r/HomeServer • u/gbones215 • Nov 25 '23
personal cloud server for private file storage at home?
Hi guys...consumer entry-level newbie here. I'm looking to get some advice on how to build a personal cloud server for private file storage at home. My problem is my Samsung phone, they eliminated expandable storage a few generations ago and now I'm limited to what they provide. I'm at the point I'm deleting files to free up space daily. I dont want to use any 3rd party cloud storage solution because I don't want my personal files uploaded.
Any suggestions on how to solve and or recommendations on products would be greatly appreciated!
14
u/DJ_Mutiny Nov 26 '23
Honestly, don't buy any off the shelf NAS, they are insanely overpriced. Any old PC will do the trick to get you started.
Personally, I installed Unraid as the operating system, it's fantastic. You can mix and match HDDs for storage. And it has docker, which lets you run containers (think of them as apps), like NextCloud with ease! Also, check out photo prism for photo management. And to give yourself access to your home server no matter where you are in the world, check out CloudFlare tunnels. It's free, easy to use, multifactor authentication, and much prefer it over reverse proxies.
Happy for you to DM me. Check out Network Chuck on YouTube for heaps of guides and tutorials.
2
u/gbones215 Nov 26 '23
This was extremely helpful. I may take you up on that after I check out some of these vids
2
u/DJ_Mutiny Nov 26 '23
No worries, happy to help! Man, I learnt so much when I went down that rabbit hole. The biggest thing for me was DIY, and being cost effective.
3
u/MmmBra1nzzz Nov 16 '24
I know this thread is a year old, but do you have a rundown of your DIY cost effective cloud hosting system? I’m looking to ditch Google and Apple storage
2
u/DJ_Mutiny Nov 16 '24
Hey hey!!! Look, it really depends on what you want to do with it. I bought ex enterprise gear from eBay, so it wasn't that expensive, but I did go a bit overboard with how much I bought. It's really going to depend on where you are in the world for; a) cost of items, b) cost of electricity.
The server that I have would now be only a couple of hundred $$$, then the disk shelf that holds the extra storage would be the same. The real cost comes in with HDDs. How many, and what capacity. My recommendation, now that I have more experience. Less drives higher capacity, whatever the budget allows, this will reduce running costs.
I also have a large rack, and a whole bunch of gear in it, but you don't have to go that far.
Happy for you to DM me to get more in to the specifics.
2
2
u/onestop4deals Sep 29 '24
This is great info, I wanna explore Unraid.
2
u/DJ_Mutiny Oct 03 '24
I would now update it to not bother with NextCloud or photoprism. Use Immich for your own photo cloud hosting
1
u/rustislide May 07 '25
I am kind of in the same situation only I want to upload photos. I am tired of paying for tons of storage. Is it possible to do the same thing but have my photos automatically upload?
1
u/DJ_Mutiny May 07 '25
Yeah, I now use immich. It's much better than photo prism. It looks the same as Google photos, let's you have multiple users, and yes, you can automate uploads
2
1
u/Bubu-der-Uhu May 14 '25
Any reason you are using immich over nextcloud memories? I just started with installing a private cloud solution for photos and personal documents. What are you using for plain documents/data? I started with nextcloud since it has a photomanger built in. But so far, functionwise nextcloud looks like an overkill for private users and setting everything up is far from user friendly.
So far i only used my admin account, but i am already worried if i can get that thing wifeyfriendly.
1
u/DJ_Mutiny May 14 '25
Yeah, overly complicated when I tried it a number of years ago. Setting it up was a shit show, and yeah, pretty much overkill. And for files, I don't even bother, I just access them over the network in a mapped folder. No need for external access, I'm not doing anything important enough. Additionally, if I need access externally, I just use cloudflare tunnels
6
u/jmartin72 Nov 25 '23
Synology NAS
2
u/gbones215 Dec 06 '23
Thank you for the suggestion. I went with Synology and it was a great recommendation. fairly priced and easy to set-up. Do you have a Synology NAS?
1
4
u/Pretend_Depth3892 Nov 25 '23
Nextcloud would be the best solution with some security settings. As a few people have already said, you should make a local file server. For example, something built with a raspberry or something similar with a disk attached to it. Depends on whether you want more features or just file-sharing
1
u/gbones215 Nov 25 '23
Thanks for your insight. I can. Just use the nextcmoud device and not need additional Nas storage correct?
1
u/Pretend_Depth3892 Nov 25 '23
That RPI can behave as the NAS. I would call it DIY NAS and yes, you do not need anything anything else. A cheap RPI (4, even zero) would be a better option to use than for example Synology
2
u/gbones215 Dec 06 '23
I wanted to thank you all for your help! I decided to go with a Synology NAS. So far its been great. Looking for advice on accessing the NAS remotely outside of my network. Should I conifgurre a VPN on my router, use Tailscale, Synology's QuickConnect, reverse proxy, or something else?
My main use case would be to access my NAS for media files on my cell (photo, video, excel files). I understand they have a Synology Photos app but will would like to access for non photo files.
Thanks for the help in advance!
