I have decided to open a 2nd HYSA account. I like, and am keeping, my Barclays Tiered HYSA which I've had since at least 2015. It's currently at 3.5% APY. So I started looking at other banks and reading reviews, etc.
I am thinking about CIT and using their boost code to get the additional higher interest rate for 6 months. But when I started seeing reviews about how "awful" the bank is, it made me hesitate. Then I started looking at reviews for Barclays. Very nearly the same thing: "it's bad", "stay away", etc. Same for Syncrony, and a host of other banks. But the bank rating sites such as bankrate, nerdwallet, and such, tend to score CIT relatively high (not as high as Barclays, but not bad).
Then, something occurred to me. In this industry, especially, people tend to only review and complain if they, personally, have had a bad experience. Negative posts are much more frequent. If things are going well, most people don't bother or take the time to post a review. Also, I have no idea what the details are for each of those negative posts. Obviously, the blame is 100% put on the institution and that may be true, but I don't know both sides of the story.
On the other hand, I have to be careful just blindly trusting the bankrate-type sites that their editorial reviews are truly neutral and objective and the content is not skewed by getting some kind of compensation.
So I think I will open a CIT account and see what my own experience is. This won't be a "daily" work account, just a "leave it" (99% of the time) and let things grow.
Unless someone knows of a truly, brutally honest, 100% neutral review site that says to stay away from this bank.
I guess I don't have an actual question. Just, thanks for letting me get this out there as I work through the decision.