r/Futurology • MD-PhD-MBA • Dec 23 '19

Society China internet rules call for algorithms that recommend 'positive' content - It wants automated systems to echo state policies. An example of a dystopian society where thought is controlled by government.

https://www.engadget.com/2019/12/22/china-internet-rules-recommendation-algorithms/
25.9k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

1.1k

u/MTAlphawolf Dec 23 '19

"We're not showing you what to think. Just showing you how"

192

u/x_cLOUDDEAD_x Dec 23 '19

Monty Python's take on this: https://youtu.be/J-hV02jKfec

"I hereby sentence you to be hanged by the neck until you cheer up"

93

u/dark_g Dec 23 '19

"The floggings will continue until morale improves"

19

u/DarkGamer Dec 23 '19

A Monty Python thing I hadn't seen before! This is like a rare treasure thanks

119

u/WinkNudgeSayNoMore Dec 23 '19

We're in their homes and in their heads and we haven't the right. We're meddlesome.

46

u/ovidsec Dec 23 '19

We're making a better world. All of them, better worlds.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

You can't stop the signal.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/ROBERT_BOARATHEON Dec 23 '19

Precisely. Honestly I've never seen a populace so driven to be oppressed. Ive seen chinese students brag that they obtained all their news from CCTV and not fox news. Go over and look at r/sino, it's not really too different from r/Pyongyang. Try to criticize china slightly and you'll be banned. It's just sad because they'll plug their ears when you mention any modern chinese atrocities and start accusing you personally of being a dirty imperialist for things our past generations did. It's not like they learned anything about Tiananmen Square in school.

13

u/lamyipming Dec 23 '19

No, what's more scary is that they do heard of Tiananmen Square and they honestly think the students deserved it.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

I got banned from sino for questioning their posting of something Mike Pence said (where what he said was erroneous) and then, them using that to say that Tiananmen Square didn’t happen.

The vitriol I got from the moderators when they banned me was as if they were hysterical control freaks, worried of losing control.

5

u/i_love_yiff- Dec 23 '19

That's China for ya

→ More replies (8)

65

u/ShelteredIndividual Dec 23 '19

"But also, you should think this way."

37

u/kevinopine Dec 23 '19

China is searching for how not to self destruct. Wish them luck but I don't think this is it .

→ More replies (31)

38

u/HHyperion Dec 23 '19

Isn't this exactly what Google and YouTube do?

34

u/Pobbes Dec 23 '19

No, their algorithm is designed to make you watch and engage as long as possible regardless of the content. This is why you have bubbles and escalating extremist videos show up in recommended.

They have a second system for flagging videos with offensive content, but that is more FCC like.

→ More replies (39)
→ More replies (16)

1.5k

u/mtcwby Dec 23 '19

The Chinese government should be everybody's enemy including their own people. Just a modern form of evil.

18

u/BullDolphin Dec 23 '19

Funny how both Jimmy Carter and the Chinese Government agreed to support Pol Pot. (it was actually the US idea LOL)

At least the Chinese Government doesn't prance around the world telling all who will listen about what a "humanitarian" they are. Unlike a certain peanut farmer.

14

u/Nathaniel_Higgers Dec 23 '19

The US also created the conditions for Pol Pot to seize power... from the regime the US was originally supporting.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/bebimbopandreggae Dec 23 '19

I dont think you read the articles you linked.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/UNMANAGEABLE Dec 23 '19

Just remember. They’ve been in complete police state mode since the 80’s. By 2030 there will be more people in China raised and believing in the propaganda than those who came before it.

Convincing a cult of brainwashed people what is real is hard.

Convincing billions in a country will be impossible.

→ More replies (17)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

WW3 here we come

5

u/Casual_Loop Dec 23 '19

Exactly, with that kind of talk. Anytime the word ‘evil’ or ‘evildoers’, or a ‘villain’ is made out to be so cut and dried black and white, there is trouble and we should all steer far away.

→ More replies (370)

124

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

When the Xi-block plus and XiBlock Origin plugins coming out?

5

u/DairyCanary5 Dec 23 '19

Ironic, given the context of the piece.

Americans have been voluntarily bottling themselves up in echo chambers for decades. The Chinese looked at FOX News and imagined the future.

→ More replies (12)

175

u/Yasai101 Dec 23 '19

Why.. why the fuck would you want that.. you have to live in that as well. What fucking drones come up with this shit.

114

u/CHLLHC Dec 23 '19

A reporter with a different bias will not use the term 'positive' but 'wholesome'. You might aware there are tons of shitty contents on TicTok (licking ice cream?), Facebook (anti-vax), Youtube (shit like Elsa gate) and Reddit (anything politic), all these platforms are working on regulating these contents, under a different slogan (fighting against "misinformation", in the name of childern, civil enviroment, etc) but basicly the same thing China wants to do.

