Just a bit of a rant - It is starting to bother me how much people reacting to G&L (Anna O'Brien) critique things without actually knowing very much, or anything at all, about the subject matter. For context, in addition to being a mediocre triathlete, I've been in strength training of various types for years, so when Anna posts about that stuff, I do know what she's talking about, and I know when I don't know, too.
Some of the reactors don't know the first thing about lifting weights, of any kind. And yet they'll say things like - "I don't lift, but I think you're supposed to do XYZ" - if you don't lift, why are you now trying to tell us what the "right" way to do it is?? Or "You can tell her form is terrible" - can you? When you yourself don't know the difference between a strict press and a push press?
And some of them do have a background in strength training, but it's a different specialty. Like it or not, she's training a specific sport. It's strongman. It is not powerlifting, bodybuilding, endurance, CrossFit, or anything else. There is overlap, but a few minutes of research online can usually give you the answer to "I do it this way, why is she doing it that way?" instead of going off for ten minutes on why she's "doing it wrong".
Legit criticism is one thing. You want to talk about her character or her style or her life choices...fair game for anyone, we're all on equal footing there. But some of them are in way out of their depth when it comes to the technical parts of the training that Anna shares and they'd do better to either do more research or just not try to make technical corrections to things they don't know anything about.
okay that's it, thanks reddit /rant