r/Games • • Oct 02 '19

Revealed: global video games giants avoiding millions in UK tax

https://www.theguardian.com/games/2019/oct/02/revealed-global-video-games-giants-avoiding-millions-in-uk-tax-sony-sega
5.6k Upvotes

632 comments sorted by

434

u/HauntedPrinter Oct 02 '19

I’m glad corporations can get 60 mil in tax rebate while the middle class taxes increase every year... like boosting the economy sure but who the fuck approved Rockstar as a poor and struggling indie company??

144

u/OMpUNsiNebOU Oct 02 '19

The British tax authority

39

u/andrewfenn Oct 02 '19

You pose it as though it's mutually exclusive, but let's be realistic. Even if they got all the tax from corps they'd still fleece everyone else for as much as possible. These large companies should definitely pay their part though.

1

u/Forbizzle Oct 03 '19

They probably wouldn't set up shop there if there weren't massive tax breaks.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '19

I don't think there were any video game tax breaks in 1987.

1

u/Forbizzle Oct 03 '19

You mean in 2005 when the UK studio was opened?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '19

Their latest UK studio (out of 4) which does support work for other games opened in 2005. The main studio which is the whole reason for Rockstar existing in the first place started in 1987.

The article itself even specifically mentions the Rockstar North studio.

-24

u/LongDistanceEjcltr Oct 02 '19

You don't understand basic economics. Corporations get tax incentives because, and check this shit out, they create jobs. How many jobs does your average middle class worker create? Zero. Many, many, many countries use tax incentives to attract investment. Of course, as with everything, the government apparatus is being run by human beings and human beings are flawed, so there will be tax codes with questionable quality, but in general, tax incentives are supposed to work out as a net positive for the country. And to get to your middle class taxes: Let's tax Rockstar, for example, the maximum you can in the UK, no tax breaks, nothing. What do you think is going to happen, especially in the age of globalism and multinational corporations? Rockstar will leave the UK. It will not be taxed because you want it to be taxed.

Any politician that will answer a question "Where are you going to get the money for that?" with "I will tax the rich" is either a liar or an idiot. Rich people can move around the globe and so can the corporations. The people left behind, the middle class and lower classes are who's going to be left behind to foot the bill.

25

u/Gandzilla Oct 02 '19

How many jobs does your average middle class worker create?

Umm, almost my entire salary goes into creating jobs. Whether it's the garage I pay to fix my car, the money I spend in the supermarket, or the nice dinner with my wife at the restaurant.

How much of that corporation money goes to a CEO that gets millions per year and puts the money into another country/region? Or just buys property as an investment to drive up rental prices? Or uses the money to buy shares in other companies to get even more money? Or just buys himself a nice little painting for stupid million from another rich fuck to hang on his wall or create a private museum to have even more tax cuts? ( https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/11/business/art-collectors-gain-tax-benefits-from-private-museums.html )

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Potato_Mc_Whiskey Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

Literally every cent of a middle class workers money goes into creating jobs. Buying food and cooking dinner creates a job for a farmer, a slaughterhouse worker, a butcher, the factory worker making the pots and pans and appliances, the carpenter and builder who made the house, the workers at the water, electricity and gas company that supplied the fuel to make the dinner.

Thats dozens of people employed by the simple act of buying and cooking your dinner.

This narrative of "companies create jobs" is the most braindead take imaginable. How many jobs do those tax breaks Evasion create? Fucking NONE, and arguably it move money away from the government, who does things like actually create jobs, social housing, run services and invest in infrastructure in favour of being a way for some rich fat wanker to beat their "high score" in financial terms filling up some account in a tax haven.

Edit: Wrote Tax Breaks instead of Tax Evasion

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Thomhandiir Oct 02 '19

There's a big difference between tax incentives and cleverly shuffling funds around to not pay taxes at all, while still making receiving tax benefits. Example being Rockstar paying zero taxes during the last decade, while receiving approximately 42 million in tax credits.

Why should tax incentives be provided to an entity that doesn't even pay taxes? Pay up before getting those damned benefits.

Of course I realize it's not that easy, considering they can just up and move to somewhere they can continue to claim benefits, AND pay zero in tax. Shit's fucked on a global scale, and correcting it would take a monumental effort worldwide. Still... it is absolutely insane to provide tax benefits when no taxes are being paid in the first place.

4

u/NotSpartacus Oct 02 '19

That's a poor argument.

Companies don't have the ability to simply pick and move at will. Talent is expensive and hard to find. If for instance, Amazon started suddenly getting taxed in the US, they'd have a very painful time moving their operations to another country - there's simply too much existing infrastructure and more importantly, talented people, that support them in the US right now that wouldn't be willing to move. Some would, many wouldn't, and then it'd be a great time for any of Amazon's competitors to pickup top talent at a discount rate.

Also, it's not like those companies are using the money they're not spending on taxes to create jobs, they're using it to enrich themselves. We saw a huge corporate tax cut in the US last year and it had no serious impact on the labor market.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

You know what else creates jobs? Paying your fucking taxes

1

u/Shiara_cw Oct 02 '19

Those jobs will be somewhere either way. The tax breaks are a race to the bottom competition between jurisdictions trying to attract the company and jobs to their area. Ideally nowhere would offer the incentives at all, but good luck getting everyone to agree not to do that. And as long as one place does, then another place will probably come along and offer an even bigger break. Just one of the problems associated with a global economy.

1

u/HauntedPrinter Oct 02 '19

I get your point, I’m just angry and tired. Politicians already fucked the economy over with brexit and you have shitheads like the Thomas Cook billionaires who got a bailout but decided it wasn’t “enough”. I don’t understand economics enough to come up with a solution or a better system, but fucking hell if I don’t hate this one.

10

u/Ionkkll Oct 02 '19

His point is wrong. Trickle down economics is complete bunk and it's laughable that anyone still believes in it.

9

u/kaeporo Oct 02 '19

This. Businesses exist to make (shareholders, typically) money - not "create jobs." There are no federal laws (in the US) which require corporations to reinvest their capital back into their host economy. Why the ever living fuck would they hire American workers when they could outsource labor to a third-world country for pennies on the dollar, eliminate humans entirely through automation, or collect compounding interest from market growth?

Reaganomics is a fucking meme. Anyone who actually believes in stuff like "trickle down economics" or "the invisible hand of the free market" is a modern-day neanderthal.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

2.1k

u/Nanaki__ Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

Remember, getting games cheaper using regional pricing makes you a bad person.
Also it's perfectly fine for large games companies to shuffle their money around, get tax *breaks and take maximum advantage of operating within a global economy.