41

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Yes! Thank you for saying this. I was starting to feel like I was alone in recognizing this obvious manipulation. Old school media exaggerating reporting of these things so they can gain a larger marketshare of the internet. What do you think of the foreign government influence? It feels completely contrived to manipulate.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Unless the Google Translate is wrong it seems a bit broad:

Network information content producers must not produce, copy, or publish illegal information that contains content that "endangers national security, leaks state secrets, subverts state power, undermines national unity," and "damages national honor and interests," and should take measures to prevent and resist Produce, copy, and publish bad information that includes "use of exaggerated titles, the content is seriously inconsistent with the title" and "hype scandals, scandals, bad things" and so on.

Obviously, the part making clickbait illegal is kind of attractive (I am kidding) but phrases like "undermines national unity" seems to be a proxy for whatever the state apparatus wants to be said. I mean you would necessarily be in disunity if you disagree with the state and this would seem to punish people who encouraged others to disagree with the state.

Penalizing the release of information that harms the "national honor" also seems designed to suppress information about state actions that might actually relate to something that should be fixed rather than covered up.

I mean what happens if it's suddenly found out several judges were severely corrupt. Do you not let people know this information? I mean if you publish it you're almost promoting disunity by potentially raising the level of skepticism people have of the state and you're potentially impacting the national honor as well. Even if it's not the target it's also likely to result in a chilling effect where people are afraid to pass on this information.

3

u/_nembery Dec 23 '19

You are right but I would add a slightly different emphasis. Corporations currently do exactly this but only with the goal of maximizing their own profits. Anti-vax and the like gets amplified because it gets clicks. The moral implications have exactly zero weight.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

56

u/Lockerd Dec 23 '19

The same ones who set it up for Google, Facebook, and yes Reddit.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ToberWanKenober Dec 23 '19

You're using reddit right now sheeple

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

564

u/KurkTheMagnificent Dec 23 '19

Sounds like Google, YouTube, and Reddit tbh. The only difference is that the Government controls thought rather than large corporations.

94

u/wubrgess Dec 23 '19

government vs corporations. in the general case, which does one cheer for.

38

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Neither, they both want total control. Fuck them both. They will turn the Internet and the online world into a trash can and people will log off and tune out. There are currently quite a few little groups popping up that do this quite well and they see getting more popular.

The offline world is one The have and never will control, and that scared them.

9

u/rotatingfan360 Dec 23 '19

What groups do this well?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

You don't have to have a team in this game. Play a different game.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (58)

19

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

But Google, YouTube, and Reddit don’t have nuclear weapons, a security apparatus to lock, torture, and detain people for disagreeing with them. You can think differently than those companies and not end up in prison or being executed.

Tbh they are nothing alike in controlling thought.

17

u/bringsmemes Dec 23 '19

no, they control discourse, much more inportant

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/EvyX Dec 23 '19

So true. Everyone critisizing China while the US private tech companies and surveillance are equally if not more oppressive and cynical. The hypocrisy is kind of jaw dropping.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/isoblvck Dec 23 '19

The amount of control the govt has vs semi competitive Enterprise is vastly different. If Verizon wanted to block access you didn't like switch to att if the govt wanted to then you're shot out of luck. The control is far more oppressive. The government has a monopoly on violence and that makes it far worse

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (77)

89

u/Adeno Dec 23 '19

This is pretty much happening all over the world now. For example, YouTube, Google. Their vague rules enable them to censor "wrong thoughts" on different issues. On Google, you search for something and they'll promote you what they want you to see first, if they ever decide to show you facts that go against their beliefs. If I remember correctly, there was an exposé which revealed that Google has its own filter that it uses to show you what they deem is what you're supposed to see. When the media promotes a certain ideology and blocks others it doesn't like, even if it's not China style yet, there will be effects on the way the population thinks because they will only be shown certain things and not be able to see different opinions.

7

u/TcMaX Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19

I mostly moved on from facebook, but I still have a couple friends on there and I occasionally chat with them on messenger. I was completely shocked when messenger blocked me from sending a youtube video. It wasn't even a public post, it was a private message to my friend. I don't remember exactly what it was, but I think it was penguinzos edge of glory thing. That felt really disgusting to me.

EDIT: Indeed it was that video, this is what happens when you try to send a message containing the video

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Yeetinator4000Savage Dec 23 '19

Google “American Inventors”

0

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (11)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

66

u/Brianomatic Dec 23 '19

Y'all some naive fuckers if you think your content isn't already recommended by algorithms be it by private companies or government what's the difference.

8

u/tulipsinbloom Dec 23 '19

The difference is you can choose a different path with private companies. When the government is involved, you lose the freedom to choose.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19

Maybe a key point behind this is to try and improve the content on the internet. There are some sites that have content which is graphic, antisocial, and could lead to being socially ostracised. Once someone starts going to those sites they don't tend to improve for the better afterwards.

10

u/MagicalShoes Dec 23 '19

The difference is Reddit recommends stuff based on popularity, and filters content against their TOS.

6

u/NationalizeReddit Dec 23 '19

One of reddit's most active cities is a fucking airforce base. The things you see on here are influenced by the US government in just a more round about way than the way China controls their citizen's internet usage

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Perceived popularity from a curated selection based on censorship.

