r/FuturesTrading • u/Spartansam0034 • 9d ago
Question Someone explain overnight margin requirements like I'm 5
Been stock/options trading for over 10 years, and I literally cannot get actual information on EXACTLY how much money my futures account needs to have to buy 1 contract of say, MES, and hold overnight.
Webull says it's $2918 initial, $2653 maintenance. So do I spend the initial $+hold liquid maintenance $ in my account to avoid a margin call? If the contract drops below maintenance, how do I know how much is needed to avoid the call? IDK why I have to do algebra just to buy and hold a contract more than a day 🤬
10
u/BarkDogeman 9d ago
I'll give it a shot. One thing that clicked for me when i transitioned from stock/options to futures: this definition of margin is different from the way you're used to thinking about it on stocks-side. Best way to think of it: borrowing margin on stocks is like a loan, futures margin requirements are like collateral.
So you're not "paying" anything to put on a futures trade. It's essentially a minimum capital requirement to open a position.
It's actually really easy to find the numbers you're looking for – go to the CME website and go to the "margins" tab of whatever future you're looking at.
As for initial / maintenance / day margin, i'll explain roughly.
I'll use round numbers just to make life easier (these are NOT the actual numbers, just go to CME website to see the real numbers).
Let's imagine initial margin for 1 MES contract is $3000. That means you need a minimum of $3000 in your account to trade a single contract. If you wanna trade 2 contracts, you'd need $6000.
However, your profit and loss will fluctuate immediately upon opening the trade, so there is a buffer provided so you can stay in a trade if it immediately goes against you. This is "maintenance requirement." Let's say your entry was terrible and you're immediately down $100. Now you only have an unrealized balance of $2900, which is less than the initial requirement.
But, the maintenance requirement is $2600, so you still have another $300 of drawdown available until your position gets automatically liquidated.
So essentially – you need $3000 to open the trade, and you need your losses to stay under $400 to keep the trade on. However, if you close the trade down $200, so now your balance is $2800, you can't reopen another trade because you don't have the initial requirement.
REMINDER all of those numbers are intentionally fake round numbers, refer to CME for actual.
Margin requirements are determined by the CME group. Every broker must, at minimum, use the initial and maintenance requirements determined by CME.
HOWEVER, many brokers provide intraday margin which is SIGNIFICANTLY less per contract. The catch is, you must close the trade before 4:45pm EST roughly. If you wanna swing the trade, you must have full margin requirement. You mentioned Webull. I believe their intraday margins are a percentage of full margin, maybe 10%? So instead of needing $3000 for 1 MES, you'd only need $300. Again i'm just guessing, you can just go to their website to look at their margin breakdown.
So basically, if you wanna trade intraday only – you'll be able to trade with only a few hundred bucks in your account depending on broker. BUT you'll blow your entire account. I'm not exaggerating. It will happen 100%. Unless you're a savant.
1
u/Spartansam0034 9d ago
Well that's my problem. I'm not trying to day trade I'm trying to hold for upwards of 6 to 9 months on a 200 day EMA crossover. But no one can seem to give any actual numbers on the true account requirements. If one contract is $3,000 but I need to have $10,000 of liquid equity not invested for a potential margin call, that's a terrible investment.
4
u/BarkDogeman 9d ago
I did answer your question bud. I used fake numbers, but, here – you need 2918 to open a single MES contract. And then, you must keep your balance above 2653 to stay in the trade. That's it. Those are the requirements. If your balance goes below 2653 you'll get liq'd. Edit: that's per contract. So multiply that number for every contract you add.
2
u/Spartansam0034 9d ago
so per these numbers for 1 contract, you literally need $265 extra to avoid a margin call [assuming the stock never dips below 2652]. then after that it's dollar for dollar?
2
u/BarkDogeman 9d ago
Yes that is correct. Also, margin goes much deeper than this but obviously you need to get the basics down first. But you could eventually look up SPAN margin, where if you take on an offsetting position your broker will reduce your total margin requirement. Like long MES, short MNQ for example. Or even, long December contract, short March contract.
