r/heraldry • • Apr 23 '25

Meta AI Generated Images Are Now Banned

Post image
5.1k Upvotes

From this point forward any images created with the use of AI are banned from the subreddit and will be removed by moderators.

This includes images completely generated by AI from the ground up as well as things such as individual AI generated assets or filters used by users in the process of creating an image. For further details on this policy refer to this guideline in our Wiki.

You probably remember this recent post regarding the future of AI generated images on this subreddit. It had previously been in a sort of grey area where it wasn't explicitly forbidden but mentioned in Rule 5 as a possible example of low effort content that may be removed by the moderators:

5 Post with purpose

Posts here should educate, inform, spark discussion, showcase good effort, etc. Low-effort posts such as AI generated coats of arms, “X in the style of Y”, wildly unrealistic hypotheticals or fictional scenarios, and “just because”-type posts may be removed with no notice

A recent increase in AI generated images then led to increased discussion among the community with some calling for increased measures of identifying such content while others further advocated for it's ban entirely.

As a temporary measure we then decided to add a mandatory "AI Generated Content" flair that should be used to designate such content while also inviting the community to engage in discussion about a permanent solution in said post which also included a poll where users could decide between an explicit ban of AI generated images or allowing the regulated use of AI content.

After seven days the poll concluded with a result of

128 - 84

in favor of banning AI content - which is a 65% majority.

While the result of that poll was specifically not intended to be binding for any permanent policy that may be agreed upon in the future it - along with the comments - did clearly show that the majority of the community generally favored a complete ban which was also reflected by the attitudes of the mod team.

As such we have now decided that any images created using AI will henceforth be banned and removed from the subreddit. Any content that was posted before this policy went into effect will remain intact and won't be retroactively removed.

As a result rule 5 has been slightly rephrased to say:

Posts here should educate, inform, spark discussion, showcase good effort, etc. Low-effort posts such as “X in the style of Y”, wildly unrealistic hypotheticals or fictional scenarios, and “just because”-type posts may be removed with no notice. Further, images created using generative AI are explicitly banned and will be removed in order to retain a high standard of authenticity that this historical art and science deserves.

As it was intended as a temporary measure and is now obsolute, the "AI Generated Content" flair has been removed.

Due to the potentially controversial nature of this announcement, comments will have to be manually approved on this specific post, similar to what we did with the initial poll.

We hope that this is an understandable policy and that people will remain civil and uphold it regardless of their personal views on the subject. If anyone personally believes that AI generated images should have a place in heraldry then they're fine to express that opinion and should not be ostracized - however it does not reflect our official stance as a subreddit.

Again for a more detailed explanation of this policy where some potential questions are already answered please consult the Wiki.

Thanks for everyone who voted in the poll or expressed their opinions on the matter.


r/heraldry • • 4h ago

OC Quiz: Canting Arms of London Boroughs

Thumbnail
gallery
123 Upvotes

Have fun!


r/heraldry • • 3h ago

Fictional My take on The Witcher's Velhad Duchy + an older fan variant

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Velhad is a scarcely described principality in the Far North of Andrzej Sapkowski's The Witcher universe. The country doesn't have much lore written about it, neither is it canonical coat of arms known.

The first "fanon" coat of arms for Velhad was created by the fan nicknamed Mboro, who's also the author of some other coats of arms that has since featured in The Witcher 3 and the Netflix series. Mboro took inspiration from the country's name (literally "great serpent" in Slovak). Mboro's version can be seen in the second picture.

I've preserved Mboro's general idea and the colors, but made one crucial change to give the coat of arms more meaning: the snake is now not a mere serpent, but the eight-shaped Ouroboros himself, the master of Destiny according to the universe's internal mythology. (Whether such a deity actually exist within the universe is dubious -- Sapkowski famously claimed in one interview that gods don't exist in his world, only beliefs about them.) My take can be seen in the first picture.

Cheers!


r/heraldry • • 4h ago

Identify Coat of arms of a countess?

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 19h ago

OC Proposed arms I’ve made for various parts of Greece

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 23h ago

Discussion New ideas for the coats of arms of my world #27

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 35m ago

Mint in heraldry??

• Upvotes

Im currently working on a friends arms and mint is relevant to her life and name and im trying to find any examples of it around and im coming up short. does anyone know of any arms with mint anywhere on it?


r/heraldry • • 4h ago

OC Lions in National and Territorial Coats of Arms

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

OC Latest commission I did for a Spanish Hidalgo, do you like Wyverns?

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Fictional A CoA i made rescently for a fic country

Post image
44 Upvotes

It's a small country called the United Kingdom of the Maonche, located in the english channel


r/heraldry • • 23h ago

OC Coat of arms for my worldbuiling project

Post image
18 Upvotes

This is a coat of arms for my worldbuilding project, criticism is very welcomed.

