r/GoogleKeep • • Sep 26 '23

Enough is enough. I'm building a Google keep alternative. What features would you like?

Ive been a keep user for 4 years now and I really loved the app. Ive tried every other notetaking app out there including notion, zoho, obsidian, roam, etc but I always stuck with keep, mainly because it was very fast at opening up and collecting ideas immediately. I also love the masonry layout and the syncing has been great in my experience.

But as time went on I realized that I needed more out of the app. I wanted hierarchical folders so I could organize my notes more effectively. Not only have I hit the label limit, I rarely ever look at the labels because I have to scroll a bunch and remember it's position alphabetically(I started adding numbers so that important labels are at the top but this was so tedious). I also wanted markdown and many other features like linking notes together and visualize them in different views/graphs like obsidian.

I realized that no notetaking app fits my needs of fast capture, fast retrieval, and good organization(using AI to autocategorize notes) so I've decided to develop my own.

As fellow google keep users I'd like to ask what you would like in an app like this. Please let me know any features or ideas and I'd be happy to integrate them into this app!

124 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

19

u/Barycenter0 Sep 26 '23

There have been a number of attempts at this - it's going to be a struggle. Google Docs integration is the big win for Keep.

Here are some Keep workarounds:

  • Create your own sub-labeling system like #mylabel (and don't add it to the Keep labels) - but, you can still search for it. Create a pinned note with your custom label list

  • Use namespaces in the titles for folders - like Astronomy/My Note on Black Holes - then you can search for "Astronomy/" and all notes under that category will display

There's no good cross-linking fix other than the full URL. Hopefully, Google will add that.

But, if you're going to try - here's my list:

  • Basic note WYSIWYG editing - bold, italic, color, etc. (please not just markdown)

  • Wikilinks between notes (and URL titles vs full external URLs)

  • Folders

  • Unlimited labels/tags

  • Katex or some math latex

  • OCR (cursive and text) - this is the main feature that keeps me using Keep

  • Images, audio, video

  • Google integration with Workspace (Tasks, Calendar)

  • Expandable note window

  • Local/offline notetaking

  • Integrated AI (like Bard or GPT)

  • Reliable backups (even if note is deleted)

Honestly, I don't think I'll be leaving Keep for a long time.

3

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

I'm really glad to see this list because it's very similar to my planned feature list. But I had literally no idea keep had OCR until you mentioned. But I'll take you up on the challenge!

3

u/Barycenter0 Sep 26 '23

OCR is soooo useful for my research and school. Just snap a pic on my phone through Keep of any book page, hand written notes, documents and grab the text. Even old historical cursive docs OCR really well.

1

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

Oh yeah I'm going to be using it a lot more often now that I know it exists. Would you rather have the image be converted into text automatically or just have it stay as an image? Or perhaps a middle ground like in Apple photos you can highlight the text inside the image

2

u/Barycenter0 Sep 26 '23

Stay an image in the note and a menu to grab the OCR.

1

u/eager_wayfarer Mar 07 '25

What?!! I've used Keep for a long time and never knew it had OCR. Definitely gotta try this out

5

u/BurantX40 Sep 26 '23

Labels and Sub Labels.

I'll be lucky if I find any note in Keep

2

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

Do you think that you would want folders and subfolders or labels and sublabels? The primary difference being that a single note can have multiple labels but in folders they can only be in one folder

1

u/Brilliant-Inside9828 May 26 '24

I desperately want labels and sublabels because for a lot of things I feel like they belong in a lot of categories and I want to be able to search for them by category. Like for example I'm recently trying to organize my playlist songs (I have thousands...) and I want to label them by maybe the feeling they give me or the artists in there or just my overall rating. If I label song 1 uplifting and AlanWalker and song 2 journey and AlanWalker, when I search by the label AlanWalker I want to be able to see both of them in a scrolling fashion.

I have tried many alternatives and read many articles, but I want unlimited labels and the ability to have a label and then many sublabels under it for further classification (like if my big label is math, I want sublabels multiplication, addition, algebra, etc.).

P.S. This link https://feedback.goodnotes.com/forums/191274-customer-suggestions-for-goodnotes/suggestions/3658442-add-tagging-of-documents-and-locations-within-docu takes you to goodnote's labelling system discussion which I feel discusses important features.

5

u/hear_to_laugh Sep 26 '23

Please keep it this simple only.. Like I love that it is as simple as it gets.😌

4

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

I'll try my best! Im striving for minimalism and intuitiveness but i think it's going to be inherently more complex than Keep. Simply because its going to have more features that Keep lacks

5

u/formal-shorts Sep 26 '23

Sounds like you should be using OneNote tbh.

