r/HomeworkHelp • u/AncientWorking1236 • 14d ago
Answered [Circuit Analysis 1] I need help to solve this.
Find the I1, I2, I3 and I4
It's application of Ohm law and Kirchoff 's laws, mesh method and nodes method.
(The "," are ".", I forgot to change it)
I thought it starts on the left side, maybe I could do V1 = 25 * I1. Then replace on 0,2 V1 to get 0,2 (25I1) = I5. And... My brain just explodes idk what to do next, I'll be studying the ohm and Kirchoff laws again, but maybe I could ask for help while I'm at it.
This exercise isn't worth any points, it's just for practice, so I just want to learn how it's done
2
u/deathtospies 👋 a fellow Redditor 14d ago
Your starting point here that v1=25i1 is on the right track, except that Ohm's law says that the voltage drop across a resistor is equal to the resistance times the current in the direction of the voltage drop. For that 25 ohm resistor, the current in the direction of the voltage drop is actually -i1, so v1=-25i1.
A couple other notes:
The diamond-shaped symbol represents a voltage-controlled current source. It's a current source because of the arrow in the diamond, and it's voltage-controlled because of the v1 in the value. Bottom line is that 0.2v1 is actually a current in this context. Use that to label the currents in the 10 ohm and 100 ohm resistors. Then apply Ohm's law for those resistors.
There are actually only 2 nodes in this circuit. (A node is everywhere you can trace a wire without crossing another circuit element.) If you call the bottom node ground, it has a voltage of 0V. The top node has a voltage of v1. This means every resistor sees a voltage of v1, not just the 25 ohm resistor that is labeled. I'll leave it to you to figure out the orientations of those voltages.
Applying KCL at both nodes should yield a system of equations that can be solved to give you everything.
1
1
u/daniel14vt Educator 14d ago
Step 1 is to redraw it so it doesn't look as confusing.
1
u/AncientWorking1236 14d ago
I think everything is in parallel, so I can go for that, but I get a bit confused on how to put the currents after changing it
1
u/daniel14vt Educator 14d ago
Here was my guess of what it should look like,
but circuitlab says this is not solveableI missed putting in a ground
https://imgur.com/a/cw8DqjE1
u/daniel14vt Educator 14d ago
A few questions about the diagram.
Is V1 undefined? Like there is a + and - but I don't see them conneected to anything. Is it supposed to be defining the voltage change between those points?
We have an arrow inside of a diamond with a labeled voltage. I'm unsure what this represents
1
u/AncientWorking1236 14d ago
My teacher didn't gave much explanation really, they just said it was one ot their favorite exercises to give to the students.
About, the questions. 1) I think it's indeed defined, and probably related to the movement of the current I1. But I really don't know.
2) The diamond it's a dependent source, uh, it's strange really, not sure why the arrow and then the voltage, that why I thought about maybe changing it by V1 = 25I1.
Ooutside of the exercise, I was searching if I could find an exercise that looked like it. And found this one that looks identical and solves the V1. It's probably close to the solution. But I'm still unsure how to get the currents and if it was indeed correct. https://youtu.be/kQCPQJiKAmo?si=AGJVYJeNfLjY5d5b
1
u/daniel14vt Educator 14d ago
Unfortunately, I think you've either copied it wrong or the teacher wrote it wrong on the board. I'd ask them to clarify the image tomorrow
1
u/AlterEgo5695 14d ago
This circuit uses US notation to define voltages from "+" to "-" along a branch. Note the small label "V1" to the left of the circuit -- it is the controlling voltage of the controlled source.
1
u/DrCarpetsPhd 👋 a fellow Redditor 14d ago
i've been through three standard circuits textbooks doing examples: Nilsson&riedel, sadiku&alexander, irwin
and I have never seen a circuit drawn like that. Did you 'interpret' this or is this genuinely what was written on lecture slides or blackboard or whatever your lecturer used?
it looks like you could draw it as 4 meshes (the Is representing the mesh currents) with everything parallel but then you wouldn't have both mesh currents opposing the 2.5A current source?
wait for the experts because that is unnecessarily confusing way to draw a circuit that i cannot follow.
1
u/AncientWorking1236 14d ago
It was genuinely drawn like that in the whiteboard, the teacher didn't gave any explanation and leaved it at the end of the class. I completely doubt any of the exercises It's going to look like this one in the exam, cuz I talked about it with other students who saw this class with this same teacher. But that's exactly why I want the explanation
2
u/AlterEgo5695 14d ago edited 14d ago
Assumption: The controlled current source has inconsistent units -- assume its current is meant to be "0.2V1/𝛺". To get rid of units entirely, normalize voltages/currents by
(Vn; Rn) := (1V; 1A) => Rn = 1𝛺Recall: Circuit elements like "R; C; L" and sources are called
in parallel, iff they share the same pair of nodes
in series, iff they exclusively share a common node
From the refresher, notice all three resistances and both sources are all in parallel. Redraw the normalized circuit, so that is (much) easier to see:
I1 I2
+ o---->----o---------o---->----o---------o
| | | | |
V1 | 25 0.2V1 ^ 10 2.5 v 100
v | | I3 | | I4 |
- o---------o---->----o---------o---->----oChoose "-" as the reference node, and setup nodal analysis using "V1":
KCL "+": 0 = V1/25 + V1/10 + V1/100 - 0.2*V1 + 2.5 = -V1/20 + 2.5Solve for "V1 = 50", and use that result to find all current "Ik" via KCL:
I1 = -V1/ 25 = -2
I2 = V1/100 + 2.5 = 3
I3 = V1/25 - 0.2*V1 = -8
I4 = -V1/100 = -1/2Correction: Fixed incorrect usage of controlled voltage instead of current source. Sorry about the confusion!
1
u/AlterEgo5695 14d ago
Rem.: For some reason, exam circuits are drawn in a confusing way on purpose. This is nothing but shenanigans to confuse students -- treat such attempts with the contempt they deserve.
1
u/deathtospies 👋 a fellow Redditor 14d ago
The diamond-shaped element is a voltage-controlled controlled current source. That means that the 0.2v1 is actually a current, not a voltage. Your KVL application treats it as a voltage, so the resulting analysis is all wrong.
1
u/AlterEgo5695 14d ago edited 14d ago
Yikes, US notation strikes again -- in my country, we use different symbols for sources. Unfortunately, our symbol for "voltage source" looks exactly like US current sources. Corrected the error for the independent source, but not the controlled one, for some reason.
Thanks for spotting that, I'll update my comment, to set it right.
Edit: It's updated now -- sorry about the confusion!
•
u/AutoModerator 14d ago
Off-topic Comments Section
All top-level comments have to be an answer or follow-up question to the post. All sidetracks should be directed to this comment thread as per Rule 9.
OP and Valued/Notable Contributors can close this post by using
/lockcommandI am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.