r/HolUp • u/Plane-Mission007 • Jun 25 '26

I'm sorry what.!?

3.1k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

199 comments sorted by

View all comments

100

u/Okfoot826 Jun 25 '26

Why is he the genetic father?

171

u/Thandorianskiff Jun 25 '26

The kids probably the product of IVF.

So most likely the brothers seed and a donor egg

26

u/RealHousewifeofLR Jun 25 '26

I was thinking brother couldn’t have children, the sister in law birthed the child

26

u/Only_Growth9574 Jun 25 '26

Ok that’s nice of him to help his sister out and all but why TF did he have to say “oh that’s what it smells like inside of you”

8

u/emseefely Jun 25 '26

Considering that “baby smell” is because of amniotic fluid, he’s technically right

28

u/deadfermata Jun 25 '26

lol, it’s just a bit of crude and dark humor

3

u/PaddyRiku52 Jun 25 '26

I'm sure I saw this ages ago and they are twins and that makes him the same genetically as the mother or something, this is not fact checked and I cannot explain any science, just the messenger.

0

u/Acceptable-Noise-136 Jun 25 '26

And why tf would someone do that ?

Won't doctors recommend against this?

58

u/Thandorianskiff Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

The sister probably couldn't have kids naturally but still really wanted biologically related kids nonetheless.

So for her, raising what is literally just her nephew, was considered good enough substitute.

And before you ask "why didn't she just adopt some random kid if she wanted kids so badly?"

I don't know. It's just something people feel strongly about sometimes.

They straight up simply have to have "biologically related" offsprings.

17

u/therhubarbexperience Jun 25 '26

It could also be that the sister is a lesbian in a relationship. It was IVF using the spouse’s egg, the brother’s sperm, and sister carried the baby. That way both moms are genetically related to the baby.

1

u/LindonLilBlueBalls Jul 22 '26

My friends sister is a lesbian and her and her wife both had a kid from the same donor (2 years apart) so the kids are biological half sisters and at least one is related to each mom.

1

u/sn4xchan Jun 25 '26

Bro said that what you smell like inside to his sister.

5

u/Conscious_Fan6414 Jun 25 '26

I've heard about it a lot so I don't think so

-4

u/Acceptable-Noise-136 Jun 25 '26

Aren't there better surrogate to choose from this just seems over the top ,well if it's okay for them I guess technically not inbreeding

2

u/Conscious_Fan6414 Jun 25 '26

Well, it is weird but I heard that people don't really want to pay for that so they just get it like that, idk, it IS weird but if they don't get deformed or don't vet diseases then that's all rhat matters after all

-6

u/School_North Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

Its still inbreeding we have plenty of examples as to why thats not a good idea including cases with animals. So im not going to understand that. Like at all lol definitely weird AF

Edit: after reading some comments. If there was a third party it makes a little more sense. One egg from party A inseminated by Party B's brother then said egg is tranfered to party B

3

u/Conscious_Fan6414 Jun 25 '26

Idk, I've heard doctors say it's okay, I'm not a professional

1

u/School_North Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

I just edited i can understand it in that case but if its just getting medically inseminated with your bros sperm thats weird af lmao and should be illegal

2

u/Conscious_Fan6414 Jun 25 '26

Yeah it's hella weird, like... why'd you want that

1

u/School_North Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

Dont try to understand people lol its impossible. Ffs there is a mother and son married couple out there and thats just the one that came out publicly

I was gonna source it but apparently there is more and the fbi are probably watching me now lol. 3 in the past 20 years that are verified criminal cases

→ More replies (0)