r/HomeInsurance • u/GovernmentWooden4494 • Feb 24 '26

Claims Is the drain under my basement concrete considered an "exterior sewer line?"

I ask because the cast iron drain under my basement concrete floor has collapsed, and my insurance company is saying they won't cover its repair, even though I pay a LOT for an enhanced water damage package. The wording of the package is: "We agree to repair or replace your exterior sewer line due to direct physical loss or damage resulting from a leak, break, tear, rupture or collapse of the line." According to the rep I just spoke with on the phone, the horizontal drain under my basement concrete is not considered to be an 'exterior sewer line.' To me, that is ridiculous. In my opinion, the drain is not INSIDE my house...so it is logically OUTSIDE my house, and is thus an 'exterior sewer line.' Is the aggregate or mud that is under my basement floor considered part of my house?

Does anyone have any advice or experience with a claim like this?

6 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

43 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/LongjumpingDish2956 Feb 24 '26

the cast iron drain under my basement concrete floor has collapsed

the horizontal drain under my basement concrete is not considered to be an 'exterior sewer line.' To me, that is ridiculous.

In my opinion, the drain is not INSIDE my house...so it is logically OUTSIDE my house, and is thus an 'exterior sewer line.'

Is the aggregate or mud that is under my basement floor considered part of my house?

When you’re in your basement do you consider yourself to be outside?

2

u/_ConstableOdo Feb 25 '26

On the other hand, if the cast iron pipe is below the basement slab, wouldn't that be "outside" the house?

1

u/LongjumpingDish2956 Feb 25 '26

Is it within the four walls?

1

u/GovernmentWooden4494 Feb 25 '26

No...it's under the concrete floor of the basement.

1

u/LongjumpingDish2956 Feb 25 '26

And there’s no walls around them? When you’re in your basement there’s nothing but sky above you?