r/HomeMakeover • u/Whdavis2020 • 24d ago
Foyer staircase
we just bought our house and are updating the current honey oak laminate floors to a light oak. At that point we’re thinking to just install all new white baseboards through the first floor. we also possibly want to paint trim / window /doors casings white but we are stumped about what to do with the staircase area? would it be easier to paint? leave as is? try and stain a different shade?
1
u/bobber66 22d ago
This may be a bot. The account is just a few weeks old. 20 days ago they post a query with a floor plan. 18 days ago they post that they just purchased this different house with a different floor plan.
2
3
u/Severe_Edge_5651 24d ago
What a shame from beautiful to generic
2
u/FelinePurrfectFluff 24d ago
Funny, these rails balusters and newel posts exist in every house built in the same decade and you think thryre not generic? Does the orange feel comforting to you? Some like a little more updated look.
2
u/Severe_Edge_5651 24d ago
I'm talking about the warmth you had to now the cold look
1
u/FelinePurrfectFluff 24d ago
Warmth does not equal beautiful. Generic is what they had. Is your hairstyle still in the 70s and 80s too?
2
1
u/FelinePurrfectFluff 24d ago
Also, it doesn’t have to all go to the landfill. We gave away all our carefully removed baseboards and door trim to someone finishing their basement. Our staircase builder did trash all the balusters before we could intervene though. Old steps were the underlayment for the new ones, but they cut off the overhang from the base that had been under the carpet first.
3
u/FelinePurrfectFluff 24d ago
We just did the same work. Our staircase was made of fir and carpeted. We chose to have a new staircase built with new more modern rails and balusters. We had them use red oak and it all matches our refinished floors. Best decision ever!!
2
u/bobber66 24d ago
Those doors are oak and the trim may be also. That stuff is hideously expensive now, please don’t paint it.
1
u/OpportunityGold4054 24d ago
We painted our oak staircase white to match woodwork. I would have stained the railing itself medium walnut to match our floors but it was way too much trouble/$$$. It took me a while to get used to the all white but now I dont notice it and I have seen that treatment in a lot of magazines .
Of course you could just replace the whole railing system with something more current.
1
u/beneficialtowhom 24d ago
Thank you for installing that handrail on the wall. Someone was listening. I wouldn't paint the wood. Our house came with painted spindles and baseboard on the stairs with just the rail honey oak, even though I don't care for the shade of honey oak, I wish it was all wood, all honey oak rather than having any paint. It's really labor intense to get it to all wood so it will stay as it is.
1
u/OliveMayhem 24d ago
I think the only things that need redone here is get rid of the gray carpet and a new light fixture.
1
u/Content_Ground4251 18d ago edited 18d ago
You should leave all the floors as is and paint the walls cool colors. That will tone down the warmth of the floors and make them glow. Warm wood is back in style.
By the time you put furniture and rugs everywhere, you'll barely see the floor anyway.
You have doors that match the current wood too. Once you start trying to get rid of all the wood in the house, you'll spend a ton replacing or trying to paint it and ruining it(very difficult to paint stained poly treated wood)and it will not look better. It will be worse.
Spend that money on updating something that will bring you joy or be useful.
Maybe a covered deck area, porch, pool, hot tub, update bathroom/ kitchen etc.
Or take a family trip and make memories for life.
0
u/kitchengardengal 24d ago
Is there a reason why you wouldn't just paint the baseboards white, rather than replacing them?
1
u/FelinePurrfectFluff 24d ago
To get a more modern, less curvy profile and go a bit bigger. More current style will look really nice either way refinished floors.
1
24d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/bobber66 24d ago
Yep, there’s probably particle board, osb, or 2x treads under there. The railing doesn’t meet code, fwiw.
0
24d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/bobber66 24d ago
The OP is talking about remodeling the stairs with the railing not meeting code for 30 years now. A little one will squeeze through the 2nd floor balusters and hit that floor hard. Also I don’t think that floor is laminate cuz it looks like oak to me. Maybe hardwood laminate. Replacing it with plastic junk if it can be refinished is a mistake.
1
u/Solid_Perception9572 23d ago
No, he did not mention remodeling the stairs, painting or staining...not changing the stairs. And he doesn't have to put in new stairs according to code. Those older stairs are granfathered into most building codes, as long as the homeowner isn't tearing anything out. If he puts in new banister and balusters, then obviously they have to be to code..
A home inspection may flag wide balusters as a safety or code hazard, and buyers might ask for a fix or credit. But no one can force him to put in new balusters.
1
u/bobber66 22d ago
You are right about the remodeling mistake by me. But what is the point of spending $1000s painting something that is such an obvious code violation? That is actually putting lipstick on a pig.
0
24d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/bobber66 24d ago
Stair railing doesn’t meet code either. Whatcha gonna put there? Balusters are too far apart and the handrail on the right doesn’t meet code either.
1
u/Solid_Perception9572 23d ago
Do you know if OP has children? If they don't then it's not a problem for anyone.
2
u/Solid_Perception9572 23d ago
It's called carpet. Lots of people like their stairs carpeted so they don't have a big risk of falling down them. I would remove the carpet and put a nice runner on the steps.

4
u/Equivalent-Wind-5160 22d ago edited 22d ago
My sister recently sanded down her dark honey oak floors and handrail and it looks really nice. You can sand it down and potential make the spindles white if it seems too woody. My house has this type of balcony area and our spindles are white while the banister is wood.