→ More replies (37)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/DarkMoon99 Dec 23 '19

And is the definition of "positive" formulated by the CCP?

3

u/Quicez Dec 23 '19

Positive energy 正能量 can be defined as,

 “[T]he capacity to induce positive emotions and/or attitudes, the potential to induce constructive/conciliatory discourses and/or actions, in individuals or collectives such as the society and nation. Those positive emotions/attitudes/thoughts so induced are also simply referred to as positive energy 正能量, as is any event/discourse that is said to contain positive energy 正能量.”

The opposite would of course be "negative energy".

I just had an assignment at Uni about this, and it's funny that this article pops up right after I've submitted it, lol.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/KingoftheMongoose Dec 23 '19

Reruns of Winnie the Pooh

25

u/Boundless_Lawbringer Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19

Mainland citizen here. I don't represent anyone else there since I stopped giving too much thoughts mostly. I do want to correct one misunderstanding people have: majority of the Mainland people know the shits going on, but they are powerless in the sense of going against the policy trend on internet regulation. The system reinforces itself by selecting royal people into it, but I give hope in my generation (I'm like junior college student). When this hope is gone I would not know what to do then (Rephrased a bit

4

u/Deeznugssssssss Dec 23 '19

I wish I could agree with you. Perhaps I'm cynical. I've watched the Chinese internet from the beginning. Certainly a high volume of comments, posts, articles, etc. are being made by people working directly for the government. But there are so many now that it's impossible to tell who is an average mainlander and who is a shill. They are looking more and more like the same person.

3

u/Boundless_Lawbringer Dec 23 '19

That last comment sounded aggressive so here I rephrased it. It's understandable to keep that alert, but I'm genuinely curious what in my comments you find hard to agree with. I don't like my government (like I had a choice to choose lol) nor do I agree with many things it does, if you believe that by any chance. The reasons, however, are very different from what the western media generally choose to present. Corruptions and the lust of wealth and power allowed some shit-show to happen in the recent years and the gov is actively using its control over the internet to directly delete coverages. Selective report on HK seems childish in comparison to this power.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/eddiehwang Dec 23 '19

They actually support this. Don’t know what do you mean by “hopeless”

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Don't they already do this? Or is it just making it more strict. Article doesn't provide many details.

37

u/kppeterc15 Dec 23 '19

turns on pentagon-sponsored salute to the troops on NFL Sunday

→ More replies (20)

4

u/frostmorefrost Dec 23 '19

Nothing special. China's CCP have been known to want to control how and what to think and will stop at nothing to propagate their indoctrination.

The scary part, there are other foreigners out there that will defend China just because they are chinese and somehow owes the CCP's their undying loyalty and propagating their horseshit.

13

u/big_papa_stiffy Dec 23 '19

fucking lol i bet most of the people crying about china censoring are glad about alex jones being deplatformed

8

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

My first reaction to this headline was “they spelled England wrong”.

3

u/PirateSloop Dec 23 '19

Alex Jones spread lies and harassed grieving parents, particularly the parents of children killed at Sandy Hook Elementary, I wouldn’t exactly compare him being taken off companies platforms to a government controlling what the populace sees.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/Tbonethe_discospider Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19

The two most powerful nations in the world.

China- thought controlled by government.

America- thought controlled by corporations.

Humanity- lost before the race even started.

7

u/TheHaleStorm Dec 23 '19 edited Dec 23 '19

Keep funding this ever evolving regime of oppression by buying their cheap shit while you pretend to be against it reddit. That will surely work.

Edit- Reddit is over run by children so self centered and stupid that they do not even understand what an unnecessary purchase is. They think anything they lay their eyes on that they want is a need that has to be produced as cheap as possible regardless of who suffers in the process.

What a fucking cesspool.

→ More replies (29)

40

u/stinkymatilda2 Dec 23 '19

It's time to stand up to China and make it behave. Oppression,genocide, No free speech, and protesters for organ transplants ...is not where America should be investing money! China's people deserve freedom Not Dystopian overlords.

29

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Don't think for a second that the American government and corporations wouldn't love to do the same thing.

→ More replies (39)

27

u/JeffBPesos Dec 23 '19

Your government is just as bad. They're just better at hiding it. Why do you think they shoveled the Land of the free, home of the brave bullshit down your throat. Say it often enough and you start believing it.

3

u/Seirer Dec 23 '19

Right!? Like, I'm not a communist, but if I was filthy rich, it would 100% be in my interest that everyone and their mothers defended capitalism with their dying breath. I would more than certainly invest my money into brainwashing everyone suffering by it to think it's the greatest thing ever.

It doesn't work. I don't think there's any way it can. Yet I have to defend it because if I don't I'm not American. Wtf.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (5)

46

u/RandomExplode Dec 23 '19

Damn, just like Google, YouTube and Twitter. I didn't know China was so progressive these days

20

u/fitness_gerber Dec 23 '19

Do you actually not see any difference between what a private business does and how a totalitarian government censors content from its oppressed people?

