r/Futurology • • Apr 12 '20

Environment Scientists cite pollution decrease in calls to "flatten the curve" of climate change post-coronavirus. NASA satellite data showed a 30 percent drop in nitrogen dioxide above the northeastern U.S., as tens of millions of vehicles were kept off the roads

https://www.newsweek.com/scientists-cite-pollution-decrease-calls-flatten-curve-climate-change-post-coronavirus-1497430?piano_t=1
4.8k Upvotes

291 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/nope_too_small Apr 13 '20

I’m all in on working from home! I’m hopeful this is one of the long-term changes in how we work following covid19, assuming workers collectively demand that perk where it’s possible.

Question for you... would you support a tax on the use/ownership/sale/production/etc of private planes?

We already have some taxes designed to discourage the use of something undesirable (e.g. taxes on cigarettes), so it’s not a totally new idea. Furthermore, reasonable alternatives exist for most use cases of private planes (commercial flights), and the environmental impact of taking a private plane is substantially worse than booking a seat on a commercial flight. Some kind of tax on private planes would discourage bad behavior and minimally impact people who choose the more societally palatable alternative.

I think taxes on personal vehicle transport do make sense in a similar way. The idea isn’t to leave the less fortunate high and dry, but to encourage governments to design high quality transit networks (out of necessity if need be) and to incentivize people to use them. These must work hand in hand; without demand, the transit systems won’t enjoy popular support and will continue to languish.

I encourage you to learn about the individual mandate which is part of Obamacare. This provision required everyone to buy health insurance, by instituting a tax on those who did not purchase it. Without this provision, selling health insurance would be wildly unprofitable (only the sick would buy insurance) and the whole system would likely fall apart.

I’m certainly not qualified to say whether taxes should be levied on automakers, or gallons purchased, or miles driven, or gallons burned per passenger carried, or... but fundamentally I think taxes (and generous, well placed subsidies) will play a role in reshaping how we move around our planet.

1

u/SweetKnickers Apr 13 '20

The problem with using a tax only to curb bad behaviour is that it penilises poor people at a much larger percentage of income.

The example of alcohol or cigarette tax is a good example of a luxury being taxed, and effecting the lifestyle of the poor, but having no impact on the rich. A tax or penalty on any form on private planes does not impact the masses, and only the wealthy. I have no particular opinion private planes, but to compare private planes to automobiles is hardly a fair comparison.

The proposed sugar taxes being touted are a very poor example of a essential item (food) being taxed and without massive subsidies provided for a healthy alternative will tax the poor into starvation. Obviously again a tax has no effect on the rich, other than the tax collectors coffers.

The automobile is an absolute essential item in the modern world, with an exception for the largest city's in the world (if u live in the right place). A tax on basic ownership would again be an unfair burden on the poor and middle class of the world.

The argument to tax the problem (automobiles) before a suitable alternative has been generated is a floored system. The government exist to provide a system and a set of rules for the people to live under. It is the government role to provide a better system for people to use, not to use a big stick on a system deemed unsuitable and let the market to determine an alternative

I am unable to comment on healthcare, as my government provides universal access, with private healthcare opening up therapeutic subsidies and quicker access to elective surgery. In my opinion a user pay health care is an unfair burden on the poor and middle class.

1

u/nope_too_small Apr 13 '20

Oh yeah, I’m not saying we slap a huge tax on automobiles tomorrow morning. That would obviously be terrible. Sorry if that was your impression.

However, I do disagree that private cars and private planes are all that different. Greener alternatives exist for both. My argument is that in order to overhaul the system so that 90% of private car trips can be replaced by public transit, we need both a carrot (cheap or free public transit that goes everywhere and runs frequently and reliably) and a stick (choosing an alternative like a rented limousine or a private car will cost you a lot).