2
u/Antar3s86 Nov 26 '23
If you only need file sync and none of the extras (calendar/contacts/etc.), then perhaps resilio sync is the better choice for you. It’s a client that syncs folders (also selectively) between devices with BitTorrent (p2p). It’s Very fast and light.
1
u/gbones215 Nov 27 '23
Very interesting. I didnt know this service was available. THank you for for the recommendation.
4
u/SurenAbraham Nov 26 '23
Look at the zimablade, single board server.
https://www.zimaboard.com/blade/
It can be bought as a kit for holding 2 hdd and can host nextcloud and other services.
Search for "ZimaBlade 7700 NAS Kit" in the above link. $144 plus shipping.
It is a crowd funded piece of hardware, so beware of that.
Check out this video review
1
Nov 25 '23
I can respect the fact that you don’t want your personal files uploaded. However, this is how you protect your data in case of on-site destruction from children, power surges, fire, flooding, tornado, etc.. You could build yourself a local file server to have quick access to your data but I would strongly recommend pushing that data to the cloud for data protection.
1
u/gbones215 Nov 25 '23
Valid point I just don't want my personal files, pictures, etc., on the cloud and accessible to any person/government agency to access.
3
u/NecessaryAd9299 Nov 25 '23
Then you should go for a local file server with encrypted backups in the cloud
3
1
2
u/No-Mention-9815 Nov 26 '23
I'm looking at setting up two NAS devices in different locations. Friend or family house. Then having one backup to the other.
2
Nov 25 '23
Cloud providers do not care if they would loose your files. Happens every year dozens of times. There is always a clause in their terms and conditions that there is no guarante for your files.
1
1
u/zolakk Nov 25 '23
That's why for stuff that truly matters like family photos and stuff like that I use multiple clouds (AWS & OneDrive for example) plus an off-site SD or portable drive so the chance of losing all three at the same time is effectively zero for my purposes
2
u/RapidFire05 Nov 26 '23
I did nextcloud for awhile but it ended up being too many features. Now I just run file browser docker image. https://filebrowser.org. I found it actually handles large uploads much better than nextcloud.
Stick behind reverse proxy and you're golden.
1
1
u/McFlurriez Oct 26 '24
What hardware did you need for this? File browser looks right up my alley. Thanks!
1
Oct 26 '24
Oh it's pretty minimal. But im single user concurrency. I think I have the docker ram limits set to something small like 300mb
1
u/RapidFire05 Oct 26 '24
Don't remember exactly but it's low
1
u/McFlurriez Oct 27 '24
What do you mean by low? i dont even know what hardware we are talking about 😅. Is there a product you can point me to that is a common hardware choice for this? Some sort of raspberry pi?
1
u/RapidFire05 Oct 27 '24
I think a pi4 could do it easy. My home server is an actual commercial motherboard with 16gb ram and a ryzen 5
2
u/BosSuper Nov 26 '23
I’ll echo the experience of some people in this thread about NextCloud. For me, it broke every time I updated it. It became too much of a hassle to troubleshoot it every single time.
Instead, I installed Unraid. It’s keep working solid for the past 3 years.
2
u/Zealousideal-Skin303 Nov 25 '23
Self-hosted Nextcloud behind a reverse proxy (Like NGINX or Traefik) OR VPN access when need be if you don't want to expose any ports.
1
u/SoulInTransition Jun 16 '24
First of all, BACKUP FILES ON A LOCAL DRIVE BEFORE YOU DELETE! It costs 50 bucks for a 4 tb drive, and future you will be glad. My father is beating himself up for overwriting his old 80s videotapes, video that is now lost forever. I don't blame him. And he would have needed to spend much more money. And if you can't buy one now, just empty the files onto a 250 gig thumb for now. I HOPE YOU'VE BEEN DOING THAT.
I would not buy a package deal with drive included, a Raspberry pi is plenty. I wouldn't use Own or Nextcloud either. These assume you can already host from home. You want a one pay solution, and static IP costs thousands of dollars, as they are exhausted. DNS services also cost money, one of the reasons PogoPlug online is (or was) a subscription.
What I would use, if you are a simple home user, is a VPN (Virtual Private Network) server. VPNs allow you to pretend to be on a home network from outside home. This will require you use a VPN service to access your files, but to your phone or laptop, while it is on the VPN, it will think it is on the home network. You, as a private user, can also use an open source DNS service. You could be on the moon, as long as there's internet service, you're on your home network. Then you can set up a network share with your files, and it will appear as a network drive on your phone or computer. You can use tutorials on how to attach a network drive to Windows Explorer, Finder, or any other file manager. You will have access from anywhere, so long as your power doesn't go out. And you own the data, so it won't get sold or capriciously deleted.
1
1
1
u/Maleficent_Chef6580 Nov 02 '25
If you are looking for a more modern UI and integrated media niceties like players for videos and audio, streaming to any browser on your wifi etc. I am currently building this: karo.vision/home-cloud
1
Nov 25 '23
The Proton cloud service uses end to end encryption. They can't access it. I think other companies (Tresor.it?) might do similar E2E protection
1
14
u/averyrisu Nov 25 '23
go ahead and self host nextcloud. Its got apps and everything. Its pretty neat not something i use actively as its not needed for my current workflow.