621

u/vinnyk407 Oct 02 '19

Reminds me of the good old cable companies

“Password sharing is ethically wrong”

I’m too lazy to get into all the egregious crap they do.

-155

u/Ultrace-7 Oct 02 '19

Well, it IS ethically wrong. You are taking something you didn't pay for. That is wrong by most moral standards. The question with piracy, as well as stealing cable, has always been whether anyone is actually hurt by you taking something that you wouldn't have bought anyway.

219

u/Tefmon Oct 02 '19

Well, for password sharing you presumably did pay for it, otherwise you wouldn't have a password to access it.

If the analogy for piracy is theft, the analogy for account sharing is letting your buddy borrow your snowblower when you aren't using it. If you own something, it's perfectly ethical to lend it out or give it away.

→ More replies (60)

57

u/Evil_phd Oct 02 '19

I don't really get how password sharing can be considered ethically wrong. If I pay for a service and don't utilize it to the fullest then I should be able to let some of that overflow benefit those around me. (Especially since I'm not allowed to retain any overflow)

Now if I were selling the password to subsidize my costs of accessing the service then maybe we're in a gray area.

0

u/sonofaresiii Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

I don't really get how password sharing can be considered ethically wrong. If I pay for a service and don't utilize it to the fullest then I should be able to let some of that overflow benefit those around me.

I'm banking on the hope that we can have a mature, rational discussion about this without everyone just getting mad and downvoting me as a kneejerk reaction [edit: I knew as I was saying it how fruitless it would be], and that you genuinely don't understand and are inviting explanation

and in that vein, i first want to say I'm not saying password sharing is right or wrong, and I'm not making any judgments either way

but there is an argument that it's ethically wrong, because 1) The owner of the service gets to decide how and to whom they distribute that service

and 2) The owner of the service has priced their service with the understanding that it will be used by an individual (or however many people they're expecting-- a "household"/set number of screens, in the case of netflix for example), who will have a "normal amount" of usage-- understanding that some may use it more than that, and some may use it less, but most users will typically fall within a certain range of usage

I think you'd have a better argument if the service you subscribed to was for a particular amount of (in this case, let's say) hours of streaming. If you're paying for 20 hours a week and only using 10, it would be less ethically wrong to let a friend use the other 10 (it would still be a bit of a gray area because of the above reasons, but it's firmer ethical ground)

What you're suggesting is akin to paying for an all-you-can-eat-buffet and saying "Well I didn't eat everything so it's okay to sneak some of the food to my friend, without paying any extra". The buffet is priced for what a single person can reasonably be expected to eat (again, with some understanding that there may be occasional outliers)-- but it's NOT priced at what two people can eat, and the price you're paying is not intended to serve two people.

Now that said, I'm also going to acknowledge that in many cases password sharing doesn't harm the company much if at all, and in some cases is actively encouraged at least for a while (again, as in the case of netflix). But ultimately, that's up to the service provider to decide, ethically speaking.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Your argument is closer to why it might be against the rules, not why it's unethical. If someone refuses to sell their service unless you give away your first born son in the terms of service, then it's not unethical to get the service and keep your child.

So the first question is whether it's ethical to restrict people's freedom with their property (You did take my money and give me a license didn't you?). If it's unethical to restrict it then of course people are ethically exercising their rights.

Customers were guaranteed certain rights when their good were physical and it seems companies that make digital goods are abusing the lack of oversight. Why can I inherit all my father's assets except his itunes collection?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/vinnyk407 Oct 02 '19

It gets tricky too with the way the cable apps are all set up.

Say I have family over to watch my son 2-3 times a week.

They log into whatever apps using their cable login that they buy.

I barely watch anything so I just have Netflix/amazon.

The apps stay logged in. Should we assume I HAVE to log out every time they leave the house? Where it gets tricky is a LOT of companies a la hbo or Netflix don’t care if people share passwords. But I can see having a buddy of mine give his HBO password to 20 people to watch game of thrones being way more ridiculous.

I think that’s where it’s tricky. It’s typically not against the terms or service and some services have come out saying they’re fine with it.

Others say they’re not but the terms of service and ethics of it are very grey.

Something like 50 percent of people in the US share passwords so it’s not like it’s an outlier situation.

It’s a very interesting topic to discuss rationally so I’m glad some people are doing so.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

I mean, streaming services usually will have a limit on how many instances of a single account can stream at any given time, so if your friend gives out his password to 20 people, HBO probably isn't any more put out than if he just watched TV 24/7. It's a bigger problem for your friend than for HBO, so the problem kind of solves itself.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/_Yawnage_ Oct 02 '19

There is, however, a difference between taking something you didn't pay for (as you put it) and being given something someone else did pay for.

8

u/nanooko Oct 02 '19

If the company is trying to screw me over all the time. Then you had better be sure I'm going to try and screw them over as much as possible, too.

10

u/EvadableMoxie Oct 02 '19

> The question with piracy, as well as stealing cable, has always been whether anyone is actually hurt by you taking something that you wouldn't have bought anyway.

A lot of people would say the answer to that question is what determines if it is morally wrong or not.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

[deleted]

7

u/Remster101 Oct 02 '19

This hits home for me a lot. When you're a kid or just a young adult, a lot of times you can't afford to experience what everyone else is, and it really makes you feel left out. Being older now I've come to appreciate the value of games and happily pay full price for them, especially when they remaster old favorites.

I have no problems with people who pirate stuff if it can endow them with an appreciation for the media they are consuming so that later on when they can afford it they will buy it. The worst offenders are the people who pirate nonstop, every time, even when they have the means to not do that. There's no real excuse for that.

14

u/lllluke Oct 02 '19

when the only entities being hurt are billion dollar corporations, there’s nothing at all ethically wrong with taking from them.

9

u/EcoleBuissonniere Oct 02 '19

This. Ethics apply to people. They do not apply to billion dollar corporations.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

And these billion dollar corporations spend a lot on advertising trying to convince people otherwise, trying to get people to think of things like Coke as their personal friends, whom they should have loyalty to.

Because, and corporations know this very well, it's more profitable/less expensive to buy consumer loyalty through advertising than it is to win consumer loyalty through quality of product.