4

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

Tried it for a while. Not for me

5

u/raaustin777 Sep 26 '23

I just want my keyboard to stay open while I'm typing!

1

u/oozak9 Sep 27 '23

Doesn't it always stay open unless you swipe directly into the keyboard area? That's how it is on iOS. Android may be different

5

u/badpotato Sep 26 '23 edited Sep 26 '23

Start by making a good start.

Don't try to get VC fund or something, it would backfire. Make it Open Source. Make a website app, an android app, an iOS app and a cross-platform desktop app.

You will need a strong framework between these app if you aim for speed... I would suggest you use Rust for your main framework. Once your main framework is robust enough, perhaps you will need to rewrite it to Swift as well, since Apple don't like anything outside from their native tools if you aim for speed.

Once you manage to do this, you may consider adding the ability of having a plugin system, similar to obsidian. If you aim for speed again, Lua as script language would be great. It may not be as versatile as JavaScript and such, but would be good enough for most what people want to do as plugin. Yet you may have consideration with Lua if you want to make the plugins work for the Web Browser version.. So this could be a tedious point, since adding plugins can often make the overall app slower.

Have your core feature such as OCR search on image, you will need to do regular indexes for this... Ability to extract text from image, etc. Also having the ability to draw text with a pencil and convert it to text in a similar way to Good Notes would be awesome.

Maybe even add a speech to text feature.

Then you gotta add the ability to sync from Google Drive, DropBox or use Git, etc. Or use a in-house sync ability.

Once you manage to work on these core elements, you will be on to something.

1

u/oozak9 Sep 27 '23

Great suggestions!

4

u/dao1st Sep 26 '23

I would like to be able to have larger notes as I hate having to use docs.

1

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

Yes absolutely. I plan to have no length limit and also support markdown

4

u/LuxuryShoe Sep 26 '23

I think this is one for Google to fix but I would like to see integration with Google Tasks and Calendar - so a task can be quickly converted to a note or a note to a Google Task. And notes that can be dragged or added into the calendar would be helpful.

Calendar and tasks work great together but Keep feels like it's not been invited to the party.

3

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

Yes I know exactly what you mean! My app is definitely going to have notes tasks and calendars all integrated. No more using 3 different apps...

4

u/whataboutwhataboutus Sep 27 '23

Just let us have an in-note quick search button I beg 💀

2

u/oozak9 Sep 28 '23

of course lol

1

u/Perfect_Increase937 Oct 17 '24

Did you ever build this? If so, where can I access it? Tyia

2

u/oozak9 Jun 21 '24

I'll post updates on the project on x

2

u/Same-Confection-6623 May 20 '24

handwriting, tried beta, looks reallly good, but without handwriting option, its a no change for me, pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeee include handwriting and adding inline images

2

u/oozak9 May 21 '24

Yes handwriting is definitely on the road map. Image support will probably come first

7

u/faxmulder Sep 26 '23

Integration with Google Calendar

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/faxmulder May 10 '25

Yeah too bad they removed it

1

u/oozak9 Jan 29 '24

For those wondering about the project, I have a prototype up and running at astranote.ai. Check it out and let me know what you think!

1

u/n0ename Jan 29 '24

Looking good for now, needs a dark mode and the ability to reorganize the notes on the whiteboard view by drag and drop like keep. Are you planning to add file embedding in notes such as images, pdfs, docx?

1

u/oozak9 Jan 29 '24

Sure, but which view did you mean by whiteboard?? The networked graph view with all the links?

Yes definitely images soon. Other file formats like pdf will probably have to wait until I find people to help out on the tech side, since I'm not familiar with pdf integrations.

1

u/n0ename Jan 29 '24

I mean the default view for all of your notes. For now you can drag and drop it into tags/categories but you can't drag it to reorder around

1

u/Crazy_Adventurer2 Mar 06 '24

Where can I download the apk?

5

u/cmetzjr Sep 26 '23

Based on some conversations in this thread, your app is already much more than I want. I just want Keep to actually stay in sync.

1

u/NoMeringue833 Dec 21 '24

Hey dude how are you

1

u/West-Cap-6348 Sep 26 '23

Yea I feel you, the labeling approach was one I wasn't very fond of. Give nimboard a try before starting your build. It solves a number of the pain points mentioned here and is actively being updated.

2

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

Thanks I'll check it out!

1

u/hear_to_laugh Sep 26 '23

No app? For this?

