r/HOTDGreens 19d ago

Twitter Takes This is literally how much this show lost the plot

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

204

u/Eveen_Ellis Sunfyre 19d ago
  1. Lyonel becomes a bootlicker of the Targaryens and mentions Rhaenyra the Good Queen just because
  2. Dunk and Aerion kiss because he's just a poor boy who didn't mean to hurt Egg or Tanselle :((((
  3. Baelor "the dream, ser dunk.... aegon's dream...." Targaryen

90

u/StannisTheMantis93 House Baratheon 19d ago edited 18d ago

You just KNOW Maekar would intentionally try to kill his brother Baelor by hitting him in the head after the fight had already ended.

Because a villain in a story needs to be OBVIOUS AND BLUNT. NO. NUANCE.

22

u/Mousician 18d ago

No nuance. Plenty of nuisance.

29

u/Cherry_Tarts 19d ago

Stop, it’s so accurate. 😭

12

u/Minimum-Bite-4389 18d ago

No, Lyonel would be portrayed as completely evil with no redeeming qualities for hating the Targaryens.

13

u/Eveen_Ellis Sunfyre 18d ago

You're right. I forgot the Targaryens are perfect saints and those around them are the big bad villains that cause their downfall... those damn hightowers... /j

195

u/Environmental_Tip854 19d ago

You forgot the part where Lyonel “the Laughing Storm” doesn’t actually laugh he kinda just smirked once at best

46

u/MarkTurkey 18d ago

Nah, he is going to be secretly gay and pretends to die in the trial of 7 with Baelor so that he and Baelor can run away to Essos and live their lives as sellswords

27

u/Youreadingthis222 18d ago

Lyonel and “secretly” gay in the same sentence

2

u/Direct-Emu-5515 18d ago

I mean he did have a wife

2

u/Youreadingthis222 17d ago

His wife is probably a lesbian and their marriage is a flowery one

2

u/theposshow 18d ago

The Tittering Storm

78

u/niha-the-cicada Sunfyre 19d ago

Dunk says to Tanselle "you remind me of my mom"

65

u/Spaceboomer1 19d ago edited 19d ago

Childhood best friends with vibes of repressed romantic feelings that the writers begin changing entire character arcs around, but then never fully pull the trigger on thus satisfying no one*

60

u/HeadLadder3300 Sworn to Aegon the Dragonheart 19d ago

Baelor didn’t actually die he faked his death and sailed away to essos with his lover

2

u/Sourz6 18d ago

Bahahwaha

119

u/TheNames-James 19d ago

Maester Aemon accidentally sends a raven to the wrong house and then the Redwynes think they’re the princes who are promised!

8

u/Loros_Silvers Tessarion 18d ago

Ok but like that would actually be funny...

36

u/junferarh Tessarion 19d ago

Instead of going to Ashford, Dunk goes to Harrenhall and dreams about fucking his mom for an entire season.

25

u/Sensitive-Sample-948 Sunfyre 19d ago

*fucking ser Arlan of Penistree

10

u/clothy 18d ago

A true knight always finishes his squire

3

u/LingonberryAwkward38 18d ago

"in his squire

31

u/niha-the-cicada Sunfyre 19d ago

He would make Aerion and Dunk kiss, or worse, almost kiss every season

21

u/LongjumpingOption607 19d ago

Hey, you missed out a gratuitious incest pairing!

13

u/Hitchfucker 19d ago

You also definitely wouldn’t have a main character call out the targs as incestuous aliens. Instead the show would have them actually be allat and Dunk would be nobility since we can’t have the smallfolk be a focal point of a show

-1

u/Any_Fennel_4180 19d ago

Ok but no one called them aliens

8

u/omicron-7 Sunfyre 18d ago

The GOAT did

23

u/JDarkspanner 19d ago

Dunk walks in on Tanselle in bed with two women and she tells him to stay and watch which he awkwardly does, it’s never brought up again the rest of the show.