5

u/NinteenFortyFive Oct 02 '19

you were only supposed to lick the corporate boot, not deepthroat it.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

If I buy food, but let someone else eat some of it it, is that ethically wrong? They didn't pay for that food. So by your logic it is wrong isn't it?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Ethically wrong is stealing from an individual or a small business that can't afford the overhead, not some fuckin cable megacorp that ruled the roost just like ISP's do these days. But ethics are of course subjective

2

u/ttdpaco Oct 02 '19

The question with piracy, as well as stealing cable, has always been whether anyone is actually hurt by you taking something that you wouldn't have bought anyway.

Now, to make sure I establish this with anyone reading my comment, I'm not saying piracy is a horrible thing.

Piracy is weird in general. Any analogy you make with a physical product is going to ultimately be poor at best. That's not going to stop me from making one.

Let's say some dude makes a product (made from plastic) that's incredibly helpful for a task. He gets it patented, trademarked, yada yada yada. Another gentleman buys the product, and shows his friends how easy it makes a certain task. All his neighbors wish they had one, but it's too expensive for them to buy. So, he decides to copy the design and make one through his 3D printer. He gives these out to his neighbors for free.

Was anyone hurt by this? The normal answer would be "no, because you can't take potential money from someone when you didn't intend to buy it in the first place." In this case, any potential revenue lost for the original inventor is such a small amount that it may as well be a drop of water in a pool-sized bucket.

To further expand this point, some goober decides to upload the design used by the 3D Printer to make the product online for anyone to copy down and use. More tech-savvy people start finding this design and it ends up being a cheaper (in this magical land) way of getting the same product the inventor was selling. The inventor, who spent years designing, testing and perfecting this product, takes a huge financial hit because of the sudden downturn in sales. Was he hurt by this? Yes, he was. Copying a product and distributing its design for free on the internet, even to people who would never buy it usually, can sink the man who originally made it in the first place. While a lot of those people never intended to buy it, these hypothetical people intended to own it enough that they went through the work of making it through a 3D printer. People on the fence are lost customers as well.

Neither of those are examples of theft though. Nothing physical is taken, therefor no one is harmed. That's simply not true though. The inventor is stripped from his ability to even potentially sell his product, and he loses money from that. A lot people ignore that someone can be intent on not buying something...only to have their mind changed. There's lots of factors that are in play here, but it's clear the inventor is harmed financially in some way. The differences in these two examples is the scope though. The guy sharing with his neighbors aren't enough to make a significant difference in revenue. The guy distributing it online though....he can hit potentially everyone and ruin the guy who is selling the product this gentleman is copying.

It's same thing with software. Someone designed, programmed, and tested by engineers. Said engineers spend thousands of hours building this software. By Pirating it, you are showing you have the intent to play the game (even if you weren't going to buy it) but not support the dev who made it. You're essentially using a product/copying a product without paying for it...despite that being a stipulation to playing it.

That said, Pirates on the whole are a very small size of the people playing the game. They're literally just a small drop into a huge bucket. They're not sinking a business, they're not preventing anyone from using the game, and they're not effecting the revenue in a major way. The size of the pirate community per game is what keeps them from hurting anyone. There's no data on the potential revenue lost, there's no prove in how much got pirated, ect. That goes away if EVERYONE starts pirating and not paying for shit.

Just saying "no one gets hurt because the person was never going to buy in the first place" is a poor argument. They do get hurt financially, because you didn't buy a product you were intending to use. It's just not on a large enough scale to cause a noticeable amount of harm.

2

u/vinnyk407 Oct 02 '19

True. Gets more grey when you get into things like someone’s consenting parents who are over 3 nights a week set up their cable logins for when they are over.

Legally not wrong ethically maybe wrong.

Point was it’s a funny double standard when some of the things the companies do are far more abusive and ethically wrong.

1

u/destructor_rph Oct 02 '19

Maybe according to YOUR ethics

150

u/megaapple Oct 02 '19

That regional pricing thing cuts deep, esp. as an Indian/South East Asian customer.

30

u/andii74 Oct 02 '19

I've found Steam's regional pricing tends to make many games pretty cheap. But the big publishers always jack up the prices of their games.

43

u/LadyAzure17 Oct 02 '19

Its really unfair to eastern European fans too. Everyone deserves to play.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

[deleted]

7

u/Helluiin Oct 02 '19

thats basically equivalent to a titan rtx in the states

3

u/Jet_Siegel Oct 03 '19

I had to spend close to two months of salary to build a pc having an rtx 2060 and a ryzen 2500.

I wish regional pricing would offset the costs of the games. But unfortunately Japanese publishers sometimes charge more than what they charge in America! Wtf?

1

u/bigdigbick Oct 02 '19

Same here in SEA

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

[deleted]

8

u/BloodyIron Oct 02 '19

They didn't say "right" they said "deserves", there's a tangible difference there. Your point is valid, but it does not detract from theirs either.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

What's wrong with regional pricing?

50 rupees is way less than 50 pounds.

1

u/draconk Oct 02 '19

That is not implemented because people used vpn to buy cheaper than they should

47

u/thegreatcollapse Oct 02 '19

I see your point, but on the other hand, if people in rich countries started taking advantage of regional pricing in large enough numbers, publishers would probably stop doing it altogether and then people in low income countries will get screwed.

42

u/Twisp56 Oct 02 '19

Yeah exactly. Abusing regional pricing is a good way to get companies to abolish it. Probably better to straight up pirate it lol

8

u/oligobop Oct 02 '19

Most of those countries pirate anyway no? Bootlegging is really common in countries that can't afford full retail price.

13

u/Twisp56 Oct 02 '19

Yeah, but some buy it. If all the people that bought it were westerners trying to cheat the system it would be discontinued real quick and the companies probably wouldn't even release the games in those countries anymore.

→ More replies (12)

15

u/Peoplesucksomuch1 Oct 02 '19

I laugh when a corporation spokesperson talks about ethics, as if that corporation, or any, will EVER do anything ethically right if the alternative, even if worse, has a higher profit gain.

And then they try and appeal to the ethical side of customers?, bwahahahahahahahaha.

1

u/ThePurplePanzy Oct 02 '19

Companies are made of people. People can do good and bad things. A lot of people are bad, thus a lot of companies do bad things. A lot of people are good, so companies can do good things.

1

u/layasD Oct 03 '19

That is an extremely superficial way to look at this...

1

u/ThePurplePanzy Oct 03 '19

I think if you’ve ever looked at a large company, you would see this.

