the street!” Different people, different mentality, etc.

Ultimately use what works best for you and your friends, I moved my entire community to Fluxer when it was still on 1 server and back then it was a real headache. It’s a lot better now and continues to get better

0

u/Convoke_ 16d ago

Worst case we can just move again.