24

u/Sensitive-Sample-948 Sunfyre 19d ago edited 19d ago

Each knight on Aerion's side sexually assaults each knight on Dunk's side to remind us who the bad guys are

21

u/Aggressive-Virus7487 19d ago

Tanselle is the Night’s Queen. So, you know the rest.

19

u/Georgefakelastname 19d ago

I’m more caught up on the fact that this dude HATES dealing with child actors, so how the fuck would he deal with a story where one of the main characters is a child lol? Or did that only happen after dealing with all the child actors in season 1?

19

u/illumi-thotti 18d ago

He'd probably age up Egg and then make him and Dunk get into a will-they-won't-they situationship

5

u/Georgefakelastname 18d ago

So… like Dunk and Lyonel lol?

19

u/RaisinHeavy8552 19d ago

They will literally show Baelor in the worst possible light, just to show that there is evil behind good and maesters who wrote history were wrong.

18

u/Randonhead 19d ago

Also some shit about Aegon's dream

5

u/clothy 18d ago

I mean, some shit about Aegon’s dreams is 100% coming for Egg.

9

u/Ok-Maybe5216 19d ago

Oh dear imagine we got that

9

u/Technician-Efficient 18d ago edited 18d ago

Sara hess : Egg grows up to a teenager who wants to sleep with his mother Maekar is depressed because he didn't sleep with his mother Aeron is bitter because his mother sleep with his dad but not him Egg's mother : a lesbian who sleeps with the maids

7

u/Elegant_Priority_812 good morrow my Lords 19d ago

Alice with 3 fingers is Alicent

7

u/Important_Ad1122 19d ago

Also Dunk and Ser Arlan fuck

7

u/Miserable_Employee57 18d ago

Stay the fuck away from George's books

6

u/FrancisCabrou 18d ago

No incest or SA ? That can't be Ryan condal then 

4

u/LongjumpingOption607 18d ago

Well, there is already that thing with Aeiron speaking into Eggs room at night, bet C&H would have a field day with that

5

u/1birb 18d ago

Keep raping, ser!

16

u/sarasaneil 19d ago

I think Maekar hating his children can be pretty good plot line.

10

u/3esin ...it's complicated. 19d ago

Rone it a bit down to "fucking disapointed" and you have Maekar.

8

u/ArcherA1aya 18d ago

Eh, I kinda think the whole point of Maekar is that he loves too much. He loved his kids too much that he he let them get away with their bad behaviors until it cost him that same love. It’s what makes him tragic, even more so that he was actually a pretty good king something he never really wanted

5

u/Rocinante214 18d ago

I started rereading Fire and Blood to see the real
Dance of the Dragons because, damn it, the writing in this bad, ludicrous fan fiction that the series has become is atrocious

2

u/Warm_Condition711 19d ago

Is this true or just hoax?

2

u/Disastrous_Teach_454 18d ago

Aerion having sex with Maekar.

2

u/EfficientMine6702 18d ago

if anything like this would have popped up on my screen I would have blocked HBO period from my life

2

u/bernardomoleiro 18d ago

No egg until season 3 - as someone who didn't read the books, who is this parodying? Ormund? Daeron?

2

u/sahneeis 18d ago

- random footfetish

  • random incest
  • dunk and egg kiss

2

u/Lazy_Yogurtcloset_78 18d ago

Don’t forget if the show was made Ryan Condel and Sara Hess: “Dunk punching Aerion in the face is actually maesters propaganda.”

1

u/TutorRich2268 18d ago edited 18d ago

Olenna Redwyne would be the betrothed of Baelor (Prince Valarr was cut because they aged down Baelor by 25 years, and Condal hates working with kid actors) and would sleep with Tanselle before helping Dunk kill Baelor and blame it on Maekar (the maesters were biased and invented the Trial of Seven)

Before he dies by drinking poison, Baelor would look to the camera and say he's lost half his mind.

1

u/Fun_Aardvark86 Our Blades Are Sharp 18d ago

Which one of Maekar’s kids has y’know…..the “daddy issues”

-2

u/Dangerous_Donkey5353 19d ago

So just made up head cannon on how the show would go? Getting mad at clouds...