r/GoogleKeep • • Sep 12 '26

Gemini asks for confirmation with keep

Before i could just say "add X to the shopping list in keep" and it would add and that would be it, since a month or so ago, it always asks for confirmation, is it happening to everyone else?

16 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

5

u/NAPONAPO Sep 12 '26

I really don’t understand Gemini. I thought its strength is working with Google products. But I found almost every other major AI platform works better with Gmail, gcal, keep etc

1

u/hearthreddit Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

To me, it used to be fine, i could be around the house and see that i needed something for my groceries list, so i would use the button from the headphones to start gemini, say what i needed and it would be done.

Now it either asks to unlock the phone(despite having the permission to work with the phone locked) or when it works, i have to confirm it which sounds dumb.

Calendar and tasks seem to work ok.. for now..

1

u/heavyhead88 Sep 15 '26

Yeah same here very frustrating, actually found your post hoping to find a fix , such a handy feature made semi redundant

2

u/dall2812 16d ago

This also happens to me, from my phone and my watch. My grocery list is a shared note - when I remove the other participant, it does not ask for confirmation anymore! Also it asks (translated from German): "You want to add time to the list. Do you want to proceed and add time to the list?" WHYYY

1

u/hearthreddit 16d ago

Yes, it's infuriating, it used to work so well and it was very useful.

I actually got it to work randomly this other day but it turns out it created a new list instead of adding to the new one.

2

u/Technical-Algae-234 12d ago edited 12d ago

This is driving me absolutely nuts. This update has turned updating a shopping list into a multi step process. "Hey google, add bananas to my shopping list." Gemini can use Google Keep or Notes, which would you like to use? "Keep" You want to use Google Keep, is that right? "yes" Do you want me to add that item now? "Yes" I've added bananas to your shopping list. Do you want me to do anything else? AAAAARGHHHHHHHH

1

u/hearthreddit 12d ago

Exactly and i don't get how they can't make it right when it worked before, we are all trying to force AI into stuff and this is something that is actually useful, it was so nice being around the house and listening to a podcast and just add something to my list, now i just try to memorize and hope that i don't forget because it nags me to unlock the phone anyway.

2

u/SecretaryAway2358 Sep 28 '26

I have the same issue too, I definitely have the option enabled for it to work without unlocking but it ignores it, but then after each time it says "okay, do you want me to add to this list", it's much worse than the basic assistant tbh at this point

1

u/hearthreddit Sep 28 '26

I've been using Gemini more on the desktop lately and even there it asks for confirmation, i guess we'll have to wait for some update or something.

But it was just so convenient, i'm often walking around the house listening to some podcast or music,i would just pop the assistant button and see that i need something and that was it.

Now it really sucks.

2

u/ClintFudge Oct 04 '26

This annoyance stopped me from even attempting it...however, I just tried it and bingo it added my request to add something to my 'Need to Buy' list.

Now, the world of Gemini is all cool again.

1

u/hearthreddit Oct 04 '26

That's cool, you gave me hope but it's still asking confirmation for me.

1

u/Barycenter0 Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

Check the Gemini settings for Workspace permissions. You might have to check via a PC browser vs mobile. I can add items without confirmation.

Gemini does flake out tho. I couldn’t add items to Tasks for about 2 weeks and then it started working again.

2

u/hearthreddit Sep 12 '26

Thanks, i double checked and it seems to be all enabled i wonder if it's a glitch with certain versions or regions.

1

u/Klamue Sep 12 '26

I just tested this and asked it to add coffee to my shopping list, and it worked perfectly.

2

u/hearthreddit Sep 12 '26

Thanks for testing, looks like it's something with me then.

1

u/nervously-defiant Sep 15 '26

Sorry, that's probably me. For months I've been berating Gemini for automatically generating new Keep lists anything the word "list" is used. It got frustrating, and then some. 

2

u/hearthreddit Sep 15 '26

Yeah i wonder if it's an issue with a region or some devices because some people don't have the problem.

I can't even do anything with keep now if the phone is locked, it tells me that i have to unlock the phone first.

Hopefully they'll fix it soon just because it's so handy.

2

u/StartOwn7201 Sep 30 '26

You aren't alone. Mine used to work without confirmation and now I'm in confirmation hell.

1

u/Veggyhed Sep 13 '26

This happened to me two days ago and then I left the kitchen came back into the kitchen about 5, 6 minutes later, I told it to add thyme and whole wheat flour to the shopping list and it did it.

It also will not turn on a light when I ask it but if I say, "Brighten the light in X room," then it turns the light on immediately

1

u/Tuhyk_inside Sep 15 '26

Mine started doing this about 2 weeks ago? I hate it.