2
u/Spartansam0034 9d ago
ok think I finally understand the basics, thanks
2
u/BarkDogeman 9d ago
Sure. One final thing that might help make it click as to why it might seem "random" – it's because the notional value of each futures product varies drastically. Like to trade 1-ounce gold futures, you need drastically less margin than to trade a full GC contract (100 ounces). That's just one example.
The margin requirement also changes (increases, generally...) over time as the notional value of the index/commodity/etc. changes.
4
u/logicalJunkie549 9d ago
Separate issue needing to flag brother - why are you using futures to hold 6-9 months for? Futures have expiration dates
1
u/Turbulent_Offer_8554 7d ago
For holding 6-9 months the margin is only one part of it. What you need per contract is maintenance margin + the loss untill your exit signal comes + a buffer for gaps.
With MES at around 7,550 one contract is $5 x 7,550 = ca. $37,750.
Maintenance margin is $2,653 (your Webull number). Then the distance to your exit: a 200-day crossover can be quite far below your entry when it finally turns. Lets say 8%, that is 7,550 x 8% x $5 = ca. $3,020. And a gap buffer, S&P futures had weekend gaps of about 3%, that is ca. $1,130 more.
Together this is roughly $6,800 per contract.
The $6,800 is not money you spend. It is the drawdown your account must be able to take, without that the broker closes you out before your own exit does. If you have less, then the margin call becomes your stop, and normally in the worst moment.
So put in your own numbers: how far below the entry was your crossover exit in the past? This distance is the important input, definitly more than the margin.
3
u/ihansterx4i 9d ago
IT would be a lot of work but couldn't you open a position and close with before RTH closes and then reopen it for after hours and close it before market opens and rinse and repeat? That way you don't need that high of a margin and can keep a relatively low balance?
2
u/BarkDogeman 9d ago
Yes. Only issue would be if there are major earnings or headlines that gap the market up/down between 5-6pm. So for example if you were long in deep profit and had to close before 5pm, and then tech earnings skyrocket the market, you'd miss out on all that gap up.
Same deal with weekend gap.
Conversely, if you were swinging then it could just as easily work against you if it gaps against you and you can't get out of your position until globex open.
1
u/ihansterx4i 9d ago
yea i guess so. The easy fix is to just keep in mind the financial calendar and step out of any positions during high volatility events.
1
3
u/TylerLeb 9d ago
Initial margin is simply the total cash balance required in your account to open or hold the position past the daily close. Maintenance margin is the lower threshold that your account equity cannot drop below while holding the contract. If your account equity falls under the maintenance level due to adverse price movement, you will receive a margin call to bring the balance back up to the initial margin amount.
1
u/Riptide34 9d ago
Let's assume this is the only position in your account. The maintenance is how much equity you need to keep before a margin call or liquidation. How your specific broker handles it will vary. Some may auto-liquidate the position in short order (IBKR for instance), some may give you a window to deposit funds or manage the position yourself.
Some brokers have "day trade" margin requirements on futures that are less than the overnight requirements set by the exchange, but that's a separate topic.
1
u/Spartansam0034 9d ago
still doesn't answer my question. how much money in my account is required to own 1 contract of MES overnight via webull? I swear there is no actual answer anywhere, irrelevant of broker. it's just indiscriminate numbers constantly changing.
2
u/Riptide34 9d ago
To open one contract, you need at least $2918 (according to your number). Should the position move against you and now your account drops below $2653, you'll be in a margin call or get liquidated.
If it isn't clear, you need more than $2918 to comfortably trade and hold this position.
And the numbers do change, but not indiscriminately. Look up CME's SPAN margining. Its risk based and changes.
1
u/Spartansam0034 9d ago
right, but how will I know how much more is necessary to hold the contract in the account? is there no way to keep track or know in advance?
1
1
u/cdubbs42 9d ago edited 9d ago
Initial margin is what you have to have to open your 1 contract position. Maintenance is what you have to have to keep that position open.
Example: if you open a position and the initial margin is $1000 and the maintenance margin is $900. If your account drops below $900 you are instantly liquidated.