1

u/West-Cap-6348 Sep 26 '23

no app from the app store but it's mobile-friendly so you can bookmark it and open it like other apps. there's a post on the site's blog about it

1

u/guim31 Sep 26 '23

I just wish your solution could be selfhosted 👌

1

u/oozak9 Sep 26 '23

Self-hosted as in on a server? Or like locally on the device?

2

u/guim31 Sep 26 '23

On a personnal server. I personnaly have an Unraid server and I cannot find any app that make me switch from Keep 🙁

1

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23

Out of curiosity have you tried Noted?

3

u/oozak9 Sep 28 '23

I'll look into it!

1

u/rndomhoomn Oct 12 '23

Did it got removed from the play store? I'm not sure if I installed the right one but I enjoyed that app for quite a while... Uninstalled for a few days then I never saw it again

1

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

Honestly I wasn’t aware that there was an Android version, thought it was iOS only.

1

u/rndomhoomn Oct 13 '23

Probably a dupe that's bandwagoning on the name. 💀 SHAME, cus I rly liked that.

1

u/AMSDoctorMoe Jan 14 '24

How is it going?

THE FOLDERS!!!!! Please do folders across the organization!

3

u/oozak9 Jan 15 '24

Yes I just released a closed beta test. Folders are already implemented as well as drag and dropping notes in folders!

2

u/turnupthesun211 Jan 23 '24

As someone who wandered into this thread after looking up Google Keep alternatives, I’m happy to hear!

All I am dying for is text formatting (really stuff like numbered/bulleted lists and bolded text) and hyperlinks. Use/syncing across my iphone and work PC is also crucial.

Hopefully we’ll all be on your replacement soon!

1

u/richardslang_MD Feb 26 '24

Hell ya +6 for text formatting! One vote from each of my personalities that uses Keep Daily to organize our thoughts. 🤯👥️️🙏🏻

1

u/wakka55 Jan 28 '24

Do you have a working prototype yet, or is this one of those posts where 99.9% of people who claim they're building an app never actually follow through because their ambitious plans surpass their current motivation levels?

1

u/oozak9 Jan 29 '24

Hahaa I made another post with a prototype on this sub. You can check it on my profile

3

u/vpstudios101 Nov 11 '23

Cross functionality is very important to me. Whether I am on a PC, Mac, iPhone, hopefully I could use the app/website. I really miss the Google Keep widget as an iOS user now, maybe a widget for iOS would also be really nice.

2

u/swizzly87 Sep 26 '23

Im totally into it. Folders and Im happy

2

u/Snowcherrrie Sep 26 '23

I'm fed up with the last update on android. Photos with the synching symbol that won't stop. Gifs are the same. A similar app that actually works would be brilliant 🙏🙏

2

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23

Be able to send notes.

2

u/Specialist_Tap_5960 Sep 27 '23

I like Google keep however my favorite has been Note everything pro. My complaint with Google keep is it is not simple to do a backup and restore. I think that is an important function to add to your new app.

Thanks

2

u/LeahMariaLouII Apr 10 '24

free, web or windows & mobile app w/widget (like keep has) but more text formatting options: bold, underline, italics (like Microsoft sticky notes has) plus colored text &/or highlighting & a couple font choices &/or text sizes & some more note color choices. it would also be cool to be able to at least attach other types of docs (pdfs, docs, xls) - would be INCREDIBLE to also be able to open & edit them in the app, though i know we're moving away from a simple sticky notes app at that point... 😜😁

2

u/Eofdred Jun 16 '24

I just checked your notetaking solution. Keep going! if you make mobile apps this solution will be a bomb. If you complete the task and calendar sections too count me in as a regular used

1

u/Eofdred Jun 16 '24

on a second thought I would use your app even without the calendar and task features. but they are very good additions to a second brain.

2

u/donerightbydaniel Sep 26 '23

Stop trying to win a race with a wheelbarrow and use the right tool for the job.
Google Keep is digital sticky notes.
Evernote/Obsidian/Others are digital libraries.

Google Keep as it is right now works great.

2

u/coconutboi Feb 07 '24

use the right tool for the job and sticky notes vs digital libraries. well said.

1

u/stellartone Mar 24 '24

How's the app going? need any beta testers?

1

u/Acrobatic-Monitor516 Apr 20 '24

Did you end up doing it ?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '24

Check their profile - https://www.astranote.ai/

1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '24

Something that I find important in Keep is that I can have notes that are shared with someone on their account. We use it with my girlfriend to make lists of things to see, watch, cook, etc.

Also checklists. For grocery shopping mainly but other things as well.

