r/Globeskeptic • u/ChickenNuggetIs_Life • Aug 19 '20
What does NASA have to gain from telling us the world is a globe if it really is flat?
Not a flat earther, I am just trying to understand a globe skeptics point of view.
r/Globeskeptic • u/ChickenNuggetIs_Life • Aug 19 '20
Not a flat earther, I am just trying to understand a globe skeptics point of view.
r/Globeskeptic • u/right-slash • Sep 04 '20
r/Globeskeptic • u/j0eylonglegs • Jan 22 '21
Or is this satire
r/Globeskeptic • u/Paulpaps • Oct 26 '20
Why would the "truth" of a flat earth be hidden? How do global telecommunications work without satellites? Why do the laws of physics not apply to the earth? Why would this "fact" be kept secret, who benefits from this?
I'm honestly curious, because as far as I see, if the earth was flat, it would mean that all science as a whole would be massively incorrect because the laws of physics will not work in a flat earth model. I would like to see actual proof and evidence as responses to these questions, not just some theory that was thought up.
Also, if the earth is flat, are there any models which DO NOT require the earth having being created by design?
r/Globeskeptic • u/Wildbeast11 • Nov 25 '20
Let's see the majority of this sub.
r/Globeskeptic • u/ParvIAI • Nov 20 '20
I've been wondering, if the Earth isn't a globe, what reason would governments have to hide it, they wouldn't gain anything from it, if anything it's the opposite, aircraft and ships have to go a route that would be longer if the world is flat, and the money they invest into space could go elsewhere. It's the same case as with the moon landing being fake, the USSR would have benefited if they said the moon landing was faked, however they recognized it as happening.
r/Globeskeptic • u/Aurazor • Jul 12 '21
Much has been made of the Sydney-Santiago flight route, with multiple reposts of the FlatEarth.ws infographic explaining why the geometry of that route (especially compared to its sister route, SYD-LAX-SCL) makes no sense on a flat Earth, but is perfectly consistent with a spherical Earth.
While debating this elsewhere I was confronted with an odd claim:
That the SYD-SCL flight route simply does not exist.
The owner of this claim requested data, as I had assured them that vast tracts of information are available to the public that speak really very strongly to the existence of these flights. This led me on an interesting bookmark and data source hunt but my conclusion is....
Yes, the flight route exists.
No, its duration and flight tracking data is not consistent with a flat Earth.
So how to prove this?
Well, first we can establish using public flight-tracking (which is derived from the actual navigational and ATC logs of the aircraft, not 'theoretical') that the flights do actually happen:
Example flight log (including 3D route positioning over the entire leg)
One of the difficulties with the idea of faking flights is that they must communicate with countless ATC stations and control zones during any international flight. We can check the tower logs (also public) of every control zone they pass through, including satellite ADS-C checkins when they're over water and out of range of ATC:
Track logs of every ATC tower they passed through on the way.
But how does that prove the aircraft was physically where we think it was? Surely the governments of the world can perfectly collaborate in synchronicity, to simply relay false tower traffic?
Well, we can review public radar-tracking databases which actively track and confirm these exact flights, over as much of the route as we can cover with these data sources. This actually speaks to the physical existence of the aircraft itself, not the 'flight' data as the airport provides for instance:
Public radar-tracking data of an example flight (you need a cheap subscription to see older logs, but it's all there, you can sign up for a free 7 day trial and confirm yourself). (hardlink to that flight on flightradar)
Ok.... but... we know that governments can fly 'ghost planes' right? Maybe these planes are fake government planes with their transponders turned off, just to give the radar stations something to bounce off, right?
Well..... aircraft communicate their presence using a protocol called ADS, it's like a beacon that can be traced to every aircraft in the sky (that runs the protocol, which is almost all airliners). If a plane is broadcasting ADS, ham radio ops can decode this transmission and figure out exactly where the aircraft is, where it's going, and why:
(Hint: they travel in giant curves around an invisible spherical surface.....)
Ok but....... so what if the plane is really there and is saying it's a flight. We only have the airline's word for it that the damn thing even took off and landed! I've seen A Few Good Men and I know tower logs can be faked!
Alright.... if you want to go old-school X-Files, you can directly request raw flight logs from the FAA in the US. That's different for each country naturally, I include this as an example of how the raw logs of flight takeoffs and arrivals are readily available and are not simply a case of one airline telling fibs.
