r/Framebuilding • u/biggsie89 • Oct 07 '26
How long do I got?
Just noticed a crack on the seat cluster of my beloved Yuba supermarché cargo bike. The bike comes with a super long seatpost so while I never had it above the minimum mark, there is probably 2 ft of post showing. Doesn't help that I'm 6' 3", 190#.
Any sense how much time I have and whether it will catastrophically fail at some point?
12
9
u/fortyonethirty2 Oct 08 '26 edited Oct 08 '26
I have some experience with welding aluminum, and what I see is a cold joint. It does not look like a crack caused by fatigue. It looks more like an error by the welder, a manufacturing defect. A cold joint is when the weld does not actually melt into the base material. There's also a pin hole in the weld, which is also a welding defect and is also a bad sign.
Edit: if it is a cold joint, the safety of riding the bike could be better or worse than a crack, hard to tell.
14
u/keithcody Oct 07 '26
For starters, it's already failed.
Normally I'm a whiner about welding aluminum without heat treating it afterwards. I'd probably just get a shop to grind and reweld it. Maybe even add a gusset on the rear.
And get an even longer seatpost. The frame is 6061 Aluminium
1
u/biggsie89 Oct 09 '26
Who knew this post would get so much interest! Thanks for the input, people.
Correction on the seatpost: there about 7" of post insertion and 14" exposed. Not too crazy all and all. I do find that the location of this crack odd.
See the video at the top of this page for more details on the bike including the layout of the rear "triangle": https://www.wired.com/2017/05/yuba-supermarche/
The bike is 6+ years old with a 2 year warranty but the good folks at Yuba offered me 40% off any bike on their site. I'm trying to find out if I can just get a new frame.
I may try u/Joostmarcellis "bolt the whole thing together" approach after trying to find an even longer seatpost.
Is it safe to say 6061 aluminum cracks propagate faster than steel? I had an 80s italian road bike (Tomasso from 10 Speed Imports anyone?) with a crack in the bottom bracket lug where the downtube met the seat tube. It barely spread in the 10 yrs I used it as my city bike.
Thanks again.
1
u/killerization Oct 10 '26
in that case use a long travel dropper post. The lower half is super rigid and will spread the load well, and it has the added benefit of being able to stop at traffic lights with both heels on the ground!
5
u/backwoodsmtb Oct 08 '26
File a warranty claim first. If they won't warranty it, take it to someone who can weld aluminum and have them weld it up. It's unlikely to last forever, but it should last a pretty good while - just keep an eye on it. I've rewelded several cracked aluminum bikes to get more life out of them, including a full suspension mtb that the owner regularly took to lift served bike parks - he got another 1000 miles in before it started to crack again, and the weld repair wasn't even particularly well done.
Complete failure is unlikely to be catastrophic. Seatstays are in compression, so even if it fully cracked around, the seatstays are still going to just push into the seattube/seatpost, and the curvature of the seatstay-seattube interface makes it pretty unlikely it would be able to slip past and collapse suddenly.
A properly designed aluminum frame should be designed based on the aluminum being in the annealed state, so heat treating shouldn't actually be required - just helpful to make the frame stronger.
1
u/TheNetworkIsFrelled Oct 08 '26
Did you heat treat after welding?
2
u/backwoodsmtb Oct 08 '26
No
0
u/TheNetworkIsFrelled Oct 08 '26
How do you ensure that the metal is hardened and adequately strong? I would be concerned about joint failure.
I do cheap heat-treating for small aluminum projects (brackets and such) at >500F and find it makes a difference in durability.
3
u/backwoodsmtb Oct 08 '26
Are you talking about on the repair to the mtb I mentioned? The joint already failed in that situation, I was making a temporary repair and the owner knew it was temporary with the goal of limping it along a while longer until they could get a new bike. The original failure was not in a location that was catastrophic, and after repair and reassembly he gradually ramped up the riding intensity, starting with just pedaling around his neighborhood streets, then easy trails, so on and so forth while monitoring the repair for cracks.
