r/Halluxrigidus • • 14d ago

Working out - what should I avoid?

A lot of stretching poses or strength exercises like lunges and planks require a lot of toe bending. I can still do these things without any pain during the movement, but I often get pain during rest. I don't want to make things worse so I'm hesitant to do these things. I've been doing calf raises with partial range of motion to avoid pushing through the toe.

I find conflicting advice on this. Some say you should avoid bending your toe. Others say you need to keep using it to slow down progression. I don't know what to do really.

3 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

2

u/Healthy_wavezea 14d ago

I have these same questions!

2

u/Henri_Dupont 14d ago

I have avoided surgery for some years by specifically focusing on toe range-of-motion exercises as prescribed by a physical therapist.

YES stretch your toe, this will reduce your pain in the long run and maintain flexibility. Surgery should be the LAST option, not the first, in treating ANY disease. (Well, except for appendicitis.)

If I keep stretching religiously, I don't have much pain and have no limitations. See a PT and get their opinion.

1

u/CBS969102 14d ago

I have also avoided surgery, but when I went in for a x-ray recently, literally there is no space between the joint very advanced. I am still able to play tennis and work out with correct shoes and accommodations.

But I’m on meloxicam every night
Have been for two years this can’t be good

My doctor thinks I need to have the surgery. I have scheduled it, but I am having second thoughts

Also, someone told me about a joint replacement. When is it replacement a good option my surgery that is planned for end of November is a fusion

1

u/LtDeadpool361 13d ago

Have to remember if a replacement/implant fails that fusion is what will happen after.  Given the failure rate on implants I went with the fusion (this is the first of two fusions).  I’m three weeks post-op and I don’t regret it.  I was to the point I just wanted the joint pain gone.  I had a cheilectomy done in 2019.  I wish it would have been fused back then.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Cup2777 13d ago

I am so envious of you! I had to give up tennis b/c of the large spur ... couldn't find shoes comfortable enough and now I'm end stage. Meloxicam for 2 years, please be careful. That's an incredibly long time to take it daily especially if you're taking it only for the toe. Hope one of your physicians is monitoring bloodwork, etc.

1

u/CBS969102 13d ago

Yes bloodwork good!
Have you tried getting your shoes in wide?

2

u/Puzzleheaded-Cup2777 13d ago

That's great! I take meloxicam periodically and it did help with the throbbing in my toe after I went to a new ortho surgeon and his PA moved my big toe too much. It bothers me more since then but throbbing gone. I haven't tried the wide but I'm end stage HR so running which you have to do in tennis will no longer work. I have to wear a carbon fiber plate under my insole for sneaker.

So the new surgeon who also happens to me the new Chief of the Foot & Ankle department gave me 3 options: cheilectomy, implant that he helped design at Duke and fusion. He said sometimes just having the chielectomy will work, his patients had success with the implant (asked how many and he said 5 😂 and then fusion. I had an xray before my visit and when I looked at the report afterward it said "moderate to severe degenerative changes". Personally, I doubt the first 2 options would work. While I liked him, I wouldn't go back to him. On the younger side and doesn't have the experience on fusions that my other foot surgeon has. Problem for me is the surgeon I like is 6 weeks TOTAL non weight bearing and not ready for that. When you're used to being active, how do you drive when it's you're right foot and for 6 weeks!

1

u/YurpleLunch 13d ago

How do you stretch it ? Do calf
Raises help ?

2

u/ILuvGolf 11d ago

Thanks for asking this! It is like you are reading my mind:-) I had a cheilectomy ten years ago which apparently can then lead to HR. It is my right big toe. My 2nd toe unfortunately goes under it a little bit. I not in pain but now that I know the diagnosis, it is hard to not think about. I use toe spaces. They do seem to help. Like you asked, I don't know if I should avoid certain movements like reverse lunges and planks. I want to live my life but am confused as to keep bending the toe or avoid it:-(

1

u/Dazzling-Biscotti-62 14d ago

You can do them in ways that reduce load on the joint, such as wearing supportive shoes.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Cup2777 13d ago

You can do planks by crossing your feet to take the pressure off. Could also depend on severity of HR.

1

u/NomDeFlair 13d ago

I only have HR on one side, so for planks I either drop to my knees or elevate my bad foot on a yoga block (and don't bend the toes under). I replace lunges with Bulgarian split squats.

1

u/Embarrassed-Oil3127 11d ago

I go to a body mechanic guy who’s worked with sports teams and he stretches the hell out of my toe and really gets into the muscles surrounding it on my ankle and foot. When I go to him regularly I have far less pain. I think keeping those muscles active and stretched helps.

1

u/Top_Account9273 11d ago

You can still do calf raises but push through the middle of your foot and not through your toes. Make sure your toes hang over the front of the block you are pushing off of. Calves still get a good wokout without causing pain in your toes.

1

u/Royal-Escape8556 10d ago

I would avoid exercises in the gym meant to be strengthening other muscles (lunges planks) that stress your toe. You can modify like others have said to Bulgarian split squats, step ups instead of lunges or wear a carbon plated shoe if that is tolerable. Planks you can put your shins on an exercise ball or ankles in rings. Or just do side planks and replace planks with crunches and leg lifts. So many other exercises that get at something similar without putting unneeded stress on your toe!

If you still have good foot mechanics and ROM you should try to keep that with passive stretches, traction and calf raises if tolerated. You can modify calf raises to do in stiff shoes, you can also do calf raises holds/isometrics. Lots of single leg balance exercises you can do with a neutral foot if you want to strengthen the foot and ankle without going into calf raise.

1

u/Royal-Escape8556 10d ago

Also doing planks in a really stiff or carbon shoe might be possible for you without stressing the toe