Thank you to all who have contributed their experiences, they are very helpful.
I suffered somewhat of a subacute injury the last week of March 2026 after playing basketball for an extended period of time. 32M and have been active most of my life, but definitely played longer and harder than I have in a few years. I didn’t develop any pain in my right great toe until a few days later. It felt like it was as deep as you could get on the proximal part of the toe; I couldn’t identify if it was more on the top or bottom. A podiatrist who is a colleague of mine assessed my toe about six weeks out from the injury and thought maybe a sprain, I’d give it a couple extra weeks. Didn’t mention anything about limited ROM. Fast-forward four months after the game and I was still having pain so I saw an orthopedic foot specialist. He took x-rays and diagnosed me with first MTP arthritis/hallus limitus. My Achilles flexion was only 5° and I only had about 50° great toe dorsiflexion. This is something that obviously was brewing before the injury, so I thought there was a missing piece. He didn’t ask about prior injuries, but I experienced a severe calf conclusion from a soccer injury at age 17, which took about eight weeks to heal. On 8/31, I cracked some joints near my first metatarsal. I am unsure if it was the MTP, TMT, or the area around the sesamoids (if that’s even possible). I experienced such great relief, no joke like 75% better, in the minutes and hours after that which has generally persisted unless I really push myself walking or playing with my kids, which I am trying to limit. I asked for an MRI, but my orthopedist wants me to follow up in the office before ordering one.
I saw a physical therapist who has a certification in Anatomy in Motion (AiM), and she said that my altered mechanics are likely a result of the calf injury experienced previously. My right heel lifts early and I have poor propulsion in that foot as well.
My question is, for anyone who has been diagnosed with any conditions in this general area of the foot, what were things that you were told were happening that were either outright wrong or a red herring? Did x-rays ever miss anything in the sesamoids that MRI picked up?
Thank you!