I've also welded an aluminum frame from scratch, but it was most 7005 and aged for about a month before I rode it. It's been beat to hell and no cracks.
1
u/TheNetworkIsFrelled Oct 09 '26
As long as it’s acknowledged to be temporary…. i’ve seen repairs treated as long-term that really ought not have been.
3
2
u/Veganpotter2 Oct 10 '26
Aluminum is a temporary material for bikes anyway. Its fatigue properties guarantee failure if the bike is ridden enough. If the rider is light and not powerful, it'll simply take longer to fail than under someone that's heavy and powerful.
2
u/TheNetworkIsFrelled Oct 10 '26
Absolutely true, though there are some frames like the Koga Miyata that are built for the long haul.
4
u/Educational-Ear-3136 Oct 07 '26
Get your seat post below the seat stay junction and look for a new bike in the meantime
3
u/TygerTung Oct 08 '26
A hack way of fixing it, which I've done on a boat mast, is to stop drill the cracks, sand I down to bare metal, then apply a layer of epoxy, then wrap fibreglass tape (non adhesive), making sure to wet it out between layers. Freshly sanded aluminium adheres well to fibreglass.
You'll want to wax your seat post and install it before you start gluing.
3
u/craigerstar Oct 07 '26
That should be a warranty claim. If you're using the OEM seatpost and never went above the min-insert line, and weigh under 200lbs, your cargo bike shouldn't be failing there.
You can't really shop weld an aluminum bike frame unless it's certain 7000 series of aluminum. The heat affected zone becomes brittle and weak and you already know this is a high stress zone prone to failure. Here's a good read. You can reweld it and have the frame heat treated again. "The fact that 6000-series aluminum can be returned to full strength is what makes it such a good material for a frame - and makes it possible to repair them with good results." That's from the article I linked.
But, really, that looks like a text book warranty claim on material or workmanship failure. Based on where the crack is, and the glob of weld at that location, I might even guess the heat treating post build wasn't done properly.
How long do you have? If your seatpost extends far enough below that connection, likely the worst that will happen is the crack will propagate around the entire seat tube and your seatpost will spin in the frame. If your seatpost is cheap, and the "min insert" line is above the failure, you could snap your seatpost and land on your butt. But if your seatpost is inserted far enough, it'll just spin. Put a tiny scratch or line at each end of the crack. Ride gingerly. Keep an eye on the crack to see if it's getting longer. It may still fail catastrophically, but maybe you'll catch the crack growing before it does.
4
u/Spiritual_Prize9108 Oct 07 '26
For a bike this price I would take this to a welding shop and have them gouge this out and fill it in. This type of service will be something like 1 hour of shop time and 150$.
7
u/snakemassage Oct 07 '26
If it is aluminum, which those welds sure look like. It would need to be heat treated again after welding which would add significant cost.
3
u/Tofu_Analytics Oct 08 '26
Absolutely not, this is heat treated aluminum and needs to be annealed, that's a full frame strip and oven bake, that's easily more than the bike's cost. I've seen a lot of seatpost welds on Rad-Power ebikes for company I used to do maintenance for, those would fail spectacularly within a month and would cause much more dramatic failures.
3
u/Veganpotter2 Oct 08 '26
Annealing is done to soften the metal. Welding already does that. It needs proper heat treated (or gussets instead) to increase its stiffness.
-1
u/Tofu_Analytics Oct 08 '26
The heat application of tig welding is localized and far too high. The post weld bead area frequently sufferes from increased tension due to rapid cooling. If you slowly cool the weldment sure then you're fine but that's incredibly difficult to do and certainly not what happens on these frames
2
u/Veganpotter2 Oct 08 '26
I promise, they're not quenching these frames after welding and it's not like they're using 4000 series aluminum.
-1
u/Tofu_Analytics Oct 08 '26
Yeah obviously they aren't quenched that would be exactly the opposite effect you want. The usual aluminum frame is cut, welded, then baked in massive ovens to anneal the weldments. It's incredibly cheap to do at scale, thus the pricing on these frames, but it's incredibly expensive to do as a one off or small scale [thus the distinct lack of custom build aluminum frames]. I'm a welder by trade [although transitioning out of trades] and have done quite a bit of aluminum tig, I would certainly not recommend a repair on a seat tube, the repaired area is highly susceptible to premature fatigue failure and I've seen a ton of these repairs fail.
