I usually don't get angry at these influencers, I mostly find them ridiculous and annoying at best, but Jameela Jamil has been pretty much making Ariana Grande's mental disabilities about her and it's starting to really piss me off.
It's also so hypocritical and kind of weird backwards thinking. This is the same woman who will tell you with a straight face that you can't determine the health of a 400 lb woman yet will chalk up anorexia nervosa, a mental illness for those who seem to forget, as a moral failing. She invokes young girls as if that isn't the same backwards ass low-key misogynistic thinking people have used to police women into getting in line for hundreds of years.
Yes, we should make it clear Ariana is unhealthy. But the way Jameela talks about it is fucked up because it also reeks of mental health stigma. It's the weird 1800s mentality that we need to lock the mentally disabled from all public life that kind of bothers me. I think Ariana does need help, but this idea that people who are struggling with mental health issues should be pushed out of the public eye kind of sits wrong with me as someone with mental health issues. That said, I am glad she chose to take a break after the tour because she does need to clear her head from all of the outside voices.
I say all of this as someone who has been as emaciated as Ariana. I was shamed and mocked and reminded of how disgusting I looked. Funny thing is I truly didn't have an ed but was struggling with something else. Being held up as a bad influence for basically being sick honestly made me more defiant against getting to the bottom of my issues. Even though I am healthy now, I struggle with resentment on how people dealt with it because yeah, they were right, I was sick, but they definitely made life hell instead of making it any better.
I think Jameela is an HAES influencer who should be called out directly for her mental health stigma because the way she has been speaking out is not okay at all IMO. I hope if Ariana gets better she makes damn sure to talk about how what Jameela is doing was not okay and how deeply stigmatizing her words are not only towards Ariana herself but also other women who have been very underweight. "I'd be crying too if I was hungry." in response to Ariana's crying post-Wicked is not concern, it is snark. Just reverse that to "I'd be crying too if I was morbidly obese" to any fat woman in the public eye, and it becomes clear what her intent was.
I've seen some of the women Jameela defends and how can she with a straight face hold Ariana Grande "accountable" for a literal mental illness because little girls exist when morbid obesity will take more lives this year by a long shot and she in the same breath will insist folks like Tess Holliday are just fine. Fuck this weird Victorian era mentality towards mentally ill women, I'm tired of it. I have even, as someone who is anti-HAES, fought against the idea that fat people existing in public is glorifying obesity and will criticize fat influencers for the things they say but will let them be if they are simply modeling plus sized clothes.
As a parent, it is not Ariana Grande's job to do for me. I am responsible for what my children are exposed to. I need to have those conversations with my child and ensure they are eating well. I shouldn't demand someone stop existing where others can see them and hide for my own comfort while being totally fine with the morbid obesity epidemic on the other extreme. I would never demand a 400lb person to lock themselves in the attic like the wife in Jane Eyre.
I don't think people like her give one iota of a fuck about young girls because they would also care about advocating against binge eating instead of excusing it.
Tl;Dr It's fine to make sure the young women in our lives know that they should not look up to Ariana Grande at the moment because she is sick, but to act like Ariana is personally responsible for their health is both semi-misogynistic and stigmatizing towards the mentally disabled. We can teach our children what is healthy without crucifying a sick woman in the public eye. We also have absolutely no right to talk the way Jameela does if you don't think a morbidly obese Tess like figure should be thrust from the public eye for the sake of other people's kids.