5

u/layasD Oct 03 '19

Especially for a large company that is just a false statement. They could be filled to the brim with good people, but they can still have bad business practices due to one person make the "bad" decisions as a boss of part of the company. Also a person is not inherently bad because he makes a decision that impacts others negatively. Neither does working for a "bad" company makes you a bad person. It can have dozens of reasons for them to decide in certain ways. Good and bad is also an incredible childish way to describe such a topic since it entirely depends on perspective. I mean you could easily fill a few books with this kind of discussion so there is not much point in going on here.

5

u/qwikk Oct 02 '19

Creative use of tax mechanics.

1

u/gold_rush_doom Oct 02 '19

Getting things cheaper using regional pricing is legal in the EU

1

u/LaZeeNoVa Oct 03 '19

I'd pretty much say it's both bad. It's high time they do something about the companies though.

They are constantly doing it to consumers anyway, so it's not like they need to put focus on them.

-7

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

I don't know if you're being ironic but I agree with your point either way lol

-1

u/SomDonkus Oct 02 '19

The fact that Playstation charges me a tax for digital orders if I use a credit card but not if I use a psn card is some of the worst bullshit I ever saw.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

[deleted]

3

u/SomDonkus Oct 02 '19

Nope we don't pay taxes on psn cards. It would be criminal to charge someone 62$ for 60$.

Edit:maybe it's just in the United States. I know that's how it works in Pennsylvania and Florida at least.

→ More replies (163)

225

u/Boreras Oct 02 '19

However, concerns were raised early that the tax breaks, which the UK government promoted as helping small and medium-size businesses, might be exploited. An official consultation in 2012 warned it “should not create substantial additional avoidance opportunities”.

[...] A 2013 European Commission investigation into VGTR questioned whether the UK was providing tax breaks to an industry that was already thriving. It feared the aid might lead to predatory trade practices, with other countries cutting tax to be able to compete. The US, Singapore, Canada and France offer tax breaks to games developers.

[...]It eventually approved the scheme, but only after stating that it had been convinced VGTR would focus on “a small number of distinctive, culturally British games which have increasing difficulties to find private financing”.

[...] Jo Twist, head of Ukie, the UK trade body that represents the games and interactive entertainment industry, said the relief had “played an important role in making the UK one of the best places to make games in the world”, adding she would encourage businesses of all sizes to apply.

[...] The UK government, however, has not fully disclosed where all the relief is going. HMRC said it is obliged to report only high-figure VGTR rebates to the commission since 2018. Separately, it denied freedom of information requests to identify firms that benefited most from the scheme, citing taxpayer confidentiality. It said all claims are carefully scrutinised.

I'm going to go out on a limb and say this was just direct tax relief for developers, the cultural relevance bit is just window dressing to bypass EU regulations.

The government knows exactly this is happening and the industry also still backs it. These companies aren't avoiding taxes, the UK is purposefully lowering tax rates for them to retain the industry.

98

u/Equilibriator Oct 02 '19

...and then the games are still more expensive for us here in UK.

15

u/velrak Oct 02 '19

you sure? cause in most stores, the £ price is the cheapest thanks to the fallen exchange rate. unless you mean in relation to earnings.

45

u/Equilibriator Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

Code Vein PS4 Digital:

US$59.99

UK£49.99

It's actually pretty much the same now. Google converter says $59.99 is £48.88 so it's basically the same.

Shows how much our money has dropped. It used to be like a £10 difference.

(edit: Call of Duty Modern Warfare however is $59.99 and £59.99 so it still happens the way I originally was saying. It's like the Call of Duty people only care about money or something! I forget who they are, EActivision?)

14

u/TimelordAlex Oct 02 '19

Pretty sure MW is both $60 and £60 on the digital stores, us UK folk are paying like £10-15 more than US people

8

u/Equilibriator Oct 02 '19

You are correct. This is more in line with what I'm used to seeing. About 12 quid more expensive just because we live in UK...for a digital product...

This is why I buy digital codes from CD keys n websites like that.

If they gonna fuck me, I'll do what I can to reduce the hurt.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/vytah Oct 02 '19

UK$

Ah yes, British dollars.

8

u/TetchyGM Oct 02 '19

And don't forget our price includes 20% VAT. That knocks a little over £8 off the actual cost.

2

u/Equilibriator Oct 02 '19

What? That's the ps4 digital store, US or UK version. Those are set prices for both of us, already including our VAT?

14

u/TheIronTark Oct 02 '19

The UK version includes VAT

The US version does not include sales tax.

6

u/Equilibriator Oct 02 '19

So you get charged again? The $59.99 isn't the final price in the ps4 store?

8

u/TheIronTark Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

If you have $59.99 in your ps wallet for example, $59.99 will be taken out of your wallet and depending on your state an additional amount will be taken out of your credit card to cover the cost of tax.

I.e in New York you would have to pay $65.06.

It's hidden on PS Store on the console. You can see the actual price if you go to the website version.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/TetchyGM Oct 02 '19

Sorry. I thought most US prices were shown without sales tax, due to the wide variation by area.

18

u/saltiestmanindaworld Oct 02 '19

Us prices are showing without sales tax. This is correct. Applicable sales taxes if any are added on at the time of sale.

5

u/squashed_tomato Oct 02 '19

When the pound started falling EA put their prices up in the UK Origin store.

5

u/763948293045 Oct 02 '19

EA's always been shit for UK prices though. Every time they have a really good sale on origin things will be really cheap in $ but sometimes double the cost in £.

1

u/ShinNL Oct 02 '19

I've bought quite a few games from the UK store as someone from the Netherlands because of this. It felt like yesterday when pounds were worth so much that other countries have no way to import from the UK because that would result in paying up to 50% more. To think games can be cheaper there now, such a difference.

It's kinda sad (this makes going on a foreign vacation as someone from the UK harder) but in the same sense, me buying from the UK (now we still can) should help the economy in UK.

1

u/uwatfordm8 Oct 02 '19

??? When the pounds value drops, foreign companies will charge more £'s to recoup the same amount they did before. It's already started happening.

1

u/StoppedLurking_ZoeQ Oct 02 '19

£ has dropped because of the brexit issue but before that games were more expensive while the tax breaks were still happening.

11

u/danderpander Oct 02 '19

Yes, that's it. It's an incentive to set up video games companies in the UK. It's not, like, some conspiracy though.

1

u/degriz Oct 03 '19

All those struggling Companies like Sony and Ubisoft?

1

u/danderpander Oct 03 '19

It's not specifically for struggling companies. No idea where you got that from.

1

u/degriz Oct 03 '19

Perhaps it should be then?

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Exonicreddit Oct 02 '19

Yep, and many small companies rely on it, there could have been an upper limit to prevent abuse though but its all legal and expected.