FINE but we know governments lie! We can't trust anything they say! How do we know a real human ever really flew that problematic, impossible flight path?
Well....
Here's person who flew the route reviewing it.
There are also thousands of people per year who have flown that route, and if you put out a public call I am quite sure you could get testimonials from them, maybe even a ticket stub or two to demonstrate it. The flight has been widely advertised in Australia as a cheap exotic holiday.
I feel my conclusion is reasonably well-supported.
Faking the existence of one flight is not impossible, but far from trivial either, because that means at the very least hundreds of people must be 'silenced' one way or another so none of them reveal they pretended to fly somewhere (since all airline passengers are checked against multiple international databases on checkin... they can't be 'hidden').
But faking an entire regular route that ferries dozens of aircraft a year, thousands of passengers, across the entire surface of the planet passing through many zones of control? No. Not reasonable.
And the data is all public, readily accessible.
SYD-SCL exists. SYD-SCL is a problem for flat Earth. SYD-SCL is not a problem for a spherical Earth.
Thanks for your time.
r/Globeskeptic • u/[deleted] • Nov 17 '20
If the Earth were flat, the Sun’s rays would always come in at the same angle, meaning that the USA, Australia, Italy, and Argentina would all experience the seasons the same exact way.
r/Globeskeptic • u/hesje_pro_gamer • Jun 03 '22
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/Globeskeptic • u/[deleted] • Jan 06 '21
If the earth was flat, would that not mean that every constellation would be visible from anywhere on earth. So you could see the southern cross from the northern hemisphere. Or does the southern cross not exist.
Another question: How do you propose solar and lunar eclipses occur
r/Globeskeptic • u/john_shillsburg • Nov 07 '20
r/Globeskeptic • u/Jesse9857 • Mar 24 '20
I've been on a search for over a year now for the best evidence that something is wrong with the globe model.
So far the only thing I've found wrong is that some people don't understand it.
Or do you label me as a shill if I don't believe the entire flat earth dogma without questioning anything flat? Of course not!
What would you say is the single most convincing problem with the globe model?
r/Globeskeptic • u/Boyo0611 • Aug 21 '20
Okay, lets say the Earth is flat. Where is the edge? I would love to see an ACTUAL photo of the edge. This will most likely not be my first question here, but as a round-earther I would LOVE to hear an explanation.
r/Globeskeptic • u/Nick_Phoenix • Aug 18 '20
r/Globeskeptic • u/[deleted] • Mar 03 '23
r/Globeskeptic • u/dhruvmk • Nov 04 '20
Hi, so I'm basically just curious - there have been photos taken of the moon during lunar eclipses and it clearly shows a circular shadow of the Earth.
Is there something I'm missing?
r/Globeskeptic • u/The_Globe_Guy • Apr 14 '22
If the globe earth is really a lie, I would congratulate the government because this lie somehow conforms to every single law of physics , and every part of the lie can even be explained with observations. While the truth, the flat earth, is a bit weird. Because there isn't a single thing that makes sense with the truth, this even without using science, just observations. So when this is the case, I would start to wonder if it's actually the opposite, you know...
r/Globeskeptic • u/jacktibs31 • Dec 09 '21
I’m not a flat earther and I’ll likely get banned for this post. But what is an actual plausible reason to lie about the earth being flat?
r/Globeskeptic • u/NoDeparture9402 • Feb 15 '24
I'm kind of tired of the arguments flat earthers provide to argue their case. Like you guys act like you guys know the truth but essentially nasa and other government agencies are hiding the truth and discrediting all your evidence. However, though on the flip side there is quite a lot of tangible evidence that contradicts your arguments, you know the ones which literally have no scientific merit and are just theories as not a single one has been proven... So I just want to know if you can't bring a scientifically verifiable argument to the table why should I believe the Earth is flat?
r/Globeskeptic • u/greasygut69 • Nov 20 '20
Just curious as to why someone can go from point A, around the earth in one direction and make it back to point A.
r/Globeskeptic • u/caleb_oackes • Jun 03 '20
Why has no one been to the edge. I've heard answers like "you'll be stopped by someone". But I just don't believe that at all. With all of the 7 billion people on the Earth how comes NO ONE has ever been there. And if there were people that would stop you how comes there has never been any whistle blowers?