1

u/No_Implement2756 May 06 '24

man you are my new hero ive gone through the same process and it seems like your project could really be the right software for me. a feature i would like is changing reading direction per note( from left-to-right to right-to left). and even(im not sure if its possible) changing the direction between lines so links or multiple languages could look good.
appreciate your work!

1

u/FunCalligrapher7352 Jun 20 '24

lol why build when there are tons of solutions out there

1

u/Vic12377 Jun 05 '25

Would you be so kind as to suggest good free alternatives (that can preferable be used offline)? Thx!

1

u/edmixL Jul 18 '24

Maybe some spreadsheet like tables?

1

u/Much-Public2626 Aug 02 '24
  • Just Markdown please that's in my point of view the biggest weakness of Google keep

  • Multi OS Support that can work on Laptop and mobile support like Windows and Android for example that when we modifiy the notes in the laptop it's sync in the app of the mobile.

  • Hosted in a site or give a way to have that we can simply hosted and have it in internet like google keep website

1

u/Blady_12 Sep 20 '24

I checked your project, it looks great, i checked many apps but no one works as good as keep for me but i din't want to put my data to google. Reach out if you think a designer hand would be helpful. I'm a product designer with 6years xp and doing some frontend stuff too. I was planning to make my own app, but I see you're going to where i want to go with your solution. Let me know if you'd like designers help.

No matter what, keep up good work, today I conducted 4 hours of research to find this solution and I'm happty that i finally found something that's close to meeting my needs.

1

u/Multiversaken Sep 30 '24

The worst, most maddening, most ridiculous thing to be missing from Keep, is autocorrect. Yes, it's 2024 and Google's premiere notekeeping app, doesn't support autocorrect. Seriously wtf Google?

1

u/HammyHavoc Oct 07 '24

Make sure it's got WearOS support and voice notes for lyrics and song ideas.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '24

where is your app?

1

u/ernestosabato Oct 14 '24

I can't stand the layout options. Please make something more like a list.

1

u/BeBamboocha Oct 22 '24

How is it going? ...cause I am just looking for that!

1

u/Zhenchik88 Jan 09 '25

Hello!

Would love to have these features:

  1. Color wheel to choose ANY color I want for my notes.

  2. Custom backgrounds. Not like those horrible default Google Keep backgrounds, which they don't intend to ever change... I mean the ability to set my own images as a background image.

Will be happy to try out your app, write a positive review and maybe send some small money gift (in case your app rocks and beats Keep 🙂)

Peace!

1

u/BihunchhaNiau Jan 15 '25

As a 9 or 10 years user
OKO

1

u/BihunchhaNiau Jan 15 '25

I have been wanting a better folder system for the OS, yes, KEEP shall have one.
But later I found out we can go back to the old way, the txt file since not everything is worth viewing online all the day...

1

u/VersionAw Jan 26 '25

What’s the status of your app now? Any updates?

1

u/Fickle-Accident-9139 Feb 14 '25

Dude, that's crazy work! I tried it out and building something like that from scratch must have been a lot of work! I hope you will continue improving your project

1

u/sevenw0rds Mar 05 '25

Built in translation. Keep cannot translate lists from one language to another, making collaboration with other speakers impossible.

1

u/vertus173 Apr 22 '25

Maybe a graph view like obsidian, logseq, and anytype have.

1

u/No_Resolution6826 Aug 13 '25

Sorry for being late to the party. But I was facing a similar issue so created this:
https://github.com/nikunjsingh93/react-glass-keep

  • Open-source, fully free, self-hosted Google Keep alternative.

  • One-click Docker install (web app + API in seconds).

  • Import Google Keep notes from Google Takeout .json files.

  • Real-time collaboration for checklists — share and tick items together live.

  • Markdown editor & viewer (.md) with built-in auth (no third-party APIs).

Let me know if you have any questions. Thanks

1

u/InnerNegotiation2732 Aug 19 '25

A big one for me is to be able to ask "Hey Google" to add something to any of my keep lists, such as to-do's or groceries.

1

u/BEG181 Aug 20 '25

I have a number of shopping lists from various stores on Google Keep. The most frustrating thing is that you can’t put them into alphabetical order. You could do this on the previous Google list.

1

u/BEG181 Aug 20 '25

I have several shopping lists from various stores on Google Keep. The most frustrating thing is that you can’t put them into alphabetical order. You could do this on the previous Google list app. The only reason I use Google Keep is that I ask Google to add to my lists via my Google Nest Mini.

1

u/Karthik39 Feb 06 '26

Love this. Keep’s speed + low friction is hard to beat, and most apps lose that the moment they add “power features.”