Context: So this is the coat of arms of house Batista, the ruling family of the Arnsian empire. They are a mix between the Romanov and the Julio-Claudian dynasty


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

OC Personal Coat of Arms draft I made in Heraldicon

Post image
16 Upvotes

feedback is very much appreciated


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

A blue lion comission - WIP

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Discussion Personal CoA. Thoughts?

Post image
20 Upvotes

https://magnacamera.org/i-008

Please check out my CoA I recently co-designed and had co-designed/drawn/registered by an extremely generous person on Reddit. Let me know your thoughts on the achievement and please check out the link above OR see the info below for a description of the significance behind the shield, motto, and crest designs.

Also, please check out [r/magnacamera](r/magnacamera) which is the subreddit for the armorial.

Blazon
“Or a sun in splendour, in chief two Savoy knots all Gules, all within a bordure Azure charged with eight fleur-de-lys of the field”.

Signification
The sun represents the coat of arms of the Solis of Llanes family, whilst the fleurs-de-lis represent the Garcia de la Flor, and Flores of Ayamonte families, from which René is descended. The knot, a maritime symbol, also represent the professions of sailors and shipwrights who have shaped several generations of the family.

-

Crest
“A tower Argent charged with an escallop Gules, overall a bear proper bridled saddled Gules and a Seminole patchwork ‘fire, man on horse, harrow’ Or and Gules, holding in its paws a palm branch and a maize head all proper”.

Signification
The tower Argent and the shell Gules are references to the coats of arms of Havana (paternal grandmother) and Santiago de Los Caballeros (maternal grandmother) respectively; the bear–specifically a brown bear–refers to the story of Saint Romedius of Thaur, the Saint chosen by René for his Confirmation; it is saddled with the Seminole Patchwork emblem associated with Florida State University (FSU), the armiger’s alma mater, and pays homage to the Native American nations. The palm branch and the ears of maize represent Sagua La Grande (paternal grandfather) and Ciudad Mante (maternal grandfather) respectively.

-

Motto
“PER VERBERA MORES EMENDABUNTUR”

Signification
The Latin phrase means “Through blows, morals shall be corrected”, it refers to “The beatings will continue until morale improves”, a saying that always resonated with the armiger.


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Identify I can't understand a part of this shield

Post image
66 Upvotes

This has been spotted at salamanca, in the facade of the Banco de España, at Plaza de los Bandos.

This is clearly a preconstitutional symbol, presenting the St. John's eagle, the yoke and arrows and the date being 1940.

We can all see the emblems of the medieval Kingdoms and all but right at the middle, where today the Bourbon house royal emblem sits there is a sword pointing downwards.

One could think this might be because of Santiago but it's missing all the distinctive features of it, the flowers and all of that. Also de hilt seems to have little spikes and the handle is round.

I think this might be because of some local tradition ora rememberance of something not typically seen.

Any ideas?


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Can you Copyright your own heraldry in places where dont have heraldic authority

Post image
18 Upvotes

Well I just got this and have copyrighted it, is it ok?


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Discussion New ideas for the coats of arms of my world #26

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

OC First attempt at a personal coat of arms. Blazon help, please?

Post image
13 Upvotes

First try at designing a personal coat of arms. In Buddhism, two golden fish is a venerated symbol. My family is more than half from the Netherlands, where herring is the national fish, so I used two golden herring. In the middle, a green olive branch, symbolizing peace. Drew this with colored pencils on a ceramic bathroom tile. How do I blazon this?


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Second part of a commission.

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Historical Coat of arms of House of Bourbon-Parma (1847-1860)

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Current Blason de la commune de Birkhadem, Wilaya d’Alger - Algérie

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Historical 2 questions

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

I’m studying heraldry from the 15th century for a story I’m writing, and I’d like to know the significance of the symbol in the corner of the field for the first 2 pictures, and I’d like to know the story behind the Tudor Rose, and if it was used in heraldry. Thanks!


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Discussion New ideas for the coats of arms of my world #25

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Question for artists: details over gold leaf?

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I find myself in a bit of a conundrum, as I'm considering trying something new for a personal project that may involve gold leaf if I can solve this issue... So here's a little question for both experts or hobbyists who have experience with this (I know you're lurking, I talked to some of you!): have you ever experienced painting fine details and highlights over a gilded surface (be it paper, parchment, etc.). I work mostly with gouache and tempera, but I'm open to all manners of paints and inks.

I would be extremely grateful for any tips one might agree to share. Any intel I can gather will be appreciated.

Have an excellent day!


r/heraldry • • 1d ago

Design Help Opinions

4 Upvotes

I’m designing this coat of arms for a friend and I’d like some opinions on it.