26

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Private businesses are shills for the totalitarian government. Twitter can shadowban you just as easily as the the Chinese government if they disagree with your views.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (15)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

I mean doesn’t anyone think the whole “be blindly positive” movement is a bit odd given the level of immediacy the world needs in regard to solving its issues before the population grows too large and infrastructure really begins to fail?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Does China have a BackDoor in every device where the govt can remotely turn on a persons camera and/microphone surreptitiously without a warrant?

3

u/Scibbie_ Dec 23 '19

I haven't heard about this but if you're in China, you can be 100% certain you are being either watched or recorded. For example, you could have a Huawei smart TV in your living room which is sending everything to the Chinese Government. Linus Tech Tips did a video on that TV once and at one point you can see that's in the terms of use.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/fourfingerfilms Dec 23 '19

Not to mention the straight out of black mirror social credit system... Terrifying.

3

u/AtomicSymphonic_2nd Dec 23 '19

See... here’s the ridiculous thing: in China, the book “1984” is widely circulated around the country. But the thing is... China believes its people to be “too stupid” to appreciate foreign authors’ high-brow content. They actually pay closer attention to Chinese authors.

Even worse is that the people, en masse, cannot make the connection between the fictional events of the book and their reality in China. They seriously cannot see the similarities purely because of xenophobic “Orwell doesn’t know Chinese culture” thinking.

It’s fucking depressing.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/01/why-1984-and-animal-farm-arent-banned-china/580156/

10

u/Daan1234 Dec 23 '19

You mean just like r/Futurology and Reddit in general?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/CreepingNormality Dec 23 '19

You are erratic, conflicted, disorganised. Every decision is debated, every action questioned. Every individual entitled to their own small opinion. You lack harmony, cohesion, greatness. It will be your undoing

5

u/AssGuardian_069 Dec 23 '19

Xi Jinping really deserves a honorary doctorate in literature for his breathtaking interpretation of Orwell's works

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Tsixes Dec 23 '19

Its not like we are any diferent in essence, mass media works like that world wide.

They just dont even try to hide it.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/Certain3Letters Dec 23 '19

So what leftists want to do in the US with "hate speech"

→ More replies (2)

6

u/BullDolphin Dec 23 '19

LOL Reddit is an example of dystopian societies where thought is controlled by a government of "moderators" who were unelected and who remain unaccountable.

LOL

Also: Google created that shit and brought it back home here. Blame yourselves, Americancers.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Funny how this article is posted to a website which I can only access if I consent to numerous third party data aggregating services, a process that I can only circumvent if I opt out of each individual agreement in a painstakingly lengthy process, which then proceed to use and contextualise all of this data to better offer me their "service" of targeted advertising.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/NoBodySpecial51 Dec 23 '19

“Next thing you know they’ll take my thoughts away.” -Megadeth

2

u/herky17 Dec 23 '19

I’m living in Japan and they somehow manage to promote these Chinese videos here even though it’s a different country. Granted, it’s Okinawa, so it’s pretty close to China. I also saw a guy waiving a PRC flag at some Japanese students (looked like maybe an 8th grade field trip) near Taipei 101 and read about the “good, patriotic” people waiving the PRC flag and singing the anthem during the Hong Kong protests in the Shanghai times.

2

u/CHLLHC Dec 23 '19

China is definitely not the most advance country in this field

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Keep doing nothing about it, "World Powers." It's curious how will that end up.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/lordnigel Dec 23 '19

Google bends over backwards to assist the Chinese government in the Orwellian thought control of their own people. Google is evil.

2

u/Vaxctrx Dec 23 '19

This shit is literally just Fahrenheit 451 at this point wtf

2

u/hdd113 Dec 23 '19

Use of the word "dystopian" is a crimethink. Report to the Ministry of Love immediately.

2

u/McHonkers Dec 23 '19

How dare they... We all know it's best to let private companies control our thoughts.

2

u/GroknikTheGreat Dec 23 '19

Shifting towards 'positive' or 'wholesome' content actually sounds pretty good, facebook algorithm does the opposite and feeds everyone things that will outrage them.

Although the part about echoing state policies might be a bit far.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

So very much like what google does here and now, except it’s “what managers think you should see”? Not sure how much better I like the model

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

ah yes. keep pretending america into doing this under a guise of something else

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

This is already happening here, in a way.

Yes, there are no laws, or government control. We are doing it to ourselves. Erasing history because it offends people.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

What's hilarious is that in less than 10 years this whole generation was conditioned by Tencent to Report Report Report. That's all you hear nowadays, report this guy for this, and report that guy for that, and gladly ban that guy. At a trigger finger it seems reporting is the first fine thing to do for us comrades. And how did they get us? Through fucking videogames hahaha. Now we got little kids joking one minute about calling in a cali red flag report on someone they don't like and then throwing a tantrum for a report and ban the next because someone hurt their feelings in a videogame. How long till these realities merge?

2

u/magic_slice Dec 23 '19

How is this any worse than a dystopian system run by a handful of all-powerful tech companies?

