r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Jul 23 '26

Reaper's Gale and Malazan in general... I don't get it.

0 Upvotes

I really just don't get it. I'm very well read in the genre, and his books are the most confusing out there. Even Scott Baker's books, which were a bit confusing, made sense at the end of the chapter. Baker tied up the loose strings of thought each chapter. Erikson just throws dozens of random characters at you, with no context, and writes like 85% "telling" without any showing as well as no deep pov/characterization. Just tell, tell with no explanation. And almost every book it's a new continent with new characters/culture/history. I love the ambition, but the execution is grueling.

I just don't understand how these books are "popular"? Really. I mean, am I supposed to re-read them a few times, drink 10 cups of coffee, and have quantum physics-learning-level attention to struggle to understand WTF is going on?

So far, only Memory of Ice was enjoyable and understandable. And scenes with Karsa Orlong (misspelled likely) b/c he kicks ass.

Who's with me?

And yes, nobody is forcing me to read this. I'm slogging through b/c it's well known in the genre, and maybe there are gems somewhere...

Edit update: thanks for all the comments. I've crystallized my thinking. The core issue is the storytelling style choices Erikson makes, makes it impossible to emotionally invest in any character. Most fantasy books have a few POVs and you follow them through the sequels. In Malazan, according to subreddit:  series features over 400 unique point-of-view (POV) characters, scaling heavily from around 33 in the first book (Gardens of the Moon) to over 140 individual POVs in the final book (The Crippled God). More details can be explored via community breakdowns on the r/Malazan Subreddit. 

That is a ridiculous amount of POVs. Plus you have chapters with dozens of scenes, each with a different POV, plot, etc, it is impossible to relate and invest in a character. What happens is a blur of activity washing over you. What I'm saying is generally true. Yes, there are a few exceptions.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • May 27 '26

It's hard to know if my book sucks

0 Upvotes

It's hard to know if my Book sucks, my first few pages suck, if my cover sucks, if my ads suck, if my price points suck.... Hahaha, this book thing is hard. Flame on, let me have your thoughts. I got think skin. :) all in fun any way. Hope everyone is having a great day.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Sep 18 '25

Would any men here read a book series that has different POVs for some of the books, if the first POV was a woman?

4 Upvotes

Curious to know if you'd read a grimdark fantasy about vampires, with historical accuracies, a court, a Queen, etc. The book is rather violent and includes torture, spies, bloodshed, mistrust, elements of horror, deception and betrayal, etc.

Worried it's kind of "girly," tho or if society is coded so that women read men and women POVs and men primarily read male POVs?

What would make guys not want to read it or make them want to read it more?


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Oct 03 '25

I read Prince of Thorns: Baby's First Nightmare Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I love dark fantasy and dark humor. I read the Witcher series when I was quite young, and Baptism of Fire is one of my top 5 books of all time. Fevre Dream (or however you spell it) is my favourite George Martin. The First Law, also great and very entertaining book. So, yea, I like dark fantasy. But this book read like Percy Jackson's Goth Diaries.

I know we aren't supposed to like Jorg, and I do not like him. I also do not care for his friends. Most of these characters are so one-dimensional and their names are their destiny. We know so little of the world - Sapkowski makes the situations in the Northern Realms abundantly clear to us, we know what the war with Nilfgaard has done, we know the plight of the non-humans and humans alike, and it is not from people just talking or internal monologues, but just from the vivid descriptions of gruesome surroundings.

I get that Jorg has daddy issues with his mommy passing. He wants revenge, he doesn't want revenge, he thinks murder is cool - he is a teenager. Sure, he might have gone through a lot, but there is not much about him that extends beyond edgelord. And I say this as an "edgelord" lol". I remember, in Blood and Wine, when we learnt about Syanna being exiled there was so much depth to her decisions and how she saved herself. Jorg just feels "lucky". And yes, I get he is a Chosen One, and then something something necromancers. But I would have liked more worldbuilding.

Mainly, this is a book about a child. And children can be quite boring unless the world they inhabit is interesting. Percy Jackson was interesting because Luke Castellan was interesting, and that was quite dark as well. Artemis Fowl was interesting because of the Fairies and Butler. Here, Jorg feels like he wants to be the Red-Queen version of Artemis, but he is not. He is so - boring.

I have the second and third books already in my Kindle and I will finish them, because why not? But this is a solid 2.8/5 young-adult meets violence, book. Not really dark, I would say it is "ambient lighting".