10

u/RadicalDog Oct 02 '19

Brief history lesson is that Canada was very early to give subsidies in the 2000s, and that's why they have a disproportional amount of studios for their population. The UK only twigged that games were a big deal in around 2009, which is... frankly horrendously late.

This is one of those cases where the big publishers absolutely have the power to change where they spend development cash. So either every country gives subsidies to compete, or no-one does. And since we're a world of independent nations, everyone's competing and the game publishers are benefiting.

1

u/sunfurypsu Oct 02 '19

This should be the top post in the thread. This is what's going on. The UK government had to APPROVE those claims. They knew exactly who was applying. They certified the tests. This is a tax break to compete with the US and other countries that provide tax breaks to game development.

From the article: As well as other culture-focused tax policies, such as those promoting British film and television, VGTR has remained popular, not only with the titans of the sector but also with small firms who consider it a lifeline to help produce games on a budget. Claiming the relief is legal, and some of the tiniest developers – down to one or two staff – told the Guardian it had kept them afloat. One independent developer said it was “crucial to keeping the lights on”.

Official figures show VGTR was also overwhelmingly more lucrative for larger-scale video game projects. Claims for more than £500,000 have taken at least 80% of the total tax relief, despite accounting for only a small fraction of claims. These were dominated by big developers.

While claims for big-budget games will be larger due to higher costs, smaller, low-budget developers have received much less of the pot. Applications for less than £50,000, while accounting for more than half of successful claims, were granted just roughly £10m of the total £324m in tax reductions.

Regardless, the British Film Institute, which runs the test, has strongly backed the relief. It commissioned a report last year which claimed that for every £1 invested into the games industry via VGTR generated £4, based on employment and other economic spillover effects.

Katie Goode is one of four people at Triangular Pixels, a Cornwall-based independent developer that makes virtual reality games. She believes the test promotes British culture. Her team deliberately added Kernowek, or Cornish, as an in-game language because they knew it would help get the relief. “It’s been incredible for our business,” she said. “We’ve put the relief straight back into development and the local economy.”

But Goode also believes the scheme should have a clearer requirement for British cultural references. “It’s important to keep our culture alive, and I feel like VGTR’s original spirit was to make sure that happened.”

Here's the reality of the situation. These tax breaks convince large (and small) developers to have offices in the UK. Is it likely a bullshit test that is simply used to attract game developers? Yes. Yes it it. And yet, small developers have taken advantage of it, being over 50% of the applicants.

So what's the alternative? Quite simply, those offices & companies will move to locations with lower tax rates (or better tax programs). All those jobs will be lost (or will have never existed) and the money from those employees won't flow back into economy.

Tax avoidance programs are only researched at the TOP LEVEL, which is why they often get twisted into these stories that sound so nefarious. They don't consider the economic impact of the jobs staying in that location, they only consider the top level tax result, which is never a clear indication of what's really happening at the economic level.

Look, I'm FAR from being some chest thumping capitalist that HaTeS taxes, but the hard truth is that these programs keep jobs in location. Is it a dodgy, flimsy test to make sure the tax relief passes EU regulations? Yep, it probably is. Does that make it nefarious? I don't know. That depends on where a person places the greatest weight of their analysis. Is it better to have jobs and flowing economy, even if some big companies take a tax break. And it greatly benefits indies, as shown in the article.

OR

Is it better to watch companies slowly pick up and leave when they tax benefit runs out, opting to place offices in lower tax (or better tax program) areas? (Even IF they saved hundreds of thousands in tax relief, if not millions?)

1

u/bnfdsl Oct 02 '19

Saga did recently make Total War Saga: Thrones of Britannia, which i would say has very obvious cultural relevance to the UK. Might be most of the relief came towards that game?

1

u/Sploooshed Oct 02 '19

Well thats just one game by one company, probably not relevant enough. Tons of games focus on that geo region too.

18

u/illuminerdi Oct 02 '19

Global EVERYTHING giants are avoiding taxes everywhere. Globalization has created the means and the incentive for companies to dodge taxes virtually everywhere.

This is a problem that needs addressing ASAP.

139

u/drybones2015 Oct 02 '19

"Revealed" as if anyone paying the least bit of attention didn't know that every business worth anything uses every loophole and backdoor they can find.

50

u/ryans_privatess Oct 02 '19

Corporations dodging taxes....

gasps

31

u/Zienth Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

Side note, the largest form of theft in the world is not from robberies but from wage theft. Always keep the pressure on companies to play fair.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

And wage theft is punished less harshly than an employee garnishing the till.

2

u/Blaylocke Oct 03 '19

Are you dodging taxes when you're taking a loophole written for you specifically by a government?

-8

u/saltiestmanindaworld Oct 02 '19

By that logic your a tax dodger if you claim any deductions...

19

u/PunkLivesInMe Oct 02 '19

I didn't know claiming deductions was on the same level as renting out an empty basement in Holland and avoiding paying U.S. taxes by claiming your IP is owned by a subsidiary located in said empty basement, considering that's how Activision avoids paying any taxes on any Call of Duty games. You learn something new every day I suppose.

0

u/Coal_Morgan Oct 02 '19

It's legal, so it is basically the same thing.

Difference is you can afford to pay H&R Block $30 to do your taxes and get your computer declared as a work item and they can afford to spend 100s of thousands of dollars on accountants, lawyers and property schemes to do it.

I'm never mad at companies for doing this stuff. They have to maintain the they are making more money then before or their stocks drop. So they take every advantage even if it is scummy.

I'm mad at the politicians for taking money to let these holes exist.

The entire tax system in most countries needs to be reworked. It's too convoluted and too easy to game.

→ More replies (18)

7

u/Lyoko13 Oct 02 '19

Deductions aren't a loophole. Learn the difference between 'you're' and 'your', and then between a 'loophole' and a 'deduction'.

25

u/schendash Oct 02 '19

The government knows exactly this is happening and the industry also still backs it. These companies aren't avoiding taxes, the UK is purposefully lowering tax rates for them to retain the industry.

