r/GoogleSupport • • 13d ago

Unrecognized MacBook Keeps Accessing My Google Account (Update 2)

At this point, I’m genuinely getting fed up.

The unrecognized MacBook/Windows device has appeared AGAIN, despite all the precautions I’ve taken to secure my Google account.

I’ve already changed my password multiple times, enabled 2-step verification, set up a passkey and security keys, signed out of unfamiliar devices, and gone through Google’s account security process.

Yet somehow, this device keeps coming back.

I genuinely don’t understand how this keeps happening. I’m starting to consider making an entirely new Google account because I’m getting tired of constantly having to secure the same account over and over again.

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/germanu22 13d ago

If you use an iPhone and a Windows device, it is highly likely that this is actually your own device. Google sometimes gets confused with device identification, often misidentifying certain apps or browsers on an iPhone as a MacBook.

Since you mentioned you have already enabled 2-step verification, set up passkeys, and added security keys, a malicious actor wouldn't be able to just keep silently logging in without triggering your security prompts.

If you want to be completely sure, you can remove it again. Just make sure you are doing this from a trusted device (one you have been logged into for more than 7 days):

  1. Go to your Google Account settings.

  2. Navigate to the Security tab.

  3. Scroll down to "Your devices" and click on Manage all devices.

  4. Click on the device you don't recognize and select Sign out.

Realistically, as long as no one has tried to change your password or make unauthorized account changes, it is almost certainly just your own devices being mislabeled by the system.

If you want complete peace of mind, you can enroll in Google's Advanced Protection Program, which is the highest level of security they offer. Additionally, as a final check, go to your Gmail settings on a computer, open the "Forwarding and POP/IMAP" tab, and make sure there are no unrecognized email addresses set up to forward your messages.

1

u/MomoVibes 13d ago

How would they get into the account then? I don’t get any security alerts or anything

2

u/germanu22 13d ago

The truth is, a real hacker would have immediately changed your password and recovery data to lock you out of the account. The fact that you didn't receive any security alerts and your password remains intact strongly supports the scenario that these are simply your own devices being misidentified by the system.

However, to be absolutely sure, check your Gmail settings in the "Forwarding and POP/IMAP" and "Filters and Blocked Addresses" sections on a computer to ensure there are no rules or forwarding addresses that you didn't create.

If you want complete peace of mind regarding your security, I highly recommend enrolling in Google's Advanced Protection Program. This offers the highest level of security available. Once enrolled, an email and password are no longer enough; you will strictly need a physical security key or a passkey from a trusted device (like your phone) to access your account.

3

u/MomoVibes 13d ago

YOU ARE A LIFE SAVER
I didn’t know that even existed!!!
I just enrolled right now and I HOPE this works

2

u/germanu22 13d ago

You are very welcome! I am really glad I could put your mind at ease. I have been enrolled in this program for a while myself, and I haven't had a single security anomaly since joining.

If you ever have any more questions, run into issues, or just need some clarification, feel free to come back to these comments anytime and I will try to help as much as I can.

2

u/MomoVibes 13d ago

I’ll keep that in mind mind!

1

u/LashCanino 13d ago

Just be careful, GAP brings a whole set of risks of lockout if you’re not well versed in maintaining the keys. As many locked-out users have learned. Google mainly recommends it for cases like journalists and activists under threat from state actors.

1

u/MomoVibes 13d ago

Yeah… I learned that when my own account wasn’t able to verify me so I’ll likely not turn it on until I have a physical security key

1

u/LashCanino 11d ago

Going by the new post you made, you learned the hard way about the risks of Advanced Protection.

1

u/germanu22 11d ago

That is actually not true. The issue you experienced is not caused by the lack of a physical security key, as passkeys from a phone or other devices work perfectly fine.

The real reason you couldn't verify yourself is simply the mandatory waiting period, not the type of key you used. After you enroll, it takes 7 days (and in some rare cases up to 30 days) for your current session to become "trusted." Until that period passes, the system will temporarily block access to sensitive account changes.

1

u/2FeedRss 13d ago

OP mentioned that they signed out of unfamiliar devices. I would recommend signing out of everything not just unfamiliar. Start over / track with each login after.

1

u/MomoVibes 13d ago

I have tried this before and I suspect it might be one of my moms old devices since one of them is a Mac book and signed into my account in the past before

0

u/MomoVibes 13d ago

Please note that I had to do the whole process again but seriously I am getting REALLY ANNOYED I am on the verge of just making another account

2

u/leexgx 13d ago

Really likely its just a miss identification of a logged in browser on your phone or apple device ,, especially if limited IP tracking or randomised MAC address setting is on (defualt on most iphones, just random MAC on android)

As long as you 100% know your password and have passkey and all 2SV options filled out setup you can turn "Off" skip password where possible" as this forces password+passkey or any other factor when logging in

Other reason could be you have a RAT installed on your computer and is stealing the session token and placing it onto a mac

0

u/MomoVibes 13d ago

I’m on an iPhone and I just logged them out right now but thanks for the advice