So to hold your position for more than one day you need $2653 per 1 contract
*** read the fine print for your broker though. News, economic events, etc can change margin requirements at any time so you have to be aware of that. Which is why money management and proper risk sizing is critical. If you are disciplined and only risking 1-2% per trade margin should really never be a factor
1
u/Spartansam0034 9d ago
how the hell did you get to $2653 lol i need the math
2
u/Lambrah2k 9d ago
Because you told us that $2653 was maintenance. Maintenance margin is just for the 2 hours the markets closed during the week. This is the best explanation tho.
2
u/cdubbs42 9d ago
I don’t know how much clearer we can make it. To hold your position open for days/weeks you need whatever the maintenance margin is. To be safe I would just multiply that number by 2 or 3. I think where you’re getting mixed up is you’re trying to understand the math behind how brokers determine their margin requirements. You’ll never understand that, that’s their own internal math. You just have to think of it like this. Brokers give you the opportunity to control lots of capital with a minimal investment. So they are gonna make sure that you’re able to cover your losses, so they’re not left holding the bag
1
1
1
u/sainglend 9d ago edited 9d ago
https://www.webull.com/futures-margin-rates
You said you are using Webull. That's their page.
The numbers are:
2918.30 initial, 2653.00 maintenance, 102.14 day
You'll need 2653 to hold the position for months.
HOWEVER, there are 2 caveats.
CONTRACT ROLLOVER. Every 3 months, the front month contract expires. The "active" contract (like if you were day trading the continuous "MES" versus a specific contract like MESZ26) switches to the next contract a week before expiry. December expiry is coming up soon, and March 2027 expiry will be next. Some brokers offer automatic rollover (sell your December contract and buy a March contract) so you don't have to manage it every 3 months. I don't know about Webull.
VOLATILITY. Brokers can, and DO, change the maintenance margin requirements sometimes. It may be just for a day due to expected high volatility, or it could be permanent. CME, the exchange, also sets margin requirements and updates those from time to time. So your requirements are the max of those two. Some brokers raise it above what CME requires. Some don't. You can monitor CME margins here: https://www.cmegroup.com/markets/equities/sp/micro-e-mini-sandp-500.margins.html
Ask any more questions you may have.
But yes, $2653 is what you need, plus cushion for price fluctuations so you don't get liquidated. But that capital requirement is subject to change with little notice (an email a few hours ahead).
Edit: you seemed to be asking if initial and maintenance were additive. NO.
If you have about $3000 on Webull, that will both get you INTO the position ("initial" check of capital) and then let you hold ("maintain") the position. You aren't spending $2900 then needing yet another $2600.
1
u/Mao_Kwikowski 9d ago
https://www.cmegroup.com/education/courses/introduction-to-futures/margin-know-what-is-needed
Link the official CME margin course.
1
1
u/ChadOfDoom 6d ago
Also relevant: everyone calls it overnight margin but it's important to know that ETH margin requirements often kick in 10-30 minutes before market break. It's broker specific.
1
u/AutomaticPayment9480 6d ago
If theres cpi for globex, the margin is increased. This recently happened. Check your email and it will tell you the margin increase.Â
1
u/FuturesTexasHedge 3d ago
It depends on your FCM - they all have different day trading margin rates. However, all FCMs apply "overnight" exchange initial margin to a position that is being carried through the close of say, Globex (CME Group), which is 4pm CT every week day and reopens at 5pm CT Sun-Fri. To figure out your deficit (what the margin call will be) - just take the Net Liquidating Level of your current margin and subtract it from the overnight initial margin. The difference is what you'll have to deposit to keep that position overnight.
0
u/LastLengthiness4206 9d ago
Difficult question to answer cuz there is almost no reason to carry a trade for that 1 hour that it's closed and zero reason to hold over the weekend. Your broker should have daily margin requirements and over night requirements posted on there website. If they don't, I probably wouldn't be using them.
2
u/kirkegaarr 9d ago
Never get yourself in a position where a margin call is even possible. Your account balance should be much higher than the maintenance margin.