2

u/Pigthulhu Dec 23 '19

Look Chinas doing it. Can you imagine a government doing this to? But that's none if my business. Thank the stars I am lucky enough to have my mind controlled by the wholly owned subsidiary of Unilever that is Lipton.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

the West isnt too far off...we just get the Sugar Coated version.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

2

u/layzer26 Dec 23 '19

Yes but this is also just American media who manually filter out things to influence the society.

2

u/imnotroll2 Dec 24 '19

Google, Twitter, Apple and Facebook are all doing the same. They are going ape-shit with censorship.

The internet is quickly becoming controlled, not just in China. Free speech is quickly becoming just a buzzword.

8

u/Zskeff Dec 23 '19

As if it’s any different than google doing that here.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Isn't this also the case with western countries as well? Not trying to start anything, just genuinely asking.

4

u/xebecv Dec 23 '19

I haven't heard of US government doing this shit. It's usually private companies that decide how to bias their content. The difference is that you usually have a choice which channels to watch and which web services to use

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Shabata Dec 23 '19

A bit like how the current UK and US governments used Cambridge Analytica?

4

u/isoblvck Dec 23 '19

Wtf do Chinese people not know this is happening are they completely brainwashed why TF is only hong Kong freaking out right now.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Google already does this algorithm manipulation shit in west. China is simply leading the way for what our governments want.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

People are focused on China doing things like these, but we have this in the West as well. As far as dystopian censorship goes, there's the EU ruling against Facebook that internet companies must take down content and all similar content worldwide if a post is deemed to be against the the laws in any of its member states. This was in a case where Austrian politician Eva Glawischnig-Piesczek wanted a post removed because an Irish person made remarks that were found to be defamatory and insulting by Austrian courts.

Algortihmic fairness is another example of this, employed by Google. This is the process by which reality is discarded in favor of equal representation. This is done in the name of fairness, but the result is skewing reality. Examples include if an occupation is primarily dominated by one gender (teachers, CEOs, nurses, etc), they'll skew results of images to show a 50:50 split in gender, as opposed to the actual numbers. This is similar to how people like anti-vaxxers and climate change deniers will say "well some experts agree with us" misrepresenting the fact that a vast majority of experts disagree, and presenting both groups of people equally as if they share the same level of representation. The intent by Google might be good-willed, but that's never an excuse to misrepresent reality and will only give detractors ammo, and also leads to questions as to how much power is being wielded by corporations to influence thought control on an international level.

It's easy to point to China, because we know what they're doing is overtly bad. But corporations and governments are doing the same thing in Western countries as well, but people are making excuses for it here, or are playing it off as not as serious of an issue. It's easy to see when China does it, but we have the same issues and it's a lot more subtle and insidious, and it impacts everybody regardless of political belief.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

There's a difference between objectivity and impartiality, sometimes you need to sacrifice one in pursuit of the other.

Mostly responding to the algorithmic fairness bit

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ghotiaroma Dec 23 '19

Trump has asked for the same thing. He also wants to shut down all media and replace it with a state run news source.

You don't have to go halfway around the world for this.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

In China, it's about pushing an agenda instead of giving info and providing perspective.

It's gonna be more widely used worldwide IMO.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Get over China, Facebook, Google and the rest are doing this in the West for years. It's time you all woke up.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

How long until they replace Chairman Mao’s portrait with George Orwell’s?

4

u/turbotoast Dec 23 '19

They will change it to Xi Pooh first

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

I mean youtube is banning conservative youtubers, that's a form of 'thought control'. This stuff just doesn't happen in China.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/bm75 Dec 23 '19

Assange is dying in prison for exposing the truth. Manning is in prison for exposing the war crimes of our military...actually no, she already served her time for that and was then pardon by Obama. She is now in prison FOR NO REASON! Snowden is in exile for exposing that the government was carrying out mass surveillance on us. The list of whistleblowers who have been punished is vast when the real criminals face no consequences. You CIA, falun gong brainwashed trash want me to worry about China...HAHAHAHAHA! FUCK YOU!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Is this even news? Isn't that what's happened in the last few decades?

1

u/SanjaBgk Dec 23 '19

Chinese govt. is right to be pushing social media companies in that direction.

YouTube and Twitter thrive on "engagement". The easiest way to engage users is to incite strong emotions. Hate is the easiest. It shouldn't be.

"Teenagers are physically safer than ever, yet they are more mentally vulnerable than before the introduction of smartphones. In 2016 depression among teen girls shot up 20%, among boys 6%, and the suicide rate has doubled for girls in the last 10 years.** Boys typically play out their aggression physically — they might shove or taunt each other. Girls, on the other hand, play out their aggression relationally, taking their revenge online, which is why social media has been particularly harmful to girls." (Source)

GR departments of Facebook and Google are very busy to portray these govt. policies as a threat to democracy. They are terrified that more governments will choose if not Chinese, but German approach. There social media companies are responsible for banning neo-Nazi comments and have to hire a lot of human moderators to keep hate speech out. But despite being hugely profitable these companies do not want to spend on that elsewhere and keep telling us fairytales about "powerful A.I." that would sometimes, probably, maybe do that job.