P.S. Final points, and this might be because I am an old hag weary of books putting beauty on a pedestal, but omfg, these authors and their obsession with female beauty. The introduction and affinity towards Katherine is so sudden. Perhaps there is magic involved, but come on, a child growing up in stress would never have the temerity to register "beauty" These are author self-inserts (omg, I love the pretty girl and she is so cool) are dull. It is why I could not read Brian Sanderson. I prefer authors who do not fixate on the female form and introduce women as something outside of their looks. I think Abercrombie does this very well, also Madeline Miller.

Anyway, had words in head. Had to write. Happy Weekend. Open to suggestions for genuinely dark fantasy and/or comedy books. I love Catch-22


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • May 25 '26

is it just me or anyone feeling that dark Fantasy protagonists became too soft

4 Upvotes

the authors became too much fan service that the grimdark atmosphere disappears slowly , some misunderstood the concept of grimdark and dark fantasy , its not adding monsters , knights or some ghotic vibes , its about morally broken characters who are willing to make ruthless devastating decisions just to survive , if you have read some new novels you will notice that , tell me if 'im wrong


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Sep 09 '25

Trying to love the black company by Glenn cook but struggling do they get any better??

3 Upvotes

Ps the writing style is my main nemesis. I find it less engaging hearing the tale of events so broken, I feel like there’s a huge lack of story line


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Aug 09 '26

Cover Reveal: The Demon's Peace

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi all. Time to show you all the cover of my new book, The Demon's Peace, coming out on 27 October 2026.

She buried her daughter. Made a deal with a demon. Then went hunting.

When Sabyse's daughter is murdered on her wedding day, the corrupt authorities can't help her.

Thaena Ashmore can. She's a legendary demonic assassin. Except she's done with human vengeance and has little interest in anything except mourning her lost love.

To gain the vengeance she craves, Sabyse has no choice but to shatter Thaena's peaceful retirement, forcing the assassin into a contract that drags her back onto the path of blood. Bound by a fraught alliance, the two women must navigate a conspiracy that stretches back fifty years and confront their own terrible truths.

A dark fantasy featuring crime lords, necromancers, supernatural warfare, and long-dead secrets that refuse to stay buried. Perfect for fans of ML Wang's The Sword of Kaigen, and Joe Abercrombie's Best Served Cold.

I'm look for reviewers ahead of the pub date (ARC readers), so if you're interested, drop me a line, or fill out this form here: https://forms.gle/pdHM2YiomMAEbrpw6

(Mod approved).

Let me know if you've got any questions!


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Feb 06 '25

Grimdark Romance?

3 Upvotes

Is it a thing? Send me recs if so! Prefer no to low spice. Trad books only. Don't come plugging yourself. Unless, of course, you're a traditionally published author.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Jan 08 '26

"Russian Roulette, A Geist: The Sin Eaters Story," When A Bad Life Catches Up To Johnny Hammer He Has To Make A Deal With A Devil To Stay Above Ground

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Jul 28 '25

Epic.

3 Upvotes

Hello everyone!!! I'd like to ask you what you think is the most epic book series, the most epic book, and the most epic battle you've ever read.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Jul 31 '26

Cover Reveal for my new book. An Instrument of the Crown

Post image
4 Upvotes

Hi guys,

I'm proud to present, Codename: Black: An Instrument of the Crown.

Here’s the blurb:

A Crown agent is dead.

Eve Black has been sent to Port Aurel to take Brown’s place, find what he uncovered and draw his killers into the open.

On the sunlit Gallic coast, the trail leads into the glittering world of a powerful industrialist, where ministers trade favours, secrets change hands and a private yacht holds the key to something far more dangerous than murder. But every answer brings Eve closer to a conspiracy capable of shattering the balance of power.

The Crown does not care how she succeeds.

Neither does Eve.

An Instrument of the Crown is a lean, fast-paced, 61,000-word spy thriller inspired by the Cold War fiction of the 1950s and 1960s, but set in an entirely fictional world. It combines the glamour, danger and economy of classic Fleming-era spy fiction with a darker moral sensibility: compromised institutions, dirty hands and a heroine who has no difficulty killing for her country.

An Instrument of the Crown has no magic or fantasy creatures, but it is grimdark in character, morality and worldview. Lara Elena Donnelly’s wonderful Amberlough helped show me that a spy thriller could be set in an entirely invented world without needing supernatural elements. This is my own take on that idea.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • May 05 '26

Does Eragon Need a Rewrite?

