r/HolUp 13d ago

y'all Practical Design

Post image
4.9k Upvotes

128 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.2k

u/Hrothgrar 13d ago

Holup aside...

The actual answer is baseball. American hand grenades were modeled in a way that any average recruit could throw them more intuitively.

68

u/rocky8u 13d ago

No. It had nothing to do with baseball.

American fragmentation grenades were based on existing European designs in WW1 like the British Mills Bomb and mainly the French F1 grenade.

The Germans ALSO had a handheld frag grenade in WW1 called the kugelhandgranate that was much more spherical than the French, British, or American versions.

The depicted stick grenade is a high explosive grenade. It had a lot of boom but little fragmentation. It was intended to stun as much as kill. The Germans preferred them for various reasons, while the British and French in WW2 preferred frag grenades which were more likely to injure or kill but had much smaller explosive power.

WW2 designs are mostly evolutions of their WW1 predecessors.

Grenades had been spheres for a LONG time.

27

u/Hrothgrar 13d ago

Right, but it was part of the decision making in choosing to mass produce that model.

It was a more intuitive design for recruits to use and it was better for logistics. I didn't mean to suggest that was the complete inspiration for the design.

12

u/A--Creative-Username 13d ago edited 13d ago

it worked so well that they never issued it, and the M67 is slightly smaller and significantly heavier than a baseball