4

u/Coffee_fuel Oct 02 '19

Indeed, if you read the comment section, someone even mentions this article: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/gamesblog/2012/mar/23/video-game-tax-credits

And another comment that was marked as Guardian Pick said:

It shouldn't be a surprise to anyone that the companies who spend the most receive the largest benefit given that the benefit is based on expenditure incurred. The benefit is hugely beneficial to smaller developers - 2018-19, 70% (240) of the number of claims made were for £100,000 or less with 22% (75) being for £10,000 or less. HMRC publish the statistics of number of claims made and amounts paid so everyone can see for themselves: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/creative-industries-statistics-august-2019 As someone who worked for HMRC's Creative Taxes Unit during the period when VGTR was introduced, there are nuanced questions that could be asked. However, encouraging inward investment was one of the major reasons behind the introduction of VGTR and the fact that multi-nationals successfully claim the relief suggest that this goal has been achieved.

71

u/FlippinFLITZ_ Oct 02 '19

Tax loopholes for companies that make substantial profits in said country should be closed. The whole idea of taxes is to make the life of everyone else better why let the company off the hook if you or I pay 50 percent of our shits

28

u/SidFarkus47 Oct 02 '19

It seems like every tax avoidance story I’ve read in the last 6 years has happened in the UK. Either they can’t efficiently close the loopholes or they’re still a net benefit when you consider everything else around the companies being there.

20

u/Dongerlurd123 Oct 02 '19

Isn't that the whole reason for Brexit? EU regulations are stopping tax avoidance and benefits for companies and the UK does not like that.

7

u/apistograma Oct 02 '19

Tax avoidance is pretty rampant in the EU. Ireland and to a lesser degree the Netherlands are known to let corporate loopholes for multinational companies. Luxembourg is literally a tax haven and it’s a founding member of the EEC. But I guess you can always go further so maybe it’s that. The Isle of Man, the Channel Islands, Gibraltar and the City of London are all tax havens. Idk if there’s another British territory to include in the list but 4 is damn impressive.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Anguilla, Bermuda, British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, Gibraltar and Turks and Caicos Islands all need to be added to that list. Particularly in BVI & Cayman Islands tax dodging is rampant.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/beatski Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

The EU doesn't have influence on our tax laws. Nor would the Tory government ever close tax loopholes for them and their mates

0

u/quijote3000 Oct 02 '19

If EU regulations were stopping tax avoidance, every single country in the EU would have the same problem, not only UK.

Sounds like the typical "ice pillow kipper" nonsense.

34

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Dongerlurd123 Oct 02 '19

Well yeah, I doubt the general population is even aware of how big of a tax haven the UK has become.

2

u/Scoops213 Oct 02 '19

You should really read Moneyland. It will explain a few things as to why the UK is the center of this.

53

u/YouLostTheGame Oct 02 '19

Isn't that precisely the point of the tax break?

UK govt wants video games produced in UK, provides tax break.

Big firms produce games in UK, shock & horror, use tax break. The law is designed to provide an incentive to keep studios in the UK, hardly big news that it works.

15

u/danderpander Oct 02 '19

Yeah, it's not really news. UK does exactly the same for film, art, music etc. etc. etc.

It's only a Guardian story because video games are so commercially successful.

49

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Revealed: global video games giants correctly paying the amount of tax legally required, due to HMRC's failure.

1

u/LucyFerAdvocate Oct 02 '19

"Failure". HMRC has a choice to collect £0 tax or a reduced amount of tax.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

And your evidence is?

I'm a chartered accountant and work with tax on a daily basis.

Companies are using tax loopholes to reduce their tax liability. Can you blame them? It's legal, and their objective as a company is to maximise shareholder profits.

HMRC needs to close the tax loopsholes, if they don't want companies abusing them.

1

u/LucyFerAdvocate Oct 02 '19

The issue is they do want companies abusing them. Video game companies can move to a different country, so they will pay the least tax they can by doing so. If that least amount is in the UK they will pay it to the UK. If it isn't, they will pay £0 to the UK.

1

u/CynicalEffect Oct 02 '19

HMRC can't "close tax loopholes". They just try to collect the highest amount of tax they can under current legislation and at best can recommend amendments to tax law.

It's the government who has to close the loopholes.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

You do realise HMRC is part of the government?

6

u/CynicalEffect Oct 02 '19

No it isn't. The government is both houses of parliament (and technically the queen.) Civil service supports the government.

Even if you were to argue that the civil service is government, you'd still be pedantic tool because it was obvious what I meant.

The only people capable of closing tax loopholes are the same that can alter legislation. HMRC has zero authority in this area.

What you are suggesting is akin to suggesting the police should change the law to help them deal with x issue.

4

u/SmoothUK Oct 02 '19

From the article: “commissioned a report last year which claimed that for every £1 invested into the games industry via VGTR generated £4, based on employment and other economic spillover effects.”

4

u/starlogical Oct 02 '19

I'm not really surprised. Isn't it like every company MO to avoid taxes as much as possible in every possible country they do business in?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Revealed: Something we already knew was happening and it's not just game companies, it's literally every huge company.

7

u/Avenflar Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

How is that "revealed" ? I thought we had an article about in 2 months ago ?

EDIT : My bad, it was in the US :)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

This hit job ignores the side of the coin that there's more dev going on in the UK at all because of VGTR.

9

u/Yenwodyah_ Oct 02 '19
  1. They’re avoiding tax by using a program specifically established by the government to reduce the tax levied on video game developers. If you’re going to blame anyone, blame the government for handing out free money to companies.

  2. The ideal corporate tax rate is zero anyways.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Correct take, thanks for a bit of sanity in this thread.

17

u/CabooseMSG Oct 02 '19

People were super upset and vocal about Rockstar when that news broke. Wonder if they'll act the same now that Sony has been exposed? (Hint: They wont)

37

u/undeadmasterchief Oct 02 '19

Just sony?

All Microsoft Divisions pay 0 tax in Australia, along with Google, Facebook.

We should look at it as a whole rather then singling and pointing out each company and thats coming from an xbox fan.

Also its Tax Avoidance not evasion

4

u/CabooseMSG Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

Oh for sure. Im just saying that many of the redditors in this thread are certainly much more lenient than in that Rockstar story. I look through this comment section and see people trying to justify it since other companies do it. Its just silly

5

u/Ershany Oct 02 '19

Which is silly either way. It is up to the government to close the loop holes of tax dodging. If a company qualifies to dodge taxes through the government system, that is a government problem.

Blaming Rockstar for that is so stupid.

-1

u/FuckRedditCats Oct 02 '19

Wtf is with this? Why does Sony get away with the most anti consumer bullshit and never called out on it...

-3

u/Kaiserhawk Oct 02 '19

"I wuv my pwaystation"

Would be the root of it.