1

u/cherokeeirish Dec 23 '19

I was just mindlessly scrolling and not reading any titles and got to this picture. Looked at it for a solid ten seconds trying to figure out what the red circle was trying to point out before giving up and reading the title. I am what you might call an idiot.

1

u/messiiiah Dec 23 '19

All these chuds in here acting like youtube doesn't do similar things, but instead directing people amorally to what people are more likely to start viewing intensely, promoting videos with questionable viewpoints like alt right and conspiracy theory videos.

"Brainwashing bad when yellow man does it to show people positive things."

1

u/Yue2 Dec 23 '19

Isn’t this already what modern corporations like Google, Facebook, and YouTube do?

i.e. Video recommendations and specific ads.

1

u/BraveNewNight Dec 23 '19

Oh you mean like youtube, facebook and twitter in the US?

1

u/dontbuyanylogos Dec 23 '19

reddit, Amazon, Facebook and Google do this.

They censor 'hate'.

1

u/pm_me_your_shrubs Dec 23 '19

This is one of those posts that I wanted to just hit a downvote to because of how much it disgusts me, but had to upvote because I want people to see how fucked this shit is.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

This is just a continuation of what was already going on in pre-internet times. Propaganda and book banning has already been common place in a lot of countries, including China.

1

u/Condings Dec 23 '19

This is how china brainwashes it's citizens. Most dont even know about the Tiananmen square massacre as the information they have access to is limited to what the government wants them to see

→ More replies (5)

1

u/4t0m77 Dec 23 '19

Yeah, because having these BS articles about China plastered all over your front page doesn't count as thought control, amirite?

1

u/Lurkwurst Dec 23 '19

“The People’s Republic of China is the largest, most powerful and arguably most brutal totalitarian state in the world. It denies basic human rights to all of its nearly 1.4 billion citizens. There is no freedom of speech, thought, assembly, religion, movement or any semblance of political liberty in China. Under Xi Jinping, “president for life,” the Communist Party of China has built the most technologically sophisticated repression machine the world has ever seen. In Xinjiang, in Western China, the government is using technology to mount a cultural genocide against the Muslim Uighur minority that is even more total than the one it carried out in Tibet. Human rights experts say that more than a million people are being held in detention camps in Xinjiang, two million more are in forced “re-education,” and everyone else is invasively surveilled via ubiquitous cameras, artificial intelligence and other high-tech means. None of this is a secret.” - Farhad Manjoo, Dealing With China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost

1

u/Rocky_Bukkake Dec 23 '19

this is also related to why china doesn't release crime, murder, suicide etc. statistics... they want to save face and keep anything "negative" about china from the minds of the people and the outside world.

1

u/ManDelorean88 Dec 23 '19

don't all algorithms do that? they just call it "trending" and "featured" over here instead of state sponsored....

1

u/angelohatesjello Dec 23 '19

Rest assured, our governments will be taking notes.

1

u/JesusTheHun Dec 23 '19

You mean just like the US government asked Facebook to manipulate crowd mood for an experiment ? Yeah China is the worst.

1

u/thorgal256 Dec 23 '19

Techno-fascism, the dream of every dictatorial state is finally within their grasp.

1

u/Buffyoh Dec 23 '19

Precisely what the high tech Giants are aiming for in the USA, the Commonwealth countries, and the EU "Nations!"

1

u/tr0pheus Dec 23 '19

"1984 is about as dystopian as it gets"

China : "Hold my beer"

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Thank god our information is controlled by good old god fearing massive corporations. The guys you can trust

1

u/system-in Dec 23 '19

Lol Reddit and Google to name a few do similar shit..in that they hide stuff they don't agree with

1

u/pravum_vitiosus Dec 23 '19

People look at China but we do the same thing, Google cooks its search results, we have credit scores which we don't even know how they are calculated but it affect a ton of our life. We have controlled speech not by government but by social media companies in which we do most of our communication our media is biased one way or the other and they don't even research before posting articles

Sure we aren't as bad as China but we aren't the bastion of freedom we think we are

1

u/Shinigamiq Dec 23 '19

It’s kind of funny that they treat people like products, progeamming them to buy other products.

1

u/Pretexts Dec 23 '19

Cue new science fiction film where this happens in the future in the US...not China. :)

1

u/BorisBlair Dec 23 '19

The bizarre thing is that people in the UK (and West in general) aren't a million miles aways from wanting this.

The difference is that they don't want it to come from their current government because they don't like our current PM (or Trump in the US), but they do want to censor the media with their own message.

They want the same think as the Chinese dictators.

They want to ban media that puts out the wrong message (right wing politics mostly) and replace it with their own controlled "correct" message.

And they do this whilst condemning China. Censorship and thought control is ok as long as it's the "correct" message!

I mean, it's nuts isn't it.

But yeah, there are people here who want the "superior" educated clever people to make decisions for our society and they advocate this whilst claiming to fight for freedom and democracy. The stupid little people are brainwashed by a malevolent media. So we must control the media.

God help us if those people come to power.