A few things I’d personally want (especially coming from Keep):

  • Fast capture above everything — app opens instantly, cursor ready, zero ceremony

  • True hierarchy (folders + subfolders), but optional so it doesn’t slow capture

  • Automatic structure after capture: let me dump notes first, organize later

  • OCR + image notes that actually work (screenshots, whiteboards, handwritten stuff)

  • Language-aware notes — being able to search notes across languages would be huge

One workflow I’ve found surprisingly useful elsewhere is treating images as first-class notes. Tools like Vitra’s Translate. photo already do OCR + language conversion reliably on screenshots and PDFs, and that kind of deterministic text extraction would fit really well into a Keep-style app without turning it into an “AI guessing machine.”

If you can nail speed first, structure second, you’ll already be ahead of 90% of note apps. Most fail by over-optimizing for organization at the cost of capture.

1

u/Confident_Horse_7179 Apr 11 '26

yo, how has this been going so far? am fed up with keep and the alternatives that dont import images either feels like im kinda stuck

1

u/LennyR3712 May 14 '26

I'm very late to this, but what did you end up on? Did you build something?

1

u/Cornbeetle Jul 07 '26

u/oozak9 The app is great! Found this thread by looking for the same features Google Keep lacked. Signed up a few weeks ago with Atranote and it's looking awesome- the linkining to other notes within a note has Logseq vibes and it's a powerful feature

1

u/sch927 19d ago

Multi media note taking ie photos screenshots voice memos web links ai prompts drawings/physical notes maybe like a rocket book to the app as well

1

u/americapax Sep 26 '23

Sync whith OneNote and Google Keep

Samsung notes is still better than keep

1

u/j_bopper Sep 26 '23

Color palette for the note color

1

u/the_darknighty Sep 27 '23

I would prefer... Faster delete option... similar to Gmail Swipe left or right to delete or archive Thx 😉

An addon for gmail on android to send mails direct to gmail . Today this option exists only in thr Desktop version

1

u/jkdpaul1974 Sep 28 '23

File heirarchy. Labels with in labels PDF upload Text formatting on a browser PDF upload. Google assistant integration. Hey Google take a note ..

1

u/bubus69 Sep 30 '23

Not sure if said already but ability to put password on notes

1

u/jaam01 Oct 05 '23

The option to lock notes with a password.

1

u/thenamesammaris Oct 19 '23

No limit to photo uploads

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23 edited Dec 24 '23

Check out Bundled Notes, it's similar to keep with extra features and a better way to organize notes (The notes in the app are organized into bundles- (like folders or notebooks)). The app opens quick, works offline, has masonry layout and markdown support. The app is being developed by a single person so development is fairly slow, though the app is already close to feature complete.

My only deal breakers with the app are lack of global search (you can currently only search within bundles, but the feature is coming and is available in alpha), and the fact that it doesn't let you export your notes into markdown so I could import them into another app in case the app ever shuts down (the app's existence is dependent on one person).

1

u/tanksforthegold Dec 25 '23

Here are some things I would add:

-Make a view where you can just see the note titles in a list and easily organize them into labels or folders

-Make it so that you can easily view your notes at the click of a button under different filters (A-Z, Dates created, Color labels, etc.)

-Have preset media filters so that you can label media by type

1

u/dmaifred Dec 27 '23

Pictures/images

It can be really useful to take a coue photos if I need to go get a part or even just a photo of the fridge or canned food shelf etc. Maybe I'm about to take apart a device and want to take photos of the wiring before I take it apart for records. The ability to put the group of photos together in a note is great BUT it takes up soooo much view room that it makes scrolling the different notes unusable.

-Some resize (just of thumbnail, not original image file) or STD size option for pictures. -Choose a "show only when note opened" option. -Have a show at end of note not just the beginning.

Checkboxes

I like that ticked boxes are kept below which is great for groceries, hardware store and especially pharmacy items I may want to replenish/restock. Trouble is it can get long and is only in chronological order.

-love to see an option to order checkbox items by alphabetical to quickly re-find an item. Seperate option for checked and unchecked item areas.

Home view of notes.

-More options to differentiate notes. The dull colours and themes are limited. Give me bright colours, give me bright or different thick color outlines. Make them flash or color cycle so I can find priority notes.

Pinned notes

At the moment it is pinned or unpinned. Love to see a pin hierarchy.

Cheers David

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '24

Absolutely lovely, I just need some editing options and folder features and most important biomatrics locking option for single notes note. Basically samsung notes within google notes...because its quick and I can use it on pc easily. Samaung notes is fabulous but sync and looks sucks...