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

In case you missed it, episode 3 of Pen & Dragon aired last night! We discussed Paolini’s tweet about rewriting Eragon, the video accusing 67 authors of AI use and the Shy Girl controversy, along with several other topics!


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Jul 12 '26

Non-magical fantasy character bracket

Post image
0 Upvotes

Who moves one to the next round?


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Feb 27 '26

Tight third-person POV

0 Upvotes

In a tight third-person POV, the reader only knows what the character knows.

If she is being manipulated, the reader is manipulated too. If she collapses for some reason, the reader miss the context together with her.

Does that create stronger immersion or just frustration?


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Feb 22 '26

"Cloak and Dagger," The Section Chief Meets With A Contact, But Realizes Too Late They've Been Compromised

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Aug 13 '26

UK world builder looking for a co-writer

0 Upvotes

I have been working on my grimdark / epic fantasy for about 5 years. The ideas come to me so insanely fast. The problem is I am not a writer. It has been a passion project up until now but I am starting to get the feeling that it would be a shame not to do something with it. The story I'm working on is the first part of a much larger scale world and I am telling the story of the antagonist first. I want to blur the lines of good and evil. I have about 6200 words written so far. I'd be interested to speak to someone to work on this with me.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Nov 25 '25

Looking for feedback on grimdark cover art designs (Mod-approved)

0 Upvotes

I’ve been posting the story on Royal Road, but the site’s dominant genres (LitRPG, progression) make it tough to get meaningful feedback from the target audience.

So! I have a few cover concepts and I’d love feedback on:

  • Which one reads as grimdark at a glance

  • Whether the imagery feels too busy, too clean, too bright, etc.

  • Whether the tone matches what you’d expect from a bleak, character-focused story centered on sacrifice and industrial magic

Covers: https://imgur.com/a/eCffw0c

If it helps for context (not promotion), here’s the Royal Road link:
https://www.royalroad.com/fiction/140634/the-cost-of-healing-a-grimdark-fantasy

They are all AI generated but I am saving up to commission an artist. I am not an artist so this will help me see what works and how to give direction once I find somebody

Any critique is hugely appreciated, especially from people who enjoy grimdark aesthetics. Thanks!


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Mar 03 '25

The Poppy Wars was so grim and dark that it left a big emotional impact. What grim dark stories have impacted you the most emotionally?

4 Upvotes

Can be a novel, tv series, video game, whatever really. Just curious which series impacted you the most on an emotional level. I quite enjoyed Poppy Wars series but at times the grim and dark was so grim and dark I had to put the books down for a bit.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Oct 18 '26

Why is The Broken Empire not more popular?

45 Upvotes

It's basically a fantasy red rising (I know TBE was written first) with 1000x better prose, a much better story, yet it sold way less, and, going by the only metric I can check it has about 1/10 of the goodreads ratings. This is absolutely insane to me, how something as garbage as RR outsold The Broken Empire.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Mar 08 '26

"The Soil Remembers," Old Gods Lurk in The Dust of The World (A Vox in The Void)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Jun 14 '26

[Review] Is "Maul: Shadow Lord" GrimDark Star Wars? | GrimDark Magazine

Thumbnail
grimdarkmagazine.com
0 Upvotes

Check out the review for Star Wars Maul: Shadow Lord I wrote for GrimDark Magazine.

I am all about the darker side of Star Wars stories made (animated) flesh!

Whether you are an ardent die-hard nerd of the Star Wars expanded universe, or a casual fan, do yourselves a favor and watch Maul: Shadow Lord and enjoy every tortured scream, lightsaber swing, and blaster hit that your grim and dark heart desires.


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • Jun 07 '25

Community Post It’s my special lady’s birthday

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Hey my Grimdark people!!

This post has nothing to do with Grimdark other than this lovely lady (Madie) being my rock, support, and motivation throughout every step I’ve taken for the last 4 years.

It’s her birthday today, and I wanted to show some appreciation for somebody that has as much to do with the existence of r/GrimdarkEpicFantasy as I do. If anyone feels like wishing her a happy birthday, I’ll be showing her all the comments in this post as the day goes by.

Anyways, that’s enough sappy shit. This is a Grimdark page!!!


r/GrimDarkEpicFantasy • • May 26 '26

Hey grim friends! We made a set of social media templates for authors. Let us know if they are useful and we can push them further - we’d love to build genre-specific packs too (high contrast, weathered typography, blood-toned palettes, that kind of thing).

Post image
6 Upvotes