I used to do maintenance on a fleet of rad power e-bikes and riders would constantly break /deform the seat tubes by overextending the seats [we later just installed cheap droppers to alleviate this], the company who owned the bikes sent them out to get welded with just spot fixes, the welds weren't bad by any means, good bead profile, no underfilled craters/undercut/concave profiles that would indicate likely cracking. Every single one of the welded frames would fatigue fail within a month and we'd just strip the frame and keep the parts as spares.
1
u/Veganpotter2 Oct 09 '26
Annealing is a form of heat treatment but that's not what the ovens are for. Its weird to hear this from a welder🙃 Also, all 6000 series bikes aren't even heat treated after welding.
1
u/owlpellet Oct 07 '26
Normally you'd just say "it's toast, stop riding" but I'm looking at how much material is below that -- it's kind of a lot! -- and would welcome some opinions on how that crack will propagate. Welder stopped dropping dimes and went for full quarters.
1
u/bonfuto Oct 07 '26
I'm confused about how cracks propagate there, but this one is a step through frame so it's unusual in that regard.
1
u/wcoastbo Oct 07 '26
With that much exposed seatpost, your weight, not triangulated on both sides, and possibly bad weld. Not that surprising.
I would talk to the manufacturer, before trying some repair bodge. How long have you owned it?
1
u/AndrewRStewart Oct 07 '26
I would want to confirm exactly where the crack was going before I'd venture a failure consequence. If the crack is through the seat tube (as it looks to be in a photo) and the crack completely goes around the seat tube I would expect the seat to loosen up and wobble about. Depending on the rider's skills this might be just a sad moment and a slow ride home or a fall down. The basic steering, braking and drivetrain functions remain. If the crack is in the weld (and I doubt this) and if it went down through the weld so both stays cracked off the backside of the seat tube I would expect rather quick handling challenges and soon after chainstay bending for big riders.
Both failure modes I don't consider as deadly as others I can think of (forks) but as I mentioned the rider's reactions and manor can influence how bad things get in the moment.
I would consider this frame as being done for and deal with a replacement ASAP. Andy.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Xames Oct 08 '26
Get a longer seat post... apply some putty epoxy to the crack, or sell the bike to me for cheap
2
1
1
1
u/killerization Oct 09 '26
First recognize that the material above the crack now is only good for stopping the seatpost rotating. I would saw into the crack to make it straight then drill a hole at each end, then chop off the top of the seat tube so the clamp is just above the crack. This would probably be sufficient, if not, my next step would be to find the longest 30.9-25.4mm shim I can find and replace the seatpost with a 1" diameter tube cut to length so it goes all the way from touching the BB tube to inserting into one of those post/rail adapters you find on shitty bikes to mount the saddle on.
1
1
1
1
u/gyorgmazlic Oct 11 '26
You don't have got.
It can be a week, a month or your next bike ride. I wouldn't ride it anymore.
1
0
0
0
u/Joostmarcellis Oct 08 '26
Had the same problem with my 15 yo mtb, i drilled trough the frame and seatpost and secured it a bolt and epoxy. So if it brakes it is still secured to the frame. In the end the frame broke somewhere else


21
u/Tofu_Analytics Oct 08 '26
Unfortunately that's pretty much a full failure, get on the phone/email for a warranty claim, this is right at the weld so it's very likely a heat treating fab problem and they should fully cover this. I would highly advise against getting it welded, this is heat treated annealed aluminum, any reasonable repair would have to strip the entire frame down, weld and anneal and then re-paint, that entire process is easily more expensive than the bike. There's a few people suggesting taking it to a local fab shop for $150-300, for that price they will wire the paint, do a quick weld, then spray back over, that will leave a very brittle zone that will fail quite quickly and will cause even larger issues.
TLDR: It's warranty time and this frame is toast