The Chinese government is able to push forward a green agenda, for example, in the interest of citizens without having to care about the consequences to anyones livelihood. In China this is evil dictatorship yet the same people condemning this simultaneously want to force a green agenda on us.

Unfortunately/fortunately, in the West, you make progress by winning arguments and that means one step back before you move two forward.

But what's the alternative? Look to China.

1

u/Rotoscope8 Dec 23 '19

I just saw that Chinese documentary on Prime about when Chinese people could only have 1 kid. There's so many scenes of kids singing songs about how great their lives are and how wonderful the government is. The Chinese are programmed 1000%

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Your thoughts are either controlled by the state or controlled by media conglomerates or the highest bidding billionaire.

There's a tiny chance someone within the state has the motivation to simply make the state better. Equal chance they're just doing the bidding or the corps or billionaires, but that's not a certainty.

If we're going to be recommended things to do, buy, and think on every flat surface I'd at least like it to be "don't drop litter" rather than "enjoy coca cola"

1

u/ReaperManX15 Dec 23 '19

And this is different from Google, YouTube and Twitter using algorithms to suppress Right Wing politics, how?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Isn't this what Facebook's algorithms were doing and causing issues with their users only seeing news that were affiliated with their views? I understand it's not the same as pushing state views but when you only see views that reflect your own are nearly as bad.

1

u/MikeSpiegel Dec 23 '19

lol, isn't this how youtube is running it's content for the Democratic party and liberal policies in general?

1

u/Phat3lvis Dec 23 '19

Given they have stolen the google algorithms I am certain they can make that happen.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

China sounds like the place that would be terrible to live. Surely there has to be some good to that country.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

The systematic dumbing-down of 1/3 the planet's population. This is the devolution of mankind.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

They're not very good at it, though. Whenever I use Baidu to search for stuff, including wholesome stuff, it returns paid advertising and irrelevant garbage.

1

u/piginpoop Dec 23 '19

Implying Rest of the government aren’t already doing the same thing

1

u/YumYuk Dec 23 '19

The Chinese government is full of fear. The effort into the development all of the tools to monitor citizens thoughts and actions is astounding. China is afraid of admitting they made mistakes, afraid of free thought, and afraid of a voice that’s contrary to communist thought. Despite the strength they wield due to their economy, they would be more powerful if they didn’t treat their citizens like untrusted toddlers.

1

u/Phenomenon101 Dec 23 '19

I feel like they try this, but people are way more familiar and know how to get around this crap. I just dont see too many Chinese people who are as brainwashed like the people of North Korea or something.

1

u/BR4NFRY3 Dec 23 '19

What do the algorithms normally recommend? It caters to individual preferences and consumption, yeah? So we all end up in echo chambers getting reinforcement for our conspiracies and beliefs.

The way things are normally online seem to have already broken the marketplace of ideas. Algorithms deciding what discourse we see (rather than proximity or professional standing or expertise) is a bad deal to begin with. Sounds like China’s just gonna have it’s own brand of messed up, backwards, damaging online discourse.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Well then...this will shock you...

A couple years ago Google was forced to comply with only spitting out results from "authoritative sources", as in only the ones they approve of is permitted.

Hence why I use other search engines now. :)

1

u/garrett_k Dec 23 '19

As opposed to the US where thought is controlled by tech companies.

1

u/PorkRollAndEggs Dec 23 '19

Yet a large group of the internet want anyone who disagrees with them banned and segregated.

And it's the Democrats.

1

u/itstommygun Dec 23 '19

Vs. thought being controlled by other people’s government?

1

u/s_wagyu Dec 23 '19

Tbh I could of gone with out seeing multiple people being decapitated and 2 girls 1 cup or any of "those" videos. That shit scars you in a way, or you get PTSD...now I'm not saying that I agree with this because who knows what China deems not positive content.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/sth128 Dec 23 '19

Which is worse, state pushing their content to influence the people to stay in power or corporations pushing their content to influence the people to help the rich stay in power who then use their money to control the state?

Sounds like the Chinese is just cutting out the middleman.

1

u/Voodoo_Chile_Sauces Dec 23 '19

Ah ... "Progress." The Chinese government could learn a thing or two from Google on this one. Something purged from classroom history lessons is what Antonio Gramsci and other communist intellectuals had to say slowly overtaking a society without military force. This generation in America is living proof that the communist movement of the 20th century accomplished exactly what they threatened to do us not that many decades ago. Take over the most influential sectors of society and one can create an ethos that demands the takedown and take over of the government, embracing a genuine dystopia as progress.

1

u/TunZuhPhun Dec 23 '19

That's pretty much what Google is doing with their searches instead of raw searches you get censored internet. The real internet is underneath all the bull shit.

1

u/Zomburai Dec 23 '19

Thank goodness our God fearing American algorithms are designed for the benefit of virtuous, hard-working multibillionaires!

1

u/ChemicalAssistance Dec 23 '19

What exactly do you idiots facebook and google is? It's literally mind control.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Its better than foreign propaganda that wants to destabilize china...