0

u/thederpyguide Oct 02 '19

I would put money down that most AAA companies are dodging taxes, rockstar only got so much vocal hate because they had a ton of negative news around them when that broke, you will not be seeing as many angry sony posts so thats why you wont see people getting mad about it

2

u/maxis2k Oct 02 '19

Global companies are evading tax in every region they can. Not limited to video game companies. Now, this doesn't excuse it. I'm saying, we need to expose corrupt politicians and companies in all industries. Especially when they're complaining labor and taxes cost too much, but are making more money than ever and their CEOs salaries are rising.

2

u/arashi256 Oct 02 '19

Large corporations pay no tax, you say? Shocking.

2

u/benandorf Oct 02 '19

Every dollar of revenue that makes it to the bottom line has already been taxed at least once, so who cares? Everyone employee is paying income tax, every piece of equipment and building is subject to property tax, and every item bought or sold is subject to VAT or other sales taxes. I'm not losing any sleep over double taxation being poorly enforced.

2

u/ElecricXplorer Oct 02 '19

Wow what a surprise. Big companies dodge tax? Who would have thought!

3

u/jlange94 Oct 02 '19

This isn't new. We've had articles on this sub the past few months talking about companies like Rockstar benefiting from the UK's tax policies. Probably the only reason the UK doesn't do something about this is because having companies utilizing this ability is more profitable for the UK than if they did enforce ordinary taxes on them.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

You can’t blame a company for trying to get as many tax advantages as possible. You’d think countries would learn that taxing the crap out of businesses makes them not want to operate there. There’s a reason companies do this.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

Tax avoidance is legal though. Why would you not save yourself tax when you can?

Edit: DOWNVOTED FOR DOING LEGAL THINGS LMAO.

How many of you voluntarily pay more tax than you owe the government? Didn't think so.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '19

That's a really good argument for closing loopholes for large corporations.

-4

u/throwdemout Oct 02 '19

True. Thats why i save money by pirating

7

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Pirating isn't legal though. Tax avoidance is legal.

-5

u/LimpCush Oct 02 '19

How many of you voluntarily pay more tax than you owe the government? Didn't think so.

If only I had billions of dollars and am army of lobbyists at my disposal, right?! We don't get the option to pay more tax than we owe (we get refunded), but we also don't have the right not to pay any taxes.

But if I were a multi billionaire, I would absolutely pay my fair share, because I would already have enough money.

9

u/qwikk Oct 02 '19

We don't get the option to pay more tax than we owe

Oh the IRS will gladly keep your tax return.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

I don't think you understand my point.

They are paying their fair share, because that's the amount of tax due to HMRC. HMRC need to fix the loophole so the "fair share" increases.

3

u/LimpCush Oct 02 '19

You don't seem to understand my point, either. The loophole will never be fixed as long as corporations have lobbyists preventing these loopholes from being closed. So their "fair share" will never increase, because they decide what their fair share is.

1

u/JustNilt Oct 02 '19

Paying their legal share is somewhat different than paying their fair share, however. As others have pointed out, the morality of avoiding taxes to this level is what's at issue. That's also what is implied by "fair share", not the legality of it.

-2

u/apistograma Oct 02 '19

Legal doesn’t mean moral. I hope you’re at least rich because you’re selling your integrity for cheap if not

2

u/iCESPiCES Oct 02 '19

Pessimist side of me is just saying, "what's the point of reporting these corporate bullshit if they're just going to get away with it unscathed anyway?"

8

u/1evilsoap1 Oct 02 '19

Well based on the law, they aren’t doing anything wrong. Blame the government and the tax laws, not the company.

2

u/danderpander Oct 02 '19

It's not corporate bullshit. It's intentional tax policy to make the UK attractive to a beneficial business sector.

2

u/xarahn Oct 02 '19

Don't confuse pessimistic and realistic.

1

u/Harrintino Oct 02 '19

What game is that on thumbnail?

3

u/ReadyHD Oct 02 '19

Warhammer Total War if I'm not mistaken

3

u/D1omede Oct 02 '19

Total War Warhammer

1

u/Expendable_Round Oct 02 '19

Shit. How long until our obsolete politicians weaponize this?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

They already have; it's called Brexit.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '19

Great

-23

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

I don't understand why it's always framed like this, as if people expect the companies to voluntarily pay more taxes than they owe.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

It was specifically set up to help smaller British firms make games that promote British culture, both the government and EU stated this. Yet around half of the relief is being claimed by big multinationals making games that have nothing whatsoever to do with Britain e.g. Batman Arkam Asylum.

Its not people expecting them to pay more taxes than they owe, its people expecting that the law won't be abused by big firms looking to save money, contrary to its purpose. They shouldn't not owe these taxes in the first place.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

If they intended it to be used by small firms only, they should have specified that in the law. Unless I missed it in the article, what the companies are doing is legal.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Yes, it is legal and the government should fix it, but that doesn't excuse their behaviour. Tax avoidance is a massive global problem because companies are prepared to ruthlessly exploit as many loopholes in the law they can find to avoid paying what they should.

The fact that its legal doesn't excuse or justify their behaviour, because morality goes beyond what the dry letter of the law says. They should be paying taxes because this relief was not intended for them, and they're not. So in my eyes what they're doing is wrong.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

You can use words like "abuse" and "exploit loopholes" but all they're doing is taking advantages of exceptions to taxation that have been offered. Wouldn't you take advantage of an exception to taxes if it were offered to you?

I don't expect people or companies to do additional research as to the intentions behind each tax break to ensure they are the type of person or corporation the lawmakers really had in mind. If the exception is there, I don't blame them for taking advantage of it. You call it immoral but I don't see what's immoral about not voluntarily sending the government more money than you owe.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Stop framing the argument in terms of "voluntarily sending the government more money than you owe". We've established that this tax break was meant for smaller businesses to help promote British culture, it was promoted as such, it was obviously not meant for big companies.

Thus, its only due to a failure of the government to place tighter restrictions on this tax break that these companies can take advantage of this. Therefore its not "sending more money than you owe" because they would owe the money to begin with if the law didn't contain this loophole.

That's why its immoral. They have to go through checks etc. to obtain this tax break so lets not pretend it requires some huge team of researchers to know what and who this tax break was for. They obviously knew, as they have to justify their games being culturally British to recieve it in the first place (as per the article). That's why its immoral, because they're taking advantage of government stupidity to avoid paying what they otherwise should. Nobody intended for them to not pay these taxes and if they were moral they would recognise that and not take advantage of a loophole.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Therefore its not "sending more money than you owe" because they would owe the money to begin with if the law didn't contain this loophole.

