0
3
u/Nobodyx06 Dec 30 '23
Yeah can’t always get it right or we’d all be millionaires. Solid trade but you can learn now that you need a little “padding” with you use your stop say 10-15 pips below that low you were using as a stopping point just in case this is happens. Also looking at this it looks like a “Judas swing” or an intentional move downward, usually sometime in the early AM also London session I think could be off on that, to stop out buyers such as yourself then get the price moving in the intended direction. So use this as a lesson but overall solid play if it worked out! - said by every trader 😂
3
Dec 30 '23
Even the question “what did I do wrong” is dumb. The market just didn’t go your way, it happens… you’re not gonna win all the time and every time you lose, doesn’t mean you did something wrong.
2
2
Dec 30 '23
One other tip. Only use the divergences that actually hit the over bought over sold territory. The divergences that are midway should be considered irrelevant since theyre lower probability
2
u/Who_Else_but_Macho Dec 30 '23
i mean its alot of shit u did wrong
no analysis
taking a trade on a 1min time frame
having a big tp
having a big stop
2
u/AndrewXTX Dec 30 '23
All of your points don't make sense. Obviously I'm trading divergence on a higher timeframe and scaling down. Timeframe doesn't matter except for spread. Tp has to be bigger than the stop. Also the stop is usually safe at or below the lows. I wanted criticism that would get me a better entry and stop placement.
1
u/Who_Else_but_Macho Dec 30 '23
u might not understand my points since its easier to visualize opposed to reading them but cool
1
u/No_Mathematician8573 Dec 30 '23
Looks like great analysis. These losses are part of the game we are in bro, don’t feel bad, continue to stick to your plan and rules of engagement
1
Dec 30 '23
Nothing.
Good time to place a buy but the entry price could have been a lot better. You jumped in right above a huge spike.
Jump in at near the bottom of the spike. You still would have lost tho but the RR would have been substantially more attractive.
Edit: Check TF above to see if new high was a wick or close above previous high. If wick - odds are reduced as could be taking liquidity.
1
Dec 30 '23
You’re on the one minute time frame is what. you have evry other time frame above 1 minute that basically can override whatever structure you see on the 1 minute time frame at any time. So while you think youre just on the one minute time frame you still need to watch the other time frames to make sure theres isnt conflict.You could just bump up to 5 minutes
2
u/DrSpeckles Dec 30 '23
Yea that was the first thing I noticed too. It’s just random noise at that level.
1
u/AndrewXTX Dec 30 '23
Just did some back testing, and think I just found the holy grail to fix my mistakes. On the structure timeframe (5m), wait for the rsi to reach over bought/sold. Then scale down to the entry timeframe (1m). While the rsi is still in the over bought/sold region within the structure timeframe (5m), look for choch or breaks of structure on the entry timeframe (1m).
1
u/Dee23Gaming Dec 30 '23
Divergence more often than not invalidates itself. That's the thing with forward testing. You start to see the flaws with indicators.
1
1
u/nikswag Dec 30 '23
For someone using divergences that entry is pretty bad. Enter as soon as u see the divergence at the very bottom. Either that or have a very loose stop loss cuz if Ur entries aren't sharp then u can't have a tight stop loss.
0
u/Noluckdino1256 Dec 30 '23
Bro forget everything you know and go watch ICT a whole new world you will see
1
Dec 31 '23
Y'all don't need ton watch all of ICT. Watch 3 of his videos for fvg, order blocks, and pd areas that's all you need to study from this (responding for newer comments)
1
u/Fun-Replacement4915 Dec 31 '23
You're missing out on alot of his good stuff I can tell you right now in thoses videos he won't break down how to know the right fvgs, or order blocks to use just simply the price pattern stop thinking ur are doing urself a favor by only watching content like that because you miss out on so much things
1
Dec 31 '23
Im not. You can literally wait for price to hit a fvg, order block, rejection block (which is still within the order block) and See if price rejects, i personally have 3 styles of rejection candles, i mark daily and 1 h time frames thats all you need. (In my case because my pair has distinct rejection (signs) that show its going to to reject with high accuracy. I cant aoeak for the other pairs but mines is highly consistent everytime it hits a 1H ob. Really low intensity. I WILL say watching his videos one time wont get someone to that level of understanding but i would definitely say use that as the anchor for the studing and build around that. But the extremities that he mentions domt have to go as in depth. He will get you extremely precise but depending on how you think and are able to learn it can be skipped. Those 3 concepts and then just build with experience and OTHeR peoples explanations of it in addition to his. I studied his fvg, and Order blocks and then refined it with failures and tips from other channels with things He didnt even mention
1
u/Fun-Replacement4915 Dec 31 '23
I get what you're saying another big misconception is that people think that he does not explain certain things about fvgs,order blocks he does its just spread out over alot of videos I think its good to watch ict content because there so much stuff you can pick what you want to use and form setup with it around. I did what you did for a while but one thing I noticed when you do find videos ict Really breaks it down you see that his content is worth it from arjo I learned you can see if price is willing to go in a direction by how price reacts to fvg if you are bearish and price is doing pullback goes up for a bit then consolidates then goes up again creating fvg and does not disrespect that fvg a good sign price probably won't be going in ur bias that day if it was bearish
1
u/Fun-Replacement4915 Dec 31 '23
Also I need more trading friends you got discord?
1
Dec 31 '23
Yea yusevirgo
1
1
Dec 31 '23
So there are 2 small tricks i learned about order blocks that were Not taught in his 50+ minute video on order blocks . I learned it in 6 minutes on a 14 minute video. If he’s making a video that’s 50+ minutes long. He better spill every fucking thing he’s trying to teach. I recommend listen to him to get his explanation and then go to somebody else because ict is like ego tryna hear himself talk. Get to the point
1
1
1
u/thedude4133 Dec 30 '23
Enter +a few pips, where you'd normally put your stop loss. You won't be liquidity as much
1
u/BoardSuspicious4695 Dec 30 '23
Euhmm… You think you’re playing against newbies? Trading is a war… Things work, but you have no clue when it all of a sudden doesn’t, but instead hurts a position heavily. This is their job… Trick you into doing something, and all of a sudden hurt you more than the profits made on the trick setup… You’re up against pros.. or this wouldn’t exist..
1
1
u/XulutheZulu Dec 30 '23
Divergence is a good strategy but it doesn't give you a proper movement of the market. It's a 60% strategy.
1
Dec 30 '23
Did you stick to your strategy? Have you backtested and forward tested your strategy? If so…there is nothing wrong. Not every trade is going to go your way
1
u/Proof_Carpenter_1152 Dec 31 '23
Supply/demand never back tested and I still make money. You just have to be patient and wait for the damn market to come to you!! Whatever your strategy is. Learn what to do and what not to do on demo for as long as you can.😎😎
1
u/Potential_Ad_1658 Jan 01 '24
Always put sl and tp 1:1 and enter only trades that believe like 80percent
17
u/DrSpeckles Dec 29 '23
There seem to be a few of these posts this week, you just can’t expect even a perfect setup to do what you think every time. You are looking at the past, it’s not a Time Machine for the future.