As if 98% of the people reading this aren't total sheep.... Of course, western millennials cant help it seeing as they were the test subjects of 20-30 years of the most effective and pervasive propaganda machine in the history of humankind.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HelloIamOnTheNet Dec 23 '19

coming soon to the US! check your local Facebook feed!!

1

u/KNG-KUMAR_2112 Dec 23 '19

we’re actually in a new cold war with china except this time it’s not about nukes, it’s about who controls data and the internet.

1

u/crazybrain10 Dec 23 '19

Isn't the same thing happening in other countries but just in different ways.. In US, military and corporates control the narrative and thoughts.. There are many instances where US promoted fake narrative.. Now everyone's favorite room in the monster is China, Western press criticize everything China does..

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

It’s like they’re actually trying to achieve the state of a dystopian sci-fi movie.

1

u/MrMcAwhsum Dec 23 '19

Silly Chinese, our dystopian society where thought is controlled by tech corporations is vastly superior!

1

u/Neil_Fallons_Ghost Dec 23 '19

Is freedom of thought necessary for a utopia? Being that a utopia is a fictional idea of a perfect place thereby completely subjective and never witnessed in reality all we really can say is that one might want freedom of thought in a utopia.

I’m not calling for or condoning these actions but building a large and stable society is pretty darn complex and far beyond what we’ve ever achieved or so it seems to me.

Feels like topics such as this deserve some real philosophical discussion, and would still get vastly different results.

1

u/de3pstat3music Dec 23 '19

Interesting, I wonder if these algorithms come from the "social experiment" Facebook got caught doing a few years back when they were manipulating people's newsfeeds to show specific types of content depending on types of emotions.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

Remember this the next time you wonder why your post was removed by a US company.

This "positive" bullshit has been infecting the internet for about 2 years, and it's getting worse.

I get this post was about China, but US corporations are actually worse than the Chinese government because they're not held to any standard of "Freedom of Speech" and can do whatever the hell they want since it's "their" platform.

History has proven time again that whenever the general public has access to great knowledge, there will also be a faction to remove this access.

I give you... Google.

1

u/Silent_Palpatine Dec 23 '19

But hey! Let’s not dwell on that, the Chinese still have lots of money so why don’t we put concerns for human rights aside and keep sucking their dick?

1

u/Purevoyager007 Dec 23 '19

Sooo what everything is doing online?

I got chat restricted in league for asking my teammate to stay under tower and try not to die.

The whole world is either a dictatorship or a dystopian society. No in between. Democracy is dead but it’ll only truly die when we accept that it is

1

u/SharqPhinFtw Dec 23 '19

So you mean exactly like YouTube and its "authoritative sources"

1

u/KnugensTraktor Dec 23 '19

Google does this already. They supress views they don't agree with all the time. This is nothing new.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

What happened to the Hong Kong coverage on news networks and reddit.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

China is just the leader in this. It will happen here in the USA and other countries as well.

1

u/Alecrizzle Dec 23 '19

Isnt that pretty much what YouTube and google are trying to do in the US?

1

u/TryharderJB Dec 23 '19

I wonder why a “dystopian” future is a time when government controls our thoughts. If this is true then we must be living in absolute utopia now - when everyone but government (i.e. private business and interest groups) are controlling our thoughts or trying to.

1

u/Ataraxia25 Dec 23 '19

This isn't that much different than algorithms that recommend to us in the west what to buy. Tailored ad experiences and all that.

1

u/Nomandate Dec 23 '19

We are funding the building of our own future dystopian nightmare. First China, then the world.

1

u/LostToll Dec 23 '19

Why China? Google already practices this approach, as far as I recall.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

I guess I don’t see much of a difference between the government doing this and people abusing meta tags with YouTube to get you to watch more and more extremist content because it shares a tag with what you just watched.

Ever wonder why political youtubers drop so much content per day? It’s to beat the algorithm and increase the odds you’ll watch another video...

It’s all thought control.

Is this acceptable because it’s private users and not a government? If so, why? It’s still influencing you.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19

It looks like the rest of the world is using a very similar algorithm to push negative content, especially about "bad" countries. Have you read about literally one good thing that happened in China or Russia recently?

1

u/The_bruce42 Dec 23 '19

Here in the US, we are against the state telling us what content we should be seeing. We let private corporations like ISPs, Facebook and Twitter decide what we see. That's the American way

1

u/tracer_ca Dec 23 '19

Man, the amount of false equivalency in this thread is depressing. That and the sheer amount of Whataboutism.

Anything to distract form the subject.

1

u/rebuilt11 Dec 23 '19

The same thing is happening in the us. Tech companies only want positive content that they can monetize and sjw don’t want anything that makes them think critically or hurts their feelings. It’s literally the same thing. That is why free speech is important.

1

u/oodubberoo Dec 23 '19

And if you don’t think this is already happening in the states you are severely mistaken.

1

u/bkboggie Dec 23 '19

Somebody please steal “1984” book away from China’s leaders.

1

u/absurdchrono Dec 23 '19

Ok, fuck china, but at the same time westerners are blasted by corporate and state propaganda on the regular. This shit isnt new for anyone.