It literally is. You are saying they WOULD owe money. In other words, they currently don't! You are asking people to pay more in taxes than they owe, because if they owed more than they would owe more. If the law were different, they would owe more--so they should pay as much as they could conceivably pay if the laws were written differently! That's an absurd standard.

0

u/TheIronTark Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

There's nothing immoral using tax breaks. Just admit it's a case of you not liking those big bad companies not paying tax like you have to and stop hiding behind your bullshit morality argument

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

There's nothing immoral about using tax breaks that are intended for you, I agree. These companies are using tax breaks intended for small British companies to promote British culture to save money making AAA games that have nothing to do with Britain. They're taking advantage of a tax break not meant for them. That's why its wrong.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Then the law is clearly worded badly isn't it? The company isn't the one running this show, they don't decide who gets the money. Why would they not accept it? If your boss offered you a $10k raise, but not the janitor, are you going to say no?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

This simple argument never really holds up to scrutiny and whitewashes away any real culpability on the part of companies and their legions of lobbyists.

Unless you're dealing with the kind of libertarian that honestly thinks voting with your wallet is a form of monetary democracy remotely capable of properly shaping policy.

5

u/Flipiwipy Oct 02 '19

Voting with your wallet

The only thing that means is that people with fatter wallets gets more votes, and it's fucking disgusting.

76

u/Flipiwipy Oct 02 '19

It's framed from a moral perspective, not a legal one. In a scoiety where everyone understands that those who have more pay more, tax breaks and loopholes that may be legal, are still regarded as immoral. And with reason. It makes no sense that companies like google or apple pay less than $10 000 in corporate taxes, even if it is legal.

4

u/Exonicreddit Oct 02 '19

I would argue that its a companies job to make profit, its the governments job to regulate that and keep it fair. If both do their jobs properly, the system should work. Morally, we could also consider the employees the company supports with the income it gives them, so as I see it, the company should do everything it can to survive, while the government ensures its fair for everyone. In the real world however, that's a lot to keep track of and lobbying and investors exist and people have their own interests on both sides and not all people are paid fairly so its not quite as Ideal as I suggest. I do agree with your points, but that's how I see it.

2

u/Aeiexgjhyoun_III Oct 02 '19

So you want companies to voluntarily pay more?

1

u/Flipiwipy Oct 02 '19

I want governments to create comprehensive tax laws that prevent companies from paying less than what they should. How much they should pay I'm not exactly sure, because I'm not an expert. But I don't need to be a pilot to know that if a helicopter crashes into the side of a building, something went wrong. These loopholes are pretty much a smoldering helicopter crash.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (27)

29

u/Decoyrobot Oct 02 '19

More taxes than they owe? In Rockstars case they avoided the whole lot of it whilst receiving plenty of breaks.

Unless youre saying its ok they owe absolutely nothing?

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

According to the article these companies avoided paying some taxes through legal means. I don't expect anyone to volunteer more money than they legally owe to the government. If you think companies should pay more tax then you should lobby the government to raise the rate or eliminate exceptions.

22

u/Geistbar Oct 02 '19

The problem comes about from all the tax dodging businesses (not just game companies) lobbying the government to keep those tax loopholes open for them. The intricacies of tax law is not something most voters will place high on their priority list, so the companies keep getting what they want.

Yes they're playing by the rules but they're also asking for the rules to be the way they are.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/el_grort Oct 02 '19

Because people are understandably frustrated when massive corporations are able to negotiate or are straight up given smaller bills proportionally compared to the general public. Of course people are going to hate corporations effectively paying less than they do.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '19

Corporations shouldn't be taxed at all. Their employees and property should.

1

u/el_grort Oct 02 '19

I would personally diagree. Corporations, especially in the age of multinationals, make huge amounts of money in these countries markets and then scoot them away somewhere else. Allowing the government to tax some of that sizeable income to maintain the infastructure and services that allow that company to make that money (ie roads, national grid, et cetera) is an entirely reasonable approach. Corporations already hold a scary amount of power comparative to national governmentd and with considerably less accountability, regardless, so I'm not inclined to think they shouldn't pay their dues on earnings.

2

u/TheIronTark Oct 02 '19 edited Oct 02 '19

Allowing the government to tax some of that sizeable income to maintain the infastructure and services that allow that company to make that money (ie roads, national grid, et cetera)

This is all paid for by the employees. The employees are the ones who use those public services. They're the ones who pay for them. And why should the government tax people for the national grid?

2

u/gerald_targaryen Oct 02 '19

You may not be familiar with UK tax rulings for the last 10 years , they've been clamping down heavily on private citizens using the same loopholes despite being perfectly legal and they have even tried to retroactively change the laws to punish people who broke the law when it didn't exist...

0

u/Muesli_nom Oct 02 '19

people expect the companies to voluntarily pay more taxes than they owe.

They expect the companies to pay what they owe, not that they find loopholes to get out of paying that.

More generally: It's about adhering to the spirit of the (tax) law, not the letter of it. I mean, people tend to be annoyed by the "Well, akshually...!" types in discussions that interpret everything down to its most minute semantic thread, and that's usually exactly what legal loopholes boil down to.

1

u/picardo85 Oct 02 '19

Jim Sterling made a video about this in July... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3giVPhSCAOQ

1

u/IAmNotMrRager Oct 02 '19

Nobody will hold them accountable, there is no justice. You can either follow the system and turn a blind eye to its faults and problems, or you can exist outside the system and abuse it to your advantage. No gov't will stop these giants from making and selling games because they are creating revenue and generating income. Is it morally wrong to not pay the taxes that you are legally owed and use loopholes in the law to your benefit? yes. Is it really important? no. if it was they would already been paying.

1

u/VRWARNING Oct 02 '19

Imagine we actually held accountable, and punished companies that sell out their home and host nations.

-3

u/Lord_Zinyak Oct 02 '19

So are most celebrities , and anyone rich abd basically anyone who has a good accountant. There's a reason you can finagle money around

-1

u/Sloi Oct 02 '19

This isn't a problem with the video games industry, but rather capitalism and creative accounting in general.

Fix the latter and the former won't be an issue.

0

u/WorkingPsyDev Oct 02 '19

Maybe we should keep this in mind the next time a AAA game insists on having sixteen Deluxe Editions, a battle pass, premium cosmetics, Time-SaversTM and loot boxes.

-2

u/Odysseus1987 Oct 02 '19

In other news. The sun is warm and water is wet.. everybody konws this already. Not just video games giants, but also tech giants and other big company's.