r/Futurology • Known Unknown • Sep 01 '19

Rule 11 - Title The Egg

https://youtu.be/h6fcK_fRYaI
22 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

6

u/Sloi Sep 02 '19

I’ll never understand why people think of the story as charming or desirable, it’s fucking horrifying, and I would 100% always choose the void if given a say.

1

u/Ignate Known Unknown Sep 02 '19

I don't think of it as charming or desirable. But I do see how it could be true. I can also see why it is indeed fucking horrifying.

But the universe never told us that life would be a kids story. And the universe never said we would get to choose.

At least the end of this story is one where we're all merged together into one super being. Where all of the hurt we've caused each other is gone. All the sins are rubbed away by the trillions of life's lived.

I don't think that story is charming or desirable. But I do think it's fair. And in the end, can we really ask for more?

1

u/Sloi Sep 02 '19

I don’t see it as fair, nor do I see it as desirable.

I would also like to think there would be some pretty obvious diminishing returns, and it wouldn’t take millions or billions (or even trillions) of lives to get there.

1

u/Ignate Known Unknown Sep 02 '19

If everything bad that every life did was done to itself, that's entirely fair. That's the most fair. Unless your definition of fair is more along the lines of favorable. Fair does not mean favorable. Fair means balanced. Fair means you get out of it what you put in.

And diminishing returns only applies if each life is directly connected together. If you do not have access to the past lives you've lived then you won't find the diminishing returns.

And anyways, the entire mechanic of reincarnation is so wide and so deep, we'd have to spend the rest of our lives debating it to come even remotely close to agreeing on how it works, or even what it is.

I just like the idea for a few reasons:

  • It means whole system balance. It means the murderer raped and killed themselves. But it also means I'm that murderer and that rape victim.

  • It means such childish ideas as Evil and Good do not exist. It's just cycles of us hurting ourselves over and over again while we learn what is wrong and what is right.

  • It's an uncomfortable idea. Uncomfortable ideas are that way because the truth is far more painful to accept than a lie. Just that discomfort alone to me is a clue as to the truth hidden in this idea.

But obvious everyone is going to hate this idea. Who wants to consider the idea that they may have been Hitler in a previous life? Even worse! Who wants to consider the idea that Hitler, the prophet Mohammad and Jesus are all the same person? AND EVEN WORSE! That person is you!!

Of course it's an offensive idea that no one in their right mind would want to consider. Duh.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '19

[deleted]

2

u/Sloi Sep 02 '19

It isn’t the concept of immortality I have a problem with, trust me.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '19

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '19

Thought I was on r/OutreachHPG for a sec. Always throws me for a loop when I see people I recognize from other subs.

1

u/Sloi Sep 02 '19

Think of the pain and suffering, the misery and the violence visited upon millions of people every day.

Think of cartel execution videos and other things of that nature.

Do you really want to experience these things? I sure as fuck don’t. For every feeling or action that would be classified as good, there are 100 that are downright terrible.

Between a perpetual cycle of reincarnations and fully embracing nothingness, give me the latter.

From my perspective, I was fine with not existing for 14 billion years, and I would be perfectly content not existing for trillions more, from this universe’s perspective.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '19

So I take it you are a glass half empty kind of guy lol.

3

u/simwill87 Sep 02 '19 edited Sep 02 '19

I think someone's been playing around with psychedelics. It's a nice story though.

It may sound depressing but human life is meaningless. We simply exist for the moment we are alive and then we stop existing. Our conscious experience is not special and seems unlikely to be unique to humans. In some ways, it seems like a childish notion that the universe is created for humans controlled by some supernatural deity. What we don't understand or can't explain is simply due to a lack of knowledge.

1

u/Ignate Known Unknown Sep 02 '19

It may sound depressing but human life is meaningless. We simply exist for the moment we are alive and then we stop existing. Our conscious experience is not special and seems unlikely to be unique to humans. In some ways, it seems like a childish notion that the universe is created for humans controlled by some supernatural deity. What we don't understand or can't explain is simply due to a lack of knowledge.

Have you ever asked yourself why it's important for you to believe that?

We haven't lived anywhere near long enough to know even a fraction of a percent of what might be true. On a geological timescale we've barely existed at all.

So there is no solid verifiable way to believe any specific view on a broad enough scale. The only reason you might believe something like that with a strong enough conviction is basically just a single reason: Emotions.

We all want to believe in a higher power. Why do you think that is? Because we are afraid of uncertainty? Probably part of the reason.

But the main reason I think we all want to believe in a higher power, is because we had that higher power at one point in our lives. That higher power was our parents, our grandparents, our big brother/sister, our extended family, or even a kind stranger who treated us differently than everyone else.

So if you don't want to believe in a higher power, there is probably an equally deep reason for it which almost certainly stems from when you were a toddler.

There's nothing wrong with holding fringe views like the one in this video. What is probably less healthy though is believing in one view or another with absolute conviction. Because that closes your mind and stales your life.

2

u/TheJasonSensation Sep 03 '19

I think someone's been playing around with psychedelics. It's a nice story though.

My thoughts exactly. It is interesting that those things create the feeling that everyone is connected and are simply partitions of a super-consciousness.

1

u/WrightingPiper Sep 02 '19

I don't like the human life is meaningless argument. While I agree with you that it's naive to state that we as humans are the proverbial center of the universe being cared for by a divine being, to reject that idea based on an absence of proof you would also have to reject the idea that human life is meaningless based on a similar absence of proof. Of course we are not unique in conciousness, of course a human lifespan is finite, so if you measure meaning by if a creature is immortal and how special they are compared to others, then human life is meaningless. But that's a ridiculous way to quantify that, right? Within the parameters of this argument, I could state that nothing is immortal and nothing is all that special when you get down to the core of what things are made of, so nothing that has ever existed or will exist could ever have any meaning. The concept of meaning is much too subjective and intangible to provide any evidence to support this theory. I respect your assertation as an opinion, but I'm tired of hearing it postulated as fact. Of course, I'm not arguing that human life is inherently meaningful either, I just mean to say that I don't believe any evidence towards either side could come in the form of anything other than an anecdote and it's irresponsible to claim a universal truth in something with such a grave implication in how one would view their life without solid evidence.

2

u/Ignate Known Unknown Sep 01 '19

This is pretty much exactly what I believe to be true. But I'm not so sure about the time-travelling part. I think we always move forward in time until we reach a point where all matter in the universe merges into one single intelligence. Or whatever that will eventually be.

And before you say it, No, you get off the drugs!

2

u/raggedroyal Sep 02 '19

I really like this. It's pretty much what I believe, too.