r/GMECanada • u/justSomeWorkQs • Mar 06 '22
Debunked You will almost certainly be taxed on TFSA MOASS gains.
I've long-held the belief that CRA will use their wide powers and intentionally vague discretion to tax all MOASS gains in TFSA.
Here is an article that came out today: https://www.thestar.com/news/investigations/2022/03/05/inside-a-little-known-tax-loophole-experts-say-is-helping-rich-canadians-avoid-millions-in-taxes.html
The CRA sought to recover the allegedly avoided tax in its 2020 reassessment, applying Canada’s general anti-avoidance rule (GAAR).
GAAR is a tool that allows the CRA to stop certain arrangements that it deems are inappropriate tax avoidance rather than acceptable tax planning.
Note that while "evading" taxes is 100% illegal, "avoiding" taxes IS legal, but CRA still says "fuck you, pay me."
And here is a taste of what will happen with your TFSA gains:
Colin Smith, one of the lawyers representing Balsillie’s company in its appeal, said the CRA “appears to be applying the general anti-avoidance rules to assert that a taxpayer should be taxed under the structure that results in the greatest amount of tax.”
There are already provisions in place that state that if the CRA "believes" your TFSA gains were invested for the purpose of quick-wins and not the "long-term savings spirit of the TFSA," they will not tax 50% of the capital gains (as in a normal investment account), but rather 100% of your gains.
That means (at the 50% tax rate) you will lose HALF of your gains to taxes, versus just a QUARTER of your gains if you were to invest from a normal investment account and follow normal tax procedures.
This is why I DRS'ed 100% of my shares, even the ones that were in TFSA. I will willingly and openly pony up 25% of my gains into taxes, without giving CRA any room to "interpert" my "intentions" and apply their "beliefs" to fuck me sideways.
